Hey mate, Honestly... I think you either hate the SMG or love it...
It does take a bit to get used to, 1st gear can be a bit clunky... but other than that its great.
I'm really loving it, it handles so well and I mean that engine is so fcking glorious.
I'm on a couple of forums M3 forum and bimmerforums... i will check out DTMpower.net.
I understand what your saying about the proper manual thing, but does that include the latest model BMW M3 E92 because it has the 7 Speed M-DCT transmission????
Because, that BMW is a brilliant car!!! even if it's not a manual...
you could say that about a lot of other cars... For instance, look at the AMG mercedes... all Auto gear boxes.