Jump to content
SAU Community

Is My Catch Can Set Up Right?

ClutchBurndout-:(

By ClutchBurndout-:(,
in General Maintenance

 Share

Recommended Posts

ClutchBurndout-:( Grand Master

ClutchBurndout-:(

Posted
Posted

hey all, installed a catch can over the weekend, just want to make sure its right, because when i was driving home the other day my car seemed to nearly stall for a second and i thought that i have installed the can wrong. for the record i got a catch can with the air filter, so the engine can breath.

catch.jpg

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/330356-is-my-catch-can-set-up-right/
Share on other sites
blind_elk Grand Master

blind_elk

Posted
Posted
after some research last night i changed my setup, how does this look now?

catch-1.jpg

It's supposed to be a "closed" system. The first option is open to atmosphere, which contributes to the "almost stalling" you encountered.

The second option is the way I have installed mine. But unblock the PCV hose (between valley and plenum).

ClutchBurndout-:( Grand Master

ClutchBurndout-:(

Posted
  • Author
Posted
It's supposed to be a "closed" system. The first option is open to atmosphere, which contributes to the "almost stalling" you encountered.

The second option is the way I have installed mine. But unblock the PCV hose (between valley and plenum).

how come i need to unblock the hose? wouldnt this ruin the whole setup? as the fumes would still get into the intake?

blind_elk Grand Master

blind_elk

Posted
Posted

The PCV valve in the plenum only opens under high vacuum, positive pressure jams it shut. The PCV valve is basically only open during "closed throttle", and the minimal amount of oil vapour that might be ingested isn't a problem for the engine.

The problem is when oil fumes are taken from the rocker covers and circulated back through the inlet side of the turbo. The oil (vapour) mixing with the fuel and air severely lowers the effective octane rating of the "fuel", which can cause the mixture to detonate. It won't detonate at effectively idle (throttle closed). The catch can is designed to condense the vapours so they don't reach the inlet side of the turbo.

ClutchBurndout-:( Grand Master

ClutchBurndout-:(

Posted
  • Author
Posted
The PCV valve in the plenum only opens under high vacuum, positive pressure jams it shut. The PCV valve is basically only open during "closed throttle", and the minimal amount of oil vapour that might be ingested isn't a problem for the engine.

The problem is when oil fumes are taken from the rocker covers and circulated back through the inlet side of the turbo. The oil (vapour) mixing with the fuel and air severely lowers the effective octane rating of the "fuel", which can cause the mixture to detonate. It won't detonate at effectively idle (throttle closed). The catch can is designed to condense the vapours so they don't reach the inlet side of the turbo.

so if i keep it blocked, whats the cons of that? cos id like to keep even the small amount of fumes out of there... or is there something very wrong with having it blocked?

ta

pipster11 Grand Master

pipster11

Posted
Posted

nissan did lots of research and put the pvc valve there

as did lots of other manufacturers

2nd setup looks right, but unblock the pcv, it does things at idle and light throttle but sfa on boost when your getting the most blowby

get some steel wool and put it in your catch can (making sure that non is gonna come off and go into the turbo)

the fine wool will catch the fine oil droplets, thus making the catch can more effective

ClutchBurndout-:( Grand Master

ClutchBurndout-:(

Posted
  • Author
Posted
nissan did lots of research and put the pvc valve there

as did lots of other manufacturers

2nd setup looks right, but unblock the pcv, it does things at idle and light throttle but sfa on boost when your getting the most blowby

get some steel wool and put it in your catch can (making sure that non is gonna come off and go into the turbo)

the fine wool will catch the fine oil droplets, thus making the catch can more effective

ok cheers, will look into the steel wool, and unblock the pipe, im gonna have to get some new pipe though since theres no way i getting the ball out lol

gotRICE? Veteran

gotRICE?

Posted
Posted

To me it looks like the 2nd pic that you have actually completely sealed off the cam covers from breathing at all.

Without the PCV or the breather to the intake pipe wouldnt the crank case pressure get rather high? As it has nowhere to go.

blind_elk Grand Master

blind_elk

Posted
Posted
To me it looks like the 2nd pic that you have actually completely sealed off the cam covers from breathing at all.
Not at all. The piece marked "PVC line" is the pipe back down to the turbo intake.

Basically all that has happenbed that a can has been inserted between the LHS rocker cover and the turbo intake.

gotRICE? Veteran

gotRICE?

Posted
Posted (edited)

Ahhhh i see! Makes sense now, it just looked like it had a block in it with that grey circle :D If the intake pipe was there, then i would have understood!

And i would have called it differently, as people generally relate "PCV" to the line between the intake cam cover and the IM that actually has the valve in it. The turbo breather hose just has a little brass restrictor :)

Makes complete sense now!

Im thinking of modding my setup due to other issues i encountered, like below. (3rd line closest to radiator is "MS Paint'ed" on.)

Deleted breather filter, and PCV as per factory.

CanPossible.jpg

Edited by gotRICE?
08yannch Rising Star

08yannch

Posted
Posted

i have heard about ppl putting a compressor water separator between the plenum and the rocker cover to filter out oil on that side and a catch can set up (like above) to filter out oil vapor on the other side. maybe something to look into ?

but the second set up look good just remove the ball bearing

ClutchBurndout-:( Grand Master

ClutchBurndout-:(

Posted
  • Author
Posted

why is everyone saying my setup is only venting the LHS valley cover? i have both valleys connected to one hose, then to the catch can, is this correct? both my valleys are going to the catch can correctly?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Just_a_datsun
      RB26 block, rb26 head

      By Just_a_datsun · Posted

      Block bump. $400. As above cyl 6 needs bore or sleeve.
    • Kinkstaah
      Blue slip

      By Kinkstaah · Posted

      I would think making the argument that the travel is limited by a spring flexing against a spring perch as "the same method". Later on in the document they do state that the spring can't bind on full bump travel and cannot come loose in full rebound travel as well. (which is all very sensible). The laws are actually pretty sensible and reasonable. It's just that the people who enforce and check them don't actually read them or know them accurately. "Oh, coilovers? Instant fail mate. Don't even need to look at it." - Guy who will be instantly reported by me. There is probably merit to people who do get defected for height also get defected for the suspension in that state that allows it. I did never consider the people who are complaining about coilovers being picked on are also running around at 50mm off the floor.
    • Kinkstaah
      Ethanol Content Sensor - Always at 11%?

      By Kinkstaah · Posted

      I think given SAU's knowledge of E85 we can strongly conclude that 10% ethanol in almost any situation is entirely fine. Almost all of the myths against E85 were overblown, let alone E10.
    • The Bogan
      Blue slip

      By The Bogan · Posted

      From your link See bold text, is this referring to damper settings, if so that may a issue for "some" inspectors, I cannot see aftermarket coilovers having the evidence that "must be available that its functional performance is equivalent to the original" Maybe just remove the adjustment knows and hope for the best???? Meh 5.2 Suspension travel In all instances, modifications to a vehicle’s suspension must ensure the integrity of the system and not compromise the ride quality. At least two thirds of the original suspension travel should be maintained in both directions (rebound (i.e. extension) and bump (i.e. compression)), and rebound must be limited by the same method used by the vehicle manufacturer or if this is not practicable due to the nature of the modification, an equivalent method. If an alternative method is used, evidence must be available that its functional performance is equivalent to the original.
    • Kinkstaah
      Blue slip

      By Kinkstaah · Posted

      They actually don't - They adhere to VSB14 rules just like Victoria. The rules are against CABIN adjustable height, and it quite clearly states that the height has to be within parameters. I asked the VASS engineer to confirm this when I got my car engineered and they refused to engineer the coilovers because they didn't meet the requirements for requiring engineering. (mine are height adjustable.) People "Not wanting to bother" with "Actually reading/knowing/adhering to the rules" should result in fines and immediately losing the ability to issue blue slips and/or RWC's in Vic.
×
×
  • Create New...