Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hey guys,

I've got an issue with my RB20DET.

When I let it rev out with the throttle only just open, (so no where near boost) around 4500- 5000rpm I am getting a clicking noise that dead set sounds like the engine fan hitting something.

The fan has around 3mm of clearance with the harmonic balancer, assumed this would be ok as the fan flex's forward when pulling air through yes?

Radial clearance to the shroud is fine, as I'm using a SR fan (they are smaller).

The noise I think is still there under full throttle, i just can't hear it.

Dont think the noise was there before I did the mods (highflow, nistune, profec b) and had it tuned.

Im running a profec b boost controller, found one thread talking about the solenoid clicking, but if I'm on low throttle % and not on boost the solenoid shouldnt be working? Will unplug on way home today to rule it out.

Its probably due for a timing belt in 10 000 km, although doubt anything in there could make that noise. Maybe?

So before I pull the fan off to rule it out, any other ideas?

Cheers

All sorts of stuff at the front of the engine could make noise. Water pump or alternator bearings. Any of the belts. Even the air-con solenoid pulling in. If it were the fan blades hitting anything at high rpm, I wouldn't expect a clicking noise so much as a continuous high pitched noise or chatter at the very least. I wore a hole through my fan shroud without ever noticing any noise. The Profec's solenoid will be completely inaudible when working (against the background noise).

Thanks for the reply,

Think i'll just bring the timing belt change forward and have a good look around,

Oh and its only when the thottle is open, if I let the revs fall from high rpm there is no noise. Doesnt really do it in 1st gear. Noticeable in 2nd and 3rd.

No air con fitted.

Will have a closer look on the weekend.

So, found the issue.

Pulled the fan shround off, some light evidence of the fan contacting the bottom of the shroud.

Put it back together and measured, and there is 12mm clearance from fan to shroud at the bottom, must be a combination of fan flexing and engine moving around, seriously thought that would be enough room, but guess not.

Ran with no shroud for the moment and noise is gone, car ran cooler too, but it is mainly freeway driving.

Will mod the shroud before I put it back on.

Here was I thinking my RB20 had some serious issue, haha should have known better.

Does the engine really flap around? I would have thought that to be plenty of clearance. maybe take a look at your engine mounts next time your under there.

The GTR I recently pulled an engine out of had no symptoms whatsoever of dead mounts. but one was completely sheared in 2 pieces...

The engine certainly does move around a bit, and more to the point, when the fan is spinning fast it can make the shroud move around a fair bit too. If the radiator mouts are loose the radiator can move towards the engine by 7-8mm! In my car I have jammed some vacuum hose in around the upper radiator pins to hold it more firmly, because the original rubbers allow a bit too much movement.

The radiator is mounted pretty tight, I made my own bushes out of a nylon material.

The shroud is bolted at the top and cable tied (firmly) at the bottom, tbh I can't see that pulling back but its a possibility.

Engine mounts are good.

Also, the wear marks on the shroud are from the front of the fan, not side to side like engine mounts would suggest,

Anyways, I'll will just trim the shroud a bit more, should be ok.

Glad its not anything worse, going in for a touch up tune soon, dont want to hold that up.

If it were me (and yes I know it might just be me), I'd want to find out where the movement is and fix it. You may mask the shroud hitting now, and thats all well and good, but the movement may cause a serious problem later on down the track. If its getting dyno tuned I would look at it on the dyno

As above, I had my exhaust side engine mount split in two, never realised this till I pulled the engine out and half the engine mount remained in the car. As far as I was concerned, everything was good

Yeah, when I give it a service before the dyno I'll confirm the engine mounts are good.

I think the issue is i'm using a sr fan where a rb one should be, and I have a 50mm radiator, so things are not fitting like the factory intended.

Im going to try and measure the fan deflection too, just to confirm how much its moving forward.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • You are selling this? I have never bought something from marketplace...i dont know if i trust that enough. And the price is little bit "too" good...
    • https://www.facebook.com/share/19kSVAc4tc/?mibextid=wwXIfr
    • It would be well worth deciding where you want to go and what you care about. Reliability of everything in a 34 drops MASSIVELY above the 300kw mark. Keeping everything going great at beyond that value will cost ten times the $. Clutches become shit, gearboxes (and engines/bottom ends) become consumable, traction becomes crap. The good news is looking legalish/actually being legal is slighly under the 300kw mark. I would make the assumption you want to ditch the stock plenum too and want to go a front facing unit of some description due to the cross flow. Do the bends on a return flow hurt? Not really. A couple of bends do make a difference but not nearly as much in a forced induction situation. Add 1psi of boost to overcome it. Nobody has ever gone and done a track session monitoring IAT then done a different session on a different intercooler and monitored IAT to see the difference here. All of the benefits here are likely in the "My engine is a forged consumable that I drive once a year because it needs a rebuild every year which takes 9 months of the year to complete" territory. It would be well worth deciding where you want to go and what you care about with this car.
    • By "reverse flow", do you mean "return flow"? Being the IC having a return pipe back behind the bumper reo, or similar? If so... I am currently making ~250 rwkW on a Neo at ~17-18 psi. With a return flow. There's nothing to indicate that it is costing me a lot of power at this level, and I would be surprised if I could not push it harder. True, I have not measured pressure drop across it or IAT changes, but the car does not seem upset about it in any way. I won't be bothering to look into it unless it starts giving trouble or doesn't respond to boost increases when I next put it on the dyno. FWIW, it was tuned with the boost controller off, so achieving ~15-16 psi on the wastegate spring alone, and it is noticeably quicker with the boost controller on and yielding a couple of extra pounds. Hence why I think it is doing OK. So, no, I would not arbitrarily say that return flows are restrictive. Yes, they are certainly restrictive if you're aiming for higher power levels. But I also think that the happy place for a street car is <300 rwkW anyway, so I'm not going to be aiming for power levels that would require me to change the inlet pipework. My car looks very stock, even though everything is different. The turbo and inlet pipes all look stock and run in the stock locations, The airbox looks stock (apart from the inlet being opened up). The turbo looks stock, because it's in the stock location, is the stock housings and can't really be seen anyway. It makes enough power to be good to drive, but won't raise eyebrows if I ever f**k up enough for the cops to lift the bonnet.
    • There is a guy who said he can weld me piping without having to cut chassis, maybe I do that ? Or do I just go reverse flow but isn’t reverse flow very limited once again? 
×
×
  • Create New...