Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

I thought I was alone on this issue but now I'm told a few people have experienced the same problem.

I have a vibration I believe comes from the OSG 5 speed...3rd gear light to medium acceleration only. I didn't realise there was a vibration there as the centre bearing in the OEM shaft(s) was on it's way out. It was only when I put in the one piece CF tailshaft, which I had checked for balance - no problem there, that I noticed it. The assembly of the box was outsourced by my tuner to a guy that has experience with these assemblies. The box does not have the billet centre plate.

Has anyone else experienced this problem? If so, do you know what caused it and what the fix is?

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/272755-osg-5-speed-issue/
Share on other sites

  • Replies 55
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I asked the Yavuz (unigroup) about it tonight when I dropped off my car. He said he has never heard of that problem... but will check it out. I know it doesnt help us at all but hey, he might know what it is. I dont like our chances though!

What speed does it wobble at and what tyres are on the car?

I had something similar to this when I had the ppg. The tyres were worn.

I changed to a new set of tyres and the problem went a way.

I have an OS gearbox now and don't have this problem.

I doubt that it is the gearbox.

^^

Mine deffo aint the tyres. Ive had two different sets on the car and exactly the same thing.

Its not really speed related either. Mine happens under load in 3rd. I can replicate that speed in 2nd and 4th and it doesnt happen. It isnt the driveshaft either. It has only happened since the OS Gearset went in.

I might copy and paste your first post in the pommie forum man. Maybe one of the tuners have come across this issue.

http://www.gtr.co.uk/forum/118627-osg-5-sp...tml#post1117930

There it is. :P

Edited by Piggaz

Piggaz..

Can you shed some light on the info you got! Was your box new or 2nd hand and you did o/haul

I'm looking at new OS 5spd with uprated input or possibly going the Auto Gallery Yokohama box..HKS boys here reckon the AG Yokohana is slightky better and smoother box

Hows the new shaft going??

Edited by elrodeo666
Piggaz..

Can you shed some light on the info you got! Was your box new or 2nd hand and you did o/haul

I'm looking at new OS 5spd with uprated input or possibly going the Auto Gallery Yokohama box..HKS boys here reckon the AG Yokohana is slightky better and smoother box

Hows the new shaft going??

OK. The guy from England was going to call me tonight. Might get a call tomorrow. I said to MSN or FB me but he was set on calling.

My box. The box i broke was a 11,000 KM old R33 box (got put in when the stroker went in). The new parts that went in was a OS 1-3 gear set with the heavy duty input shaft, and i put a new stock 5th in as i didnt need nor want the shorter OS gear. I also bought the billet centre plate oh and a few new synchros. Sealed bearings. Couldnt have done much more so it was practically brand new.

This is the post on the pommie forum from him:

"was built a good 2 year ago only found out the other day its a box problem,

have been told its not to much of a problem just a bit annoying, mine only happens in 3rd at 80mph, if your accelerating through the gears you do notice it, it can be fixed but obbviously its a strip down job, let me know if you have any joy with it mate, regards Dave"

Now my problem doesnt happen in any other gear apart from 3rd. 3rd seems to be a little noisier then the rest also. You notice it most when you come on boost and there is a driveline vibration. I dont know how else to explain it. When i put the rear sub frame alloy locking collars on MOST of it went away. Now I can only assume i have just masked them problem... not fixed it. The box doesnt crunch gears, its very direct and smooth.. just this damn vibration! I just cant see when pumping over 400 rwkw through a box and its vibrating can be a good thing!

The shaft. I had it balanced up. Put it in last saturday. Ive only done 20 odd kms on it. I'll get back to you with that after i drive the car in anger :banana:

OK. Just got off the phone to the guy in England. He said the vibration isnt detremental...just annoying. Its caused by one of the shafts not being balanced up right inside (im not sure which one.. he couldnt tell me). He said if you are REALLY worried about it you can give RB motorsport in England a call and they can set you on the straight and narrow.

His issues were the same as mine. Vibration in 3rd at around 80 MPH which is about 120 km/h (give or take).

So in summary. It can be fixed. But it means the box has to be rebuilt! BOOOOOOOOOO!

Thanks for the input guys and cheers Paul for posting on the UK site. I've sent off an e-mail to the OSG distributor over there that is mentioned in the thread and we'll see what happens. I don't know that any vibration in a g/box can be a good thing...but I'll wait for the verdict from RB Motorpsports. Then I guess I'll rebuild it :)

Ahh nice one.

The bloke i spoke to on the phone has put 8000 Miles on his box and so far has run a 10.7 @ 135 MPH. So he is putting a little bit more grunt out then what I am. I suppose thats some peace of mind.

Piggaz..

Can you shed some light on the info you got! Was your box new or 2nd hand and you did o/haul

I'm looking at new OS 5spd with uprated input or possibly going the Auto Gallery Yokohama box..HKS boys here reckon the AG Yokohana is slightky better and smoother box

Hows the new shaft going??

the AGY 690 box is very nice. they are two kind of different things though. you can have OSG gearset with the AGY synchros. the AGY SS690 is a stock gearset but with new dual cone synchros where as the OSG set does not replace any synchros, it's just gears that are different ratio and have a different tooth profile (still helical though) on the gears. AGY can build you one using OSG gearset and their own dual cone synchros that has the best of both. :P they also do rebuilt/modded transfer cases which are worth doing as they do get a bit tired after 10 years+ of use. plus they have the 690R versions which have different ratios too. I haven't tried their extreme one which has a first gear that would take you to about 130kph! but I'm sure they are good too. get pretty exxy though. their hardcore one is super close ratio. would be great for drag and probably good circuit box too as you could use first on slow corners.

I've got a similar issue in 3rd with my os box on my R33 gtr. It vibrates only in 3rd but I don't notice it unless you keep your hand on the stick. I've also got a brand new os giken set in my 32 gtr and it doesn't do this at all - totally vibration free in all gears. My old man who's a gun mechanic assembled both os boxes. He is putting it down to the 3rd/4th selector fork being a bit worn on the 3rd side in my 33 os box, making it vibrate when it's trying to hold it in gear. If it were a shafts, it wouldn't vibrate in only one gear.

Thinking of going back to a stock box for the 33 anyway as I don't like the ratios of 1st,2nd,3rd on my GT-SS turbos gtr. I think they are way too tall. Seems a good match for my T51 on the 32 though.

Hey Paul, where did you source the 1-3 OS gears etc from?

Mine needs rebuilding in a big way, PM prices if you can too.

$2768 from Greenline in june last year. That was for the 1-5 + input. However i bought a new stock 5th as i didnt want the shorter 5th gear.

Worn selector forks? My box was only 11,000 KMS old when i destroyed 3rd gear. Cant be that.. can it?

Who's car are we talking about now ? Mr. Keets seems to have a R32 GTR so he would've needed all the same parts I needed for my R32 GTR, which would include a new selector on 3rd/4th. Piggaz your sig says series 3 R33 so you would still probably have your original fork. Your right it shouldn't be stuffed if it was new after 11,000km as my R33 series 1 GTR forks are still OK after 80,000km.

Shouldn't be as the 3rd/4th selector should be changed when you go to the late model synchros. Your old selector won't work if you had early sychros. Think about it, how else will the gear stick vibrate if it's only vibrating on one gear ? Has to be selector fork or something wrong with the synchro on that gear. Can't be the bearings or gears or it would be constant. I too have stock 5th in both boxes and OS input shafts.

The newly put together box is holding a monster amount of power on the R32 and it doesn't vibrate at all with the different fork.

I hate quoting dyno figures as the difference between mainline and dyno dynamics is so far out it's not funny but the R32 is holding onto a GENUINE 502 kw at wheels on a mainline and that ended up being 620 kw on a dynamics. Tuned 7 days ago by Willall.

Edited by BK

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • My goals for it atm are to get it registered, respray and some mild power gains eventually... I picked up the car from an elderly gentleman near the border of NSW and VIC, its honestly a bit rough and looks like its been driven on a farm (because there was so much dirt underneath). Last week I dropped the subframe and emptied the old fuel out + added a new fuel pump (think the old one went bad from old fuel). Now I'm onto fixing a coolant leak at the rear of the engine + adding a new radiator as the old one is corroded. After that i have a new bumper, coils (as the old were leaking) and lots more
    • Welcome buddy! Plenty on here and YouTube. What are your plans for it? Good luck with the Rwc and Rego bud!
    • Love this so much! Please post a photo when you have a bike on the trailer.  I was a little bit worried about having a tow bar on the Skyline, but having it hidden behind the number plate is genius
    • Came here to say, put all the wiring from the new motor and gearbox in that you can, then throw the stock ECUs in the bin, and get an aftermarket ECU. Should be pretty easy if you can use a multimeter and read a wiring diagram to then use a PNP aftermarket ECU to suit the motors wiring loom, and make the minimal changes you will to get it to work in with the body loom (If any). This will mean you can very easily circumvent/bypass the Park/Neutral start disable switch, and get everything running really easy!
    • If the roof is dual skinned the whole way, IE, there's a "top" metal piece, and a "bottom" metal piece, to slow it down as much as you practically can, you should be able to get an attachment for a spray can/your spray gun, where it is a long, thin flexible hose, and when you're "spraying" it is spraying it in every direction possible. The I'd get that, and feed it through the roof as much and as far as you can. It's basically like fish oiling the car, but you're soaking it in rust converter. Then do the fix like Murray has described having cleaned up the existing metal as much as you humanly can. I'd also throw as much rust converter on that exposed metal before putting the fibreglass/metal filler over everything.   As for welding a replacement in. I've owned my own MIG welder for about 10 years. I've also worked in an industry doing MIG welding for a job for about 3 months dead straight, and we were doing 11.5 hour work days 5 days a week, plus a Saturday 6 hour day. (I then moved over to running the massive CNC plasma as I could understand the technology, and work with the main guy out there). I also f**k around with my welders a bit at home. So what I'm saying here is, I've probably got more hours on a MIG gun than you'll manage to get under your sleeve doing home sorts of jobs over the next 5 years. I also have an ACDC TIG that I got myself a year or two back. I've got a short amount of experience on the TIG only. My home MIG is also presently setup for doing thin sheet metal. Unless I didn't care about how that roof looked, and I just wanted a functional metal roof, and it being out of alignment, warped, and bowed, I would NOT attempt a roof replacement UNLESS I could do it as a whole panel like Murray described where the spot welds were.  Welding has this REALLY annoying thing, where if you want something to be perfectly square, unless you can clamp that thing to damn perfection (Welding fixture table), it is NOT going to be square, so you start to learn, the type of metal you're working with, how thick it is etc, and weld in VERY specific ways, and by knowing how YOU are as a welder, so that as the welds cool, the metal work pulls itself into place. If you want to see some cool tricky shit done, Bennets Customs is an Aussie guy, and he mentions a guy a lot call "Kyle", who is from "Make It Kustom". Watch some of their welding videos, especially on sheet metal. You can use the welder to shrink the steel in, and you can also use the welder to stretch the panel out. When you have the skill level that I have, you can shrink the metal in and out... But never on purpose like those two guys do. You just manage to f**k it all up. Then I smack it around with a hammer till it sits lower than I will want it too, then I shove filler on top and then pray to deitys that I can sand it into some form of sane shape that doesn't look like a dog has taken a shit, after eating a tonne of pumice stone... I'm all for DIY, and for learning, and please, feel free to give it a go, but be aware, you need to live with the consequences of how time consuming it is to do, AND that it's going to look no where near as good as what you can make it look with just some filler now. Oh AND, even once you replace it, it's like to still rust away again eventually, because you'll have missed putting primer and paint on some part of the newly welded in sheet metal, or against part of the existing metal you couldn't get to...   Oh, and to weld all that in, you will need to pull the window out, and strip at least the roof and A Pillars of interior trim and wiring. You'll then need things like the big fire proof/weld spatter proof mats to lay down, OR you'll end up needing to strip the ENTIRE interior to avoid sending it all up in a ball of flames. If you want to see how annoying sheet metal is to weld, head to bunnings, buy there 600x600 1.6mm mild steel (Not GAL!) sheet, and cut a few pieces, and try and weld them together. Then understand, 1.6mm sheet is nearly 50 to 100% THICKER than the cars sheet metal.   The photos I posted before, I'm replacing with 1.2mm thick mild sheet, and it's very easy to blow through both the original steel (Especially if I hit an area that should have probably been cut out a bit more) or straight through the new sheet metal. And I'm doing the floor, which can be hidden easily, and doesn't matter how pretty I make it, as long as it's damn strong! I'm also doing it in a 4WD, that has seen many off road trails, and doesn't need to look that pretty ever
×
×
  • Create New...