Jump to content
SAU Community

  

115 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 103
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I agree.

The Rules in basic Principle i agree.

P platers shouldnt be driving round in silvias and lines.

If this is implemented well (lol - i doubt it) i bet we will see it in other states soon too, like QLD WA SA

But yes, More Driver Training should be required.

maybe to move up to a further vehicle class you have to pass advanced test etc etc.

Get sick of seeing too many 17 year olds with their r33 gtst and chromies doing stupid things ont the road.

I learnt in low powered fwd cars. I see nothing wrong with that.

Michael

I am still scratching my head - how can these things fix up a behavioural problem? Even driver training isn't going to fix it either, merely reducing the amount some of them might hurt themselves. Kids will always be kids..

this is so true, kids will be kids.

but a kid going silly in a RWD turbo car and a n/a fwd are 2 different things...

I know I wasnt less idiots driving rwd turbo cars.

I think i read in another thread something about power to weight ratios being restricted already in some states ...

What are your veiws on this??? Does this seem to you as tho it would be a better option rather than just a blanket ban???

If im not mistaken i think VIC already has this law <--- feel free to correct me on that

Also just out of curiousity how long is Provisional Term of your license in VIC???

Is it just me or do you the older generation of people in this country really need to find themselves a hobby ... and perhaps the young ppl who feel they need to link up multiple corners with some slideways action need to get themselves down to track meets and off the street <---- hey if kids didnt wrap theselves around poles then we wouldnt have this problem!!!

:werd:

U guy stop bitching none of u will b touched they won't make 20000 p plater with skyline and turbo sell them its just to hard they will make it everone that get there P's after a date

To bad for me i am a L plater that has a Skyline and if i don't get my P's soon i will have to sell it ****wits

I going for them on the 21st of June so i have a chance and i think the cut off is the 11th of july

I'm 17 btw just been to busy buying this car to go for P's

I think i read in another thread something about power to weight ratios being restricted already in some states ...

What are your veiws on this??? Does this seem to you as tho it would be a better option rather than just a blanket ban???

If im not mistaken i think VIC already has this law <--- feel free to correct me on that

Also just out of curiousity how long is Provisional Term of your license in VIC???

Is it just me or do you the older generation of people in this country really need to find themselves a hobby ... and perhaps the young ppl who feel they need to link up multiple corners with some slideways action need to get themselves down to track meets and off the street <---- hey if kids didnt wrap theselves around poles then we wouldnt have this problem!!!  

:werd:

yeah i think the vic rules are better.

kw/perton or hp/tone or whatever.

instead of a blanket rule.

mick

U guy stop bitching none of u will b touched they won't make 20000 p plater with skyline and turbo sell them its just to hard they will make it everone that get there P's after a date

To bad for me i am a L plater that has a Skyline and if i don't get my P's soon i will have to sell it ****wits

I going for them on the 21st and i think the cut off is the 11th of july

I'm 17 btw just been to busy buying this car to go for P's

Didnt mean to offend you bro i seriously feel for your situation. We still are in the same boat as you however or i at least believe so, i still want an RTA person to what the exact deal is. GL fingers crossed you get to keep your LINE!!!

i went to the RTA yesterday the said if i don't get P's before a Date on in July i can't drive it on my P's

But i can Still Drive it on my L's WTF

there not making anyone on there P's stop driving turbos just new P platers have to

Unless u Lose ya P's then u go onto the new Thing

if you cant keep your car do what i was goin to do ...

buy yourself a rev happy type R or V-tir civic wack a big zorst and pod and rip up and down the streets making huge amounts of VTEC noise.

again bro GL ... i've got my fingers crossed!!!

if you cant keep your car do what i was goin to do ...

buy yourself a rev happy type R or V-tir civic wack a big zorst and pod and rip up and down the streets making huge amounts of VTEC noise.

again bro GL ... i've got my fingers crossed!!!

neway im off to tafe smell you guys later!!!

is that true  

well then in that case YAY!!!

I thought they were taking the cars from everyone ... and i love my car i spend more time with it than i do my gf (and she really p@#!!*d about that too)

my bad for jumping to conclusions

still would like to hear everybodies opinion however!!!

The law only comes into place on June 11th so your sweet mate but if you get caught speedng or anything in your car they wont let you drive it until you get your full licence.

Thank god Ive got my blacks.

i went to the RTA yesterday the said if i don't get P's before a Date on in July i can't drive it on my P's  

But i can Still Drive it on my L's WTF

there not making anyone on there P's stop driving turbos just new P platers have to  

Unless u Lose ya P's then u go onto the new Thing

strange.

like the import law changes,

you think if you can provide evidence you have financially commited to a vehicle before this date that they would allow you to drive it.

hard luck anyway.

hope you can get the car and your license before that date.

michael

yea i will have to get a Vtec if they won't let me drive my Skyline or kick up a mega bitching and write ****s letters and shit

I still have a chance to get my P's if i **** it up its my fault

IF anyone know the shit i have been thought in the last few weeks now this CRAP after i get the ****en car it makes me just wanta get a civic

First i find car

then i worrie about it being ok

Checked out ok

then it got stolen from dealer

then i looked and found a new one

then stolen one was recoverd Undamaged

dealer fixed it and put new alarms and shit in it for me

i get car

drive home

on radio there all this P plater ban turbo bullshit

Got to rta put car in my name

they say if i don't get my P's b4 july i won't b able to drive my Own car

Booked P's for 21st June its my D day

Booked heaps of lessons due to me not Driving Manual much cause my silvia was auto

I AM STRESSING OUT

And everyone that thinks my Mum or dad pay for my car can get ****ed i worked my arse off and i don't go to school due to wanting this car my mum makes lease money then me just for anyone that things i am a little rich bitch

Guest Mashrock
how are they going to police this

"P1 and P2 licence holders will be banned from driving turbo-charged, super-charged vehicles (diesel vehicles excepted), eight-cylinder vehicles and those with engine performance modifications."

how is Mr. Policeman going to know if my excel has extractors or not just by me driving past?

lol

because even if you do put extractors on an excel, its still not going to be as quick as the go go mobile!

I heard Mr Costa regurgitating the stats last night on the radio... apparently P-platers make up 7% of driving population, but are involved in 17% of fatal accidents...

NOW, what i want to know, firstly of that 7% how many actually drive performance cars... i would say it would be <1% or ~10% of p-plater drive performance cars probably less... Secondly of the 17% incolved, how many were driving performance cars in the accident (this i can't say but it would not be about 10-20%).

So why do the remaning 90% of p-plater who probably cause 80% of the fatal accidents get off without any sort of "penalty"... It's clear the only solution is to ban p-platers full stop (tongue in cheek)...

Congratulations to the Carr government and it's continued short-termism on issues in NSW. Carr has to go... for these reasons:

1) He waits til Sydney is in crisis before addressing the water issue;

2) He waits til the trains are in crisis before he addresses them;

3) same as above two but it's Hospitals in crisis;

4) These bollocks p-plate rules;

5) NSW is the most highly taxed state in Australia.

I only have one more point to make, which has already been made... but if a p-plater is going to drive like an idiot, they will do it in whatever car they have. I know, i was there did that somehow survived my p's, bought a skyline and respect it more than i respect my own parents...

End rant.

Hey its going to piss a lot of you guys off but as a victorian who had to deal with the same thing here in Vic for the 3 years i drove on my p's between ages 18-21, i totally agree with the NSWs governments decision.

The fact is that it is an effective way to reduce road deaths of young people, who are way over-represented in the death toll. I know if i had a RWD turbo car on my P's, i would probably have killed myself, even though out of my group of friends I am one of the most responsible drivers, with no fines or accidents so far.

It is simply a matter of inexperienced drivers and fast cars - they dont mix!

Just be glad you guys can drive when ur 17!

what are you talking about? in vic you arent allowed to drive any car that has more than 100kw per tonne. the r32 gts-t fits under this rule but the r33/r34 don't. not sure if the silvia/180sx would. just realised your in qld, oh well welcome to vics rule ;) its not too bad i mean its probably kept a few kids from hitting power poles at 130kmh in their vl turbo's . the rule applies to all cars, regardless of displacement, induction, cyclinders etc. however its not harshly enforced daily you see p platers driving high powered cars (well those over 100kw/ per tonne) and cops drive past them and dont blink an eyelid. i think it just depends on the copper and time of day really wether they will pull you over i guess. i mean its a raod rule right, vicroads knows what licence you have and what car you have. why not do an sql query every week

im a p plater, and i drive an R33 gts-t... coppers dont harrass me about the car, only the stuff under the bonnet that shouldnt be there... pod filter, bov., but apart from that, they've never said to me " you shouldnt be driving this car "... the way i see this issue is, n/a 6's and 4's go equally as fast as turbo ones.... living in vic. and already having my P's none of that new law crap affects me, but i still dont agree with it... also, dont take offence as this isnt meant to offend.... but being off your p plates and driving a high powered sports car doesnt make you any less liable to crash it... thats jst my 2 cents anyways :)

hey, Yesterday i emailed RTA about this matter .. this is what they emailed back:

. Will the prohibited vehicle conditions affect those who already

hold a provisional licence?

No. Existing provisional drivers, that is, drivers who entered the

3-year provisional licence scheme prior to 11 July 2005, will not

have the prohibited vehicle condition applied.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Latest Posts

    • As I've said elsewhere, I am using the stock intercooler piping path in the engine bay, and a return flow cooler, and making ~250 rwkW (without any effort put into trying to turn it up past there just yet) and expect to be able to make some more, and frankly, I would be perfectly happy with 260-270rwKW. This is peak road Skyline usability territory. You go past there and, sure, the car will snap necks more when it's on boost, but it will also break shit all the time, cost a (even larger) fortune in tyres, etc etc. Anyway, I also do not like the over-the-fan pipe path, and you don't have to do it.
    • I see, honestly I’m not too fussed about the looks. The only reason to go plenum is to make the piping easier instead of the classic over the rad etc. 
    • Not easy to quantify wrt something like how many fractions of a second slower it would be over 0-100. But given that a 250-300rwkW car is able to do that launch sprint in 5-6 sec (and faster with appropriate tyres, and surface)..... giving up as much as a second would feel like torture. A ~450HP capable turbo is not going to make lots of boost in the 2000-3000 rpm range. So, whilst with some boost on hand it will be faster accelerating in that rev range than your engine currently is NA, it will not feel like a fast car until the boost is solidly in. You know what your car feels like right now when you open it up at 2000rpm. if you've ever been in an actual fast car, you will appreciate that the NARB25 is.... not exciting. Well, add some boost and it will be better. But shorten the intake runners and it might not be better at all. It might come out better, but it could end up feeling the same. For me, it's not the 0-X km/h sprints that matter. It is easy to fry the tyres with anything over 200 rwkW. You can't use all the power available in 1st and 2nd anyway, you have to modulate the throttle. What matters is how the car reacts when you're driving in traffic in 4th or 5th and have maybe 2000 rpm on board, and you want/need to add some speed quickly, and don't have time for the downshift. It won't make boost, it will be all NA (at the speeds we're talking about - remember how fast you're going at 2000 in 4th! and don't plan on breaking the limit by too much.) So giving away NA torque is not what I would consider practical for a street car. And retaining that NA torque builds boost faster which makes the car faster. The flashy plenum is not actually better, unless you're looking at a track car where you can keep it on the boil all the time.  
    • So how much difference does it make you think? Like 1 second in the 0-100?  I was have smaller turbo so hopefully that spools quick GTX2871.  currently it’s NA so you can imagine pretty slow, but I do want fast accusation a little as there’s not many places I’ll be driving where I go over 80 even near me. So 0-60 and 0-80 targets   
    • Short inlet runners cost quite a bit. Dulls off the off-boost torque, and delays boost onset, because arrival of boost is driven by gas flow is a product of the ability to flow air which is torque. This is the reason that the stock manifolds have longer runners. On a 3L, or bigger, you can usually accept the compromise of giving away some torque because the extra capacity gives you a little extra to waste. But on a smaller motor, there's not a lot there to start with. Example, I swapped RB20 out of my R32, 25NeoDET in its place. The "wall of torque" that I experienced afterwards made it all worthwhile. That's because I came from RB20 land where torque is not a thing. But I would not do anything, anything at all, to reduce the low/mid torque I have now, because I remember what it is like to not have it!
×
×
  • Create New...