Jump to content
SAU Community

Tapping Noise When Engine Is Cold..

Wacky Dee

By Wacky Dee,
in General Maintenance

 Share

Recommended Posts

Wacky Dee Veteran

Wacky Dee

Posted
Posted

Have had the car for a couple of months now and after about a month is started making this tapping noise when the engine is cold .. the tapping gets faster when you press the gas pedal and it goes away completely after about 5 minutes when the engine warms up.

Took it for an oil change and the mechanic says (car still with them for other issues) it's still making the tapping noise even after the oil change ... so what could it be? He reckons lifters .. but I thought a new oil should fix that up if it's lifters (new oil is 10W40)

could it be anything more serious than the lifters? There's no noise when the engine warms up ..only for the first 5 mins when engine has cooled down. Cheers

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/229786-tapping-noise-when-engine-is-cold/
Share on other sites
mid life crisis Veteran

mid life crisis

Posted
Posted

i bet money its a exaust manifold gaskets . my sons had exactly the same symptons and i was convinced it was a lifter but i was proved wrong it was the manifold gasket due to broken studs.

ticked like crazy when cold and disapeared completly when warm

GTR-N1 Grand Master

GTR-N1

Posted
Posted

Hiya D,

Either of posts #2 or #3 could be right.

You've only had the car for 2/12. So did you buy a car with full service history? Meaning were all the services done?

Check for sludge around the oil-fill opening. Hopefully the seller didn't put additives in before the sale to disguise the noise at cold. If so, the noise from valve lifters will come back.

If there's sludge, talk to your mechanic about cleaning it out.

I don't know if the Nulon product for lifter noise is good or how it works; or whether it can lead to sludge residue.

It can also be the gasket which was mentioned above because with heat, the thin gap can disappear through expansion.

Best to change this though if it's the problem eh?

Cheers, T

DECIM8 Grand Master

DECIM8

Posted
Posted (edited)

Its the lifters... Using a higher grade oil say 10-40 or 15 (wouldnt go higher) will stop it.

I must add ive just got this problem and It was due to the car running extremely rich and fouling the oil, thinning it out anyway.. Im actually replacing it today as it was becoming more noticable.

Id also mention your car most likely has not done the recommended KM.

The gasket problem mentioned above does not particularly form as a tapping sound more a hissing sound or squeel.. Just like a fuel pump of course this depends on your particular leak.. tapping could be a lose turbo but its very noticable.

When it all comes down to it.. It could also be your injectors as they do tap .. but I doubt it unless you've upgraded.

My money is on the lifters as its the most common noise complaint with skylines .. Cheers

Edited by DECIM8
mid life crisis Veteran

mid life crisis

Posted
Posted
Its the lifters... Using a higher grade oil say 10-40 or 15 (wouldnt go higher) will stop it.

I must add ive just got this problem and It was due to the car running extremely rich and fouling the oil, thinning it out anyway.. Im actually replacing it today as it was becoming more noticable.

Id also mention your car most likely has not done the recommended KM.

The gasket problem mentioned above does not particularly form as a tapping sound more a hissing sound or squeel.. Just like a fuel pump of course this depends on your particular leak.. tapping could be a lose turbo but its very noticable.

When it all comes down to it.. It could also be your injectors as they do tap .. but I doubt it unless you've upgraded.

My money is on the lifters as its the most common noise complaint with skylines .. Cheers

well when my sons gasket was gone it was a def tapping noise not a hissing at all thats why i was conviced it was a tapped the noise got quiter as the engine warmed up as the gap got smaller as the manifold expanded ive worked in the motor trade for many yrs and still work part time as a mechanic and this one had me fooled and was glad to be proved wrong . if putting thicker oil in helps then you can rule out the gasket .

but i still stand by my statement that its a fair chance of been the gasket .

cheers mid life crisis

ricsvtr Rising Star

ricsvtr

Posted
Posted

My car just started doing this as well. I've been seaching these forums for the cause of the tapping and I'm convinced its broken exhaust manifold studs (as midlife crisis pointed out). Does anyone know if its safe to just leave the broken studs as is? I'd rather replace the studs and gasket when my turbo dies rather than pay the $500+ in labour just to replace the studs.

Wacky Dee Veteran

Wacky Dee

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Thanks for all the tips .. I'll tell me mechanic to take a look at each. The oil's already been changed to 10W40 and the noise is apparently still there so I'll have em take a look at the manifold gasket next. Cheers

trel Mentor

trel

Posted
Posted

Well, how certain are you that your car has actually done 64k... A genuine 64km car wouldn't have noises like that not for 5 mins at least till its warm. But if you are convinced that it's lifters thicker oil couldn't hurt... All depends on how tight your motor is. A higher K motor will do good on 20/50 but I think its a bit thick.... Will cause you some bad cold start issues. Just start the car and get a screwdriver and use it like a stethoscope see if you can track down if the noise is coming from the rocker cover OR broken studs.

Worse comes to worse a decent mechanic can track it down for you.

Good luck man.

GTR-N1 Grand Master

GTR-N1

Posted
Posted

Hey have you checked out that Nulon Valve Lifter additive yet?

And BTW you know already eh, that whilst you might go up from 10W to 15W,

you replace synthetic with synthetic & non with non? If poss. same brand too?

Tell us how it goes...

T

Wacky Dee Veteran

Wacky Dee

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)

Thanks Terry I'll give that valve lifter additive a go if the mechanic can't find the problem ... Does this stuff have any negative effect on the oil?

EDIT: never mind, found my answer ..seems safe and apparently doesn't affect oil viscosity (http://www.autobarn.com.au/products/10/70/3303550)

Edited by Delta Force
Wacky Dee Veteran

Wacky Dee

Posted
  • Author
Posted

just read in another thread about this lifter additive how it cleaned out all the crap from some poor chap's engine that it started to sound like a tractor due to all the lifters becoming noisy. Might give it a miss then :D

Wacky Dee Veteran

Wacky Dee

Posted
  • Author
Posted

just spoke to mechanic and he said he listened to the engine with a stetoscope (or whatever the spelling) and reckons it's near the cam inside the head .. so most likely the lifters. He said he looked at the manifold gaskets and it wasn't that .. Ah well.

Does anyone know how much it would cost approximately to repair r34 (gtt) lifter(s) incl. parts and labour? I'm just looking for a ballpark figure ..

  • 2 weeks later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • WMDC35
      Tomei gasket

      By WMDC35 · Posted

      Are you sure the gasket is blown? What are the issues? Thermocure is the only flush I've seen do anything with rust, very impressed with that, Prestone, rust will be by the pool having a cigarette.  
    • MBS206
      Tomei gasket

      By MBS206 · Posted

      And since the flush you have a blown head gasket? Have you lifted the head off yet?
    • GTSBoy
      Hr34 fuel pump not turning on

      By GTSBoy · Posted

      The answer is to get a hold of the wiring diagram, work out what voltage is supposed to be where, when, and then work out why it is not there, then. I can't speak to the HR34 stuff, because I have never paid any attention to the NAs. There is a possibility that the turbo diagram will help, but it could also be different - depending on whether there is an FPCM on the NAs.
    • Trinicandian
      Hr34 fuel pump not turning on

      By Trinicandian · Posted

      Hey guys. New here. I am having an issue with my hr34. The fuel pump isn't turning on. I removed it from the tank. Bench test it. Wasn't working. Order new one and installed it today. Still not turning on. Checked the relay. Relay has voltage on the contact side. I jumped it and it tuned the pump on. Which lead me to checked the coil voltage.  Turned on the ignition and had my meter across the coil and there wasn't any dc voltage. Had my meter lead on the positive and I used the frame ground and noticed there was 12 volts. Which lead me to believe the relay isn't getting a negative signal. I traced the wire ( black with pink strip).it goes back to the bottom on the steering and it gets lost into the harness.   I checked at the ecm and I can't seem to find that wire color.   My question if any one knows is. Can I not just run the negative through a ignition relay to turn on the fuel pump relay?. Or anyone ever had this issue and if so how did u go about fixing it.    
    • MBS206
      Dose's Sometimes DIY and Pay Someone Home & Boat Improvement Thread

      By MBS206 · Posted

      So many people don't notice it, as batteries decay slowly over time. Two big reasons people end up noticing and needing to replace batteries: 1) The cold weather. The cold not only makes it harder to turn the engine for a few reasons, but it also increases the batteries internal resistance. So this means you need MORE power to turn a colder engine, AND the battery has a lower limit on how much current it can provide. 2) Something gets modified/altered/added in the wiring, typically an aftermarket accessory, like a dash camera, or an alarm etc, and this adds a small amount extra onto the battery, and pushes it over the edge in its failing days. But if you hadn't have read this thread, and just pushed through, chances are you might have made it through this winter, just. But come next winter, it would have been kapoot. But the fact you changed it out now, means you've instantly noticed how much nicer it is for starting, and will be less worry for you that the engine won't start now.
×
×
  • Create New...