Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

I've asked this in other threads but haven't had any luck as yet.

I have a bit of reversion from a high flow turbo.

One of the things I notice on the map trace if you hit it in 2nd (or any gear >1st) and then back off - i.e. rev to about 4 or 5k and then back off the fot doesn't go straight back to the top - there is a slight delay. THen when it hits the top It shoots back down the vertical axis for a second or so even with the throttle closed.

Anybody with stock or other turbo - have you noticed this?

Also going up a hill in 4th gear hovering around 0-3psi you can see the dot flutcuating between about 3 or 4 load points in the vertical axis with a steady throttle opening.

Thanks

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/173278-map-tracer-query/
Share on other sites

  • Replies 62
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

I know that!! I am trying to troubleshoot a particular problem

What I suspect is happening is the turbo is delivering too much air and flow reversion is occurring where the engine can't consume all the air.

Most of the time at lower loads (in load points 2-6 I can hold the dot in the same box going up a hill - i.e. hold the same load). As the load increases I feel the turbo may be spooling too - as you go up to load point 9 etc in4th gear the AFM voltage is fluctuating a lot!

Can anyone answer the questions I posted and check their map trace.

I don't think what I described is normal but I never checked it that closely with the stock turbo.

Edited by benl1981

Yes, It sounds like you are experiencing fairly mild compressor surge (it must be mild if you can't feel it, only see it on the map trace).

I haven't watched it in that situation, but i have logged my afm voltage before (when i had no bov) and watched the numbers bounce around all over the place when i lifted the throttle. In my case, basically, big spike, down to nothing, not so big spike, down to nothing.....you get the idea.

I can get mine to chuff away quite happily in similar situations (partial throttle, up hill), though generally 3rd gear, 5000rpm or so.

Sometimes I can definately feel it - but that's when it jumps about 5 or more cells in one hit straight down the vertical axis.. So with the BOV attached did you still get a similar effect.

What spec turbo do you have and on what engine?

Cheers

Edited by benl1981

Ben, I'm not sure of the specs on your particular highflow, whether it's the same as the current gcg. Nor do I have a powerfc, so I can't comment on the map tracer.

If you fit a pod filter on and when you're flooring it, do you hear flutter as the revs are rising? not when you take your foot off. How bad is the compressor surge?

As I mentioned in your previous thread I've seen and experienced it on stock turbo'd cars, highflows and GT35r's with and without a bov.

Without a bov it is much more severe; with the factory recirc it only occurs under specific circumstances; you can drive around it easily.

From my understanding of your problem it isn't so much compressor surge but rather the air travelling backwards through the afm, so reversion as you say. But yes.. There is compressor surge in there but its not the compressor surge causing the drivability problems but rather the air hitting the afm be it via the dump of the recirc bov or the air travelling backwards through the turbo and out past the afm.

I've found running no mesh on the turbo's side of the afm does slightly increase this reversion so to speak.

The fix from what I've found.....

1. Drive around it/change your driving style - This is the big one.

2. Atmo Bov (but you then have overfueling stalling as a result)

3. If your running no bov reconnect the stock bov to reduce the intensity and frequency of the afm reversion.

4. Larger dia. afm to turbo pipe or if possible longer.

A 4" afm to turbo pipe appears to work well in reducing this afm reversion.

To try and reduce the reversion in the AFM, you could build an anti reversion cone into the intake pipe. Im going to do this on my gtr with these pipe sizes

____________

____________ / : : \_______

____/ : :

: :

Turbo 4inch 3.25in : 5inch : 4inch Air filter

: :

____ : :

____________\ : : _______

\__:________:_/ The AFM is in the 5 inch bit, so i helps that im running a 5in AFM

The : is mesh(like the standard stuff except thicker)

To try and reduce the reversion in the AFM, you could build an anti reversion cone into the intake pipe. Im going to do this on my gtr with these pipe sizes

____________

____________ / : : \_______

____/ : :

: :

Turbo 4inch 3.25in : 5inch : 4inch Air filter

: :

____ : :

____________\ : : _______

\__:________:_/ The AFM is in the 5 inch bit, so i helps that im running a 5in AFM

The : is mesh(like the standard stuff except thicker)

It may work - could also compound the problem via increasing the air speed as it necks down to the AFM. Whats to say it wont cause reversion as you back off ie in stead of the turbo and engine inducing the air in it reverts off the 3.25in section. You could do what the EF falcons do via introducing a helmholtz resonance pipe on a particular bend. different theory but it should work.

Ben,

Its possible. All though I run a stock airbox with a 100mm cai I don't see why you couldn't run a larger afm->turbo pipe on the rb25.

With the larger afm->turbo pipe + retaining the mesh on your afm + retaining the stock bov + ensuring you haven't blocked up the bov's bleed hole the reversion is basically non existant apart from a few select driving conditions. That was a mouth full.

Yours may be a little more touchy I'm not sure but...... (<<< Lots of dots for those who care lol)

You obviously know how to get it to do it... Have you tried to adjust your driving style to prevent it and just accept the fact that its part of owning a modified car? :mrt:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • They’re so great that I know of someone pulling one out to go back to a sequential 
    • Hello everyone. I've recently started the research into R34 GTR front bits and running into eye watering prices. On the plus site it looks like some places make 'replacement' fender liners for these cars. At eye-watering-but-less than stock prices. I also noticed there's plenty of diffuser options available too. What I would like to know is if my following assumptions are correct. 1) The OEM guard liners are actually only 'half' the liner. They go together with the OEM brake vents which are a separate item which looks to be quite a large 'panel' that is part of the liner. The GTR bumper has bolt holes along the front. I assume the ones in the vent correspond to the ones the OEM liner does not have (circled?)   2) The V-Spec front diffuser supplants the brake ducts in the above item. I am assuming these still work with the guard liners as there's no alternate part that I'm aware of. I don't see how they go together, so I'm making the assumption that they have to, somehow. I know the center splash guard is different on the V-Spec (and is the price of the damn diffuser alone). How does the liner interact with this? 3) There's alternate front diffusers that do away with it all. Annoyingly, a lot of the clones and CF different ones... have no brake ducts on them. I like the idea of them though. My brakes get hot on the track. These alternate diffusers are a lot cheaper than plastic splash guards. I'm assuming you don't have to/aren't supposed to remove guard liners to run a diffuser. I suspect that quite a few people actually do not run the guard liner because with a front undertray you're getting a lot of 'splash' guarding anyway, and most people remove liners given they're probably running a pretty aggressive setup with a diffuser at the front. It would also be nice to know if anyone has ever run the 'reproduction' guard liners and know whether the fitment is OEM quality or "OEM Quality". Example: https://www.ebay.com.au/itm/356254671561 https://carbonetics.net/products/nissan-skyline-r34-gtr-plastic-front-wheel-arch-set Is this knowledge still around?
    • Really, effort is pretty low. You hand fistfuls of cash over to someone else and pick it up when done...   And at least this shitbox isn't drinking coolant right?  
    • And most chargers that most DIY people own would put bugger all power back into the battery between cylinders. I've always done it with jumper packs/second battery connected. And that's on any car.   Because race car, and wanting the lightness.  At least in an R33, putting a bigger battery in can at least help shift the weight balance backwards  
    • OR, Tell the Motec to STFU, you said shift, so try shifting! But then yes, I agree, more sensors needed to. Put either a wheel speed sensor, or a diff speed sensor on it. Then get an input shaft speed sensor too. (I say input shaft speed, and not engine RPM). This way, you can now also log and see if the clutch is slipping (RPM, vs input shaft speed), and you can calculate gear (Input shaft speed / Output shaft speed). At least then if the gear position sensor fails you have a backup. And realistically, the Motec should only worry about what gear you're in for the parts where I'm assuming you have some power management strategies in it for the lower gears. (IE, lower boost, maybe different throttle curves, different ignition curves, etc etc). But it should stop it shifting. Pull the flappy, that f**ker should just attempt the motion! Heck, even on a sequential like on a motorbike, you can keep trying to kick it up a gear all you want, the physically part of the box takes care of not being able to loop the whole way around the box! Only part you'd have to worry is how it gets to reverse.  But that's on the driver... An R32 shouldn't be so smart as to try and override the driver on a gear shift  
×
×
  • Create New...