Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

On Monday, A Current Affair had a report on tests between regular, premium and high octane petrol, efficiency, cleanliness, cost-effectiveness, yadda yadda... saw the preview on Monday morning, so I got my mate to tape it for me.

And here are the results... well... it's actually a copy and paste job from a chat log on msn... here goes

me: Oh yeah how was that program anyway on current affair

my mate says: yeah theres not much difference apparently

my mate says: between 98ron and normal 96 octane premium

my mate says: well not enough to warrant the price

my mate says: the mileage worked out being more for the car that had normal premium

me: tf

my mate says: it traveled like 1.5km further than the 98ron

my mate says: i doubt the accuracy of those tests tho

my mate says: they used 3 new accords

my mate says: but like, the cars might have been different in some way

my mate says: a more accurate way wouldve been just to use the same car and measure from the trip meter instead of line up 3 different cars at the same time and see how far each one goes

my mate says: eitherway

my mate says: the main difference between 98 and 96 is a pollution factor

my mate says: which i dont really care about

my mate says:so im going for shell premium

my mate says: u can use the coles discount voucher there too :)

Anyone else watch it or hear otherwise? feel free to disagree nicely, justify, etc etc... for example, i wonder if results are same for turbo'd cars (since the tested car was an accord) ...?

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/77888-regular-vs-premium-vs-98-octane/
Share on other sites

yeh i get way more kms out bp 98 than any other fuel?by the way i have only used shit fuel when nothing else was round and just cruized home!plus i once put normal fuel in my vl turbo and just would not run right ended up draining the fuel

The go with the fuel was touched on in the earlier post.

98 RON does help stop the onset of detonation in a turbocharged car.

Bare with me here guys as I am not a Lab Tech.

With normally aspriated cars the use of normal premium is fine and the use of 98 Octane products is a personal choice.

But with a car running forced induction, a better burning fuel as well as a fuel that combusts better under load is prefered. While under load a 98 Octane fuel actually burns better / or for a better wording explodes in a more prefered manner.

*Taken from the Web*

*If you are running too low of an octane for your motor, you will get

pinging. Pinging in its extreme form is also known as detonation. The

fuel/air mixture is igniting all at once and exploding instead of igniting

as a flame wave. The resultant "bang" is very hard on the pistons, head,

rods, and cranks.*

I have been using BP Ultimate while I have been here in QLD, but while I was in Sydney i was using Mobil Synergy 8000, both fuels out perform the shell product in my opinion.

Hope this helps.... I am sure it is as clear as mud!

Mike

Bugger the economy , fuel is a consumable , like tyres & gearboxs! :thumbsup:

I dyno'd my old soarer on Vortex then BP & the 98 gave 6hp more!..... go the power

Having said that , I have a company Starcard so the line is tuned for Vortex.... works fine...

crap mileage (Tho that MAY be the driving style) :burnout:

Wow - Well you know what I've only ever filled up like $10 of crap petrol in the last 2.5 years I've had my car - and that was only to get home obviously.

The rest of the time it's been BP Ultimate - something about me being anal about servicing and car care might have something to do with it :P

I wish I could honestly compare but having never used the shit I cant :thumbsup:

i used to use Shell vortex stuff in my car and it used to ping and shit... changed to BP 98 and its sooooooo much better... the car has cleaned out so much and is totally running better....

its a little bit more $$ but the BP 98 is worth it :thumbsup:

If the fuel cost 10c per litre more, using 40 litres of fuel per week will only cost around $200 a year. Worth it? How much does it cost to rebuild an engine? How much do mods that give a few rwkw cost?

Knock, or pinging, or detonation is a spontaneous ignition of fuel/air mix in the cylinder before the flame front - it is an explosion. Normal ignition is a controlled burn, not an explosion. Detonation will smash engines, the more power and revs you are making, the more severe the effect it will have.

The RON (octane) of a fuel is its resistance to detonation. If you dont think 98 makes any difference, with a stock ecu, fill it with 98, run it for a while, fill it again (to get ant 96ron out of the fuel system) - do a reset on the ecu and drive it around for a week, overtake a few cars, give the car a squirt - Then, fill with 96 and drive in a comparible manner, you will notice a difference.

I drove my skyline from SA to WA, on the way I had to use 96 a few times, as even carrying 40litres of 98 ron with me, at times I could use nothing else. I noticed a considerable reduction in power around peak torque (4000 ish rpm) and above. Very, very noticeable, not just a little, the stock ECU was pulling out timing to prevent detonation destroying the engine - its self learned maps had been adjusted to 98 ron. Upon reaching pumps that supplied 98 ron, I reset the ecu and the difference was instantaneous and very noticeable.

The higher the RON, the more timing/boost can be used before detonation will occur. If your ecu is set up to run timing appropriate to 96 ron, and you switch to 98 - it will make little difference because the timing hasnt changed, maybe only a little difference at idle, and run a little smoother, a little more power, but very marginal. Generally, you need to increase timing to gain the full benefits of higher ron.

Higher oygenate fuels, such as elf LMS is different all together, not only is it less prone to detonation, but it will make more power because of the chemical structure of the fuel.

If you tune your engine with 98ron, and run 96 it will make a difference. If you run 96ron on the stock ecu, it will not run as well as 98. If you upgrade to 98, you MUST reset the stock ecu, to take advantage of the higher resistance to knock.

Any comparison of different fuels SHOULD have the cars tune adjusted according to the fuel they are using, then be conducted in identical situations, such as an ADR drive cycle test to be of any real worth. Even throwing the cars on a dyno would have been of more worth than just getting 3 different cars and driving them on the road - what a joke. Just throwing 3 different fuel is 3 cars is really a waste of time and money.

sorry, starting to waffle on a bit now :)

I watched the program. The testing did seem to be fairly fair in terms of consumption but they neglected several factors. None of these cars were run on a dyno for power. The 98RON car would have probably made more power than the others. They also didn't take into account pollution, the 98RON car would have burnt cleaner giving off less emmissions.

The actual results were: 91 RON car out first, 98 RON car out 4km or 6km later (can't remember sorry) and finally the 95 RON car out a further 1.5km again. Taking other factors into account, the 98 RON car would have made more power, burnt cleaner and only stopped 1.5km short of the 95 fuelled car. Therefore, you pay a premium for more power, cleaner burning fuel that goes a very similar distance. As others have mentioned the 98 is better for other performance reasons such as engine detonation too.

If the fuel cost 10c per litre more, using 40 litres of fuel per week will only cost around $200 a year.  Worth it?  How much does it cost to rebuild an engine?  How much do mods that give a few rwkw cost?

Knock, or pinging, or detonation is a spontaneous ignition of fuel/air mix in the cylinder before the flame front - it is an explosion.  Normal ignition is a controlled burn, not an explosion.  Detonation will smash engines, the more power and revs you are making, the more severe the effect it will have.

The RON (octane) of a fuel is its resistance to detonation.  If you dont think 98 makes any difference, with a stock ecu, fill it with 98, run it for a while, fill it again (to get ant 96ron out of the fuel system) - do a reset on the ecu and drive it around for a week, overtake a few cars, give the car a squirt - Then, fill with 96 and drive in a comparible manner, you will notice a difference.  

I drove my skyline from SA to WA, on the way I had to use 96 a few times, as even carrying 40litres of 98 ron with me, at times I could use nothing else.  I noticed a considerable reduction in power around peak torque (4000 ish rpm) and above.  Very, very noticeable, not just a little, the stock ECU was pulling out timing to prevent detonation destroying the engine - its self learned maps had been adjusted to 98 ron.  Upon reaching pumps that supplied 98 ron, I reset the ecu and the difference was instantaneous and very noticeable.  

The higher the RON, the more timing/boost can be used before detonation will occur.  If your ecu is set up to run timing appropriate to 96 ron, and you switch to 98 - it will make little difference because the timing hasnt changed, maybe only a little difference at idle, and run a little smoother, a little more power, but very marginal.  Generally, you need to increase timing to gain the full benefits of higher ron.  

Higher oygenate fuels, such as elf LMS is different all together, not only is it less prone to detonation, but it will make more power because of the chemical structure of the fuel.

If you tune your engine with 98ron, and run 96 it will make a difference.  If you run 96ron on the stock ecu, it will not run as well as 98.  If you upgrade to 98, you MUST reset the stock ecu, to take advantage of the higher resistance to knock.  

Any comparison of different fuels SHOULD have the cars tune adjusted according to the fuel they are using, then be conducted in identical situations, such as an ADR drive cycle test to be of any real worth.  Even throwing the cars on a dyno would have been of more worth than just getting 3  different cars and driving them on the road - what a joke. Just throwing 3 different fuel is 3 cars is really a waste of time and money.  

sorry, starting to waffle on a bit now :)

Hmmmm,

What he said!

Mike

I actually recorded this segment in mpeg format (266mb) it's 5mins in length. I've just converted it to Xvid (23mb).

Click [here] to download.

This is the first time i've used SimpleDivX (Dr DivX ran out of trial time) so I had to manually play around with the quality/settings/aspect etc so it could be abit out of whack (lemme know if thats the case for future recordings).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • For these last 7 years of ownership, I've always had to use a small scissor jack under one of the front tow hooks to raise the front just enough so my low-profile jack fits under to reach my subframe jack point. I'm beginning to get annoyed of always having to do this. Are there any lower low-profile jacks that fit under the gtr lip on a dropped car?
    • Seat of the pants assessment of the new intake: The car is way less "doughy" when hitting the loud pedal, especially off idle when stopped or in traffic, I did use a cheapo lazer thermal thingo to measure the temp around where the pod filter got its air, it was between 55 - 60°C, in saying this the car was shut off and not moving, so the OEM intake pipe was not supplying any fresh air to where the pod was when the car was at least moving A weird bonus was induction noise on the throttle in the cabin increased a bit,  I was worried that I was actually going to lose some of that induction noise I love so much, outside though, when I got the daughter to do a WOT drive by pass for me, the induction noise has increased alot when on the throttle, not quite ITB doort, but well up there I'm extremely happy with the results and have been exploring the country roads in the region  As for house mods: 1.New front fence is up and is awesome, it really upgraded how the joint looks from the street, and the added security is nice 2. Electricians have replace some interior lights, and with more lighting in the garage, a few new motion detecting lights out the front above the garage, front room, and at the front door, which I have already found heaps helpful coming and going, also now has fancy pants CCTV all round the house The only hold point for power though is the solar and batteries due to supply issues, although this will happen over the next few weeks 3. I have done a heap of landscaping out the front and I'm almost ready to do a new small retaining wall with some nice blocks to replace the brick and cemented in rocks around the raised garden beds cemented in river stone "was the fashion at the time" the house was built. I currently have a pallet of retaining wall blocks and 2 bulka bags of 20mm blue metal to replace the wood chip that is in the raised garden beds around the house 4. I now have 3 big raised garden beds for out the back to grow some vegetables, about 70cm high, 200cm long and 100cm wide 5. My 2 compost bins are already pretty full with brown, green and kitchen waste from the landscaping I'vedone so far, but they will probably take a few months to break down, so anything else that gets chopped, trimmed, and kitchen waste will just start filling the base of the raised garden beds to about 30cm before I start throwing 40cm of good compost, and stuff, for the vegetables to grow in, I'll need a few ton of compost and soil, but the local supplier can sent me bulka bags of the stuff Basically the logs, wood chips and a few strategically placed rocks for drainage, will give the beds some good organic materials down low to break down over time, and they will hold moisture during the warmer months to save the water in my big arse water tank if we don't get alot of rain So, all in all, the car and house mods are going well, and I'm really enjoying being retired, I sleep in too 0700 and slowly plod around inside until I feel like actually doing anything, and only work in the yard for as long as want, which has actually been alot over the last few weeks,  although when you look at it, it seems that not a huge amount of work has been done,  until I look at the before I started the work pics Happy days and good times indeed 
    • hahaha yeah. Plan is to get side skirts and probably just rear pods. But going to do them one-by-one. I've got a set that I really like from RHDJapen, but that one isn't shipped to AU. So need to find someone who can get it for me
    • Here's an idea, answer the questions I asked you as they are trying to work out WHY the LSD will be binding up in a straight line.
×
×
  • Create New...