Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

im trying to work out what wheels to get for my stag.....does anyone know how much tollerence the attesa system has for rolling diameters? the rolling diameter of a 205/55r16 (the stock 16" wheel) is 632mm and the standard RS4s mags are 215/50r17 with rolling diameter of 648mm... how much either way can we go without upsetting the attesa?

D.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/219178-attesa-question/
Share on other sites

ahhh... the question that has been sked and answered a thousand times....

heres my answer from last time someone asked -

For long term issues tho, i nutted this out - this is my reasoning as to why something that seems so inconsequential can cause dramas -

A difference of 10mm in rolling diameter (Say 660mm front and a 650mm) rolling diameter rear tyre is a different of 31.42mm difference in distance travelled per rotation. Given that each rotation of a 650mm diameter tyre is about 2050mm, your larger tyre would rotate about 65 times every time your smaller one does 66times. So your larger tyre will have rotated one less time than your smaller one every 133 metres. If you do 1000 km a month, so 12,000km a year, then its a matter of your clutch packs coping with a difference of 90225 rotation difference every year. Thats a lot of wear and tear on your clutch packs, from a difference of 10mm.

if you have 225 tyres with 40 section, and 225s with 45 section, your difference in diameter will be 22.5mm (45% of 225 - 40% of 225, then multipliy it by two as we're dealing with diameter, not radius), so double the above figure. A differene of rotation of more than 180,000 times is what ur gonna get. How long do you think your clutch packs will last.....?

Hope that A) that makes sense and that B) my maths is correct!!

Bobbeh

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/219178-attesa-question/#findComment-3865911
Share on other sites

so you're saying that even 10mm can be fatal over time?

the RS4s wheels are already 16mm larger rolling diameter than the standard 16" wheels... would the manuals have been adjusted at factory to suit this or are all manuals running their standard 17" wheels going to burn through clutch packs quicker than autos?

and, should i be trying to match rolling diameter of the standard 16" with the factory 205/55r16 or the 17s that came on my manual?

D.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/219178-attesa-question/#findComment-3865946
Share on other sites

it doesnt matter what the rolling diameter is - what matters is that is it the same rolling diameter front and back.

and yes, im saying it will be damaging over time. It is not the issue of changing the diameters, that doesnt hurt. Just make sure there is no difference between front and back.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/219178-attesa-question/#findComment-3865995
Share on other sites

so you can garruntee that changing the diameter wont effect the system, as long as they're all the same? coz i've been told that it will cause problems

D.

As long as the front left, front right, rear left and rear right wheels (wheels = rim and tyre) equal the same diamater/circumference, then you're safe.

For example, I'm running 235/40 tyres on 18" rims all round = no problems.

Apparently the ATTESA system can't handle even the slightest differences in circumference ... something I'm reading about at the moment for myself.

:O

Edited by RubyRS4
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/219178-attesa-question/#findComment-3866133
Share on other sites

What happens when your 8mm deep tread wears down to the 1.5mm wear bars...? thats a 15mm change in rolling diameter. Doesnt matter. As long as front and rear is the same. The atessa system wont even know that the diameters have changed, as long as they are changed equally. only issue is that your speedo will be out. Bigger diameter means that your car will travel further with every rotation.

so you can garruntee that changing the diameter wont effect the system, as long as they're all the same? coz i've been told that it will cause problems

D.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/219178-attesa-question/#findComment-3866565
Share on other sites

yes that is very likely the reason. new rear tyres or just swap front to rear.

BTW it is difference front to rear that matters not the difference to stock wheels. I run 245/45/17 on mine which is pretty big - but no problems with attessa

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/219178-attesa-question/#findComment-3866704
Share on other sites

What happens when your 8mm deep tread wears down to the 1.5mm wear bars...? thats a 15mm change in rolling diameter.

If you're talking new tyres (8mm deep tread) front and worn tyres (1.5mm wear bar) rears then its:

8mm - 1.5mm = 6.5mm

6.5mm x 2 = 13mm

Thats a 13mm change (not 15mm) in diameter :D

Sorry couldn't help myself :P

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/219178-attesa-question/#findComment-3867394
Share on other sites

So if I do a hard left the inside tires will do less distance than the outside tires then a km down the road I do a hard right everything will right itself (just kidding) I plan to get new tires for the rear very soon. LOL

I am going on a trip this weekend so I will swap front to rear and see how it goes.

Thanks for your help.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/219178-attesa-question/#findComment-3869927
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Yeah i found that alot of parts can be wrong or "very" hard to get the real right one. I already bought some brakes years ago on me "old" GT calipers and they were wrong too 😄  I told them too. Even send them pictures...but they said "EBC catalogue has them on my car... So i dont know what their answer will be. I call monday them and let them know that they are really not on my car. If they were they would be already on a car...
    • Welcome to Skyline ownership. Yes, it is entirely possible parts websites get things wrong. There's a whole world of inaccuracies out there when it comes to R34 stuff (and probably 33 and 32). Lots of things that are 'just bolt on, entirely interchangable' aren't. Even between S1 and S2 R34's. Yes they have a GTT item supposedly being 296mm. This is incorrect. I would call whoever you got them from and return them and let them know the GTT actually uses 310mm rotors. Depending on where you got them from your experience and success will obviously vary.
    • Hi...a bit a "development" on the brakes. I spoke to the guys where i get brakes from...and they are saying that 296mm EBC are for R34 GT-T. I then went to their site: https://www.ebcbrakes.com/vehicle/uk-row/NISSAN/Skyline (R34)/ and search for my car(R34 GT 1998 - it has GTT brakes) and it show me this USR1229 number and they are rly 296mm rotors... So now iam rly confused... The rotors i have now on the car are 310mm asi shown... So where is the problem? Does the whole EBC got it wrong or my calipers are just...idk know what?  
    • Oh What the hell, I used to get a "are you sure you want to reply, this thread is XX months old" message. Maybe a software update remove that. My bad.
    • This is a recipe for disaster* Note: Disaster is relative. The thing that often gets lost in threads like this is what is considered acceptable poke and compromise between what one person considers 'good' looks and what someone else does. The quoted specs would sit absurdly outside the guards with the spacers mentioned and need  REALLY thin tyres and a LOT of camber AND rolling the guards to fit. Some people love this. Some people consider this a ruined car. One thing is for certain though, rolling the guards is pretty much mandatory for any 'good' fitment (of either variety). It is often the difference between any fitment remotely close to the guards. "Not to mention the rears were like a mm from hitting the coilovers." I have a question though - This spec is VERY close to what I was planning to buy relative to the inboard suspension - I have an offset measuring tool on the way to confirm it. When you say "like a mm" do you mean literally 1mm? Or 2mm? Cause that's enough clearance for me in the rear :p I actually found the more limiting factor ISNT the coilover but the actual suspension arms. Did you take a look at how close those were?
×
×
  • Create New...