Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

G'day,

So on top of my Turbo flutter noises which worsened in the hills at the snow, yesterday, on my way back to Sydney the stagea decided to play up on me a couple of times throughout the drive.


So first thing i noticed, and i do get this very occasionally so thought nothing of it, was i got a mild shudder through the drive system, sort of like the gear box is thinking about changing gear then doesn't, backing off the throttle has always cleared it, and i've read of other people having similar issues without any on going issues, but after what happened yesterday i'm beginning to wonder.


So yesterday i slowed down to round a corner at an intersection, just after i went around the bend, during light acceleration, i flicked the high beams on, and the car dropped back to what i suspect was first gear, revs shot up to 4500RPM, as i was doing maybe 40-60kph but didn't really look, but they shot up, and stayed there until i did the whole wtf, and moved it from 'D' into tiptronic mode and went up a couple of gears. I put it back into drive and continued on driving a bit puzzled by what had just happened. I didn't make the connection that it happened when i flicked the highbeams on, and continued using them as required along the drive.

About two hours later on the Hume this time doing 110kph, again, i flicked the high beams on and the car dropped back maybe 2 gears to 3rd, and the revs again shot up to 4500ish RPM, and it stayed there again until I went into tiptronic. This time i noticed that the AT transmission light came on, and possibly a few others, until i selected tip tronic. Confused again, and a bit nervous that the car might try and drop down to first gear or something at freeway speed I pulled over, switched the car off, popped the bonnet and had a look around in the engine bay and underneath the car for any thing leaking or looking untoward. The only thing i noticed, and i'm not sure whether this is completely normal or not, but the rear diff casing was too hot to touch, but i had been sitting at 110kph for a couple of hours. I phoned a mechanic mate and he recommended that so long as i hear no grinding clunking sounds or anything out of the ordinary i limp it home,which i did at about 80kph. I also decided not to try the high beams again.


Just around the corner from home, this time going 40 odd kph, i tested the high beams again. This time there was no gear changes, or none that i noticed, but the instrument cluster lit up with every warning light, just like when you start the car, and my passengers noted that the aircon displays and radio switched off for a split second. Once home and stationary i tried the high beam again with no issues.


I'm at a complete loss as to what all that was about, if its a gear box issue or an electrical issue thats causing this problem. Any advice as to how i go about fixing this issue, whether i go to a auto electrician, a auto gear box specialist or just a mechanic would be really appreciated. I need the use of my car, including freeway driving ASAP and at the moment i'm not even keen to take it around the block.

Cheers for the help


Nick

That is very odd Nick, the high beams are controlled by the BCM and the auto by the TCU, the only thing connecting them is the battery and fuse/relay box.

Was it raining at all?

I would start by cleaning the battery terminals and checking the relay box behind the battery for moisture/corrosion. It sounds like there is a short somewhere...

Further to what Scotty (quite rightly) said, also think about getting your battery tested if it's older than a few years.

I've seen a slightly tired battery cause 'weird' issues that only came good after it was replaced. I've never had a car before where a dud battery caused the most random symptoms. Hope you get it sorted.

Cheers for the advice,

Checked the battery, negative terminal was perhaps a little loose but otherwise fine, still cleaned them both and put them back on. Relay box seemed fine, no fuses blown or any sign of moisture. Checked around the engine bay for all the earthing points that i could see/find.


As far as battery goes, I had it replaced just prior to my drive across from Perth, about 6000kms, and two weeks ago, so I would have thought it was fine. I've had no other funny things going on up until this point aside from the annoying turbo flutter on medium/light throttle.

So aside from perhaps being caused by a loose negative terminal I'm still at a loss. Is it possible for the gearbox to shift down to say first at freeway speeds? I guess thats my main concern at this point destroying the box and or the engine... confidence in the car is at a new low :unsure:

Not likely to be the battery then, but could have been the loose terminal. I know my neg battery terminal is slightly too small for the clamp (even when tight it could be moved by hand). I wrapped copper wire around the terminal & then pressed the clamp over. Now it's tight when done up & has not given me any more trouble.

I doubt the TCU would allow the gearbox to drop into a gear lower than it could handle at any given road speed (the speed wire goes in/out of the TCU so it would 'know').

Just a theory:- the loose battery connection caused your car to think the battery wasn't up to the task when you flicked on high beam, so dropped the gears down to produce higher revs for alternator to boost current.

Could be way off, but let us know if it does/doesn't come back so we can all learn/help more etc.

Edited by Commsman

Commsman, you could be onto something there, my (apprentice)mechanic mate mentioned something along those lines, albeit not knowing the battery terminal was loose, but said he had heard of cars doing it before to compensate for a lack of electrical power for one reason or another.

I need to do a couple of trips to and from Newcastle this week, so that'll be the test I suppose.

Cheers Craig I really appreciate the offer. Like I said I'll be two-ing and fro-ing a bit this week so just let me know when suits. I'm manly way anyway so not that too far any other time.

Chatted to mechanic mate again, said that given the loose terminal, he'd be surprised if it were anything else causing the car to play up.

  • 2 weeks later...

almost 1500km since having this issue. no repeat in plenty of night driving selecting high beam etc looking like the loose terminal was the probable cause.

any further thoughts anyone?

almost 1500km since having this issue. no repeat in plenty of night driving selecting high beam etc looking like the loose terminal was the probable cause.

any further thoughts anyone?

Yeah, make sure my battery terminals are nice and tight!

Crazy.....

almost 1500km since having this issue. no repeat in plenty of night driving selecting high beam etc looking like the loose terminal was the probable cause. any further thoughts anyone?

Loose terminals & dying batteries seem to be the source of most random NM35 electrical gremlins.

Mine did all kinds of weird stuff when the battery was dying.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • I normally run with I think a 10mm, and definitely use the second handle you can add to a drill. They hurt when they bins up!   For the crush tube, once all subframe is clear, I'd try some stilsons and see if I can get it to start to twist.
    • Probably because they couldn't, because the use of the variable resistor to create a "signal" in the ECU is managed by the ECU's circuitry. The only way that VDO could do it would be if they made a "smart" sensor that directly created the 0-5V signal itself. And that takes us back to the beginning. Well, in that case, you could do the crude digital (ie, binary, on or off) input that I mentioned before, to at least put a marker on the trace. If you pressed the button only at a series of known integer temperatures, say every 2°C from the start of your range of interest up to whatever you can manage, and you know what temperature the first press was at, then you'd have the voltage marked for all of those temperatures. And you can have more than one shot at it too. You can set the car up to get the oil hot (bypass oil coolers, mask off the air flow to oil coolers, and/or the radiator, to get the whole engine a bit hotter, then give it a bit of curry to get some measurements up near the top of the range.   On the subject of the formula for the data you provided, I did something different to Matt's approach, and got a slightly different linear formula, being Temp = -22.45*V + 118.32. Just a curve fit from Excel using all the points, instead of just throwing it through 2 points. A little more accurate, but not drastically different. Rsquared is only 0.9955 though, which is good but not great. If you could use higher order polynomials in the thingo, then a quadratic fit gives an excellent Rsquared of 0.9994. Temp = 2.1059*V^2 - 34.13*V + 133.27. The funny thing is, though, that I'd probably trust the linear fit more for extrapolation beyond the provided data. The quadratic might get a bit squirrely. Hang on, I'll use the formulae to extend the plots.... It's really big so you can see all the lines. I might have to say that I think I really still prefer the quadratic fit. It looks like the linear fit overstates the temperature in the middle of the input range, and would pretty solidly understate what the likely shape of the real curve would say at both ends.
    • I got a hand held bisssel one and it's a piece of shit. Doesn't work for more than about 5 seconds. So much so that I nearly refuse to believe any wet dry vac actually works or has enough suction to clean the carpet of a car. I'm discouraged as all the good ones are $300+ for an unknown result. I saw MCM did a Ryobi video where they use this thing: https://www.ryobi.com.au/products/stick-vacuum-cleaners/18v-one-hptm-brushless-spot-cleaner-tool-only Anyone have any experience actually using a tool like this when not paid to showcase it?
    • That could very well be the thermistor, but the ECU only sees Volts. VDO don't seem to provide a 0-5 volt curve, only the resistance curve.... (or line).
    • Yes. Probably, given that there is only access from the bottom end of it, go with a drill bit. Don't start too small. 7 or 8mm is probably the right size. You want something that can make a big enough hole to do some damage, but not so bit that it clashes with the steel or binds up and breaks your wrist. A slow speed is probably a good idea too. Once the rubber is destroyed, you then have to get the crush tube off the stud, which will be the whole heat/oil/cutting exercise all over again, but this time with the need to strictly avoid damaging the stud (any further than the corrosion might already have done.
×
×
  • Create New...