Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

you wont have problems running the sub, but its certainly underpowered. Whether or not u'll notice it depends on how picky u n ur ears are. If you want spl, its really fallen short; if u want sq you'll probably be happy for a while but u may find it a bit muddy after a while (or maybe not, depends on how picky u are); or u may be completely happy with the sound...... yes yes, very vague but hope it gives u an idea, cos i kinda had the same thing happening. I eventually had to/am going to change to a more powerful amp

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/32860-help-with-ampsub/#findComment-661447
Share on other sites

Okay, there is a long reply and a short, the short is; No, having little power won't harm your speakers if your sensible with the volume knob.

The long answer is this; In most systems when you hears the speakers ‘distorting’ it’s not the speaker that is struggling, it’ the amp. Speakers are quite simple devices, all they do is reproduce the sound given to them regardless of what that sound may be.

When you ask an amp to do it’s job, it takes a relatively small sound wave and amplifies it before sending that bigger signal to the speakers. If you ask it to do more than it’s capable of (by turning the volume up full blast), it still tries to do what you have asked, but the new amplified sound wave becomes rough and sketchy. This sketchy sound wave jerks the speaker engine around violently and erratically which causes it to heat up and / or break…

Imagine for a second a weight lifter. He is on the bench doing bench presses. With 100 pounds his movement will be nice and smooth and he’ll be almost faultless in his technique. Now you throw on another 300 pounds. He may still just be able to do it, but his arms and legs shake, his breathing becomes irregular and it looks woeful to watch.

You amp does the same, it still attempts to do what you have asked of it, but it sounds dreadful and you get that ‘distortion’ everyone talks about. And here lies the biggest problem – most people assume the speakers are dying, so they go and get a SMALLER amp and as you can imagine from reading above, the problem is just amplified (sorry, couldn’t resist throwing that pun in! :D ). Anyway, it gets worse.

Now don’t get me wrong, you can fry your speakers with too much power, but there is only two ways – bottoming the voice coil out damaging the speaker internals and believe me, you will hear when you do that. The other way is to thermally overload it – in other words cook it, fry it, burn it – say it how you will.

But the volume will be way louder than your comfortable with I imagine before that happens.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/32860-help-with-ampsub/#findComment-665071
Share on other sites

if distorting, you are prob just running the preamp and end transistors in the amp at the top end of their limits

isn't a speaker basically a long thin piece of wire coiled? how does having a lower voltage output (even with distorted signal) cause overheating in the speaker coil?

the current consumed by the speaker is constant and the voltage (which is underspecified in this case - hence wattage is lower) so you shouldn't burn out the speaker, the amp would die first

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/32860-help-with-ampsub/#findComment-665368
Share on other sites

I didn’t say low volume distortion hurts speakers. Extreme volume distortion damages them.

When it comes to in-car audio issues, I reply basing my answers on twenty years of installation and journalism (testing etc for magazines) experience rather than scientific formulae. We (installers) run with what does work, not what should in theory…

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/32860-help-with-ampsub/#findComment-665710
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • They care about emissions, and cost the most. Save weight where possible, and make manufacturing easier. Less material also let's the engine transfer heat to water quicker, and bring the engine up to temp quicker, better for emissions and getting them past their warranty period.
    • I was under the impression the reason why OEMs are going with solutions like relatively thin "right-sized" cylinder walls with technologies like PTWA and open deck is because they care a lot about whatever marginal knock margin benefits they get from that vs the structural rigidity benefits of a closed deck block and thicker cylinder walls. I also see some weird stuff like plastic inserts in the water jacket around the cylinders to try and equalize cylinder wall temperatures. re: the PRP blocks and heads at the end of the day it's hard to know what is and isn't going to work there, just have to see what the initial buyers say about it.
    • Which is why I didn't mention that hardness testing, and specifically mentioned the bore and deck thickness testing. Yeah, not really. The bore temperature will be a lot more even around the top half inch or so, where the material distribution is dominated by the deck, and which is the only place where the bore surface temperature heating any gas in the cylinder is likely to have any effect on detonation. Think about it. Another inch or so down the bore, you might have a hotter spot. The gas there might get a bit hotter, then the piston rises squeezes that gas away from there at high speed and mixes it with other gas from nearby. Instant dilution of the problem. I'd be surprised if it was an issue at any time other than in racing engines or OEM dev engines being run at the ragged edge of tuning. Say what now?
    • https://dsportmag.com/the-tech/education/engine-tech-material-hardness-testing/ The PRP testing on block hardness I'm not sure how much it actually can be trusted. The thinner cylinder walls on RBs is a bit of a problem vs 2JZ but it really depends on the design goal. Siamesed cylinder bores like a 2JZ cause uneven cylinder wall temps too, which means a bit of distortion induced by that + the hotspot can affect knock margin. Something that actually gives me a bit of pause with the PRP block, whether super thick cylinder walls are going to keep it from being drop-in compatible on an otherwise OEM rebuild. 
    • Yeah very valid point. I am waiting for one of the other tuners to come back from vacation so he can help me a bit when the cat is installed again. In the meantime I am going to finish up my polishing and ceramic coating that I have started myself.    N45 Dr Beasley product is highly recommended for a paint primer / polisher. Using this EXO Gtechniq also for the ceramic but next time might use the light serum before hand also. Looks great. 
×
×
  • Create New...