Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

So the X5 has recently started making a whirring noise in the front. Volume of the noise is related to road speed, not revs. We just discovered today that it goes away when going up a hill and is back when on the flat or going down a hill.

That makes me think it could be bearings as there would be less weight on the front when climbing. Does that sound sane?

We will take it in for an opinion from my BMW guy on Thursday but in the meantime just trying to work it out.

We did try to load up each front side at 70ish kph by doing a bit of a slalom. I did hear that you can isolate each wheel this way but we heard no difference from each side. 

I'm just hoping its the bearings and not the front diff or something else. Not after what I just spent on the E90! :rofl:

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/485467-how-to-identify-wheel-bearing-noise/
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, GTSBoy said:

Maybe, but the % change is actually pretty small.

So I'm not a genius? Is that what you're saying?

What else would change in volume based on climbing or descending ?

  • Like 1
3 minutes ago, GTSBoy said:

It's a Euro debt trap, so....just about anything? Cam drive, flux capacitor, money pump, etc.

Money pump was done recently. So, it must be that.

  • Haha 1
  • 1 month later...

Ok, bumping this because I still need help. 

Front and rear diff fluid done and gearbox service with new pan/filter. 

Noise is still there. It's only happening under load which is why my wife thought it was not happening when going up hills. 

The front tyres are wearing strangely (mainly outside edge) but there's no lumps or mounds in the tyres. 

Could this still be wheel bearing if the noise is conditional to the load? Maybe under load it lifts the front a little? Maybe I'll get it on the jack and see if there's any play there. 

Thanks guys.

I just spent a silly amount of time reading other forums' posts and watching "whats this noise" videos on Youtube.

It *appears* to be the front diff having killed a pinion bearing or similar. Its almost definitely driveline, I haven't tested to see if the car makes the noise in N though but either way I think it's gonna be pricey. This is outside my area of comfort and expertise so I'll get my BMW guys on it.

The bearings are attached to the hubs so are super easy to replace (at least in comparison to press in bearings) so I'll do them also. 

19 hours ago, niZmO_Man said:

Man... good luck. Let us know how it goes (since my car is getting 10 years old soon).

I booked it into a diff place, Monday week. 2500 for the full rebuild. Expensive but even if I went the Chinese option it's over 1k to fit and I'd much prefer the genuine one rebuilt. 

Shit part is that the old girl is up for sale soon. 😩

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Yeah and hence my ghetto way of slamming the brakes, get the ABS to cycle, rebleed seems to be a sensible workaround.
    • Hey! Happy to help. Nothing inherently wrong with the adapter, it's more so with Brett Collins himself. He gave me a lot of incorrect information when I was in contact with him and was extremely rude when I challenged him. He stated I could not use any aftermarket twin plate clutches except for his own, not to use the dush shield, bla bla bla and it was all BS.  Collins stated to cut roughly 14mm's off the housing, I took off 15mm to make room for the dust shield. I would confirm with whatever adapter manufacturer you're using. 
    • There's plenty of OEM steering arms that are bolted on. Not in the same fashion/orientation as that one, to be sure, but still. Examples of what I'm thinking of would use holes like the ones that have the downward facing studs on the GTR uprights (down the bottom end, under the driveshaft opening, near the lower balljoint) and bolt a steering arm on using only 2 bolts that would be somewhat similarly in shear as these you're complainig about. I reckon old Holdens did that, and I've never seen a broken one of those.
    • Let's be honest, most of the people designing parts like the above, aren't engineers. Sometimes they come from disciplines that gives them more qualitative feel for design than quantitive, however, plenty of them have just picked up a license to Fusion and started making things. And that's the honest part about the majority of these guys making parts like that, they don't have huge R&D teams and heaps of time or experience working out the numbers on it. Shit, most smaller teams that do have real engineers still roll with "yeah, it should be okay, and does the job, let's make them and just see"...   The smaller guys like KiwiCNC, aren't the likes of Bosch etc with proper engineering procedures, and oversights, and sign off. As such, it's why they can produce a product to market a lot quicker, but it always comes back to, question it all.   I'm still not a fan of that bolt on piece. Why not just machine it all in one go? With the right design it's possible. The only reason I can see is if they want different heights/length for the tie rod to bolt to. And if they have the cncs themselves,they can easily offer that exact feature, and just machine it all in one go. 
    • The roof is wrapped
×
×
  • Create New...