Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hey guys.

I just transplanted an RB25DE (with VCT) in my S. This new engine under load has a strange metallic noise around two and three thou RPM, more like two metal parts being in contact and resonating. It always occurs around 2-3K then goes away. It seems to settle down slightly when the engine reaches operating temp. The noise is the same even with VCT solenoid disconnected.

The noise appears to be coming from the exhaust, yet I removed all shields and is still there. Noise could transmit though from the engine.

The spark plugs are very clean and white, so there seems to be no valve problems. The car accelerates and idles very smoothly. Fuel consumption for this new engine seems to be higher than what it should be (although these issues may not be linked).

Any ideas to what it may be and how to fix?

Thanks in advance =]

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/170221-rb25de-metalic-resonating/
Share on other sites

no idea what it sounds like... but if it is what i think you're trying to describe then it's a typical inline 6 twin cam characteristic... the m3 has a slight metallic raspy sound (and yes i have heard one in full song in real life) - and although not comparable, it is quite distinct.

try to put a sound file up... easier to diagnose

could be either one of ur mufflers have collapsed. or your cat. hit them to see if it rattles that or check for loose bolts or washers

Done that.. Exhaust is fine. Nothing rattles.. no loose bolts.. only thing I found once I took off the sheilding was a small rock. Muffler and cat have no noise at all.

Ill try getting a sound file :O

Im going with eugene, mine sounded terrible till i got a proper exhaust put on it, its a twin cam thing, do a search on exhausts in this section to get a better idea of muffler, resonator and pipe diameter to fix the problem. I also learned the other day, like a resonator a pipe can be added perpendicular to ur normal exhaust just to act as another expansion chamber.. honda uses this to deal with the twin cam resonance.

Unfortunately I cannot import a sound clip from my phone to my copmputer.

Is there anywhere I can hear a 25DE engine? On a video or sound clip to compair the two?

As per before.. just sounds like metal clipping.

It could be your gearbox. I ran my car with the rubber gear boot off once, and the noise was extremely loud and it was obviously coming from the gearbox. Nothing to worry about. Could see if changing your oil improves it. Check that your gear boot is fitted properly.

It could be your gearbox. I ran my car with the rubber gear boot off once, and the noise was extremely loud and it was obviously coming from the gearbox.

But why would the resonating be between 2-3 K? If it was the G-box.. wouldnt it be throughout all RMP range? And Im pretty sure its from the engine. When we opened the G-box it was in pretty good nik. It seems like its comming from the engine and all simptoms seem to point that way. Thats why Im so freaked out about it.

I have that sound too. Ill try get a sound file now.

Much appreciated brother bear!

But why would the resonating be between 2-3 K? If it was the G-box.. wouldnt it be throughout all RMP range? And Im pretty sure its from the engine. When we opened the G-box it was in pretty good nik. It seems like its comming from the engine and all simptoms seem to point that way. Thats why Im so freaked out about it.

no. it hits its natural frequency at this rpm range, hence making the noise.

I have the same noise with my r32 gts25, it has the rb25de as well and is making the metallic noise around the same rev range. I have only just started noticing it within the past 2 weeks( have had my licence for a month now lol)

my exhaust seems to be running quite hot as well, but not hot enough for the exhaust overheat light to come on.

Ill check my cat and exhaust out on the weekend anyway.

Ps i have an auto gearbox and flushed it out as well as the torque convertor and replaced with new fluid but still sounds the same.

YES!..

But without the sexual exhaust note..

Got my papa bear to drive it today.. its freakin LOUD!.. the metalic resonating is just like the one you showed.. but just much louder and somehow.. nastier sounding..

I take it by the replies that its just a normal sound?

It has a stock RB20DET exhaust with the slightly bent R33 25DE connector from the headers to the exhaust flange. Does anyone see anything wrong with this?

Much appreciated sound clip :)

What size is your exhaust GTS4WD anyway now that you did the transplant?

I transplanted a Rb25DE from a 4wd Stagea into my R32 GTS4 which had an RB20DET. It has a stock 20DET exhaust. The only difference is that I used an R33 connector pipe from a RB25DE to connect the headers to the stock RB20DET exhaust.

  • 3 weeks later...

if anyone still cares.. This metalic resonating is a common problem in early RB25DE's.. It causes absolutely no damage to the engine/exhaust.. The only way to get rid of it is a cat/exhaust/muff.. or bear they annoying very loud rattle..

Advan (in Syd) + 1 point!

The way it was explained to me is that:

"all engines make noise due to moving parts/rpm/mods etc..

Most engines sound different, they have different mechanical characteristics and that makes them sound diff..

early models of the RB25DE have that loud metalic raspy resonance due to the way the engine was designed"

Its a shit load louder than a raspy cams sound.. Got a mate to drive it the other day so i could hear it from the outside..

its LOUD! i mean FREAKING LOUD! it resonates through the whole exhaust and is amplified and expeled out the end.

In the later Rb25DE's there was a small flap that was kept closed at row rpm and opened at WOP and higher RPM to help keep the noise of it to a minimum.

An exhaust/muffler will cancel the sound, hence there arnt any/rarely do modded 25de's have the sound. Couple it with a new exhaust, and it disapears completely.

So yeah, its just a natural characteristic that 25de's have. Its similar to cams on full symphany, but a million times louder, and out the exhaust.

Theres no mechanical defect with the engine/exhaust. It causes no damage and will not harm the engine.. its just there..

hope this little bit of info helps anyone in the future..

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • I don't understand how this hasn't boiled down to - Upgrade the turbo when you have everything required. ECU, injectors, fuel pump, turbo, etc. Do it all at once.  If you don't have everything required, just enjoy the car as it is and keep saving up your pennies. 
    • Sounds like you've got an interesting adventure ahead here with local support if you have trouble! My guess is that, unboosted, you will be OK with a small upgrade like -9. What will happen is that once the stock ECU sees more airflow than it expects it will add a heap of fuel and pull a heap of timing to be safe because it can't understand how it could get that much air without there being an issue. You will see clouds of black smoke and it won't pull hard through the midrange and top end. So, overall it will be a bit frustrating but should be OK. If you are still nervous set the base timing back 2o through the CAS, but it will be even more sluggish everywhere. As said above through...this is not my guarantee your engine won't be blown into a million pieces, leaving you looking for very hard to find parts A better idea is get a computer with logging ASAP, wire in a wide band O2 sensor and a use remote tuner. I've done multiple cars this way and while it is not as good as a specific tune on a dyno they can get it 90% right. I'd suggest if you can afford an R33 GTR these days you can afford an ECU and tune. And if you can't afford that you sure won't be able to afford the rebuild if it goes bad in the meantime,.  
    • Yeah it would be nice if someone took the time to put that sort of information together, but there are a lot of variations in looms. I think you are making this way hard for yourself if you just want to get it running....sourcing an SR20 with the right wiring will be a billion times easier than matching the RB loom to an S15 chassis. If you do end up going this way, you just need to trace every wire in the loom with a multimeter, 95% of them will go to a location you can confirm at the ECU.....and then post it up for the next person who needs it  
    • Just top it up with water, and keep a general idea of how much you added. It is normal for water to be pushed into and pulled out of the reservoir through the cap, and it should not be more than half full or it will be likely to overflow when hot. Any decent mechanic can do a pressure test of the cooling system to confirm if you have a leak. Keep in mind if it is only leaking a little and when hot it may well evaporate before you see it hit the ground
    • I'd ask the shop what they used and use that. Mixing coolants is sometimes OK, sometimes not, and you have know the details of each coolant to know whether it's a good idea or not.
×
×
  • Create New...