Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Diagnosing front end suspension knock.

R34 GT sedan.

Since I put new coilovers in the front, I have been getting a knock when going over small bumps in the road, going up driveways etc. I can feel it coming through the floor In the car when I am driving and the front end gets "bouncy" at the same time. The coils are not bottoming out and the damper and rebound is generally fine. But the bouncy ness and knocking comes and goes and is really annoying. I can hit big bumps etc and it's perfectly fine and comfortable in a coilover friendly point of view.

These coils are far stiffer then the greddy type s coils I originally had, and to match I'm still using hard race adj control arms and tie rod ends with a 26mm 4 point adj swaybar as I was with the old coils. The swaybar is set on the second stiffest setting and the link is so tight that I don't see a way possible It can be set to the next setting point. Could all this combind be an issue? Being such stiff coils now that it's upsetting the link ?

On the other hand, the coils were a little iffy to be put in. They are non base adj HKS. When installing, if I put the coilover on the bottom mounting point it then would not line up with the 2 holes in the chassis up top, then of I mounted the coil in the 2 chassis holes, then it would not line up on the bottom. In the end, I had to put it 1/4 on bottom mounting bolt, then put top 2 bolts through the chassis and tap the bottom of the coilover with a rubber mallet to get it over the bottom mounting bolt.

They are labeled L AND R And I have out the R on the drivers side and L on passenger so they are not on the wrong sides.

Could it be a possibility that the control arms are set wrong making installation hard ? Before was easy as the greddy coils were base adjustable and could be rotated down low to match the mounting point. Where now I can't.

Should I remove the LCA from the hub, and see if the coils line up perfectly ? Then if they do, adjust the LCAS to match the hub location ?

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/432692-diagnosing-suspension-knock/
Share on other sites

Good thorough description, tough one that. It may be a case where the most obvious thing (coilovers) is not at fault but instead highlighting an issue somewhere else in the suspension.

Couple of things worth checking that came to mind:

  • What suspension tops are you running with the new coilovers? Are they substantially different to the previous ones you had?
  • Sway bar link pins can get noisy, have you checked these?
  • When I was installing my aftermarket tension (caster) rods, they came very close to the aftermarket swaybar when the car is jacked up. Could these be touching?
  • Are your swaybar bushes ok?
  • Is the knock simultaneous on both sides?

The root cause for my suspension knock was incorrectly sized crush tubes in the aftermarket tension rods that were loose around the OEM bolts. Never crossed my mind to check for like this before installing.

With the coilover being iffy to put in, I've found that you may need to adjust the LCA height a bit to line it up correctly. I've used a scissor jack underneath to just lift it slightly.

Good luck.

Cheers fellas.

Swaybar bushes are fine, links are old and tight as f**k on the adjustable sway. I may take it to the next "softest" setting to reduce the tension onto the swaybar. It's abit hard seeing as it didn't do it before, or it just wasn't noticeable with the softer coilovers.

The new coils are pillowball where as the old ones were bush resulting in a softer more enjoyable ride.

As for the tension rod, I do not have one of those tension rods that sit behind the swaybar, I will be purchasing one soon tho. I'm going to look into the links first.

Between the 26mm 4pt adjustable swaybar and the hardrace adj control arms, I have less then a finger width clearance. So I would imagine when hitting bumps the control arm raises and is hitting my swaybar ? After I looked at that, I tested it and tightened up my damper abit more and the knocking is there less and less.

How would I got about this ?

  • 2 weeks later...

Okay, this wasn't the issue. I've listens more and more into depth and the knocking isn't there when both sides of the car is under suspension travel, eg going over a speed bump head on. But then it knocks and bounces dramatically if you take the speed bump on an angle, eg 1 wheel at a time.

ARB dropped, then test driven. Knocking is still there. So swaybar is out of the question.

Perhaps it actually is these coilovers ? They are not bottoming out at all. But I can feel the knock coming through the floor.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • After using a protractor for an actually accurate assessment of what is required,  and by NOT using my uncalibrated eyeball I worked out I need a 25° silicone bend from the TB ro the MAF, but, my choice was either a 30° or a 23° (23° is a weird spec), so I grabbed the 23° one from Raceworks I also grabbed 1mtr of 3" straight from Just Jap, I needed 350mm, but they only had 300mm, or 1mtr lengths....meh Also ordered a 1/2" hose bulkhead fitting from fleabay, this has a smoothish mushroom looking head (they are designed for below the water line of boats) that will fit inside the bend, the hose bit and threaded bit looks to long, but nothing that a hacksaw cannot fix if required, the hose will then just get jamed on the threaded bit up to the retaining nut Fingers crossed and the unsightly amount of hose clamps will be reduced down to 4 once all the parts arrive 
    • Oil change does not trigger code 21. Code 21 is for coilpacks primary side connection. You can try to clear the code with a battery disconnect, hold down the brake pedal to drain capacitors through the brake lights with the ignition on for 10-15 seconds before you reconnect the battery. I have seen R35 coil conversion permanently cause this code with no ill effects so it might be the resistance it wants to see isn't quite right on one or more coilpacks. Could be inside the ECU, could be the harness, could be a coil. You can test it all if you want or just ignore until the car actually starts misfiring.
    • I forgot you have a Nistune ECU. Use Nistune to do all the tests I mentioned instead of faffing with 30+ year old electrical connectors. You can read MAF volts off that too, there are reference values in the service manual to tell you roughly what it should be in different conditions.
    • No. I think it might be the AFM. Hence the use of the terms "swaptronics", which implies the use of swapping out electronics for the purpose of diagnosis. It's about the only way to prove that a small/niggling/whatever problem with an AFM or a CAS or similar is actually caused by that AFM/CAS/whatever. A known good item swapped in that still gives the same problem is likely to be caused somewhere else. They're all the same. Spraying AFMs with cleaner is an each way bet between cleaning it and f**king it.
    • Oh wow! This might actually work amazingly. Do you know the ratio of the diff? I was told the only thing you need to make sure of is if the front & rear diff ratios are the same. Ours is a 4.083 Thanks!
×
×
  • Create New...