Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Im trying to understand this engine, i really dont want to test how far the timing goes, since the fuel here isnt that safe.... not trustworthy.

So. i got 360hp/310tq @ 18 psi on a Holset HE341 turbo. VTC Disabled. Running on 100 octane fuel. stock engine with a greddy copy intake.

I understand that this Neo rb25, comes with stronger head parts. solid lifters etc....

2 simple questions:

- How safe is it to race this engine up to 8k RPMs, ill be drifting it. So far im running 7600 rpms. Not a hitch on my last event. Running Castrol full synthetic 10-50w

- Timing map, 5000-6000 rpms high load im seeing 27-25 ignition timing, on the 6000+ range high load im seeing 23-19 timing. How are those numbers for an engine like this one? Are they low, high? What timing numbers are you guys seeing on ur setups with 98+ octane fuel and how much hp/tq,

Edit: Interesting, seems that the Stagea RB25 Neo, the first mark on the crank pulley is the TDC 0 Mark, ill have to do the timing again.

Im interested to know so i can have an idea of how this engine behaves and what timing numbers are low/safe/high for it.

On the last tune/dyno runs, we used headphones with knock sensors, we heard no noise at all other than injectors and normal noise, no knocking at all.

Thanks in advance.

Edited by Lopin18
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/445216-rb25-neo-tuning-question/
Share on other sites

I wouldn't run a 25 Neo to 8k regularly, especially in a thrashy fashion (like drift tends to be). They seem happy enough in the mid 7s. You really really really DO NOT WANT to be banging the limiter though. So out of the 2 choices of banging the limiter or setting it high enough that you don't bang it, then setting it high and revving the engine a bit too much is probably the less evil choice. On that basis, if that's your plan, then you really should consider some stronger valve springs. The Neos are shim over bucket. At the first sign of valve float they will be prone to spitting shims, and you don't want that.

The only other useful thing I have to say is, find a way to get VCT running. You want that to be working.

Less useful stuff I have to say....The stock maps have 20 - 25 degrees in the 5000-6000 range at highish loads before they drop right off to single digits at the highest mapped loads (which is part of the R&R strategy). Above 6000 at the same loads it's more consistently around 23-24 degrees. Your loads at 18psi on a bigger turbo will be much higher than these loads though. I would suspect that you running 27 degrees in that range might be a little on the high side. A lot of other timing numbers you hear from RB25 tunes are below 20 degrees at significant load. Maybe at the higher revs you're talking about here they would creep back up above 20 degrees, but I would be surprised to see a lot of them get as high as you have.

So the obvious knock detection questions need to be answered (or considered where you already have the answers).

  • Did not hear any knock = probably isn't knocking.
  • If you did not do extensive sensitivity testing = don't really know if it starts knocking at just a little more timing, or if you never hear knocking even though it must eventually knock.
  • If you play with the timing you can find the point where adding timing doesn't gain you more torque and that lets you know when to stop anyway, even if you don't hear knock.

Because you're ROM tuning, I don't know how much time you spent in the last 2 points. If you've done enough to convince yourself that you're OK, then all's good. If not then perhaps back to the dyno to find out. Using the emulator at least means you can tune live though, so you should be able to do everything that every other tuner would do, rather than the burn, test, edit, burn, test, edit, burn cycle that used to be the norm!

Hey there.. just reading your post..

Listen to GTSBoy's advice, also coming from some backyard tuning experience you've got way too much timing at those boost levels. I won't tell you exactly how to do it or not however some advice.

  • Less timing at mid range area
  • A little more timing towards the top, i.e. more than the mid range
  • RB's don't like a massive ramp in timing like other cars - unless it's on ethanol
  • at 1.3bar on 98RON at peak torque, i.e. ~ max VE anything in the 20s is way too much timing (from my tuning experience) - shops/professionals might say other wise
    • however on that note, you've got VCT disabled so the motor will take a few more degrees of timing
    • I usually pop a couple of degrees in after VCT is disabled around 5000rpm (that's my personal preference)

Thanks, now i can sort of get an idea of how the RB likes timing.

A friend had a Neo too, revving it up to 8k for several years, not a problem ever, but im not in the same range of income as him soo i probably wont go up so far, maybe ill add so i can stay of the limiter more.

On the other hand, i set base timing to 15 on the second mark of the pulley (if i remember correctly) so that would mean im running 20 which makes things more aggresive.

Im not tuning it myself, i have a well backgrounded tuner doing the work. Im just learning about the RB to have an idea of how close or far we are from safety.

Ill be enabling the VTC soon and going back on the dyno, surely ill set the timing to 15 base and retest on the dyno everything. Amazingly we didnt see any knock and when we added some degrees on the high rpm/load section of the map, we saw torque improvement, so i think we are safe as far as audio from the knock headphones and tq band goes.

I will try to get the map up here for you guys to see after i check the base timing to confirm it. Maybe ill do a run on the street and bring the map with the trail from the run.

For knock detection im using a SR20 Knock sensor, bolted to the block close to the stock knock sensors, with headphones and amplifier connected, i can hear everything, most of the time the injectors, but neither i or the tuner heard anything at any range other than the injectors. So i think we are safe in that part.

Edited by Lopin18

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Hey y'all! I'm curious about how y'all go about widebodying your cars. I noticed that when running a square setup, my front wheels are a bit more tucked in than my rear wheels. Not by much, maybe 5-10mm. This leads me to wonder - when I widebody, should I use narrower front flares and wider rear flares? I found a set of 40mm rear flares that I really like, and was thinking of pairing them with some 18mm front flares, but I don't want the car to look strange. How have others done this? Note, I'm in a sedan. Thanks!
    • And if it was anything other than an auto tranny part, it might be a problem. But seeing as all auto trannies belong in the recycling bin, it's fine.
    • I have an R32 Fenix rad. It is good.
    • All the schemas I can see, indicate your typical setup of ATF 'cooler' (read: heat exchanger) in the bottom radiator tank..ie; https://nissan.epc-data.com/stagea/wgnc34/5413-rb25det/engine/214/ ...but I can prattle on a bit here. These trannies have a thermistor in the sump ~ the TCU reads this and 1. bumps the line pressure up when the ATF is 'cold' and 2. prevents the TC lockup clutch from operating, until the ATF comes up to minimum operating temp (keeps the ATF 'churning' through the TC so it heats up quicker) -- trigger point is around 55C. In these conditions, the engine coolant temperature rises faster than the ATF temperature, and also helps heat the ATF up, which is why it's best to think of the in radiator tank setup as a heat exchanger ; the heat can flow in both directions... ...with these trannies, the 'hot' ATF comes out the front banjo bolt, flows through the cooler/heat exchanger, and returns to the box  via the rear banjo bolt. This gets a mention, due to the wildly different opinions wrt running auto trans fluid coolers ~ do you bypass the in radiator tank altogether, or put the cooler inline with the in radiator tank system...and then, do you put the additional cooler before of after the in radiator tank system?... ....fact is the nominal engine operating temp (roughly 75C), happens to be the ideal temperature for the ATF used in these trannies as well (no surprises there), so for the in radiator tank system to actually 'cool' the ATF, the ATF temp has to be hotter than that...lets say 100C -- you've got 25C of 'excess' heat, (slowly) pumping into the 75C coolant. This part of the equation changes drastically, when you've got 100C ATF flowing through an air cooled radiator ; you can move a lot more excess heat, faster ~ it is possible to cool the ATF 'too much' as it were...(climate matters a lot)... ...in an 'ideal' setup, what you're really trying to control here, is flash heating of the ATF, primarily produced by the TC interface. In a perfect world, wrt auto trans oil cooling, you want a dedicated trans cooler with builtin thermostatic valving - they exist. These should be run inline and before the in radiator tank system ~ when 'cold' the valving bypasses the fin stack, allowing the ATF to flow direct to the in radiator tank heat exchanger, so it works 'as intended' with helping heat the ATF up. When 'hot' (iirc it was 50C threshold), the valving shuts forcing the ATF through the cooler fin stack, and onto the in radiator tank heat exchanger...and you sort of think of it as a 'thermal conditioner' of sorts...ie; if you did cool your ATF down to 65C, the coolant will add a little heat, otherwise it works as intended... ...the 'hot' ATF coming from the front bango bolt, is instantiated from the TC when in use, so all/any flash heated oil, flows to the fluid-to-air cooler first, and because of the greater heat differential, you can get rid of this heat fast. Just how big (BTU/h) this cooler needs to be to effectively dissipate this TC flash heat, is the charm...too many variables to discuss here, but I just wanted to point out the nitty-gritty of automatic trans fluid coolers ~ they're a different beastie to what most ppl think of when considering an 'oil cooler'... /3.5cents   
    • Been a busy but productive day. Axle and hubs acquired. All fitted up after a bit of modifying. Need to sort out wider mudguards and running light reflector covers but other than that the trailer is gooood to go !!
×
×
  • Create New...