Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 71
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Hey,

I was just wondering...

Would an NA R32 RB20DE beat a commodore or falcon v6 off the lights?

My skyline has no mods ATM, and all my m8s commos and falcons don;t either

I wouldn't think so.

All though peak power might make the power to weight look ok its the average power accelerating to that peak power that is lacking. The 2ltr really is too small for the 1320kg R32.

A good example of this is pull up next to a VL 5speed RB30E. ~116fwkw or there abouts. Mine made 80rwkw bone stock back in the day but it used to whoop 3.8ltr manual commo's. Well not whoop but just edge them out in the top end. :P

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/142303-vrs-falcodore/#findComment-2649730
Share on other sites

when i had an auto n/a 3 litre, i had no chance againts auto vs commys, used to race my mates commys all the time, could never get em off the line.. u would expect the n/a r34s to beat commys n falcons wouldnt u ?? rb25de

Edited by GTR Power
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/142303-vrs-falcodore/#findComment-2650301
Share on other sites

Yep the Vl auto box's are like rubber bands. :P

+ the 3ltr doesn't have that much down low so the only option is a manual where you can bring the rev's up and play fair. :(

I found the manual VN-VS's to feel a little sluggish off the line actually. Its as if the auto actually help them lunge off the line.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/142303-vrs-falcodore/#findComment-2650381
Share on other sites

it really depends on the driver of each car, and what model commodore. the later model, like vx and vy are heavier than the vr/vs. they have a touch more power though.

the skyline may have the same power, and be a touch lighter, but it is well down on torque. this means that you have to rev harder to get the power, where as a big aussie 6 will pull from lower in the rev range.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/142303-vrs-falcodore/#findComment-2650596
Share on other sites

Hey,

I was just wondering...

Would an NA R32 RB20DE beat a commodore or falcon v6 off the lights?

My skyline has no mods ATM, and all my m8s commos and falcons don;t either

Teh Falcon V6 can nevah lose!!!!!!

...because they don't exist.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/142303-vrs-falcodore/#findComment-2651521
Share on other sites

I've driven VX/VZ commdores and they weren't too great. A R34 non turbo would beat them no problemo if you let them rev up.

Current model falcons on the other hand are hell fast, I've floored an auto BA series 2 falcon and it gave atleast as much g-force as a stock auto R34 GT-T no shit! The non-turbo R34s would definately be beaten by a BA falcon.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/142303-vrs-falcodore/#findComment-2652242
Share on other sites

I didn't really ever want to get involved with this "this is faster than that" type thing... But my friend, who regularly rips me off decided to say my car (R32 4 Door, RB25DE) was a crappy Japanese peice of gay F***en s***. He really doesn't like imports or something, anyway he brought up this discussion which replied with nothing. I hate arguing.

Thing is, he rides dirt bikes... and just about every bike he has ridden/rides is Japanese. I don't see his point :S Typical Commodore lover, when he rips off Fords he looks at me because he knows I don't "support" Holdens... thing is I don't really "support" Fords either. I used to "prefer" them, haha in yr 6 but since I've been into imports I'm not much into Aussie Cars.

He said that his/my friend's mums VN Commo Auto Wagon, would beat my Skyline easily, now it may well be the truth I don't know, however he then went on to say that I would be there "changing gears" and from what I've read, Manuals are usually a quicker change, except from an auto racing box or something who cares. Then he said his Dad's VP Auto could beat my friends mums commodore... so in other words he said his dads car was really fast and my car was a piece of shit.

My car was weighed today: 1340kg. It's a Manual RB25DE R32 with pod and exhaust (soon :( hehe) vs a VN Commo Auto Wagon... 1500kg?

Anyway I'm just sick of him ripping of mine/my family's cars too... he continuenly says my Dad's E46 328Ci is a piece of crap etc etc. I think people should get over the "this would beat that" thing.

-Jimmy.

Edited by -Jimmy-
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/142303-vrs-falcodore/#findComment-2652948
Share on other sites

  • 9 months later...

The best way to find out is to have a race?

but think about it this way,

its a 2.0ltr vs a 3.8

the commodore rightfully should win as it is a much bigger and more pwerful enigne, regardless of the few extra kilo's the commonwhore is dragging around.

the falcodores autos dont help them as stock they are shit family cars but a manual version would win easily.

my N/A Rb25de beats them easy but the newer models are a bit faster.

the Rb20de doesnt have enough power, so basically get a turbo.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/142303-vrs-falcodore/#findComment-3283250
Share on other sites

The best way to find out is to have a race?

but think about it this way,

its a 2.0ltr vs a 3.8

the commodore rightfully should win as it is a much bigger and more pwerful enigne, regardless of the few extra kilo's the commonwhore is dragging around.

the falcodores autos dont help them as stock they are shit family cars but a manual version would win easily.

my N/A Rb25de beats them easy but the newer models are a bit faster.

the Rb20de doesnt have enough power, so basically get a turbo.

Rubbish, you'll be surprised what an RB20DE will do with some light mods. Don't just write them off. :nyaanyaa:

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/142303-vrs-falcodore/#findComment-3283619
Share on other sites

there are too many variables. it depends on model commodore/falcon as a vn/vp is much lighter than a vt/vx (infact they are about the same weight as a r32), but then the vx will put out about 30-40hp more on a dyno.

if it was standard manual ea falcon (s-pac) vs manual vp commodore, vs manual rb20de, i would say the order would be probably falcon, commodore, skyline. i used to own a manual s-pac ea falcon and they don't actually go that bad. i did it with those models as they are all about the same age.

if you were to change that scenario to late model cars, and add in a magna then the order would change slightly. the order would be something like: magna, falcon, skyline, commodore

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/142303-vrs-falcodore/#findComment-3284023
Share on other sites

Okay.

My Supra held dead level, with a R34 GTT (Auto in both)

Later on, I got my rear end handed to me by a V8 VN with an exhaust.

Basically, the R32 would most likley be beaten down like my Supra against a V8 in the VN.

Now against the V6, on the roll, I just start to loose out.

So I'd be hazarding a guess, that the R32 would loose out too (BTW, my Supra IS twin turbo)

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/142303-vrs-falcodore/#findComment-3284240
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Latest Posts

    • Great work! Give it a clean up with some Emery paper, and I'd run a thread die over the threads too to clean them up. It will make reinstall much easier, and also life easier for the next time it needs to come out.
    • I'm not a fan of high humidity, it's one reason I don't mind being further inland out Ipswich, except the last 3 odd years, the drought broke, and it won't stop raining, which is making the humidity nearly unbearable when the rains are in during summer! For me, my body hates the cold, once the cold sets into my body, I'm totally screwed. I end up with severe muscle spasm in my back/shoulder muscles, and it feels like someone is trying to tear the muscles out. I have no issues with it getting stupid hot, so long as the humidity goes away. So the last 3 years as above, have been woeful! Ha ha. However, June 1st, and I'm only just converting from shorts and a tee, to long pants and a t shirt. And that's mainly as it's a bit wet and miserable and I wanted to work on a car.
    • I much prefer colder weather to hot weather, and especially prefer cold to hot and humid, Goulburn does gets pretty warm in the hotter months, but, I've found the humidity there is not as painful as even Sydney, the humidity up north is to oppressing for this old rooster  In saying this, it does get rather "nippy" in Goulburn for early morning, late in the evening walks, but nothing that a layer or two, some thermal gloves, and a beanie doesn't fix to make it an enjoyable experience, which is much more bearable to me than the oppression of heat and humidity,  especially at night when your trying to sleep If I recall correctly, a "wise man" once said that the "Southern Tablelands" was gods country, and I will not argue that point with him for the fear of a "permaban" LOL In car part related news: My intake is currently in Botany getting processed for the last leg of its shipping journey to my door   
    • Had a go at the stuck crush tube this afternoon. Tried things like grips and a chain wrench first but wouldn't just twist straight off. So got to work with a drill. Started small and kept a depth stop on to make sure I didn't drill into the bolt. Made a line of drill holes all the way up and enlarged them. Then a combination of chisel and Dremel to split it all the way up. Levered the split to get oil in there and eventually it gave a bit while levering. Worked it back and forth with loads more oil till it was spinning freely, then with grips I could work it downwards and off. And no significant damage to the bolt (not by me anyway - just the 27 years of rust)
    • Well, I'm tired. I'm tired because about 4PM yesterday, before today's appointment someone immediately bought my bumper. They couldn't get it any other day as they're on the way back to NSW. So I had to do that big GTR conversion I had been planning. Unfortunately, the information on SAU about what you need and how this is done is incomplete. So what should be a simple bolt on affair, yeah, it's not. Did you know if you use all GTR items the bonnet won't close? This little manuever sent me into about 1am the night before trying to dodge a way to get it closed. I will have to revisit this in the next few days  - or maybe not, I may let a body shop figure it out. It all needs to come up and my motivation to pull the bumper off is low. It also seems to hit things in the bay where the GTT bonnet didn't. Yes I used 100% new OEM GTR items. Today, I had the joy of driving to the dyno looking like this: Given I had roughed in the fuel and given sensible but pretty conservative timing, I didn't really bet on having the car drive out any real difference than when it drove in. Sadly due to a miscommunication and laptop fun and games (and almost bricking the dongle, prayers and firmware updates indeed), I ended up using HP Tuner credits to licence the car that was already licenced. So in the end my laptop was used. It turns out my butt dyno is still well calibrated after all this time. The 325kw was on 74% Ethanol, the 313kw line was on 98. The other line is the 'before' line which was 281kw. While the numbers are pretty low, they're pretty in line with what you'd expect. Even if US dynos bump the whole result up about 50KW, gaining 10-15% is similar gains.  The curve of the cam is pretty much spot on with what was discussed as well. All this said, it still feels bad to not see the number you secretly want to see. Even if the car drove great beforehand, and I knew pretty confidently the car would drive out much the same way it drove in due to the nature of a wellish dialled in LS1 not gaining much if anything at all from being tuned from where it was. As expected, the car isn't particularly sensitive to running it at anywhere between 12.0 and 13.0 - And the initial timing at 20deg and 12.0 made 308KW. So 3 degrees of timing, and leaning it out to 12.7 for 5kw, anything above stopped giving any benefit until E85 (which has an additional 2 deg as before). Car itself behaved entirely fine. I found out that 100C = 1.15V! IAT at about 7pm was 19C. I might mess with the bonnet mounting.. but given the REO NEEDS TO BE CHOPPED TO FIT A GTR BAR this is possibly something I may leave gathering (more) dust until it returns to paint jail.
×
×
  • Create New...