Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

hey guys

might not get many hits or responses but after opinions anyway....

looking to spend around the $800ish mark on front splits.

i have been a devoted alpine sound man for around 13 years now and they have never dissapointed. so with that in mind have been looking at the 17pro. also have been looking at focal splits lately. namely the 165v30 and 165krx2.

anyone had experience listening to these speakers????

if so what are your thoughts/opinions.....pro's cons etcs

thanks in advance

mick

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/364539-focal-splits-vs-alpine/
Share on other sites

yep.

Focal for the win.

German handcrafted speakers, warm sound(with the right amp) and would choose em over alpine any day.

Theyre up there with the Previous models of MBQaurt and German Maestro stuff!

would also reccomend a Rockford i360. with a 24 band eq for each speaker you can make the mid range speakers sound better than the top end.

oh yeh I'm a sound engineer :nyaanyaa:

yep.

Focal for the win.

German handcrafted speakers, warm sound(with the right amp) and would choose em over alpine any day.

Theyre up there with the Previous models of MBQaurt and German Maestro stuff!

would also reccomend a Rockford i360. with a 24 band eq for each speaker you can make the mid range speakers sound better than the top end.

oh yeh I'm a sound engineer :nyaanyaa:

you say focal all the way.....im reading reviews and starting to think the same

not sure whether i want to spend the 550 on v30 or the extra 400 say for the krx2(around the 900 mark). by the way i can get the x pro for same price as the v30

would i notice difference between the v30 and krx2??? almost double price thats all

not competing or anything.....just for me to listen to

depends on how sensitive your ear are. being an engineer for this stuff the slightest difference will piss me off over time. hence the rockford i360.

but to alot of others, the entry level will sound the same as mid. and mid will sound the same as top.

Its vital to know the amp your getting, it will change the sound of the speakers dramatically.

I have some brand new German Maestros splits for sale cheap $350 delivered. i bought em for i think $700 mark and they are genuine. might be worth it for you if not competing!!

honestly if your not competing, you wont notice any difference. i bought midrange maestros for my previous car and made em sound like the $1300 top end model lol.

again alpine amp..........had four of these already since 98 and never ever had a problem......i know they are a bit pricey etc but i trust the brand

amp will more than likely be pdx-f4

also the v30 vs. your maestros for sale??

keep in mind you are trying to sell em

well the PDX are good.

v30's go i think about 10db higher(if that) and run 20w more at normal but 10-15w less at peak.

keeping in mind i am trying to sell them, but also in mind that if i was sold ghey speakers i would locate n kill the person lol.

look Focals yeh i wouldnt look twice, they would be mine. Hand Made warm sounding and a respectable brand with relaibility(be careful of ebay sellers). But if it came down to it I wouldnt be buying $7-800 speakers, when i could find something near enough, for $350 delivered I would know what im looking for..

lol

I'm not sound engineer but I've had a couple of decent home and car systems and I try to keep up(more with home sound now) I've always been rewarded by following the rule that speakers must come from a speaker company, same for amps, Alpine can provide the complex electronics (source). As for spending money on amp vs speaker. Generally the influence of speakers is by bar the most important aspect of any half-decent decent system (so spend on good speakers and install over slightly better amp unless required).

I'd agree with Aaron that $900 for splits is a bit much in 2011. Maybe back in 2000 it was needed but things are soo much cheaper now I couldn't justify it.

Current (post 2005)model specifics I have no idea but are you sure you can't fit something a touch bigger than 6" in the doors???? How about a shallow 7" or 8" to bring the upper bass forward in the cabin? (AFAIK this type of thing can't be fixed with a equalizer).

FWIW I currently have alpine head deck and proper splits in the doors (my own MDF mounts and Jaycar amp).

Edited by simpletool

Having currently in my ute a Set of Focal 165VR's i can assure you that im currently waiting for Freeway car audio to have their yearly sale to buy another pair,

The best speakers i have had to date.

Also Aaron i thought Focal was French?

yep.

Focal for the win.

German handcrafted speakers, warm sound(with the right amp) and would choose em over alpine any day.

Theyre up there with the Previous models of MBQaurt and German Maestro stuff!

would also reccomend a Rockford i360. with a 24 band eq for each speaker you can make the mid range speakers sound better than the top end.

oh yeh I'm a sound engineer :nyaanyaa:

Focals are made in France not Germany,

Made in france link

polydax in france makes a lot of speakers for others.

not my first choice for that kind of money, actually not even in my top ten for the money

some half the cost sound better and perform better IMO

Alpine, over rated- type R average speakers , the top of the line aren't made by Alpine, but another company .

go with Vifa, Morel, DLS, Dynaaudio, Hertz, SEAS, Rainbow and build your own crossovers to save lots of dosh

the vifa from jaycar are just as good or better then Alpine, Focal with proper crossovers/baffles and installed right a 1/4 the cost

Audiocontrol DQT like the pair in my car has 31 bands of Digital EQ per speaker with 8 program modes , and 13 volts pre amp out per channel

Audison Bit one or 10 is another option new to the marketplace

Alpine has one too.

MB Quart sounds nice but cost a fair whack for paper cones. . the 3 way splits sound really nice, but a bit harsh on the top end

sorry french.. my mistake!

MB Quart only recently (4years or so) went to paper cone when they were taken over by the Chinese. thats what i was told anyway..

as im aware German Maestro bought the original design of the speaker and took over from there!

Lanzar............!!!

That's the brand of splits I had in my first car, back 1997 with a Rockford Fosgate amp. Thanks sapphiregraphics, you're signature reminded me.

Sorry, nothing more to add. Except speaker choice is really up to personal preference. Scientific measures are as useful to comparing speakers as they are to picking the right shirt for a date.

yes lanzar, until a new sponsor comes on board..lol, they sell stuff from the cheap side to the extreme. a new 24,000 watt @.5 ohm spl mono block amps for the bargain price of 24k.....6- O gauge power connections on it

and other amps for 60 bucks

once again a company that uses someone elses curcuits with lanzar on it. very common these days after the GFC

the speakers arent as good as some others but the cost was right..lol its more about the install to make cheap equipment sound good

lanzar has been around for the long haul.

sorry french.. my mistake!

MB Quart only recently (4years or so) went to paper cone when they were taken over by the Chinese. thats what i was told anyway..

as im aware German Maestro bought the original design of the speaker and took over from there!

the ones I sold in 1988 had papercones, but the 3 ways were awesome sounding for paper..lol

Edited by sapphiregraphics

oh really lol.. i wasnt even born hahaha.. the German Maestros i have arent paper cones but as i said they are the original design of the MBQuart discus range(although my ears tell me theyre much better)

  • 4 weeks later...

Pulp paper is still used in some of the most expensive and best sounded speakers in the world. I think the real problem with paper cones is that the material itself can be destroyed easily due to poor environment conditions and moisture.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Even with the piston at TDC there was room for it to drop, but I don't think it can drop fully into the cylinder, the problem you have is that you need something pushing against the valve to hold it up so you have enough room to put the new stem seal on and the spring etc.  I used compressed air only because putting rope in the cylinder seemed a bit risky to me, I know people have done it countless times before like this. Overall it's a pain in the ass job. Honestly you'd probably be better off taking the head off because the risk of dropping something in the engine and the finicky-ness of it all is very stressful. If you are going to attempt it though i 10000% recommend a 36050 valve spring/keeper tool. I had both the traditional lever type and after doing 1 cylinder it was absolute pain to get those valve keepers in place, even with 2 people. That 36050 is amazing, you do have to push hard to get them in place but it works perfectly almost every time. Back to my actual issue I think my engine is just tired and old and the rings have gone bad. The comp numbers (cold, no oil) were: Cyl 1 -129psi Cyl 2 - 133psi Cyl 3 - 138psi Cyl 4 - 137psi Cyl 5 - 157psi Cyl 6 - 142psi   Cylinder 5 and 6 having the most carbon on them.
    • Who did you have do the installation? I actually know someone who is VERY familiar with the AVS gear. The main point of contact though would be your installer.   Where are you based in NZ?
    • Look, realistically, those are some fairly chunky connectors and wires so it is a reasonably fair bet that that loom was involved in the redirection of the fuel pump and/or ECU/ignition power for the immobiliser. It's also fair to be that the new immobiliser is essentially the same thing as the old one, and so it probably needs the same stuff done to make it do what it has to do. Given that you are talking about a car that no-one else here is familiar with (I mean your exact car) and an alarm that I've never heard of before and so probably not many others are familiar with, and that some wire monkey has been messing with it out of our sight, it seems reasonable that the wire monkey should be fixing this.
    • Wheel alignment immediately. Not "when I get around to it". And further to what Duncan said - you cannot just put camber arms on and shorten them. You will introduce bump steer far in excess of what the car had with stock arms. You need adjustable tension arms and they need to be shortened also. The simplest approach is to shorten them the same % as the stock ones. This will not be correct or optimal, but it will be better than any other guess. The correct way to set the lengths of both arms is to use a properly built/set up bump steer gauge and trial and error the adjustments until you hit the camber you need and want and have minimum bump steer in the range of motion that the wheel is expected to travel. And what Duncan said about toe is also very true. And you cannot change the camber arm without also affecting toe. So when you have adjustable arms on the back of a Skyline, the car either needs to go to a talented wheel aligner (not your local tyre shop dropout), or you need to be able to do this stuff yourself at home. Guess which approach I have taken? I have built my own gear for camber, toe and bump steer measurement and I do all this on the flattest bit of concrete I have, with some shims under the tyres on one side to level the car.
    • Thought I would get some advice from others on this situation.    Relevant info: R33 GTS25t Link G4x ECU Walbro 255LPH w/ OEM FP Relay (No relay mod) Scenario: I accidentally messed up my old AVS S5 (rev.1) at the start of the year and the cars been immobilised. Also the siren BBU has completely failed; so I decided to upgrade it.  I got a newer AVS S5 (rev.2?) installed on Friday. The guy removed the old one and its immobilisers. Tried to start it; the car cranks but doesnt start.  The new one was installed and all the alarm functions seem to be working as they should; still wouldn't start Went to bed; got up on Friday morning and decided to have a look into the no start problem. Found the car completely dead.  Charged the battery; plugged it back in and found the brake lights were stuck on.  Unplugging the brake pedal switch the lights turn off. Plug it back in and theyre stuck on again. I tested the switch (continuity test and resistance); all looks good (0-1kohm).  On talking to AVS; found its because of the rubber stopper on the brake pedal; sure enough the middle of it is missing so have ordered a new one. One of those wear items; which was confusing what was going on However when I try unplugging the STOP Light fuses (under the dash and under the hood) the brake light still stays on. Should those fuses not cut the brake light circuit?  I then checked the ECU; FP Speed Error.  Testing the pump again; I can hear the relay clicking every time I switch it to ON. I unplugged the pump and put the multimeter across the plug. No continuity; im seeing 0.6V (ECU signal?) and when it switches the relay I think its like 20mA or 200mA). Not seeing 12.4V / 7-9A. As far as I know; the Fuel Pump was wired through one of the immobiliser relays on the old alarm.  He pulled some thick gauged harness out with the old alarm wiring; which looks to me like it was to bridge connections into the immobilisers? Before it got immobilised it was running just fine.  Im at a loss to why the FP is getting no voltage; I thought maybe the FP was faulty (even though I havent even done 50km on the new pump) but no voltage at the harness plug.  Questions: Could it be he didnt reconnect the fuel pump when testing it after the old alarm removal (before installing the new alarm)?  Is this a case of bridging to the brake lights instead of the fuel pump circuit? It's a bit beyond me as I dont do a lot with electrical; so have tried my best to diagnose what I think seems to make sense.  Seeking advice if theres for sure an issue with the alarm install to get him back here; or if I do infact, need an auto electrician to diagnose it. 
×
×
  • Create New...