Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

hey hey,

so i understand why car manufacters 'detune' cars, that 'gentlemans agreement' of 207kw, restrictive exhaust, small injectors, turbos etc.

why wouldnt they just sell the cars with all the mods; maybe along the lines of; GTSS turbos, dumppipes, decent size injectors, decent fuel pump, i mean these add ons wouldnt cost that much more to sell on the car, but for us to upgrade costs thousands, sell the car with these bits, a restrictive exhaust and bugger all boost, i mean after all people do is change them all anyway, or is it a way for the car manufactures to make a killing of us, selling us aftermarket parts?

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/232973-detune-gtrs/
Share on other sites

There are about 1,000,000 ways to answer your question, some of them are:

1: Cost - If a manufactured did what you said, they wouldnt make profit because their target market wouldnt be able to afford it.

2: Reliability - Building it to its maximum and lowering the factor of safety doesnt make a good car. As you know, cars are designed to go well over 100,000 km. Sure they can do it, but again, for how much.

They are the two i can think of.

Simple logical reasons you probably use everyday, but just on a large large scale.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/232973-detune-gtrs/#findComment-4086107
Share on other sites

OEMs are penny pinching, unless their brand's reputation can let them afford not to be.

If they can save $5 a car they will, since over a hundred thousand cars that's $5 million. Imagine saving $5 a part, on all the parts you replace. Why do you think most mass produced cars have such nasty press-bent exhausts with ugly welds? Its because doing the job properly takes time and money, two things OEMs hate to lose. One OEM used to brag that the entire speaker set in their most popular car only cost them $20 - that attitude explains why most factory stereos have traditionally sounded like shit.

Manufacturers don't want you modding your car anyway, especially in "undetectable" ways. They overengineer their cars (for the performance provided) to last a long time, for warranty and reputation purposes. If they put bigger "bolt ons" while keeping the core block etc as "affordable" (read cheap) as they do, the cars become less reliable. If they upgrade the core, that's even bigger dollars.

If you choose to mod your car, the hardware changes are easy to detect and they can just void your warranty should something break.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/232973-detune-gtrs/#findComment-4086422
Share on other sites

There are about 1,000,000 ways to answer your question, some of them are:

1: Cost - If a manufactured did what you said, they wouldnt make profit because their target market wouldnt be able to afford it.

2: Reliability - Building it to its maximum and lowering the factor of safety doesnt make a good car. As you know, cars are designed to go well over 100,000 km. Sure they can do it, but again, for how much.

They are the two i can think of.

Simple logical reasons you probably use everyday, but just on a large large scale.

^^^ and...

3: Warranty - If a new owner of such potent vehicle were to be granted a license to fang it, he'd get pretty disappointed if the dealer didn't replace a clutch,, rotors, turbo, CV etc. No the dealer would do better if we were the bunnies that added things on; and became individualistic about it.

Caveat Emptor

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/232973-detune-gtrs/#findComment-4086817
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • That's probably OK. That's a face to face compression joint between two surfaces with the clamping load provided by those bolts. So.... it's unlikely that the bolts will end up feeling that load in shear, unless the clamping surfaces are not large enough, bolts not got enough tension on them, etc etc to prevent the two faces from moving wrt each other. Which... I would hope the designers have considered, seeing as it's probably one of the most important things the upright has to do apart from resist collapsing in its own right. But yes, it would definitely be worth asking them what their safety factor on that part of the design was. I tend to think that the casting, being a casting, is not necessarily the strongest bit of material in the world. It's about an inch square, and when you think about the loads that are being put into it, you have to wonder what safety factor the Nissan boys (and every other OEM engineer who has designed all the millions of other uprights that look essentially the same) used to account for defective casting, aging, severe impacts on the wheel, etc etc. 
    • Those bolts would be orders of magnitude stronger that cast aluminium though.  And its mainly clamping force, not shear they are dealing with?
    • Except all that twisting force that is breaking a cast piece, appears to be going through 4 bolts in the picture Johnny posted of the BryPar one...
    • The smart approach is to use the gearbox loom from the manual car. Makes it a lot easier - just plugs into the switches on the box and plugs into the main loom up near the fusebox. Then you only need to deal with bypassing the inhibit switch. The other approach requires you to use the wiring diagram to identify those wires by colour and location, perhaps even indulging in a little multimeter action to trace them end to end to make sure, and then.... you will have the answers you need. The R34 wiring diagram is available on-line (no, I do not have a link to it myself - I would have to do a search if I wasn't able to go to the copy I have at home).
    • Hi, i’m converted my r34 4dr auto to manual but need help with gearbox wiring. There are bunch of wires no idea which one for speedo drive, neutral, reverse can anyone help me. IMG_6860.mov
×
×
  • Create New...