Jump to content
SAU Community

Gearbox Making Odd Noise At Idle

TiTAN
 Share

Recommended Posts

TiTAN Grand Master

TiTAN

Posted
Posted

just recently my gearbox has started making clunky noises while idling, the noise goes away if you push the clutch pedal in. it has been suggested that it could be the spigot bush but i know it has a manual one in it and not an auto/none at all.

in the same time it has locked me out of all forward gears 4 times while driving, to get it into gear again you have to completely stop the car moving, select first and it will then work fine again, someone said this could be a synchro ring jamming out of alignment?

any other ideas as to what it could be before i go to the effort of taking the gearbox out?

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/394714-gearbox-making-odd-noise-at-idle/
Share on other sites
Birds Grand Master

Birds

Posted
Posted

A damaged synchro won't lock you out of all 4 gears...it can, however, lock you into a gear. A selector issue, on the other hand, can lock you out of all gears.

Locking out of all gears is usually a clutch dragging issue - input shaft is turning despite clutch pedal being depressed, meaning gears will be hard to select as if you're not touching the clutch at all. When you try to engage the gear while locked out, does it crunch or just keep you locked out? If the latter, then I'd move towards a selector issue. It CAN also be a spigot bush/bearing issue, as a jammed up spigot can also turn the input shaft making it difficult to engage a gear. Does it ever happen on first start up? If not, then it is likely heat related - hydraulic systems behave differently under cold and hot operating conditions. The next time it jams you out of gears, check your clutch fork travel under the car while someone pumps the pedal. If there is plenty of travel then it could be the pressure plate.

The clunking itself may or may not be related. It is likely a gear rollover noise, be it a loose piece of metal inside the gearbrox or a missing tooth on your input shaft/cluster. Does it change the clunking when you rev the engine in neutral, i.e. clunking sound disappears or gets louder?

Sorry for the clustered questions and thoughts, there are lots of possibilities with drivetrain issues...the trick is to diagnose it part by part, and there is a logical process for it. You need to get as much information as possible to make the best diagnosis.

TiTAN Grand Master

TiTAN

Posted
  • Author
Posted

A damaged synchro won't lock you out of all 4 gears...it can, however, lock you into a gear. A selector issue, on the other hand, can lock you out of all gears.

Locking out of all gears is usually a clutch dragging issue - input shaft is turning despite clutch pedal being depressed, meaning gears will be hard to select as if you're not touching the clutch at all. 1. When you try to engage the gear while locked out, does it crunch or just keep you locked out? If the latter, then I'd move towards a selector issue. It 2. CAN also be a spigot bush/bearing issue, as a jammed up spigot can also turn the input shaft making it difficult to engage a gear. 3. Does it ever happen on first start up? If not, then it is likely heat related - hydraulic systems behave differently under cold and hot operating conditions. The next time it jams you out of gears, check your clutch fork travel under the car while someone pumps the pedal. If there is plenty of travel then it could be the pressure plate.

The clunking itself may or may not be related. It is likely a gear rollover noise, be it a loose piece of metal inside the gearbrox or a missing tooth on your input shaft/cluster. 4. Does it change the clunking when you rev the engine in neutral, i.e. clunking sound disappears or gets louder?

Sorry for the clustered questions and thoughts, there are lots of possibilities with drivetrain issues...the trick is to diagnose it part by part, and there is a logical process for it. You need to get as much information as possible to make the best diagnosis.

1. Keeps you locked out of all the gears, no crunching it just wont let you select any at all.

2. it doesn't have any issues going in or out of gears with the clutch in normally, only on the 4 occasions that it has done that

3. it has never happened on immediate startup, the car has driven fine for a few km, then it has done it (not up to temp yet for 2 occasions but the other 2 car was at normal operating temp and had been for a bit)

4. clunking sound appears to go away during a free rev in neutral, the sound is also not there while the car is moving in gear. only while idling in neutral

Birds Grand Master

Birds

Posted
Posted

1. Keeps you locked out of all the gears, no crunching it just wont let you select any at all.

2. it doesn't have any issues going in or out of gears with the clutch in normally, only on the 4 occasions that it has done that

3. it has never happened on immediate startup, the car has driven fine for a few km, then it has done it (not up to temp yet for 2 occasions but the other 2 car was at normal operating temp and had been for a bit)

4. clunking sound appears to go away during a free rev in neutral, the sound is also not there while the car is moving in gear. only while idling in neutral

There are still many possibilities, as to what it could be, however I'm leaning towards loose bits of metal inside your box for the clunking sound. Gears missing teeth tend to make a grinding sound that increases with RPM in neutral. Try dumping the oil and see if anything comes out...if not, then do the proper checks to rule it out as a clutch issue and start whipping out the box for a reco or second handy.

Possible that the loose metal is sporadically getting stuck in the selectors and locking you out of gears, or if the clunking issue is unrelated to the selecting gears issue, it could still be a clutch issue responsible for the latter. Hydraulic pressure doesn't change so much with the rest of the vehicle heating up, it tends to work independantly based on continued use of the clutch pedal, thus it will never happen on start up even if the engine/gearbox is warm.

It's a shame gearboxes don't have glass cases!

iseekool Veteran

iseekool

Posted
Posted

Just wondering have you changed the gearbox oil yet?

Had a simlar issue with my IS200 (partially locking me out - until you force it a little).

Change the gearbox oil - No problems...

TiTAN Grand Master

TiTAN

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Just wondering have you changed the gearbox oil yet?

Had a simlar issue with my IS200 (partially locking me out - until you force it a little).

Change the gearbox oil - No problems...

gearbox oil is 6000km old, was changed when i put the engine back in the car.

whole gearbox had a full reco about 3 years ago (~25-30,000km), all new seals, gaskets, synchros etc

TiTAN Grand Master

TiTAN

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Took the car to get checked out by a gearbox shop, they suggested it stop being driven at all after getting it up on the hoist and playing around with it, they feel its something to do with the clutch/pressure plate but cant say for sure until the box is out.

  • 1 month later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • GTSBoy
      R34 Handbrake light saying ON and intermittently flashing

      By GTSBoy · Posted

      Well, yes, every CU on the bus is available via the Consult port, but whether the scanner you are using is capable of talking to the TCU, the ABS/TCS modules, etc etc, is what is at question here. Many of them are only for engine codes. So, if you have one of those, you won't know if the ABS is having a bitch.
    • GTSBoy
      Wheel Sizes & Offsets For Skylines

      By GTSBoy · Posted

      That's now. R chassis Skylines come from a time when the tolerance in the ADRs was a bit more....slack. My car, on 235/35-17, which is damn near the exact same size as the original 205/55-16, is pretty much bang on correct indicated speed across the whole legal range. That's demonstrated with constant speed run over 5km, and GPS speed. It's just the luck of the draw. My particular speedo head has to be the thing that is "calibrated" that way, because everything else (the diff ratio, the gearbox and the speedo drive**) are all same same as most other Skylines. **OK, so the speedo drive is a Navara unit to drive the R32's cable, not the electronic unit than an R33/4 would normally have with teh same gear on it. Otherwise, I applaud your OCD tendencies, and I would do the same if I needed to.
    • RB25inside
      R34 Handbrake light saying ON and intermittently flashing

      By RB25inside · Posted

      Not too sure, I believe the Nissan consult port does everything? Also just filled up the reservoir to full and the light is still on. The float seems to move up and down fine.
    • The Bogan
      Wheel Sizes & Offsets For Skylines

      By The Bogan · Posted

      The speedo's can be very conservative, when my Mazda NC MX5 speedo is showing 118kph, the GPS, and a calibrated radar.... cop mate.....hits me at around 110kph +/- 1 or 2 kph, and that is on a 215/45 17, stock tyres size is 205/45 17 as well, so weirdly conservative with stock tyre size When my Commodore speedo red 116kph GPS had me at 110kph on 255/40 17, so again conservative Google says manufacturers need to set the speedo from 4 to 10% slower than actual road speed.....for safety.....and compliance  After doing some offset and clearance measurements to see what can fit the NC on 17x8 +40, without guard rolling or rubbing anything at my current ride height, I've decided that when my tyres are toast, I'm going to fit 225/45 17 and see where that gets me IRT actual speed of my speedo and GPS/radar From the online calculator I should be still be doing around 5kph under an actual 110kph when the speedo is showing 110kph My ADHD requires that when I'm doing 110kph on the speedo, that the actual road speed is actually really close to that, and not alot slower And going from 205 to 225 still keeps the car within the %/mm allowable in the NSW vehicle rules and regulations, which is nice, as long as I'm looking at the latest version that is.....LOL https://www.nsw.gov.au/sites/default/files/2021-02/RMS-13.464-Light-vehicle-modifications-Vehicle-Standards-Information-No-6-November-2013.pdf
    • MBS206
      R34 25GT Engine Light 21

      By MBS206 · Posted

      Take the value it measured as, and pick the closest range available that is above the reading on the screen.   Also, no point just testing the coils. Read what has been said again. You need to test all your wiring, everything.
×
×
  • Create New...