Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 283
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

True Roy, BTW, the prices I quoted are not back yard rates, but a legit business with shop overheads and all the rest.

Intersting though, I think that unfortuneately for retailers, and fortuneatly for consumers, that people are being more savvy with their money, and I-business is becoming more and more a reality that needs to be accepted.

End of the day, you order over internet, or overseas, and you take whats coming - you buy from retailer and you know what you are getting and exactly how much it will cost

sorry a bit off topic.

Although the price vs performance is an important factor, it's not really going to help a company that exports from Japan much. Garrett being much more of a global company would have more resources and opportunities to reduce overheads manufacturing these components. I wonder what retail prices of Garrett turbos are in Japan?

I prefer Garrett turbos because they provide compressor maps and I can therefore easily match them to my requirements.  HKS don't provide compressor maps and I refuse to guess as to whether they will suite my requirements or not.  BTW Apexi, Blitz and Trust don't provide compressor maps either.

HKS say that their turbos are designed to work efficiently at over 1.5 bar.  I never run more than 1.3 bar in my engines, there is simply no need.  I can match the Garrett compressor airflow to make all the power at that boost level I need.  I know that airflow makes power, boost is merely a measurement of resistance to airflow.

While I am having a whinge, I am not impressed with the magazines that continue to avoid answering this question.  They have the resources to do it, have scouted the edges a couple of times.  But they haven't gone and done a true back to back, same size turbo comparison from different manufacturers or rebadgers.  It is something their readers want to know, but maybe their advertisers don't.  Next time you are sending an email off to Zoom, HPI, Fast Fours, Speed etc why don't you ask them.

Sydneykid & others, "just a thought??"

I am willing to put up my GTR for a back to back comparison between the commonly used HKS 2530's, & the closest Garret equivilant "maybe the garret GT25", You say that you can match specs to suit requirements?? let me know what you need to know, & I will be willing to buy a pair of Garret turbos if someone can supply the HKS 2530 for the compare.

I'm sure the boys at ICE could orgainse something with ben from racepace for some dyno time. My mods are your basic gtr mods such as:

Power FC

HKS EVC IV

Full Exhaust "stock dumps"

Cam Gears

Don't know how difficult or big a job this would be between the two makes, but it's just a thought.

Although the price vs performance is an important factor, it's not really going to help a company that exports from Japan much. Garrett being much more of a global company would have more resources and opportunities to reduce overheads manufacturing these components. I wonder what retail prices of Garrett turbos are in Japan?

Garrett makes HKS turbos. So if they save money on manufacturing I expect they would pass along at least some of these savings to HKS (and any other big customers of theirs). It's not like they'd be charging HKS anywhere near full retail price for their turbos anyway.

Hi Sydneykid,

Quote:- "Hi Freebaggin, I can read a compressor map and choose a compressor and cover to suite my application. I then tell the turbo expert (we use GCG) what I have chosen and the engine spec and armed with this information he picks the turbine and housing to suite."

I've just got a quick question for you, I hope you can help. I know how different A/R's affect the turbine, and I have learnt how to size a compressor for the job, but I don't know what effect the compresor A/R has...

If you could explain this to me that would be great.

Cheers,

Matty.

Sydneykid & others, "just a thought??"

I am willing to put up my GTR for a back to back comparison between the commonly used HKS 2530's, & the closest Garret equivilant "maybe the garret GT25", You say that you can match specs to suit requirements??

I am up for that too.

I'm just about to have a GT30 installed within the next 2-3 weeks.

the exact turbo spec im not 100% on 'just' yet. But by installation time i will.

I need to get a set of injectors first so we can push the power up as i still have stockies, and that'll be approx 4 weeks later.

i'd probably need a PRF or something donated, i've only got a standard ECU with a chip to modify things.

Anyone in Vic wanna swap a HKS to my motor ?

i'll provide the car so we can get more details on this HKS/Garrett argument.

Same dyno, same day.

I've got ALL other mods, exhaust/cooler/intake etc.

And maybe can someone get HPI to cover it?

that way we can do the reasearch, get the figures over a few beers one day. and finally say,

Well that is that.

Absolutely... I'm sure we can get Ben to cover a comparo, and perhaps source some turbos for us to swap with.

High mount turbos like the GT30 on an RB25 would be a VERY easy swap to make with an HKS GT3040. But to make use of the HKS's higher boost and rpm threshold, you'd need to have done internals (at least pistons and rods)

I only had stock internals and the HKS GT3040 pulled all the way to 8000rpm without any sign of dropping off power, but that's not so good for stock rods :D

Actually, I was thinking about these HKS GT2540s having different compressor housings depending on what application they're for...

Apparently:

GT2540 for RB26DETT has HKS specific comp housing, GT2540 for RB25DET has modified Garrett comp housing with aluminium insert.

How can that be? Obviously the two compressor housings aren't the same. So how can they both be GT2540s if they're different turbos??

Hmmm........

Absolutely... I'm sure we can get Ben to cover a comparo, and perhaps source some turbos for us to swap with.

High mount turbos like the GT30 on an RB25 would be a VERY easy swap to make with an HKS GT3040. But to make use of the HKS's higher boost and rpm threshold, you'd need to have done internals (at least pistons and rods)

mine will be a low-mounted GT30 :D

but yeah, i aint go internals at this stage.

that may hold us back a bit

Garrett makes HKS turbos. So if they save money on manufacturing I expect they would pass along at least some of these savings to HKS (and any other big customers of theirs). It's not like they'd be charging HKS anywhere near full retail price for their turbos anyway.

On the surface that seems about right, but having worked in the manufacturing industry tells me that this may not be the case. If you look at a highly automated production line then the cost and down time associated with doing smaller runs using different components, Garret GT25/GT28/GT30 vs HKS GT25/GT28/GT30 turbos may in fact increase the costs.

Then on top of actual manufacturing costs HKS want their slice of the pie, just like anyon ein business they have their mark ups on top to make the whole thing viable.

Actually, I was thinking about these HKS GT2540s having different compressor housings depending on what application they're for...

Apparently:

GT2540 for RB26DETT has HKS specific comp housing, GT2540 for RB25DET has modified Garrett comp housing with aluminium insert.

How can that be? Obviously the two compressor housings aren't the same. So how can they both be GT2540s if they're different turbos??

Hmmm........

Apparently:

GT2540 for RB26DETT has HKS specific comp housing, GT2540 for RB25DET has modified Garrett comp housing with aluminium insert.

How can that be? Obviously the two compressor housings aren't the same. So how can they both be GT2540s if they're different turbos??

Hmmm........

Perhaps whilst they are physically different housings, the end result is the same, ie the internals have been machinded to be identical, so same compressor wheel with idential clearances etc etc????????????

MattSR, in reply to your question about compressor cover a/r.

The cover is at least as important as the wheel trim in deciding the shape of the compressor flow map. All flow maps lean to the right, and the efficiency islands vary quite a bit in shape depending upon the wheel and housing combination.

Small compressor cover a/r will give a flow map that is tall and narrow. The efficiency islands will be stretched out along the tilt of the map. This works really well at high boost with a largish turbo, where the flow line rises at a steep angle through the centre of the tilting flow map. Matching will be pretty critical though, and the wastegate will remain shut right up to almost redline. This sort of matching would be used where the exhaust turbine is very large and you want maximum top end power at relatively high boost levels. (drag racing).

A larger a/r cover would produce a flow map that is not as tall, but much wider. The efficiency islands will be rounder, and there will be a much wider flow range between the surge line and the choke region. This works best where you run a small exhaust turbine and arrange for the wastegate to open at lowish engine RPM and hold boost constant up to redline.

In this type of matching the flow line on the map will be horizontal, because boost is constant over a fairly wide engine RPM operating range. Also boost will probably be lower for this type of application (street car).

I had a long discussion with a Garrett applications engineer (Geoff Lotterman) in the US on this topic, a few years ago.

I have no idea, but the fact that HKS are supposed to be better matched for higher boost levels suggests they may be using smaller a/r covers, I don't know this for sure though. The Garrett GT turbos seem to have huge covers, and can be a bastard to fit in some installations.

Does anyone know for sure about the comparative a/r of similar trim HKS and Garrett ? It might explain a few things.

It may very well be, that a Garrett GT may actually be BETTER than an HKS for a low boost road car ? Wouldn't that be something !

I strongly suspect Garrett have optimised their turbos for mass produced OEM applications, and HKS for all out racing applications. Both are good, but one might be more suitable for YOUR application.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • OK, so again it has been a bit of a break but it was around researching what had been done since I didn't have access to Neil's records and not everything is obvious without pulling stuff apart. Happily the guy who assembled the engine had kept reasonable records, so we now know the final spec is: Bottom end: Standard block and crank Ross 86.5mm forgies, 9:1 compression Spool forged rods Standard main bolts Oil pump Spool billet gears in standard housing Aeroflow extended and baffled sump Head Freshly rebuilt standard head with new 80lb valve springs Mild porting/port match Head oil feed restrictor VCT disabled Tighe 805C reground cams (255 duration, 8.93 lift)  Adjustable cam gears on inlet/exhaust Standard head bolts, gasket not confirmed but assumed MLS External 555cc Nismo injectors Z32 AFM Bosch 023 Intank fuel pump Garret 2871 (factory housings and manifold) Hypertune FFP plenum with standard throttle   Time to book in a trip to Unigroup
    • I forgot about my shiny new plates!
    • Well, apparently they do fit, however this wont be a problem if not because the car will be stationary while i do the suspension work. I was just going to use the 16's to roll the old girl around if I needed to. I just need to get the E90 back on the road first. Yes! I'm a believer! 🙌 So, I contacted them because the site kinda sucks and I was really confused about what I'd need. They put together a package for me and because I was spraying all the seat surfaces and not doing spot fixes I decided not to send them a headrest to colour match, I just used their colour on file (and it was spot on).  I got some heavy duty cleaner, 1L of colour, a small bottle of dye hardener and a small bottle of the dye top coat. I also got a spray gun as I needed a larger nozzle than the gun I had and it was only $40 extra. From memory the total was ~$450 ish. Its not cheap but the result is awesome. They did add repair bits and pieces to the quote originally and the cost came down significantly when I said I didn't need any repair products. I did it over a weekend. The only issues I had were my own; I forgot to mix the hardener into the dye two coats but I had enough dye for 2 more coats with the hardener. I also just used up all the dye because why not and i rushed the last coat which gave me some runs. Thankfully the runs are under the headrests. The gun pattern wasn't great, very round and would have been better if it was a line. It made it a little tricky to get consistent coverage and I think having done the extra coats probably helped conceal any coverage issues. I contacted them again a few months later so I could get our X5 done (who the f**k thought white leather was a good idea for a family car?!) and they said they had some training to do in Sydney and I could get a reduced rate on the leather fix in the X5 if I let them demo their product on our car. So I agreed. When I took Bec in the E39 to pick it up, I showed them the job I'd done in my car and they were all (students included) really impressed. Note that they said the runs I created could be fixed easily at the time with a brush or an air compressor gun. So, now with the two cars done I can absolutely recommend Colourlock.  I'll take pics of both interiors and create a new thread.
    • Power is fed to the ECU when the ignition switch is switched to IGN, at terminal 58. That same wire also connects to the ECCS relay to provide both the coil power and the contact side. When the ECU sees power at 58 it switches 16 to earth, which pulls the ECCS relay on, which feeds main power into the ECU and also to a bunch of other things. None of this is directly involved in the fuel pump - it just has to happen first. The ECU will pull terminal 18 to earth when it wants the fuel pump to run. This allows the fuel pump relay to pull in, which switches power on into the rest of the fuel pump control equipment. The fuel pump control regulator is controlled from terminal 104 on the ECU and is switched high or low depending on whether the ECU thinks the pump needs to run high or low. (I don't know which way around that is, and it really doesn't matter right now). The fuel pump control reg is really just a resistor that controls how the power through the pump goes to earth. Either straight to earth, or via the resistor. This part doesn't matter much to us today. The power to the fuel pump relay comes from one of the switched wires from the IGN switch and fusebox that is not shown off to the left of this page. That power runs the fuel pump relay coil and a number of other engine peripherals. Those peripherals don't really matter. All that matters is that there should be power available at the relay when the key is in the right position. At least - I think it's switched. If it's not switched, then power will be there all the time. Either way, if you don't have power there when you need it (ie, key on) then it won't work. The input-output switching side of the relay gains its power from a line similar (but not the same as) the one that feeds the ECU. SO I presume that is switched. Again, if there is not power there when you need it, then you have to look upstream. And... the upshot of all that? There is no "ground" at the fuel pump relay. Where you say: and say that pin 1 Black/Pink is ground, that is not true. The ECU trigger is AF73, is black/pink, and is the "ground". When the ECU says it is. The Blue/White wire is the "constant" 12V to power the relay's coil. And when I say "constant", I mean it may well only be on when the key is on. As I said above. So, when the ECU says not to be running the pump (which is any time after about 3s of switching on, with no crank signal or engine speed yet), then you should see 12V at both 1 and 2. Because the 12V will be all the way up to the ECU terminal 18, waiting to be switched to ground. When the ECU switches the fuel pump on, then AF73 should go to ~0V, having been switched to ground and the voltage drop now occurring over the relay coil. 3 & 5 are easy. 5 is the other "constant" 12V, that may or may not be constant but will very much want to be there when the key is on. Same as above. 3 goes to the pump. There should never be 12V visible at 3 unless the relay is pulled in. As to where the immobiliser might have been spliced into all this.... It will either have to be on wire AF70 or AF71, whichever is most accessible near the alarm. Given that all those wires run from the engine bay fusebox or the ECU, via the driver's area to the rear of the car, it could really be either. AF70 will be the same colour from the appropriate fuse all the way to the pump. If it has been cut and is dangling, you should be able to see that  in that area somewhere. Same with AF71.   You really should be able to force the pump to run. Just jump 12V onto AF72 and it should go. That will prove that the pump itself is willing to go along with you when you sort out the upstream. You really should be able to force the fuel pump relay on. Just short AF73 to earth when the key is on. If the pump runs, then the relay is fine, and all the power up to both inputs on the relay is fine. If it doesn't run (and given that you checked the relay itself actually works) then one or both of AF70 and AF71 are not bringing power to the game.
    • @PranK can you elaborate further on the Colorlock Dye? The website has a lot of options. I'm sure you've done all the research. I have old genuine leather seats that I have bought various refurbing creams and such, but never a dye. Any info on how long it lasts? Does it wash out? Is it a hassle? What product do I actually need? Am I just buying this kit and following the steps the page advises or something else? https://www.colourlockaustralia.com.au/colourlock-leather-repair-kit-dye.html
×
×
  • Create New...