Jump to content
SAU Community

Mongoose Or Viper?


rb25_r32
 Share

Recommended Posts

Well i've found one fundamental design flaw which means i WONT be buying the Viper 791... Something Chris and other may have touched on, but not clearly explained. If i was to buy the viper, i would be buying it as a remote start and turbo timer TOY, not an alarm or immobiliser, not for security.

Immobilisers normally have circuits which are Normally Open (NO). This means the immobilisation circuit is open, and car will not start, until the alarm module disarms, and applies power to the circuit. Cut power to the alarm, and the car will not start, because the immobilier needs to power up the relay to close the immobilised circuit.

The viper is a Normally Closed (NC) system, the circuit is normally closed, and the alarm must apply power to break the circuit. ie, cut the one power wire to the alarm, and the immobiliser will not keep the circuit open, meaning the circuit is not immobilised and the car can be started. Not a good immobiliser!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...
Hi Chris.

This Mongoose alarm on ebay says it is Aust standard certified. So this should be fine to get installed right? The difference in price is huge!

http://cgi.ebay.com.au/MONGOOSE-M80G-CAR-A...1QQcmdZViewItem

if you want to pay EVERYTIME it breaks - yes. it has NO warranty despite what the seller says. (they are not a dealer and other dealers WILL NOT warrant it.)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

if you want to pay EVERYTIME it breaks - yes. it has NO warranty despite what the seller says. (they are not a dealer and other dealers WILL NOT warrant it.)

Because alarms break so often too....

And other dealers will warrant it.. You may not.. but don't speak for every installer/dealer around

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey Chris i did sum research on the mongoose wedsite n it says got 11 programmable features. what r they ? can we get a module or something make it to auto start ?

Thanks

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hey Chris i did sum research on the mongoose wedsite n it says got 11 programmable features. what r they ? can we get a module or something make it to auto start ?

Thanks

it does haev them. no module for RS though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

yeah I've got a Viper 791. I've found it to be great. I had my installer put in an extra two immobiliser points, plus a remote kill switch...

I dont know how helpful this will be for insurance purposes, although its bound to slow the pros down for at least another 30 seconds! :happy:

The remote start feature is the best thing about it for me.. The amount of damage I'm saving on the engine is not calculable, but surely good in the long run. That marketing campaign a few years back for an oil company said that a majority of engine damage is done when the engine is cold. Anyway thats just a perk.

If I had my choice again, I'd have a very difficult decision - although I'd probably end up with the M80 for security purposes. People cant say that their Viper alarm is great because their car hasnt been stolen! It's not until you lose your car that you will change your mind! haha

The remote start and auto window winding is awesome, although window winding can be implemented into most alarms i think?

Conclusion:

Buy the Viper for - Remote start, Flashy remote, 2 Way paging (only if its parked in your garage or within a few hundred metres- sif you aint gonna hear the exhaust anyway!!), engine saving ability if you religiously use the remote start to warm your engine

Buy the M80 for - Security - Black Wiring = harder to steal, Insurance approved (check the viper with your insurance company tho), possibly cheaper, easier to find replacement parts

using remote start to warm your engine is the worst possible thing you could do to your motor, and is causing more engine wear. yes most engine wear is caused when the engine is cold, starting your car when old, then letting it idle for an extended period and SLOWLY warm up just prolongs the amount of time the engine is operating at less than optimum temp. you should be hopping in the car, starting it, let it set for 10 seconds to ensure the oil temp is up, then drive out and heat the engine by driving it.

as for the viper being good, listen to what the car security pro's keep saying over and over. they have wanky features, but zero substance. I'd much rather have my car unstolen then have a massive fancy remote and useless features.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the previous owner installed a viper alarm. but i have no idea what it is. can anybody tell me how the hell i can find out? i've checked the engine bay and i can't seem to find where the module is.

if somebody could pm me with the possible location of the module(for security purposes obviously) that would great.

EDIT: fortunateley the owner before that(the first owner) fitted a 3-point vdo immobiliser which i am thinking of reconnecting in place of the viper. i just did a few tests. i prefer the vdo.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

the previous owner installed a viper alarm. but i have no idea what it is. can anybody tell me how the hell i can find out? i've checked the engine bay and i can't seem to find where the module is.

if somebody could pm me with the possible location of the module(for security purposes obviously) that would great

most likely under drivers side dash

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
 Share




  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Opened up the cluster to inspect the gauge itself for signs of damage and it looks good. Got curious since that needle doesn't go back to a "neutral" position by itself (it stays in the same position when ignition is off. so I manually moved it to 1/2. Connected it back, turned on the ignition and the needle started moving up! Not sure what's up with that but before that the needle was way down below empty like fully south west. There's always a chance that the needle moved slightly the first time I tried and I didn't notice because of how slowly it moves and how far it was from the markings. I don't know if the current needle position is accurate so I'll fill it up and see where that brings it. I guess I'll try to adjust it manually if it doesn't get to F. Looks like the needle position is relative and not absolute? Thanks all for your help and patience!
    • You're confusing two different responders and more than one issue. The stock Neo ECU boost sensor is used by the ECU for protection purposes. It is essentially only an overboost sensor. It is not used for determining engine load for fuelling or ignition purposes. That task falls solely to the AFM. Any aftermarket ECU that either has an onboard MAP sensor or a plug in one, will use the MAP sensor as the primary load sensor. Or I should perhaps say "can", rather than "will", because some of them have the option of using other primary load sensors. That MAP sensor is not for the same function as the stock Neo boost sensor. The reason I recommended against a plug and play ECU is that they are intended to run a particular engine and usually in the car that the particular engine came in. So, if you have a transplanted engine in a different car, with some parts of the original missing (such as the boost sensor, for example) and therefore likely non-standardness of the loom and its insertion into the car's loom, then it is very likely that you will run into the same problems with needing to fix up wiring to make it work that you would with the stock ECU. And, if doing so for the stock ECU is enough of an obstacle that you start considering a standalone plugin as a solution, it should become clear that the plugin is quite possibly not the solution you'd hope it to be. It would just lead to more of the same type of problem solving work to get it going. In the above paragraph and in my earlier post, the lack of the boost sensor is not critical. It was just used as an example of something that we knew you did not have right, such that the stock ECU would not work. I took that as an indicator of a reasonable probability that there were other related problems hiding there.
    • I can think of two places in my city of <1.5million population that specialise in automotive instrument repairs.Unless you're out in the wilds of Quebec, you have 3 major Canadian and 3 major US cities within the same distance as the single nearest city to mine. Surely there is somewhere you could send it.
    • I never cared for twins but whenever these conversations came up, I always presumed the higher number represented a larger turbo. Learn something new everyday. 
    • Interesting, I've never seen a failure like that before but with the age of these cars and the general questionable-ness of all kinds of parts these days you can't rule anything out I suppose. Boost leak testing the boost control system would've revealed this though.
×
×
  • Create New...