Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hey Guys,

I've got a S2 R33, a consult cable, and the nisdatascan software. What i want to know is if it is possible to determine when a knock occurrs... the ecu error code can tell you that a knock DID occur, but how useful is that? Wouldn't it be better to know at what RPM the engine knocks? Is this possible to do in our cars, i mean, without the stethoscope and a keen set of ears?

Cheers

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/224823-knock-sensor-logging/
Share on other sites

Hey Guys,

I've got a S2 R33, a consult cable, and the nisdatascan software. What i want to know is if it is possible to determine when a knock occurrs... the ecu error code can tell you that a knock DID occur, but how useful is that? Wouldn't it be better to know at what RPM the engine knocks? Is this possible to do in our cars, i mean, without the stethoscope and a keen set of ears?

Cheers

the ECU error code for knock sensor doesnt tell you if a knock occurred. it tells you if it detects a fault with the knock sensor.

I have datascan and as far as i know it cannot log the knock sensor. As Pete said above, ECU error code for detonation sensor circuit just means that your det sensor circuit is showing an abnormal resistance (open circuit, dead sensor etc) and will trigger the error code.

When your car does detonate it will go into safety mode, it will not show an error code.

Have you considered an aftermarket product like a knock-link? You can read up about them on the AMEC website ( www.amecautocare.com.au ) under the electornics section.

I don't know if this applies to all Nissan's, but I do know that on the Zed the knock sensor is only monitored by the ECU up until approx 3500rpm... after that the sensor can get confused between normal engine vibration/noise and detonation and may put you into safety maps even though you're not detonating. I reckon the best way would be something like a knock-link.

theoretically if you know what memory address in the ecu that the ecu uses for whether its in safe mode or not, then you can monitor that, but im not sure its generic (location could be different for diff cars) and it will just be a yes/no, not an amount.

a knock lite or similar would probably be the best choice.

your other alternative is to get something like a Knock Link LED det display unit, which BTW we can get for you :ermm: I have one in the race car, the LEDs usually start flickering at the top of the rev range.

oh another product that is similar is the TurboXS knock lite.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • I see you've never had to push start your own car... You could save some weight right now...
    • Sounds good.  I don't 100% understand what your getting at here. When you say, "I keep seeing YouTube videos where people have new paint and primer land on the old clearcoat that isn't even dulled down" do you mean this - there is a panel with factory paint, without any prep work, they paint the entire panel with primer, then colour then clear?  If that's what you mean, sure it will "stick" for a year, 2 years, maybe 3 years? Who knows. But at some stage it will flake off and when it does it's going to come off in huge chunks and look horrific.  Of course read your technical data sheet for your paint, but generally speaking, you can apply primer to a scuffed/prepped clear coat. Generally speaking, I wouldn't do this. I would scuff/prep the clear and then lay colour then clear. Adding the primer to these steps just adds cost and time. It will stick to the clear coat provided it has been appropriately scuffed/prepped first.  When you say, "but the new paint is landing on the old clearcoat" I am imagining someone not masking up the car and just letting overspray go wherever it wants. Surely this isn't what you mean?  So I'll assume the following scenario - there is a small scratch. The person manages to somehow fill the scratch and now has a perfectly flat surface. They then spray colour and clear over this small masked off section of the car. Is this what you mean? If this is the case, yes the new paint will eventually flake off in X number of years time.  The easy solution is to scuff/prep all of the paint that hasn't been masked off in the repair area then lay the paint.  So you want to prep the surface, lay primer, then lay filler, then lay primer, then colour, then clear?  Life seems so much simpler if you prep, fill, primer, colour then clear.  There are very few reasons to go to bare metal. Chasing rust is a good example of why you'd go to bare metal.  A simple dent, there is no way in hell I'm going to bare metal for that repair. I've got enough on my plate without creating extra work for myself lol. 
    • Hi, Got the membership renewal email but haven't acted yet.  I need to change my address first. So if somebody can email me so I can change it that would be good.    
    • Bit of a similar question, apprently with epoxy primer you can just sand the panel to 240 grit then apply it and put body filler on top. So does that basically mean you almost never have to go to bare metal for simple dents?
×
×
  • Create New...