Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

  • 5 months later...

Great Thread! My R33 GTST has a damaged engine (RB25DET). I’m considering purchasing a RB25DT engine & swapping the bits over as per this thread. I’m slightly nervous about the long term durability, considering the high k’s the vehicle does and the way in which it’s driven, however I’m interested due to the great price of a RB25DE engine!

The vehicle still has the standard ECU so the lower boost wouldn’t be an issue.

Question? Should I be paying some consideration to my Garret/HKS GT 25/35? As in, is this a too bigger Snail for this application? I suppose not as long as I’m using a decent tuning workshop right. (Racepace Melb). The only other mods are: larger intercooler, pod filter, 3in exhaust, spitfire coil packs & decent plugs.

180rwkw was achieved recently, however the engine had a damaged head/valve or valve guide seals or other. It still went really well, despite chewing through a heap of oil up until a piston went through the side of the block the other night! not good..

Thanks in advance for any tips.. HBOSS

  • 4 weeks later...

Geez dan after all these years this thread has been goin on, how much do you think you have spent to turborize ur car and all the stop and gos along the way? The slowness is starting to get to me but i love my car. Im thinking of selling it and getting a manual turbo? what does everyone think? worth the trouble converting or get a GTT?

  • 2 weeks later...

hi,

i reckon if you put a det motor in it would be better at least it would have had a turbo run in to it, plus you can boost it more, instead of having a stock turbo on, it a de could maybe do damage cause of compression.

hi,

i reckon if you put a det motor in it would be better at least it would have had a turbo run in to it, plus you can boost it more, instead of having a stock turbo on, it a de could maybe do damage cause of compression.

hmm good point.

Anyone know much much price difference is for stock RB25DE motor? Its done 59,000kms very clean.. Compared to price of GTT motor? and where can I buy a gtt motor? wreckers n stuff ay?

Dont forget that the transmission, brakes, and diff are all different between the turbo and non-turbo. Just dropping in a turbo engine can put these parts under alot of stress. It is alot cheaper to buy a turbo car from the outset, but when you get paid like me ($6.80/h apprentice mechanic) converting your N/A to turbo is easier because it can be done is small instalments!

Geez dan after all these years this thread has been goin on, how much do you think you have spent to turborize ur car and all the stop and gos along the way? The slowness is starting to get to me but i love my car. Im thinking of selling it and getting a manual turbo? what does everyone think? worth the trouble converting or get a GTT?

I spent bugger-all doing the conversion, you've got to remember I did this back when GTT''s were damn expensive (my 25GT was $34K back then!!!! ) My GT + t was stolen and written off a long time ago, I've now got a real GTT.

Seriously the stupid price I've seen parts going for you'd be looking at under $1500 for the conversion DIY over a weekend :D

  • 3 weeks later...

Ok well anyone want to critique my current thinking...

RB20DET in my HR31 coupe has died of old age.

I am considering an R32 RB25DE+T setup.

Would comprise of the following...

R32 RB25DE

HR31 RB20 plenum top and throttlebody (cable is on opposite side, will not clear my strut brace otherwise, plenums basically the same)

HR31 RB20DET cams (more agressive than R32 RB20 or 32/33 RB25 items)

Nistuned HR31 RB20DET ECU, sensors, coilpacks.

GT-R 440cc injectors

BB VG30DET Turbo, full 3" exhaust

Blitz LM intercooler

Bosch 984 pump

?Perhaps a thicker aftermarket head gasket?

?Possibly Z32 AFM?

I know the ecu is old however I'm fairly confident the Nistune board would allow it to be more than tuneable enough. Could possibly run a Nistuned R32 RB20DET ECU if totally necessary, however I think with the Nistune setup the HR31 ecu won't be a significant restriction compared to the R32 item

-I do not want a knife edge tune. The car will probably often see high load/knock threshold driving (i.e. between home and work is a steep, wide open throttle, 5 minute long climb at 80kmh in top), the occasional track day. It won't be an every day car though.

-Fuel is a limitation here, it would have to be reliable on Caltex Vortex 95 or BP Ultimate.

-Ideally I want to swap back to my original RB20DET eventually (with a stout rebuild), in a year or two, so I don't want to have to butcher the original loom. This is part of why if possible I'd like to retain the original ecu.

So, would I be able to do this reliably? What sort of power output can I reliably achieve - can I realistically make enough grunt to justify the expense over slipping another RB20DET long motor in? It needs to be a reliable, turnkey performer that could potentially do a few years or more as a weekender and fun car.

Edited by floody

Sounds like it'd be spot on

i wouldn't run a thicker head gasket, doesn't solve anything. It'll make good power on stock boost (7psi on a high comp 25 should eat a 20det on over double that)

DO EET :down:

but good luck finding an R32 25DE, everyone snaps them up for 30det conversions

Theres no reason why you couldn't use an R33 rb25, you could hook all the same electrics up (you don't have to have a plug for vct it will work fine without it) you'd just have the plenum issue - I'm not sure how different they are, if its just port sizing i wouldn't call it an issue.

Oh I have a line on a motor...and they aren't that hard to get anyway. Plenum is mainly due to the throttle cable fouling the strut brace on a R33 RB25, and ability to run HR31 RB20DET plenum top on a R32 RB25 which means my throttle body will bolt up and my cable won't be in the way.

I was only thinking thicker gasket as in an aftermarket one, HKS, Tomei etc; standard thickness would be fine I guess and reduce chances of hotspots etc.

At 10:1 comp and the hills here, with our at times dodgy fuel I am a bit worried about detonation though...suppose I could tune it very rich and run Shell V-Power from Autocraft.

Oh I have a line on a motor...and they aren't that hard to get anyway. Plenum is mainly due to the throttle cable fouling the strut brace on a R33 RB25, and ability to run HR31 RB20DET plenum top on a R32 RB25 which means my throttle body will bolt up and my cable won't be in the way.

I was only thinking thicker gasket as in an aftermarket one, HKS, Tomei etc; standard thickness would be fine I guess and reduce chances of hotspots etc.

At 10:1 comp and the hills here, with our at times dodgy fuel I am a bit worried about detonation though...suppose I could tune it very rich and run Shell V-Power from Autocraft.

i really don't think that compression is going to be a problem, and decompressing it wouldn't really solve anything except kill some of its power, you should really only use them when you've shaved a bit much off the head etc.

Look at Juddo with his 25de+t, didn't stress it in the slightest, and he only ran 95ron, but on like 10PSI, everything stock. On stock boost i really cant see it complaining at all, esp with a good fmic, i wouldn't worry about richening it up (rich enough from factory), maybe wind some base timing out of it, but still would be fine.

If you can run 7psi through a 9:1 CR 30e, you should definitely be able to run 7psi on a 10:1 CR with a good cooler.

as for the throttle cable, cant you just use a std RB30e position one? thats all i did for my 30de, got a thick flat bit of steel, few bends, drilled a few holes, added some spacers and made one shmicko, looks way better than stock, sits at perfect height. When i fit my ff plenum i prob wont need it actually...

Edited by SKiT_R31
  • 3 weeks later...

so is it really worth turbo-ing a non-turbo engine?

i have a R33 GTS and i really want more power.

i've considered buying all the turbo parts and doing it, but then thought it would be a headache, so

my next option would be to do an engine swap... RB25DE to the RB25DET, but then all the gear box and ecu

and what ever else needed got to me.

so would it be easier to buy a skyline turbo or a 200sx when im off my P's?

any suggestions would be appreciated

josh

the n/a gearbox will handle a 25det just as much as it will handle a 25de+t, ditto for clutch

^ the gearbox should be ok with it, pending how you treat it

The ecu has to be changed anyway

I'd rather run 7PSI on an n/a engine that i know and trust, over 10psi on a random engine, to make the same power.

You'll hit the ecu power/airflow restriction before you have any other problems, just the same as with the 25det, but on less boost (as its drawing in more air and making more power)

Id rather rebuild the N/A bottom end with some lower comp pistons than waste money on a flogged 25det

And changing all the turbo bits over is easier/less hassle that an engine swap any way imo

that said, if your not attached to your car, buying a turbo model is definitely the easiest and possibly cheapest option, as brakes, etc are already upto spec just if you don't know a ot about cars/engine, get some one who does to have a look over it for telltale signs of water pump, oil seals etc, test CR etc. As if its a turbo import in Australia, its been thrashed.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Hey crew, Failed my WOF cause of a lower control arm, and I've decided to hit both arms, and also the compression rods at the same time(seems they're gonna be the most likely upcoming failure points from some discussions with the lads over on the G35 reddit). I've looking at these form Z1:  https://www.z1motorsports.com/front-suspension/hayaku-automotive/hayaku-g35-front-compression-rod-p-40716.html https://www.z1motorsports.com/front-suspension/hayaku-automotive/hayaku-g35-front-lower-control-arm-p-40674.html I asked Z1 if they'd work as it's the same platform, just RHD vs LHD. I basically got told "Lol dunno". Specifically they aren't aware of any difference but can't guarantee fitment as they haven't done it on a 350GT. So guess I'm asking is if there is any issues with using 2005 G35 coupe suspension parts on a 2005 350GT coupe? Orginally I thought it could be something in the way of the arms that each control arm is designed to be positioned around, but that'd be an engineering nightmare for Nissan needing two different shaped control arms 😅
    • ^ This. The mode door actuator is a common failure, as is the actuator and/or the actual valve for the coolant flow control valve. I also don't know how available the mode door actuator is these days. I've been meaning to look into it and get one from wherever is possible, to keep in the shed for the rainy day when mine eventually fails. Anyway, the advice to you is to search the usual NOS part supply places, or even just go to Nissan and see what they list.
    • Have you got a pic of the actuator? My guess is that unit has failed internally and was flopping around, so the previous engineer who owned it forced it to be fully open to cold air (blocking the heater core path). As far as you can tell, is anything else wrong in the system? Likely you just need a new actuator (not sure how available they are) and then "installation is the reverse of disassembly"
    • I'm happy with the Lsailt unit that I put in, it puts full Android on the top screen so you can run whatever Nav and other Apps you want, while still existing inside the factory functionality like automatic reverse cams, audio input switching, retains factory bluetooth etc. Not cheap and the install was moderate (not simple, not hard) Yours is a V36 not V37 though right?
    • Yeap, all the NC's that I originally looked at that had a hard top were PRHT, which makes the roof line look horrible, hence why I said nope to them My only caveat for another MX5 was it needed to have a hard top, and initially I didn't think you could get a detachable hard top for the NC,  like my NB had Again, a big thanks to Matty for helping me source the detachable hard top for my little girl, they are as rare as hens teeth in Australia, and the few people who have them, keep them Also to Greg, for initially pointing me in the NC direction NC PRHT 🤢🤮 Not mine (I really should take more photos of my car), but a NC with the detachable hard top 😁 To me, the difference in how the detachable hard top roof line looks, and how it actually follows the bodies lines, like they do on NA's and NB's, is chalk and cheese compared to the bulbous looking PRHT  
×
×
  • Create New...