Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hey guys,

I went to have a look at a silver r33 series 2 this morning which I found advertised on eBay. (see link)

http://cgi.ebay.com.au/nissan-skyline-r33-...3#ht_911wt_1137

Ebay says 97000, the odometer reflected 103,000 fair enough I guess

I was handed some regency paperwork showing an inspection 1 month prior

THE ODOMETER READING ON THIS PAPERWORK WAS 162,000kms

He couldn't explain the discrepancy, and on closer inspection, scratch marks on the odometer.

So hence, I walked. But tell your friends if they're looking, as this is a c*nt of an act.

Cheers.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/329256-silver-r33-series-ii-manual/
Share on other sites

Lots of valid reasons why the kilometres don't match up. But no point in speculating. In the end it actually looks pretty tidy in the pics for the current price. A good honest R33 SII still fetches 12-14k. You expect the world for 8?

I don't think a discrepancy in kilometres is sufficient to bash this dude's sale :D

Cryogenic, I'm not out to bash the sale, but there is being honest, and then doing the dodge to jack your price. The car drove well, the car had great suspension & interior, but the car also had another 60,000 on it that they were trying to do the dodge with. Should I also add the scratch marks on the odo numbers?

I was under the impression that the whole reason of the skyline forums were to help other users and educate people on certain things, I think I'm much better saying this than letting someone get jipped.

Also, it's an auction. It'll go to whatever price it goes to. Who said anything about $8k?

Cryogenic, I'm not out to bash the sale, but there is being honest, and then doing the dodge to jack your price. The car drove well, the car had great suspension & interior, but the car also had another 60,000 on it that they were trying to do the dodge with. Should I also add the scratch marks on the odo numbers?

I was under the impression that the whole reason of the skyline forums were to help other users and educate people on certain things, I think I'm much better saying this than letting someone get jipped.

Also, it's an auction. It'll go to whatever price it goes to. Who said anything about $8k?

Granted, it's shady. I think everyone can agree on that. But nonetheless, i think anyone should look further than just what the dash reads to determine the condition of a car, especially imports.

This is the for sale forum. Are you selling the car here? Well why post this thread here? There are other areas of SAU where you could post this. From the sounds of it, you never got a definitive answer as to why the numbers didn't match. I'd like to give someone the benefit of the doubt before judging anything though. Give the guy a chance to explain himself before black flagging him automatically. Some kids buy cars with no friggin idea. How long had he owned it? Did he import it? Someone probably bought it over with 164k, blew up the engine and replaced it with an engine with 90k. The dude probably bought it in that state. Who knows? Not me. And if you don't for sure, then you should probably reserve your judgement on the issue.

Once again, just because kilometres don't match up, doesn't mean the car is a lemon, or is not worth whatever price someone is WILLING to pay for it. the link you provided shows the current price at 7600 odd. Reserve isn't met, but what is the reserve? Who knows. If the dude sold it for 8k, i'd say it was probably a decent buy, even with 164k on it.

Granted, it's shady. I think everyone can agree on that. But nonetheless, i think anyone should look further than just what the dash reads to determine the condition of a car, especially imports.

This is the for sale forum. Are you selling the car here? Well why post this thread here? There are other areas of SAU where you could post this. From the sounds of it, you never got a definitive answer as to why the numbers didn't match. I'd like to give someone the benefit of the doubt before judging anything though. Give the guy a chance to explain himself before black flagging him automatically. Some kids buy cars with no friggin idea. How long had he owned it? Did he import it? Someone probably bought it over with 164k, blew up the engine and replaced it with an engine with 90k. The dude probably bought it in that state. Who knows? Not me. And if you don't for sure, then you should probably reserve your judgement on the issue.

Once again, just because kilometres don't match up, doesn't mean the car is a lemon, or is not worth whatever price someone is WILLING to pay for it. the link you provided shows the current price at 7600 odd. Reserve isn't met, but what is the reserve? Who knows. If the dude sold it for 8k, i'd say it was probably a decent buy, even with 164k on it.

True, and I can completely understand that, and everything that you've mentioned above.

He told me he's had the car for a year, and the regency paperwork was from about 28 days ago. That's why I didn't reserve my judgement.

I didn't want to get in anyone's grill about this, I just thought it was only fair that the general purchasing community knew, hence why I posted it in this thread.

Cheers

regency paperwork was from about 28 days ago. That's why I didn't reserve my judgement.

Well, after getting that little nugget of information, I have to agree with your judgement ;)

I'll stick my tail between my legs and walk away now ;)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Wow ELVIS. You have an....interesting approach to conversation. Did you not notice that I wasn't talking to you?
    • Hello Liam - HA - somewhere in flies - possibly I have an update, but I have been so busy, projects have taken a back seat to getting business back on track.  I will let you know the outcome, but I think I am going to go for the 8HP,  CHEERS.  ELVIS
    • Thanks Joshuaho96, yes - as someone else also suggested, the 8HP seems the 'smart choice' - HA - and ZERO to do with cost, but I am sure 8 speeds will be better than 6 speeds - HA - maybe.  I will purchase a new 8HP,  Thanks.  ELVIS.
    • Nobody said anything about getting a "...cheap Falcon box..."- it was JUST a question about a specific transmission.  And YOU may have a problem with not enough $ - HA - I do NOT - so please keep your comments like you are some financial guru to yourself.  BUT - much appreciated re the cost of a new 8HP and I twill probably be the way I go.  Thanks.  ELVIS.
    • Most people I know in the BMW world are swapping 6HPs for 8HPs. The 6HP has a big issue with one of the clutch drum bushings wearing out shockingly early which leads to them going into limp mode going into 5th/6th gear as the oil pressure loss from the worn bushing causes clutch slip. Even with the adaptations in shifting the TCU can't bump line pressure enough to keep the clutches from slipping and burning. I've personally looked at a 335d with 6HP28 with one owner and ~90k miles on it and the transmission adaptations were way out of spec and even though it nominally drove ok I'm confident it would have needed a full rebuild sooner than later. Other than that they're fine, but the 8HP doesn't really have weird issues like this to my knowledge and they're in everything these days so pulling them out of crashed cars isn't too hard.
×
×
  • Create New...