Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

what about the internals used - forged internals will read higher knock - yes ?

this is especially so when the engine is cold.

I get readings in the 40-55 range on my R32 GTR - but dyno testing show no ping (thank god!!)

I've spoken to guys that have built and raced GTRs for many years - and the answer to this question depends on many factors. So I guess - the correct answer is - it depends

Get your car on a dyno – that's the only way to tell for sure (AFAIK)

Forged internals won't read higher.. Maybe if they are running super sloppy clearances, if that were the case the motor wouldn't last much longer than 25,000km's.

The knock sensor works off various frequency's..

I have forged pistons in the 3ltr that run on the sloppy side, to Wiseco's 24+psi/race spec. They see a max of 10 on start up, once idling and you can hear the pistons slapping away, knock is 1.

When reading knock levels I think the trick is to watch the graph, under acceleration it will rise up and hold fairly even, ping or detonation is when you see sharp little spikes. If yours is rising to 45-55 and those values are consistent, i.e no spikes then there's no need to worry.

Also remember a little spike here and there won't hurt a fairly stock motor, push 300rwkw+ through it and its a different story.

Edited by Cubes
  blk180 said:
yer my car will idle at 3-7 but a WOT can get up to 25-30 and have seen it get to 42 max when backing off mainly was tuned on a dyno

you'll find that what you have just stated is pretty damn spot on

  Cubes said:
Forged internals won't read higher.. Maybe if they are running super sloppy clearances, if that were the case the motor wouldn't last much longer than 25,000km's.

The knock sensor works off various frequency's..

I have forged pistons in the 3ltr that run on the sloppy side, to Wiseco's 24+psi/race spec. They see a max of 10 on start up, once idling and you can hear the pistons slapping away, knock is 1.

I have wiseco's too - not sure on the clearance - but it's VERY niosy @ start up, and I get higher knock readings (still under 50 tho)

  Quote
When reading knock levels I think the trick is to watch the graph, under acceleration it will rise up and hold fairly even, ping or detonation is when you see sharp little spikes. If yours is rising to 45-55 and those values are consistent, i.e no spikes then there's no need to worry.

good advice - I have not looked for this - but I think I'm OK

  Quote
Also remember a little spike here and there won't hurt a fairly stock motor, push 300rwkw+ through it and its a different story.

well - I am pulling 300awkw - so why is that different (knochk is knock - right) ?

  itbmils said:
I have wiseco's too - not sure on the clearance - but it's VERY niosy @ start up, and I get higher knock readings (still under 50 tho)

good advice - I have not looked for this - but I think I'm OK

well - I am pulling 300awkw - so why is that different (knochk is knock - right) ?

Its interestering you get high knock readings on start up, I know of an other R32 that on startup spikes to 50 or so. Why it does this I don't know, it shouldn't but it does.

I have heard some VT Commodores ping on start up.

Probably just a bad ignition timing and rich cold start afr mixture causing a rapid uneven burn.

Detonation is detonation but when you make more power you have higher combustion pressures, as a result a little detonation is much more likely to damage something. Exactly why those little old ford lasers can rattle along for many years without cracking a piston. :D

mine registers about 30-40 on startup

I reckon its something to do with the starter motor on the flywheel

Engage that while the motor is going, I see about 40 knock if I do that

OK

let's take this thread in slightly different direction

is what the PFC reads as knock actually detonation ?

WAIT !! before you answer ....

I have just had a power run done this morning - and one of the things I asked them to look at was knock. My PFC will sit @ ~40 all day - even under light load and low boost, but I have no signs of detonation (or so I'm told). This has been checked and rechecked by three different workshops on three different dynos and three different days.

if the man with the head phones on says – no ping – then I happy with that :(

My understanding is that the knock sensors will pick up ANY noise – and translate that into a reading on the PFC hand controller. This supports my understanding that if you have forged internals with large clearances – you'll get what the PFC picks up as knock – but it's not actually detonation – it's just a noisy engine.

I had an old 323 BMW that had the same thing once.

I have weisco pistons – and I do no know what clearances where used – but I do know that I can hear the forged internals – even once the engine is warm. So if I can hear them – so can the PFC.

This is all just my opinion, and opinions can be changed – so I'm happy to hear evidence to the contrary.

I have wisecos @ 87mm.. i don't really hear the piston slap, and the motor doesn't sound any different once warmed up. My knock gauge on the pfc floats around 0-25 while just driving around normally. No abormal knock value upon startup.. my guess is around 0-10 on the start. haven't gunned it yet on the new motor (no tune)

so - I'm guessing I have a loose motor

clearance was set by Marty White from John White Racing up here in Bribane. They also did the hone and deck of the block and a port and polish (reco) of the head.

He does the work for Theo W - so that was good enough for me (yes I spoke to Theo before going to him)

Might just be an 'over active' knock sensor. Picking up frequency's it shouldn't or something?!? :P

On that note now the warmer weather is here I can't actually here any knock. I had a listen this morning.. No Slap, water temp was 24degree's before I had started the car first thing this morning.

Last winter some mornings I saw water temps of 2degree's. :D

Edited by Cubes

i havent noticed much more knock since air temp's have increased. if anything they are a little better. i dont get any knock on startup. i think knock of over 100 ish is "detonating" as ive never heard mine ping on the road. only time ive ever heard my car ping was stock everything and i ran 1 bar (bypassed the actuator by accident) and then it pinged its ass off

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • I came here to note that is a zener diode too base on the info there. Based on that, I'd also be suspicious that replacing it, and it's likely to do the same. A lot of use cases will see it used as either voltage protection, or to create a cheap but relatively stable fixed voltage supply. That would mean it has seen more voltage than it should, and has gone into voltage melt down. If there is something else in the circuit dumping out higher than it should voltages, that needs to be found too. It's quite likely they're trying to use the Zener to limit the voltage that is hitting through to the transistor beside it, so what ever goes to the zener is likely a signal, and they're using the transistor in that circuit to amplify it. Especially as it seems they've also got a capacitor across the zener. Looks like there is meant to be something "noisy" to that zener, and what ever it was, had a melt down. Looking at that picture, it also looks like there's some solder joints that really need redoing, and it might be worth having the whole board properly inspected.  Unfortunately, without being able to stick a multimeter on it, and start tracing it all out, I'm pretty much at a loss now to help. I don't even believe I have a climate control board from an R33 around here to pull apart and see if any of the circuit appears similar to give some ideas.
    • Nah - but you won't find anything on dismantling the seats in any such thing anyway.
    • Could be. Could also be that they sit around broken more. To be fair, you almost never see one driving around. I see more R chassis GTRs than the Renault ones.
    • Yeah. Nah. This is why I said My bold for my double emphasis. We're not talking about cars tuned to the edge of det here. We're talking about normal cars. Flame propagation speed and the amount of energy required to ignite the fuel are not significant factors when running at 1500-4000 rpm, and medium to light loads, like nearly every car on the road (except twin cab utes which are driven at 6k and 100% load all the time). There is no shortage of ignition energy available in any petrol engine. If there was, we'd all be in deep shit. The calorific value, on a volume basis, is significantly different, between 98 and 91, and that turns up immediately in consumption numbers. You can see the signal easily if you control for the other variables well enough, and/or collect enough stats. As to not seeing any benefit - we had a couple of EF and EL Falcons in the company fleet back in the late 90s and early 2000s. The EEC IV ECU in those things was particularly good at adding in timing as soon as knock headroom improved, which typically came from putting in some 95 or 98. The responsiveness and power improved noticeably, and the fuel consumption dropped considerably, just from going to 95. Less delta from there to 98 - almost not noticeable, compared to the big differences seen between 91 and 95. Way back in the day, when supermarkets first started selling fuel from their own stations, I did thousands of km in FNQ in a small Toyota. I can't remember if it was a Starlet or an early Yaris. Anyway - the supermarket servos were bringing in cheap fuel from Indonesia, and the other servos were still using locally refined gear. The fuel consumption was typically at least 5%, often as much as 8% worse on the Indo shit, presumably because they had a lot more oxygenated component in the brew, and were probably barely meeting the octane spec. Around the same time or maybe a bit later (like 25 years ago), I could tell the difference between Shell 98 and BP 98, and typically preferred to only use Shell then because the Skyline ran so much better on it. Years later I found the realtionship between them had swapped, as a consequence of yet more refinery closures. So I've only used BP 98 since. Although, I must say that I could not fault the odd tank of United 98 that I've run. It's probably the same stuff. It is also very important to remember that these findings are often dependent on region. With most of the refineries in Oz now dead, there's less variability in local stuff, and he majority of our fuels are not even refined here any more anyway. It probably depends more on which SE Asian refinery is currently cheapest to operate.
    • You don't have an R34 service manual for the body do you? Have found plenty for the engine and drivetrain but nothing else
×
×
  • Create New...