Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

If planning on having an r33 gtst with the following:

- full exhaust (dump/front/rear)

- pod & CAI

- stock intercooler

- EBC (11psi)

what is the better way to go (considering I dont want to blow mega bucks) a Power FC or an SAFC?

I know overall a power FC is a better unit, but wanted to hear opinions from people who know or those who have gone from an SAFC and upgraded to a Power FC (with similar mods)?

Is it worth the extra $$ to go for a Power FC considering the std turbo & cooler?

The main thing in terms of making power I guess is the ability to tune ignition with the PFC, will the ignition map really be that bad with the above mods?

How much extra over the SAFC will the PFC give in terms of kW?

thanks

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/21935-safcii-vs-power-fc/
Share on other sites

definatley go for a saf-c if thats all you want to do to your car. But in terms of bang for bucks.... I'd say spend the money on a front mount intercooler, to replace that side mount heater box. You have to spend an extra $300 to $400 over a saf-c but you will not regret it.

And then later down the track you when saf-c's are becoming cheaper you could snatch that up for $300....

Only reason i say go a front mount, is because if you are considering a power fc, i take it you are willing to spend money, and a front mount intercooler is your next best investment, as far as power wise.

can get some good quality second hand ones at a decent price. Gtr ones, or something a bit smaller if you must...

best of luck,

GTST's have a restrictive intercooler if I'm not correct??? Maybe that's the better option first. As for PFC or SAFC depends on how much your going to do to it later. Even still, get a SAFC then a PFC later as there are always people wanting a SAFC anyway.

Well yeah. I would go a larger intercooler first before the ECU. Then PowerFC.

Don't buy the SAFC because you will eventually want to upgrade to the PowerFC anyway (even if you don't know it yet). Since the price difference is only $300 anyway its not a huge leap.

Oh yeah, and buy it from Japan. www.greeline.jp or www.nengun.siteblast.com. All aussie retailers having amusing prices for this stuff.

Sewid, the price difference is a lot more than $300. Looking at the Greenline site you quoted:

SAFC-II: 32918 yen = ~$422

PowerFC: 79233 yen = ~$1015

That's closer to a $600 price difference. On top of that, if you want the hand controller for the PowerFC, throw in another $360. (although admittedly you may need a fuel cut defender for the S-AFC). The S-AFC is also a lot cheaper to tune. For someone on a tight budget, I don't think you can go past a second hand S-AFC.

There is a big market for second hand S-AFC's, so even if you buy one and want to upgrade to PowerFC later, you will make most of your money back on the S-AFC. Especially if you bought second hand to start with.

I've thought about selling my S-AFC and getting a PowerFC, but the upgrade will cost me around $700 (or more) plus tuning costs. I'm already getting over 200rwkw with no pinging, so I can't justify this massive expense. Once I upgrade my injectors and can break through the 220rwkw barrier, I will look again at upgrading to a PFC. My choice was a lot easier because my car already came with a fuel cut defender and EBC.

Originally posted by JimX

Sewid, the price difference is a lot more than $300. Looking at the Greenline site you quoted:

SAFC-II: 32918 yen = ~$422

PowerFC: 79233 yen = ~$1015

There is a big market for second hand S-AFC's, so even if you buy one and want to upgrade to PowerFC later, you will make most of your money back on the S-AFC. Especially if you bought second hand to start with.

Right, yeah shouldve looked at that. I was going off the price I had seen someone selling one for locally. Shoulda figured the Jap price would've been a lot better.

As you say, yeah there seems to be a good second hand market for them, although i cant see why. I have seen a lot of people selling them second hand (on these forums for example). A 2nd hand unit rarely goes for less than you can get a new one in from japan for. Silly but true. (Did a search for SAFCII in the For Sale forum, these are the prices i found from the top 5 hits: $500, $565, $350 (bargain), $650, $570). Is the moral of that story, buy SAFCII == Profit!? Or maybe, "do no research == get ripped off".

Originally posted by sewid

Well yeah. I would go a larger intercooler first before the ECU. Then PowerFC.

Don't buy the SAFC because you will eventually want to upgrade to the PowerFC anyway (even if you don't know it yet). Since the price difference is only $300 anyway its not a huge leap.

Oh yeah, and buy it from Japan. www.greeline.jp or www.nengun.siteblast.com. All aussie retailers having amusing prices for this stuff.

I can reccomend against the upgrade of the standard intercooler on a standard turbo setup. It's value for money sucks.

99% of the gtsts with upgraded intercoolers and standard turbos eat my dust, even with my little 205 tyres and 10psi of boost.

If you want to go pretty quick on a budget of say $2k then read the 13.4 second thread, page one.

I've spent about $2.5k so far without the NOS (add $500) and that package is good enough for a 12 on reasonable tyres (unlike the ones I presently have).

S-AFC is short for Super Air Flow Converter (made by Apexi). In simpler words, it's just a mixture controller. Very popular on R33's because these cars don't have a reprogrammable ECU. It doesn't change the timing, but generally does quite a good job on mildly modded Skylines.

SAFC 1 dun have fuel cut defender. Not sure about SAFC 2.

However either someone said or wrote in some article somewhere that there was no fuel cut for over boost in R33, so buying a fuel cut defender for hi boost application for your R33 is a waste of money? Maybe the ECU just retard the timing when it senses higher boost to a point that it almost felt like a fuel cut?

so, with the mods listed above - what differences would you expect to see in rwkw with:

- adding an SAFC

- adding a pfc?

what I want to know is if the ignition map is really that bad when you are only running about 11psi (0.75bar) or is it mainly the A/F ratio which goes haywire?

If with those mods and 11psi, there isn't that much power to be gained ($800 dollars or so worth) with a PFC, then I will go the SAFC!

Most of the power gains are made by the mixture map. Timing allows for a smoother power curve and slightly better economy and power. The PowerFC also compensates for temperature so you don't have to run "safe" (richer than optimal) mixtures to cater for summer heat. It also has a few other bells and whistles like a knock sensor readout.

If you have the bucks the PowerFC is worthwhile, but on my last S-AFC tune I got around an extra 30rwkw, at which point my injectors were maxed out. I couldn't get any MORE top-end power out of the engine with the current setup, although I could gain more in the lower rev ranges with a PowerFC where my injectors aren't at full duty cycle.

If/when I upgrade my injectors I will look at upgrading to a PowerFC.

Guest Robo's

Most of the gain is in the fuel, but dont discount timing. Timing with the PFC can be added/retarded throughout the rev range. There are gains to be had there. If you have the money, get PFC, if you dont have the money get SAFC.

Most people are getting 15rwkw with A/F mixtures adjusted and about an extra with timing changes. But there maybe some midrange etc.

As Robo's said, the timing (PowerFC) will help in the lower rev range. This is assuming you set your timing based on the upper rev range where you want your peak power. That will leave the lower rev range uncatered for, and the PowerFC will help.

In theory, both the PowerFC and S-AFC will give you almost the same peak power - for the latter you just set the timing to the optimal advance in the peak of your power curve. The PowerFC is still better all round, because you can run it slightly leaner with more safety.

With my car the AFR is around 11.5:1 at full noise - which is very rich, but doesn't bother me at all because I'm still maxing out the injectors anyway. I might be able to squeeze another 5kw out of it with a PowerFC by running it a little leaner, but I've already said above, this option would cost me over $700 (over $1000 including tune).

The real question you should be asking is how much money do you want to spend? If you've got lots to burn, get the PowerFC.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Any update on this one? did you manage to get it fixed?    i'm having the same issue with my r34 and i believe its to do with the smart entry (keyless) control module but cant be sure without forking out to get a replacement  
    • So this being my first contribution to the SAU forums, I'd like to present and show how I had to solve probably one of the most annoying fixes on any car I've owned: replacing a speedometer (or "speedo") sensor on my newly acquired Series 1 Stagea 260RS Autech Version. I'm simply documenting how I went about to fix this issue, and as I understand it is relatively rare to happen to this generation of cars, it is a gigantic PITA so I hope this helps serve as reference to anyone else who may encounter this issue. NOTE: Although I say this is meant for the 260RS, because the gearbox/drivetrain is shared with the R33 GTR with the 5-speed manual, the application should be exactly the same. Background So after driving my new-to-me Stagea for about 1500km, one night while driving home the speedometer and odometer suddenly stopped working. No clunking noise, no indication something was broken, the speedometer would just stop reading anything and the odometer stopped going up. This is a huge worry for me, because my car is relatively low mileage (only 45k km when purchased) so although I plan to own the car for a long time, a mismatched odometer reading would be hugely detrimental to resale should the day come to sell the car. Thankfully this only occurred a mile or two from home so it wasn't extremely significant. Also, the OCD part of me would be extremely irked if the numbers that showed on my dash doesn't match the actual ageing of the car. Diagnosing I had been in communication with the well renown GTR shop in the USA, U.P.garage up near University Point in Washington state. After some back and forth they said it could be one of two things: 1) The speedometer sensor that goes into the transfer case is broken 2) The actual cluster has a component that went kaput. They said this is common in older Nissan gauge clusters and that would indicate a rebuild is necessary. As I tried to figure out if it was problem #1, I resolved problem #2 by sending my cluster over to Relentless Motorsports in Dallas, TX, whom is local to me and does cluster and ECU rebuilds. He is a one man operation who meticulously replaces every chip, resistor, capacitor, and electronic component on the PCB's on a wide variety of classic and modern cars. His specialty is Lexus and Toyota, but he came highly recommended by Erik of U.P.garage since he does the rebuilds for them on GTR clusters.  For those that don't know, on R32 and R33 GTR gearboxes, the speedometer sensor is mounted in the transfer case and is purely an analog mini "generator" (opposite of an alternator essentially). Based on the speed the sensor spins it generates an AC sine wave voltage up to 5V, and sends that via two wires up to the cluster which then interprets it via the speedometer dial. The signal does NOT go to the ECU first, the wiring goes to the cluster first then the ECU after (or so I'm told).  Problems/Roadblocks I first removed the part from the car on the underside of the transfer case (drain your transfer case fluid/ATF first, guess who found out that the hard way?), and noted the transfer case fluid was EXTREMELY black, most likely never changed on my car. When attempting to turn the gears it felt extremely gritty, as if something was binding the shaft from rotating properly. I got absolutely no voltage reading out of the sensor no matter how fast I turned the shaft. After having to reflow the solder on my AFM sensors based on another SAU guide here, I attempted to disassemble the silicone seal on the back of the sensor to see what happened inside the sensor; turns out, it basically disintegrated itself. Wonderful. Not only had the electrical components destroyed themselves, the magnetic portion on what I thought was on the shaft also chipped and was broken. Solution So solution: find a spare part right? Wrong. Nissan has long discontinued the proper sensor part number 32702-21U19, and it is no longer obtainable either through Nissan NSA or Nissan Japan. I was SOL without proper speed or mileage readings unless I figured out a way to replace this sensor. After tons of Googling and searching on SAU, I found that there IS however a sensor that looks almost exactly like the R33/260RS one: a sensor meant for the R33/R34 GTT and GTS-T with the 5 speed manual. The part number was 25010-21U00, and the body, plug, and shaft all looked exactly the same. The gear was different at the end, but knowing the sensor's gear is held on with a circlip, I figured I could just order the part and swap the gears. Cue me ordering a new part from JustJap down in Kirrawee, NSW, then waiting almost 3 weeks for shipping and customs clearing. The part finally arrives and what did I find? The freaking shaft lengths don't match. $&%* I discussed with Erik how to proceed, and figuring that I basically destroyed the sensor trying to get the shaft out of the damaged sensor from my car. we deemed it too dangerous to try and attempt to swap shafts to the correct length. I had to find a local CNC machinist to help me cut and notch down the shaft. After tons of frantic calling on a Friday afternoon, I managed to get hold of someone and he said he'd be able to do it over half a week. I sent him photos and had him take measurements to match not only the correct length and notch fitment, but also a groove to machine out to hold the retentive circlip. And the end result? *chef's kiss* Perfect. Since I didn't have pliers with me when I picked up the items, I tested the old gear and circlip on. Perfect fit. After that it was simply swapping out the plug bracket to the new sensor, mount it on the transfer case, refill with ATF/Nissan Matic Fluid D, then test out function. Thankfully with the rebuilt cluster and the new sensor, both the speedometer and odometer and now working properly!   And there you have it. About 5-6 weeks of headaches wrapped up in a 15 minute photo essay. As I was told it is rare for sensors of this generation to die so dramatically, but you never know what could go wrong with a 25+ year old car. I HOPE that no one else has to go through this problem like I did, so with my take on a solution I hope it helps others who may encounter this issue in the future. For the TL;DR: 1) Sensor breaks. 2) Find a replacement GTT/GTS-T sensor. 3) Find a CNC machinist to have you cut it down to proper specs. 4) Reinstall then pray to the JDM gods.   Hope this guide/story helps anyone else encountering this problem!
    • So this being my first contribution to the SAU forums, I'd like to present and show how I had to solve probably one of the most annoying fixes on any car I've owned: replacing a speedometer (or "speedo") sensor on my newly acquired Series 1 Stagea 260RS Autech Version. I'm simply documenting how I went about to fix this issue, and as I understand it is relatively rare to happen to this generation of cars, it is a gigantic PITA so I hope this helps serve as reference to anyone else who may encounter this issue. NOTE: Although I say this is meant for the 260RS, because the gearbox/drivetrain is shared with the R33 GTR with the 5-speed manual, the application should be exactly the same. Background So after driving my new-to-me Stagea for about 1500km, one night while driving home the speedometer and odometer suddenly stopped working. No clunking noise, no indication something was broken, the speedometer would just stop reading anything and the odometer stopped going up. This is a huge worry for me, because my car is relatively low mileage (only 45k km when purchased) so although I plan to own the car for a long time, a mismatched odometer reading would be hugely detrimental to resale should the day come to sell the car. Thankfully this only occurred a mile or two from home so it wasn't extremely significant. Also, the OCD part of me would be extremely irked if the numbers that showed on my dash doesn't match the actual ageing of the car. Diagnosing I had been in communication with the well renown GTR shop in the USA, U.P.garage up near University Point in Washington state. After some back and forth they said it could be one of two things: 1) The speedometer sensor that goes into the transfer case is broken 2) The actual cluster has a component that went kaput. They said this is common in older Nissan gauge clusters and that would indicate a rebuild is necessary. As I tried to figure out if it was problem #1, I resolved problem #2 by sending my cluster over to Relentless Motorsports in Dallas, TX, whom is local to me and does cluster and ECU rebuilds. He is a one man operation who meticulously replaces every chip, resistor, capacitor, and electronic component on the PCB's on a wide variety of classic and modern cars. His specialty is Lexus and Toyota, but he came highly recommended by Erik of U.P.garage since he does the rebuilds for them on GTR clusters.  For those that don't know, on R32 and R33 GTR gearboxes, the speedometer sensor is mounted in the transfer case and is purely an analog mini "generator" (opposite of an alternator essentially). Based on the speed the sensor spins it generates an AC sine wave voltage up to 5V, and sends that via two wires up to the cluster which then interprets it via the speedometer dial. The signal does NOT go to the ECU first, the wiring goes to the cluster first then the ECU after (or so I'm told).  Problems/Roadblocks I first removed the part from the car on the underside of the transfer case (drain your transfer case fluid/ATF first, guess who found out that the hard way?), and noted the transfer case fluid was EXTREMELY black, most likely never changed on my car. When attempting to turn the gears it felt extremely gritty, as if shttps://imgur.com/6TQCG3xomething was binding the shaft from rotating properly. After having to reflow the solder on my AFM sensors based on another SAU guide here, I attempted to disassemble the silicone seal on the back of the sensor to see what happened inside the sensor; turns out, it basically disintegrated itself. Wonderful. Not only had the electrical components destroyed themselves, the magnetic portion on what I thought was on the shaft also chipped and was broken. Solution So solution: find a spare part right? Wrong. Nissan has long discontinued the proper sensor part number 32702-21U19, and it is no longer obtainable either through Nissan NSA or Nissan Japan. I was SOL without proper speed or mileage readings unless I figured out a way to replace this sensor. After tons of Googling and searching on SAU, I found that there IS however a sensor that looks almost exactly like the R33/260RS one: a sensor meant for the R33/R34 GTT and GTS-T with the 5 speed manual. The part number was 25010-21U00, and the body, plug, and shaft all looked exactly the same. The gear was different at the end, but knowing the sensor's gear is held on with a circlip, I figured I could just order the part and swap the gears. Cue me ordering a new part from JustJap down in Kirrawee, NSW, then waiting almost 3 weeks for shipping and customs clearing. The part finally arrives and what did I find? The freaking shaft lengths don't match. $&%* I discussed with Erik how to proceed, and figuring that I basically destroyed the sensor trying to get the shaft out of the damaged sensor from my car. we deemed it too dangerous to try and attempt to swap shafts to the correct length. I had to find a local CNC machinist to help me cut and notch down the shaft. After tons of frantic calling on a Friday afternoon, I managed to get hold of someone and he said he'd be able to do it over half a week. I sent him photos and had him take measurements to match not only the correct length and notch fitment, but also a groove to machine out to hold the retentive circlip. And the end result? *chef's kiss* Perfect. Since I didn't have pliers with me when I picked up the items, I tested the old gear and circlip on. Perfect fit. After that it was simply swapping out the plug bracket to the new sensor, mount it on the transfer case, refill with ATF/Nissan Matic Fluid D, then test out function. Thankfully with the rebuilt cluster and the new sensor, both the speedometer and odometer and now working properly!   And there you have it. About 5-6 weeks of headaches wrapped up in a 15 minute photo essay. As I was told it is rare for sensors of this generation to die so dramatically, but you never know what could go wrong with a 25+ year old car. I HOPE that no one else has to go through this problem like I did, so with my take on a solution I hope it helps others who may encounter this issue in the future. For the TL;DR: 1) Sensor breaks. 2) Find a replacement GTT/GTS-T sensor. 3) Find a CNC machinist to have you cut it down to proper specs. 4) Reinstall then pray to the JDM gods.   Hope this guide/story helps anyone else encountering this problem!
    • perhaps i should have mentioned, I plugged the unit in before i handed over to the electronics repair shop to see what damaged had been caused and the unit worked (ac controls, rear demister etc) bar the lights behind the lcd. i would assume that the diode was only to control lighting and didnt harm anything else i got the unit back from the electronics repair shop and all is well (to a point). The lights are back on and ac controls are working. im still paranoid as i beleive the repairer just put in any zener diode he could find and admitted asking chatgpt if its compatible   i do however have another issue... sometimes when i turn the ignition on, the climate control unit now goes through a diagnostics procedure which normally occurs when you disconnect and reconnect but this may be due to the below   to top everything off, and feel free to shoot me as im just about to do it myself anyway, while i was checking the newly repaired board by plugging in the climate control unit bare without the housing, i believe i may have shorted it on the headunit surround. Climate control unit still works but now the keyless entry doesnt work along with the dome light not turning on when you open the door. to add to this tricky situation, when you start the car and remove the key ( i have a turbo timer so car remains on) the keyless entry works. the dome light also works when you switch to the on position. fuses were checked and all ok ive deduced that the short somehow has messed with the smart entry control module as that is what controls the keyless entry and dome light on door opening   you guys wouldnt happen to have any experience with that topic lmao... im only laughing as its all i can do right now my self diagnosed adhd always gets me in a situation as i have no patience and want to get everything done in shortest amount of time as possible often ignoring crucial steps such as disconnecting battery when stuffing around with electronics or even placing a simple rag over the metallic headunit surround when placing a live pcb board on top of it   FML
    • Bit of a pity we don't have good images of the back/front of the PCB ~ that said, I found a YT vid of a teardown to replace dicky clock switches, and got enough of a glimpse to realize this PCB is the front-end to a connected to what I'll call PCBA, and as such this is all digital on this PCB..ergo, battery voltage probably doesn't make an appearance here ; that is, I'd expect them to do something on PCBA wrt power conditioning for the adjustment/display/switch PCB.... ....given what's transpired..ie; some permutation of 12vdc on a 5vdc with or without correct polarity...would explain why the zener said "no" and exploded. The transistor Q5 (M33) is likely to be a digital switching transistor...that is, package has builtin bias resistors to ensure it saturates as soon as base threshold voltage is reached (minimal rise/fall time)....and wrt the question 'what else could've fried?' ....well, I know there's an MCU on this board (display, I/O at a guess), and you hope they isolated it from this scenario...I got my crayons out, it looks a bit like this...   ...not a lot to see, or rather, everything you'd like to see disappears down a via to the other side...base drive for the transistor comes from somewhere else, what this transistor is switching is somewhere else...but the zener circuit is exclusive to all this ~ it's providing a set voltage (current limited by the 1K3 resistor R19)...and disappears somewhere else down the via I marked V out ; if the errant voltage 'jumped' the diode in the millisecond before it exploded, whatever that V out via feeds may have seen a spike... ....I'll just imagine that Q5 was switched off at the time, thus no damage should've been done....but whatever that zener feeds has to be checked... HTH
×
×
  • Create New...