Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Ive been thinking about the need for running aftermarket main studs instead of the standard bolts, and at what point aftermarket is really needed.

Researching engine failures, it seems very rare that a bottom end failure occurs except through oil surge related issues. And even then the failures occur more on rod journels than on the mains.

Id like to know if anyone has ever had a failure due to the main bolts stretching or letting go?

anything up to 350rwkw and I wouldn't bother. after that they are worth looking at depending what else is going into the build and how much power you're ultimately after. :)

Remember that main studs will pull the crank bearing surfaces out of round (higher tensioning) requiring re- machining, which is a little more complicated than normal tunnel boring with the RB26 due to the one piece cradle cap apparently, ask a reputable machine shop about it.

Thanks for the feedback there guys. Kind of a mixed bag of responses. I follow doo doo about pulling the mains out of round. It makes sense.

Does anyone shuffle pin (Hollow dowel around the main studs) the girdle to the engine block, or is that considered overkill?

So it seems that nobody has managed to break a girdle or crank other than by having a bearing spin or a rod thrown. So just using good head studs is where ARP bolts seem to be really needed to stop the head lifting. And 1/2" seems the go there if your going custom.

I cant help but think about what those RIPS guys do with RB30's and standard main bolts...

I have them in my car. Tomei 2.8 stroker, GT block running anything up to 1.9 bar through twin RS's revving no more then 8300RPM. 12000 KMS and no issues :P Although mine are Jun main studs.

I wonder if people are using the factory torque specs for tightening the arp studs down on the cradle, or do ARP recommend a higher tension?

The whole point of a bolt is that is has a designed in degree of elastacity so that it can stretch a little under load, and while an arp bolt can be tightened to a higher tension its not necessarily a good thing that it is. The possability that it could distort the block for example.

So if a bolt is tightened to factory specs results in the factory designed in level of block distortion, but the bolt can also handle considerably more stress (from the engine bottom end taking a 9000+ RPM pounding) before it stretches beyond safe limits then that is possibly the way to go.

The last engine I assembled used carillo 5/16th WMC5 conrod bolts, and for curiosity sake I torqued them to spec in stages and measured the bolt stretch to see how it related to the applied torque tension. The results were:

30ft-lb - 3 thou

35ft-lb - 4 thou

40ft-lb - 4.5 thou

43ft-lb - 5 thou

45ft-lb - 5.1 thou

46ft-lb - 7 thou

Normal 5/16th arp 2000 bolts only go to 28ft-lb and have the same bolt stretch of 7 thou. ARP 8740 were something like 24ft-lb.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Just wanted to pop in an update on my setup. The CD swap has been great, I love the mazworks housing for the overall simplicity. I ended up sealing my trans tunnel with a thin sheet of aluminum reused some of the holes on the trans tunnel, and laid some window sealing EPS foam around the edges. Works great, really quieted things down and sealed up the car.  As for the power comment. Right now I am also running about 650whp. with the way the bell housing is attached to the face of the transmission I have zero doubts it would be fine, mainly because the input shaft and main shaft bearings are seated into the bell housing adapter. This means the load is NOT on the bolts to maintain the power, rather into he casing of the bell housing; Yes the bolts are doing some work there, but with both shafts locked in zero worries.  End of the day, the Mazworks solution is the easiest and safest. no need to take your trans to a shop to get milled perfectly, it fits with minimal clearancing, and you can use all your existing clutch and flywheel.  Driving wise the CD has been great compared to the big box, I'll probably swap my final drive at some point. The serial 9 shifter is gooooood, my only qualm is how tight it is, it takes a fair bit to get use to, 5th and 6th are a bit eh/hard to find at times, but maybe I need re-adjusting, and I think my clutch master is very tired and needs a rebuild. 
    • If you are keen, have a look at my build thread. Car is for sale for the right money or straight swap for a F80 M3 LCI.
    • Welcome mate.  No point in over thinking it, buying any one of those cars you mentioned is not a smart or logical choice with the availability of many "better" (re price to performance) cars available to you.  The heart wants what the heart wants, buy whatever it leads you too.
    • Hey everyone! Im so grateful to be apart of this community and ill do my best to be apart of this. Firstly, i'm not disclosing my real name due to in real life circumstances surrounding my privacy and public image (sorry lol) Secondly, The only thing personal I am willing to share is that I'm from Sydney and a descendant of one of Sydneys largest mortgage firms. I got gifted my first ever car, a 2022 Porsche Cayenne and I love it to death. Ive been driving it for about 5 or 6 months now and honestly Im so grateful for my parents for gifting me this vehicle. However recently I've been working my ass off to afford my second car (which I need help deciding soooooo community help me out please?). Once decided, im planning to try modify it myself. Recent I've been thinking about getting a Skyline, particularly a 25GT or GT-V, yes I know overrated as hell, but I'm also considering a Chaser which I recently came to love. However my dream is to one day own a 180SX (So hard to find clean versions and im not really into importing).  Lastly before I send this off, I want to apologize if I sound tacky or pretentious. I try not to and want to genuinely learn from everyone and anyone. (Im no expert in this area) Thanks for reading!
    • I've got three stashed away but it's starting to get silly with the prices 
×
×
  • Create New...