Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

So heres the story.

My mate has his car at a workshop, (prefer not to name the workshop, as he has good rep and plenty of support on the site)

and while its in the mechanics possession, the car was left outside behind locked gates.

Now, the cars been broken into and 7k plus worth of goodies stolen from it.

The big question here is, who's at fault. The mechanic as its in his possession, or my mate as he left it w/ the mechanic.

Just like some feed back rom you guy's as the mechanic is taking no responsibility beacuse legally you leave your car agt a shop at your own risk?!?!?!???!?!?!?!

Any feed back wouyld be great

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/233732-mechanic-troubles/
Share on other sites

I was under the impression that mechanics must have insurance for customers cars.

I have heard recently that this policy only applies within the work shop. Could be wrong.

Something similiar happened recently to Primal Garage and the customers car wasn't covered because it was outside.

If it's a reputable business, either way, I'm sure they'd have no problem footing the bill.

This happened to my mate as well. He left it at a workshop and they put it around the back behind locked gates. They broke in put his car on bricks stole his rims, his headunit and other crap. Think it woulda been an inside job. His insurance covered it

Unfortunately your mate will get nowhere chasing the workshop. Insurance for the car is the owner's responsibility, not the shops. They didn't breach their duty of care as it was behind gates, it's not like they just left it on the street. A workshop's insurance doesn't normally extend to the cars kept inside the grounds.

Read about what happened to Primal Garage when they got broken into.

Sorry to say.

Edited by llama_au

funny how when something like this happens, the workshop will wash their hands of all responsibility, but watch exercise a lien over your car [ie. keep it!] if you fail to come up with the cash at the end.

however, assuming they took reasonable steps to secure the car, i'd say they won't be forced to cough up. private insurance would be the way to go.

owner onus applies at all times, wherever you park your car

in the street, out the front of your house, at the carpark at the train station, at the shops, at a workshop, at the MCG

it doesnt matter - owner onus always applies

so your mate should make a claim with his insurance company and problem solved

I believe the Workshop and its Insurer should be liable for it or at least pay for the stolen good at a good will, unless your mate's insurer is willing to cover the lost.

this is not possible, the workshop isn't liable in that way.

if the workshop is open to liable for this sort of thing you would have to sign an agreement at the time the car was taken into the workshop.

as no workshop in the right mind would take liabiltiy for a customers car regardless of where its stored it wouldnt apply

so if you take your car to workshop you should have insurance for it

Just like parking lots have 'conditions of entry', shouldnt workshop have something similar, at least a warning to the customer?, 'you can leave your car here but we are storing it outside'. The customer has a right to know i think.

I bet if this scenario happened to the people who have said 'vehicle owners problem' they would think differently. Defenitely.

I think 50/50 is fair, as its a fine line.

Sorry about your friends car. That really sucks.

I recently had to leave mine in the workshop. I specifically asked where it would be because someone could easily jump the fence and take what they wanted off it/out of it. We all know Skylines are targets so I would rather have taken it home and brought it back if it was to be outside because I dont leave my car anywhere, let alone overnight.

They said it would be locked inside the garage on the hoist because 'apparently' all the wheels were off and they couldnt get parts that day. I was fine with that, figured it was safe.

( btw, as a side note, it rained that night... )

Interestingly enough, when I picked it up the next day it was filthy ( you know, like say, it had been left out in the rain??? ) Lucky nothing happened to it, but I wasnt impressed because: a) I had just paid a fortune to have it professionally detailed 3 days before and: b) They told me it was going to be inside when it was just left out...

Good to know Im up for excess if something happens to it while in their grounds though, I didnt know that!

the first thing i said to him was go thru private insurance...

but being the smart intelligent boy he is, his wolf3d and cooler kit etc was not under insurance...

personally if a customer had just spent the best of 15k w/ me and something happend to his car like this

i'd be doing my best to meet him 1/2 way where i could... not go get my own lawyer in preperation for a battle...

There is a difference between parking a car in a car park, and leaving the car in someone elses possession.

The garage had the keys, they had taken temporary possession of the car. Failure to even use any security systems besides a $12 pad lock and some steel mesh would not seem adequate for most cars.

If your mate borrowed your car, and crashed it, He'd be liable, as it's in his possession, with, or without your permission.

A case could be made for either party, though I think it's a bit harsh for the workshop to park it wherever they like, then deny all responsibility when it goes pear shaped.

I'd be getting legal advice if I were you, but don't try and be a hard-arse, or think that you'll be able to sue them and retire rich. See if you can come to an agreement where the missing parts are replaced at a discounted rate, and you'll save yourself a lot of hassle. Threatening to sue and stuff only pisses people off more.

Mechanic is liable 100%.

They probably don't want to be liable, but they are.

So heres the story.

My mate has his car at a workshop, (prefer not to name the workshop, as he has good rep and plenty of support on the site)

and while its in the mechanics possession, the car was left outside behind locked gates.

Now, the cars been broken into and 7k plus worth of goodies stolen from it.

The big question here is, who's at fault. The mechanic as its in his possession, or my mate as he left it w/ the mechanic.

Just like some feed back rom you guy's as the mechanic is taking no responsibility beacuse legally you leave your car agt a shop at your own risk?!?!?!???!?!?!?!

Any feed back wouyld be great

I agree with Kozeyekan. Get some legal advice and try to negotiate an agreement of 50/50.

I actually had a chat to a lawyer friend and he said the mechanic was liable. He said something about it being a "bail-let" or "Bailent" or some other legal term.

It boils down to the fact that they took possession of the item, whilst doing services you were paying for. They were hired to do a service, and return the car in the same condition as it was when you deposited it (with whatever work done as you'd expect)

How the damage happened is largely irrelevant, it could be that when moving the car, they hit a pole, or that they had a portion of the roof collapse, it's all the same, or, as in this case, someone busted into it.

seek proper legal advice if they do not come to the party. I expect that they'd not want to go to court, as damages to the car is covered by insurance, your court costs (which you can recover in your suit) are not covered by most insurances.

Be cool though, don't go in expecting a pay day. Have a value on items to be replaced, and have that as your goal.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • There are several aftermarket options available, from not-too-painful moneyhttps://justjap.com/collections/driveshafts-bearings/products/d-max-reinforced-replacement-rear-driveshaft-set-fits-nissan-s13-s14-s15-r32-r33-r34-c35 and  https://justjap.com/products/crank-motorsport-billet-rear-axles-fits-nissan-skyline-r33-gts-t-r34-gt-t?srsltid=AfmBOorQk4xkGUa98kO7v2ePLUiNt-HRrM2AwWNw9mbSIVE1ujBVwY__, all the way up to The Driveshaft Shop https://driveshaftshop.com/skyline-cv-axles/
    • Yeah based on old XRC5964S specs, it looks to be roughly GTX3576R sized? But this 5964S compressor will flow 90lb airflow somewhat similar to the compressors in both the GTX3584RS or G35-1050.. I fully expected the 0.64 rear A/R to choke up top - seems way too small from typical convention - but these are seemingly beneficial over the prior 0.82 results.. Be interesting to see if he comments on the EFR question in that thread - he mentioned in a prior video that BW EFR's were the "cats pajamas 10 years ago", but by the sounds of things all his kits have been using Xona for quite a while now.
    • Yeah it’s still got the oem manual gearbox and clutch, only kinda mods are a blow off valve, coil overs, and a aftermarket intercooler. Also had it for about 2 months now with a lovely midnight purple paint on it.
    • Yeeeppp, been following a lot of the testing on the latest Xona stuff and there are some mental results.  He also went over 1000hp @ 4 hubs on his Mainline with a XRE6364S (63mm) which was also well into the 20psi range before 4000rpm on a 2.5. Crazy stuff. Fwiw the XRE5964S is basically the modern equivalent of their old HTA3582 - would drive nicely enough on an RB25 or 26, but proven capable of a huge amount of power if you want to spicy with rpm tho even at sane boost levels will make stout numbers 
    • The axels in my R33 seem tired, and have a bit of play in them. I cannot find any new of course, not interested in buying used, but I am looking to see if anyone can identify some cross compatible axles. In the states I have seen suggested for S chassis the J30 axles, however for the skyline (as best I can tell) the lengths are about an inch off (2.5cm) on both sides. R33 my measure L 22" R 24.5" GPT L 22.5" 24.25" J30 L 23.5" 25.5"  so shaft length is probably an inch wider. Not sure if someone has another still remanufactured option besides the J30. I figured worst case I can buy a pair tear them down and swap the center shaft. My other option was reaching out to GSP to see if they cannot piece together a set, since the axle stubs are still manufactured, I wouldn't think it be that hard to find a shaft or make a shaft work. 
×
×
  • Create New...