Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

You can't mess with the knock sensors very easily. They are really just piezo microphones. They listen and feed the waveform back to the knock board in the ECU which decides if it's hearing knock or not. If you wanted to fake a knock sense, then you'd need to send a convincing waveform that you'd have to synthesize somehow.

From my experience with the knock sensors and the knock map, the whole thing is not reliable anyway. I couldn't get my ECU to stay on the main map even though it wasn't pinging, so we just did what a lot of Nistuners do, which is to make both maps the same. That way you don't find yourself drivign around on a soft map, and the extra safety actor can go to hell. My ECU has been tuned like that for a few years now, and there has not been a single moment where it has been bad.

  • Replies 59
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

That was me with the CarPC and switching maps and PULP98 and E-Flex and all that...

After running between the 2 different fuels for a while now, I've found it a bit of a waste of time...

As in i wanted to get around the "draining the tank and then switching fuels" But I end up just loading the PULP98 map and trimming the AFR's to suit for the couple of "Inbetween tanks" where the mix is somewhere in the middle of E70 and E0.

But having 2, 3, 4, as many maps as you'd like is easy with NIStune.

As for the capacity of power limits ect. forget about it...

You can't mess with the knock sensors very easily. They are really just piezo microphones. They listen and feed the waveform back to the knock board in the ECU which decides if it's hearing knock or not. If you wanted to fake a knock sense, then you'd need to send a convincing waveform that you'd have to synthesize somehow.

Just make a headphone jack for the knock loom and plug it into some really bad metal, lol.

If ever there was a bad way to achieve something - you guys have found it

Buy an ECU that gives you all the functions you want. If you really wanted to do double maps, you can do what some of the Jap companies were doing and doing a double EPROM with a switch on pin 1 for power or whatever it was. It just swapped power to the other EPROM and ran a seperate map.

Doing it with knock sensors is kinda dodgey and pretty funny at the same time.

If ever there was a bad way to achieve something - you guys have found it

I don't think anyone was actually going to bother heh.

Buy an ECU that gives you all the functions you want. If you really wanted to do double maps, you can do what some of the Jap companies were doing and doing a double EPROM with a switch on pin 1 for power or whatever it was. It just swapped power to the other EPROM and ran a seperate map.

Doing it with knock sensors is kinda dodgey and pretty funny at the same time.

In the $2k range what ECU would you recommend? The V500 still?

I don't think anyone was actually going to bother heh.

In the $2k range what ECU would you recommend? The V500 still?

Yeah the V500 is actually more advanced than the Motec at this point. Runs 6 multi controllers and is the only ECU other than Motec that does.

You need to read up on this ECU to fully understand what it is capable of. You can overlay each map over each other and each multi controller has 6 inputs and outputs or something like that. Each one can be made as a 32x32 table which can be layed over any other table.

So you can do boost over wheel speed over tps over fuel pressure over nitrous pressure over ignition timing if you want

Pretty much whatever you can imagine.

Only after swapping to the V500 did all our problems go away.

As far as I know it's really good. I am not a tuner, just an end user. From what I have seen though, it is very 'thorough'. I don't think it's something just anybody can get a handle of. You need to know what you are doing. I have heard people complain about the current software but it's always stuff that exceeds their knowledge so they are only complaining in ignorance

I don't think anyone was actually going to bother heh.

In the $2k range what ECU would you recommend? The V500 still?

V500 is junk... cannot be compared to a $1400 LINK G4 or Vipec or haltech for that matter... worlds apart in quality.

V500 is junk... cannot be compared to a $1400 LINK G4 or Vipec or haltech for that matter... worlds apart in quality.

This is pretty much what my mates tell me, but I always hear conflicting reports on here, though I get the feeling the people who say it is good don't actually use it.

Heard much about the DTAFast range of ECUs?

Edited by Rolls

Lol @ using a vibrator to set the knock sensor off.

Im not 100% sure but if the knock sensor is faulty it will run on the knock maps. I havent checked the resistance on a faulty sensor but i know a good sensor is 570kohm.

So if it was as simple as setting a 2nd wiring circuit with a higher/lower resistor so when u switch to the 2nd circuit it jumps to the knock maps.

I dont trust the knock maps. Especially at higher rpm where there is alot of valve train noise

If ever there was a bad way to achieve something - you guys have found it

Doing it with knock sensors is kinda dodgey and pretty funny at the same time.

I thought it was an AWSOME idea... ha ha ha. it's right up there with the clasics- trim pot on the afm, welding the clutchplate to the flywheel, skipping a tooth on the cam gear/belt on a vl rb30, stick on wrx bonnet scoops and plastic spinners rims.

J.

LOL

only thing i dont like about my NIStune is it doesnt show knock readings for the r32 gtr, but apparently Matt has been trying to make it work for years now...

You can get real knock (audible on knock ears) but have it not register on the knock count, I wouldn't trust the standard nissan system.

Non of them accurately show knock reading like power fc does michael.

The ecu has an internal knock board that senses knock which then switches to the knock maps. But doesnt let the user know when it does it.

would you prefer that the ecu shows you that its knowing and flashes a light at you yet does nothing about it and by then it may be too late (power fc) or would prefer an ecu that when it senses knocking reverts to a knock copy map which saves the engine. (nistune)

would you prefer that the ecu shows you that its knowing and flashes a light at you yet does nothing about it and by then it may be too late (power fc) or would prefer an ecu that when it senses knocking reverts to a knock copy map which saves the engine. (nistune)

The issue is it doesn't half the time. We put a set of knock ears on my old car and reved out 3rd gear on a hot day (30c) after idlding it around for 30 minutes to get it real hot and it started pinging its tits off, didn't go to the knock map where we had taken 5degrees out across the whole boost section.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • It was a great, but typical track day, and some VB was ingested at the night time debrief 🤪
    • And so, to round this out, I couldn't be happier to confirm @MBS206 has decided to buy the car. He drove down from sunny QLD with a trailer last week and it is off to its new home today. I'll let Matt confirm on next steps but I understand broadly that the plan is to leave it pretty much as is, and just get some quality wheel time with a nicely balanced car that is pretty much track ready. There are a few a jobs still to be done first but nothing too major and I think its a very smart buy Dinner last night at the Paragon with a round of VBs (mostly) for Neil
    • Well, 50 pages and the end of a chapter for this car. We took it out for a shakedown at Wakie yesterday, and everything went well. There were a couple of niggles: - Oil cooler fitting leak - tightened, cleaned, stopped leaking - Radiator cap overflow fitting was leaking....Mark called it, the overflow fitting was threaded in and not tight....tightened, tested and held pressure - Small oil leak at the rear of the block, probably the turbo oil feed - too hot to get at it comfortably but probably just needs to be nipped up - leak at the driver's side rear brake line where it meets the hardline. Fitting wasn't loose, so Matt backed it off and back on, no further leaks - there's also a leak somewhere on the top of the fuel tank, maybe that cross over fuel line - that was has been left to fix when its on a hoist Otherwise than those niggles the car went great, turned great and stopped great so it was a very successful day out. I'm always really nervous when a car first hits the track after a long break, especially with a brand new engine as well but it was great. VID-20251011-WA0007.mp4  Big thanks to @The Bogan who dropped by and helped out, @MBS206 and my nephew Lachlan the apprentice.  Neil's wife Mel also surprised the hell out of all of us by dropping by; she's up in Tamworth these days but was travelling to Melbourne so had plausible deniability for turning up at the garage, it was great to see her but also obviously a bit sad all round.
    • Skyline R33 Series 2 sedan tail lights in excellent condition. These are becoming harder to find, especially in this state.    BOTH SETS ARE IN FANTASTIC CONDITION (REFER TO PHOTOS)    ✅ No broken covers or cracks ✅ Lenses are in flawless condition ✅ All rear mounting lugs intact ✅ Comes complete as pictured ✅ Perfect for restoration, replacement, or upgrade   These lights are ready to go, no surprises just quality OEM parts.   These are definitely one of the better sets we have seen in a while. With minimal wear and tear they will come as you see. Bear in mind they are not brand new they are almost 30 years old now. To find them in this condition isn’t easy they can only be obtained on the second hand market.   Australia Wide Postage Available At Buyers Expense. Silver Set:$850 Grey Set:$850 PM Me for purchase or any other questions  IMG_2166.dng IMG_2165.dng IMG_2172.dng IMG_2173.dng IMG_2174.dng IMG_2179.dng IMG_2180.dng IMG_2260.dng IMG_2258.dng IMG_2259.dng IMG_2261.dng IMG_2266.dng IMG_2273.dng IMG_2274.dng IMG_2276.dng
    • Unsolicited advice? Keep the engine as close to stock as you can. Nothing wrong with adding some boost and making a little more power, but given where you are, you really don't want to try to make it into a monster. I can't imagine the roads are up to it, and the lack of locla support when it grenades will be a ball ache. FWIW, If there is a dyno around that you can access, then brand new injectors are a good idea, which will lead you to (at least) putting a Nistune in it, which will allow you to put an R35 AFM on it, all of which will make it possible to make it much much nicer to drive and live with.
×
×
  • Create New...