Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

It was attached to the gearbox sump plug! :Bang:

haha ..... argh ..... faaaaaark ....

Put Motul gear 300 oil in there .... helped a little bit but still crunches badly going into 4th.

Any other solutions? Or will I have to get a new box?

Could it be to do with my clutch pedal travel or something, as I just put a new clutch in about a month and a half ago and I'm sure it was worse when I got the car back.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/34733-finally-i-found-4th-gear/
Share on other sites

No oil is going to fix this problem. Unfortunately you have to bite the bullet and buy another 2nd hand box from a wrecker, or get yours rebuilt. It wont be long before the metal circulates and starts busting the other gears too.

What clutches are u blokes using?

I've been running a Xtreem 30% Organic full faced clutch, it has got quite a bit of give in it as a flat change in to fourth will feel a little spungy. Third will chirp though.

I'm about to go the heaviest Xtreem clutch that is a 1058kg pressure plate with a cushioned ceramic clutch that has 12 puks. I know of this clutch holding ~300rwkw with no slippage, (Matt's R33).

I am sure as soon as I go the heavier clutch the box will die.

I've got a 9 puck organic with a 2500lb pressure plate in mine ... before that I think it was a brass button one that came with the car.

I launch the car hard but I wouldnt have thought that it would affect 3rd and 4th (3rd crunches a bit too now).

What sort of money are we looking at to rebuild 3rd and 4th synchros do you know?

Or to get the whole box rebuilt?

I re-counted.. Mine also has 9 puks on either side, the puks look a dull orange with specs of dark grey through out it. Previous organic clutch's I have seen tend to be more light grey, a bit brake pad looking.

A 2500lb is also the same pressure plate as mine.

Do you find it hard on the ol' left leg at a set of traffic lights.

I had a HD clutch put in a VS 5ltr Commodore I used to own, that used to make my leg shake at a set of traffic lights or when waiting to pull out in traffic.

I used to rebuild my 4 Speed single rail box in my TE Cortina, I constantly used to do syncro's & front main bearings.

To replace just the syncro's is just as much work to also slap in a set of new rear and main bearings.

Generally the rattle from a gearbox that you get & can hear when riding the clutch to move forward a little in say Mc Donalds drive through is the layshaft bearings, the lay shaft in the 4 speed g/box was a solid shaft with different sized gears attached, they all moved at once. A solid metal shaft would slide through the middle of this layshaft with hundreds of tiny roller bearings. It takes a long time to replace those as you need to stick them on to the solid metal shaft with grease then carefully slide it in the middle of the layshaft hoping you don't hit the sides to much as to dislodge the roller bearings. The layshaft bearings don't have to be replaced and generally arn't. I had the VS 5 speed g/box rebuild and specifically asked for the layshaft bearings to be replaced. Got the g/box back and they screwed me. The rattle was still there.

I knew from experience with the 4speed that the same rattle noise was definately the layshaft, if I didn't replace the layshaft bearings the rattle would stay.

From memory the parts for the 4 Speed Single Rail box (syncro's, front/rear main bearings, layshaft bearings cost me around $100)

To get some one to fully rebuild the gearbox I was looking at around $800-$900. I could have got jobs done for $450-$500 however I highly doubt they would have replaced the layshaft bearings.

Jimih,

Thought about an RB25 box? Bit stronger than the Rb20 one. Rebuilding is going to cost you a fair bit, gearboxes are labour intensive. Theres no point in doing it by halves either, because as soon as you fix 2 synchro's something else will break and youve gotta pay labour on taking it out again.

Jimih,

Thought about an RB25 box? Bit stronger than the Rb20 one. Rebuilding is going to cost you a fair bit, gearboxes are labour intensive. Theres no point in doing it by halves either, because as soon as you fix 2 synchro's something else will break and youve gotta pay labour on taking it out again.

Yeah 33 box would be good ... but my car is 4wd so I need a GTR box of some description I think :(

Joel: yeah I think the box has copped a bit of a punishing. The tyres are 255's all round, 4wd and heavy duty clutch. So I think the gearbox takes a fair amount of pain. The pedal isnt too bad on the left leg though :(

The motor's coming out soon anyway so I think I'll just change the box to a GTR box when the new motor goes in ...

Cheers anyway fellas! :D

hey jimih you dont have to buy a new box, my gears were crunching in 3rd and 4th, soi had the gears modified, costs about 50 bucks per gear, and 200 bucks labour, now it doesnt crunch and goes into gear much easier,..

hey jimih you dont have to buy a new box, my gears were crunching in 3rd and 4th, soi had the gears modified, costs about 50 bucks  per gear, and 200 bucks labour, now it doesnt crunch and goes into gear much easier,..

Wreckedhead, where did you get the gears from, were they new gears or only modified the existing cogs?

hey Craved sorry i made a mistake i didnt get new gears he bought new syncros for me and had the modified every 2nd or 3rd tooth was taken off.i had my box stripped to see all the gears and if there was any damage, he told me for a 9 year old box, it looked almost brand new inside, no damage to any gears, the only problem was when i was in fifth it was very hard to gear down to forth, but the new syncros fixed that up stright away, now going through the gears is much easier...

but i can give you the number of a place which can help you modify your box or basically do what you want to it

Joel,

Try telling that to my bucket of bolts gearbox. Pretty much stock standard car just over 100,000k's and it sounds horrendous, like its on its last legs. From experience and listening to many many issues RB20 owners have had with them, its my belief the box isnt so tough.

Red17

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • I guess when I say it's a POS I mean.. the solution and the stuff has the capacity for maybe... 1 spot. You know, as a spot cleaner. What I really *want* is the ability to do an entire car, all upholstery, all carpet, mats, all seats, door card inserts, A pillars, roof liners, etc. In one go. I get lured by all the jank that comes out and think "I'd like to be able to clean to that degree"
    • I've got one (not the car one, the domestic spot cleaner one, which is basically the same jobbie) and have driven it hard for hours and hours at a time. Grimy sofas, 6' floor rugs, etc. I'd blame your specific example rather than the whole category. I haven't used mine in the car, because.... you know, it's my car. So there is no-one else's ball sweat in the driver's seat, there's no kid food/drink spills or hand prints inside because they've never had an opportunity to put them there. You know, basic, standard Skyline rules.
    • I normally run with I think a 10mm, and definitely use the second handle you can add to a drill. They hurt when they bins up!   For the crush tube, once all subframe is clear, I'd try some stilsons and see if I can get it to start to twist.
    • Probably because they couldn't, because the use of the variable resistor to create a "signal" in the ECU is managed by the ECU's circuitry. The only way that VDO could do it would be if they made a "smart" sensor that directly created the 0-5V signal itself. And that takes us back to the beginning. Well, in that case, you could do the crude digital (ie, binary, on or off) input that I mentioned before, to at least put a marker on the trace. If you pressed the button only at a series of known integer temperatures, say every 2°C from the start of your range of interest up to whatever you can manage, and you know what temperature the first press was at, then you'd have the voltage marked for all of those temperatures. And you can have more than one shot at it too. You can set the car up to get the oil hot (bypass oil coolers, mask off the air flow to oil coolers, and/or the radiator, to get the whole engine a bit hotter, then give it a bit of curry to get some measurements up near the top of the range.   On the subject of the formula for the data you provided, I did something different to Matt's approach, and got a slightly different linear formula, being Temp = -22.45*V + 118.32. Just a curve fit from Excel using all the points, instead of just throwing it through 2 points. A little more accurate, but not drastically different. Rsquared is only 0.9955 though, which is good but not great. If you could use higher order polynomials in the thingo, then a quadratic fit gives an excellent Rsquared of 0.9994. Temp = 2.1059*V^2 - 34.13*V + 133.27. The funny thing is, though, that I'd probably trust the linear fit more for extrapolation beyond the provided data. The quadratic might get a bit squirrely. Hang on, I'll use the formulae to extend the plots.... It's really big so you can see all the lines. I might have to say that I think I really still prefer the quadratic fit. It looks like the linear fit overstates the temperature in the middle of the input range, and would pretty solidly understate what the likely shape of the real curve would say at both ends.
    • I got a hand held bisssel one and it's a piece of shit. Doesn't work for more than about 5 seconds. So much so that I nearly refuse to believe any wet dry vac actually works or has enough suction to clean the carpet of a car. I'm discouraged as all the good ones are $300+ for an unknown result. I saw MCM did a Ryobi video where they use this thing: https://www.ryobi.com.au/products/stick-vacuum-cleaners/18v-one-hptm-brushless-spot-cleaner-tool-only Anyone have any experience actually using a tool like this when not paid to showcase it?
×
×
  • Create New...