Jump to content
SAU Community

Gmax Vs Coppermix Vs Os Giken Twin


ned
 Share

Recommended Posts

Hi all,

I need a new clutch in a GTR with ~250rwkw (std turbos with PFC, EBC, and poncams) that is driven daily in Sydney traffic. I have the option of a custom built strengthened single (Jim Berry), vs a OS giken twin (~2 x price), vs a Nismo Gmax twin (~1.3 x price).

MOstly I am interested in holding the current power with no real plans for turbo upgrades or much beyond current power.I have heard good things about the driveability of the Nismo coppermix, but nothing about Gmax, has anyone use dthe older one?

Can anyone comment on the driveability of a Jim Berry single vs the twins for clutch feel, take-up point, driveability, and slip rate?

Cheers

Thanks

Ned

Link to comment
Share on other sites

whats a Jim Berry clutch twin plate worth or even some details on the single plates would be good? Not sure how an OS giken (can be had for around 1800 if you look hard enough) costs twice as much unless Jim Berry singles does some damn cheap singles. From the people I've spoken to, a lot of single plate puck clutches can be damn right nasty to drivetrains and gearboxes and I have been recommended to steer clear of them unless i wanted to. Nismo G-Max clutches are no longer made and are replaced by the coppermix ones. The Coppermix ones are probably the easiest to drive with out of any twin plates other than the carbon ones. Os Gikens are the cheapest twin plates to buy plates and parts for out of any twin plate - though some clutch places seem to want to charge the earth for them still >_< Os Giken seem to still be bitier than the Nismo Coppermix ones but I'm not sure what their like compared to the Os Giken STR as I'm yet to drive my S13 with one but I'll let oyu know how it compared to the old OS Giken I had.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

whats a Jim Berry clutch twin plate worth or even some details on the single plates would be good? Not sure how an OS giken (can be had for around 1800 if you look hard enough) costs twice as much unless Jim Berry singles does some damn cheap singles. From the people I've spoken to, a lot of single plate puck clutches can be damn right nasty to drivetrains and gearboxes and I have been recommended to steer clear of them unless i wanted to. Nismo G-Max clutches are no longer made and are replaced by the coppermix ones. The Coppermix ones are probably the easiest to drive with out of any twin plates other than the carbon ones. Os Gikens are the cheapest twin plates to buy plates and parts for out of any twin plate - though some clutch places seem to want to charge the earth for them still :happy: Os Giken seem to still be bitier than the Nismo Coppermix ones but I'm not sure what their like compared to the Os Giken STR as I'm yet to drive my S13 with one but I'll let oyu know how it compared to the old OS Giken I had.

Jim doesn't sell full clutch kits as far as i know, he just rebuilds them, costs around a grand to have your single or twin rebuilt from him, easy to drive and he says will hold big power....

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi there,

the JB was about $1300, the OS Giken from otomoto delivered was ~2500, and I found a Gmax for ~1700, so theres a fair range. The coppermix aren't available locally that i can find, so at the weight and with potentially GSt and duties wfrom Japan, would be around the OS Giken price I guess.

Cheers

Ned

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a Nismo Gmax twin and its not really fun for daily driving. I was ok with it after a day or so but still stall it every now and then, especially after driving other cars for a while.

Pick up point is ~2/3rds of the way up and its got very little give between off and on.

Not many (if any) of my friends can drive the car anymore but doesn't slip one bit!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a Nismo Gmax twin and its not really fun for daily driving. I was ok with it after a day or so but still stall it every now and then, especially after driving other cars for a while.

Pick up point is ~2/3rds of the way up and its got very little give between off and on.

Not many (if any) of my friends can drive the car anymore but doesn't slip one bit!

The pickup point can be adjusted to be closer to the floor you know. The coppermix is 100 times better than the old G-Max, for one the clutch plates are full face not puck type.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Thanks for the replies. Jim Berry does sell complete kits, but as you say its from rebuilt hardware and new plates etc.

I have taken a punt on one of his strengthened singles (sprung organic) which will clamp to 3000lbs vs 1900 for the stocker. It comes witha new lightened flywheel, and since I couldnt read a bad thing about them, I decided to save the extra G over the OS or Nismo and put it toward other things. Hopefully I am still smiling in 12 months.

Cheers

Ned

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You didn't go for a carbotic one? I've always thought all the hot Jim Berry clutches were carbotic not organic. Or am I confused?

Hi there,

Jim tells me he has a variety of materials at his disposal, with organic giving the closest feel to stock, carbotic taking more punishment again, then I guess its carbon or kevlar. Since I commute 45mins each way daily, his recommendation for a clutch that is easily lived with was, strengthened single in organic.

cheers

Ned

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Actually, it is probably pretty legit. I mean, it's still woke feminazi bullshit academia, but you would have to agree that it is very likely that there would be a correlation between wanting a loud exhaust and scoring at the unpleasant end of the scales for dark triad personality traits. The fact that they found it didn't correlate with narcissism and only with psychopathy and sadism definitely shows that the loud exhaust thing is more of a "f**k you" than a "look at me", and I reckon that rings pretty close to most of the dickheads who take it to the extreme. Remember, this is correlation with tendency to be closer to one end of a personality trait scale than the other end. Of course someone who is at the literal opposite end of the psychopathy scale is going to be so considerate of others that they wouldn't even think about wanting to upset anyone with a loud exhaust. So the finding isn't that "you are a psychopath". Just that you score more towards that end of the scale than someone who doesn't like loud exhausts (on average, not necessarily even for specific individuals).
    • Blitz ER34 at some point hopefully, should be allowed in Gr3 if they do.
    • Stock R33 boost control, with the exhaust, and FMIC done, will boost creep. There is no tuning around it if it is the factory boost solenoid.   If it has an aftermarket electronic boost controller, the settings/mapping can be altered in it.   Oil could be anything as mentioned, however did it ever do it before you did the turbo swap? How much and how often did you drive the car before the swap?   I'm hinging on too much oil supply, or it's not draining properly.   To check, pull the air outlet off the turbo. Is it full of oil? Drop the exhaust at the turbo, does it appears to be oiled/coked? Now pull turbo and check the exhaust manifold, does it appears oiled and coked the same way?   Secondly, the PCV could even be stuffed / not functioning properly and will cause blowing of blue smoke.
    • Almost any ECU would work, from a 30 yr old PowerFC to a new Motec/Autronic. But presumably you want new middle of the road ECU, meaning that you want a Haltech or a Link, most likely. As to which model though? I dunno. I don't keep track of what they have in their current ranges. You don't want a plug in though, because plug ins can start to cause you the same wiring issues that you have to chase up with your stock ECU/loom swaps when an engine transplant is involved. If you use a Haltech (and presumably a Link) you could put the base map for the engine in and drive it around and not even need to "tune" it. It will work just fine. I can't recommend a tuner without a location (and even then I can't recommend many, being as I never use any tuners except myself and my brother-in-law). And not many tuners are happy to remote tune. Maybe they'd be happier doing it for a basically stock setup that just needs to be demonstrated to be working properly. But even then, not being able to be with the car to see what the hell is going on and sort out the inevitable problems that will result from an engine conversion done by an amateur..... unlikely to be enthusiastic about the job. And if you think that just adding 2 wires for the boost sensor is difficult - you don't want to be trying to install and set up an aftermarket ECU. You're going to have to bite down hard on something with either approach.
×
×
  • Create New...