Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 55
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

hey would anyone know if removing the center muffler from a cat back would make the sound softer or louder?

i got a 3"splitdump, 3" cat, 3.5" HKS super dragger catback

the center muffler is way too low and scraps everywhere

if i remove the center muffler and replace it with a 3.5" piece will it alter sound??

reason i ask is ...the local exhaust shop said it would sound shit....but i need sound road clearance

hey would anyone know if removing the center muffler from a cat back would make the sound softer or louder?

i got a 3"splitdump, 3" cat, 3.5" HKS super dragger catback

the center muffler is way too low and scraps everywhere

if i remove the center muffler and replace it with a 3.5" piece will it alter sound??

reason i ask is ...the local exhaust shop said it would sound shit....but i need sound road clearance

Replacing a muffler with a similarly-sectioned piece of plain pipe will make it louder (unless the muffler's not

really a muffler, which I've seen before, on some of the available-on-ebay systems :whistling:)

Usually removing a resonator results in a 'brassier' note; harsher, a little louder.

If you're having clearance problems with 3.5" your exhaust has dropped a mount, or the car is too low :P

HKS stuff usually fits pretty well so I'd be checking the rubbers before I deleted a muffler.

I have an R32 with SK's suspension guideline setup (355mm centre-to-guard) and it's passed engineering

(that is, 100mm clearance _everywhere_) with a 4" system. If all mounts are OK, and it's still too low, you

_could_ try an offset muffler to keep it quiet and get more clearance (or, you could set the car to the correct

ride height :):yes:).

Regards,

Saliya

Edited by saliya
Usually removing a resonator results in a 'brassier' note; harsher, a little louder.

brassy as in droney?

coz i want to get rid of the drone from my system, and am hoping a straight type resonator will do it.

besides the cat and rear cannon, there's no other mufflers/resonators on my system.

whatcha think ? will it do the trick?

brassy as in droney?

coz i want to get rid of the drone from my system, and am hoping a straight type resonator will do it.

besides the cat and rear cannon, there's no other mufflers/resonators on my system.

whatcha think ? will it do the trick?

hmm; brassier as in sharper/harsher. Think the difference between the sound of someone playing a trumpet

at normal level, and someone blowing the crap out of it but in the next room - the volume is the same, but

the tone is different.

Adding a resonator _can_ be used to cure 'drone' (if you mean a resonance at a particular RPM); but it needs

to be the right size and material - you need someone experienced to sell you the right resonator. If you only

have a rear muffler, chances are the right resonator will do just what you want - but you need the right one.

Regards,

Saliya

now only if this magical creature existed. lol.

i've asked around and got the same response... "it might fix it, it might not, but it will have some effect"

Should be pretty easy to solve this one.

Go to an exhaust shop, tell them what you want. If it happens at a particular RPM, show them the

RPM. Tell them _exactly_ what you want fixed, and ask whether they will back their work.

That is, if they do work but don't fix your problem, they won't charge you.

If you're reasonable in your expectation and you clearly communicate what you want to them,

an experienced shop will be able to say 'yep, this will do what you want'; or 'no, you can't do

what you want with the system you have' to within reasonable limits.

If they say 'we don't know what will happen' you don't want that shop.

The easiest way, of course, is to hear a car that sounds like what you want - and see if you can

replicate that :P

Regards,

Saliya

i will try some more exhaust places.

since 3 inch jap systems often have a cat > straight thru resonator > cannon, i figured that the resonator is what i'm missing. but since you brought up the point of different resonators for different results, i'm less confident now.

my exhaust sounded perfect when it had the restriction of the 2.5" standard cat. i just wanna offset the new highflow cat with a resonator. i'm just babbling on now. need an expert. unless you can give me a model and guarantee over the net. lol.

My friend has a db tested thing. Same as the exhaust place uses. He tested my exhaust at 108 db from memory. Then i made up this thing to go just after the cat. Just got a bit of tin cost me $1.75 from bunnings. Cut it to the size of the gaskit. drilled some holes in it and put in in the exhaust. Got may mate to test it again and it was 92db. The exhaust shop tested it at 86db.

Removed it after the test. I have a 3" system.

great idea i might just do that. wait and see how much im over first.

why better from cat back? turbo back has got to be better, get the pressure away from the exhaust turbine quicker.

edit: i see you mean as far as performance for value. k then. i have turbo back. put a highflow cat, now exhaust note sounds like crud, and not so sure the car wasnt going better before.

Edited by Munkyb0y
hey guys

did a search but cant find many actual answers with proven results. everyone says 'yes my exhaust is quiet' but havent actually had it tested.

just got off the phone to a tester who claimed that no 3" system will be under 90db. can anyone prove him wrong? ive got a 3" split dump to a wide body hiflo cat, 3" cat back system with a hotdog muffler and jazma oval muffler. he claims it will be over 100db.

what have you guys got.

Had to have mine tested before going onto the skidpan at Mt Cotton in Qld, due to the circuit being near a residential area. 2 measurements were taken, one was at 3200rpm and the other at 4000rpm. My S2 registered 81db at 3200 and 84db at 4000.

At the time I had the standard dump and a 3inch cat back system. I have 2 mufflers (one is a jasma, the other i'm not sure). I now have added a custom split dump and a new cat. Have not had it measured since the changes.

so have i got this right?

the less back pressure the better (rb25det).

so even if there was no exhaust at all, just a dump pipe, theoretically this would be good for performance?

A turbo will work the best with nothing behind it, yes.

Of course, you'd set fire to everything that was directly behind it, but meh :blink:

Regards,

Saliya

ok, coz i'm not convinced that the car wasnt performing better before the highflow cat came into the equation.

but i guess that's unfounded, seeing as it's created more noise, hence more flow, and unfortunately drone.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • So, version 4 intake is on its way I was looking at these a while ago but at around $200 or more it was a little pricey for something that might not work, but, I had it in my watch list, but, I got a message saying it was on special, and I had a code thingie to use, it eventually came in at $120 delivered, so BAM, BUY NOW.....LOL I'll need to have a look when it arrives but I feel it will "look" better than what I currently have, as it comes with a PCV fitting, so I will be able to get rid of the alloy pipe that goes to the throttle body with the PCV fitting  Well, that's what the voices in my head are telling me  Oh, and this happened today Yeap, it was a Trojan, and it was cheap, so I headed back to the hardware store and actually spent a little bit more on a heavy duty,  one that was actually recommended by a plumber mate, a Cyclone one with a fibreglass handle that is actually rated for clay The broken shovel will eventually be "modified" into a short handle shovel
    • When you pulled it off, there is no signs of blown head gasket? Is it possible you have some other issues going on? Possible cracked blocked? Or do you think it's straight up lifting the head? Did you check what the head was torqued to before pulling it down (To see if possibly they're stretching, or starting to break threads out etc)?
    • Seems like a decent result for a modded JZX110. They are bulky in comparison to the 100 and 90 models (which I'd prefer myself) but they are getting very few and far between here in JP these days. Thanks for the detailed review and the import process into the UK. I also have a car which I'm hoping to export from Japan at some stage so it's good to know if someone from the UK was interested in it. By the way the corrosion underneath is par for the course for cars which were located in/near the mountains or along the Japan sea coastline. They get huge amounts of snow every winter and the sodium chloride is used on the roads. Many cars have some kind of rubber like treatment underneath but they tend to limit it to the wheel arches underbody and fuel tank. Suspension arms and sub-frames will have similar corrosion to your JZX110 which is a common sight. See it all the time and car dealers here generally don't even mention it unless asked.
    • If the sound goes away when you clutch in, the 1.5/2 way diffs are just shit, and you are a normal person. The diff is likely "fine" but driving at anything under 30kmh is a violent horrible experience. It would be exaggerated with solid diff bushings and subframe bushings if you have those.
×
×
  • Create New...