Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 146
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted Images

Yeah if the issue is a combination of too high comp, incorrect squish etc as an engine builder he should be checking these things and not expecting the customer to have checked everything 100% before, should at least give a discount on any work that has to be done as it is as much his fault as anyone elses. Assuming that is the issue though.

I still personally think it is something completely different, eg exhaust restriction, intercooler full of oil, massive blow by or something along those lines.

Since we are going to chuck RB20DET turbo cams in, I am going to see if i can get him to take the head off aswell whilst most of it is off.

Once that is done, majority of the stuff listed previously can be checked. Also the condition of the pistons after the detonation can also be checked.

Id be tracking down the issue first before throwing other items into the mix. Your running the same cams as I am and cubes did to start, which worked fine.

Not sure if we mentioned it, but Cubes looked around and picked our engine builder at the time we did ours. The builder was also the machinist, who was used to do v8s. No special knowledge of RB motors, only going off the information Cubes gave him. Its an almost proven setup, you just need to find that gremlin.

If you get stuck finding cams, ive got 2 sets here and cam gears I can lend you.

  • 2 weeks later...

I really hope it pans out well.

How did the leak down end up?

No boost leaks? (turbo to tb boost comparison turned out ok?)

Piston ring gap all ok?

What else really is there. :S

RBMAN had a similar issue with his RB30. It really struggled to make decent power.

I really hope it pans out well.

How did the leak down end up?

No boost leaks? (turbo to tb boost comparison turned out ok?)

Piston ring gap all ok?

What else really is there. :S

RBMAN had a similar issue with his RB30. It really struggled to make decent power.

Hey cubes,

Haven't done a leak down test yet - Ive been to flat out with work to get anything done on the car plus its at the builders.

Borrowed and bought one exhaust and intake set of RB20DET camshafts to try. Probably won't work, but its worth a shot.

Trying new ignitor aswell just in case.

As far as the ring gaps are concerned, Ill get these off the builder on Monday as Im curious aswell. I would say they would be in the region on 0.02"-0.04". Judging by the piston slap when cold I would say around 0.04". Either way I don't think they're excessive.

Boost leaks - not sure of either. From driving it, it didn't seem like it had any boost leaks. But I guess I cant be too sure. Next time it jumps on the dyno, I'm going to be there so I will be more in the loop.

Failing all this, the head is coming off...

Then pending what is found from that, E85 may be the only option.

Got any contact details for RBMAN or know of what he did to fix it. Did he ever track down the problem?

Cheers,

David

  • 2 weeks later...

Think he is waiting for the builder to put the cams (rb20) in still, pretty busy by the sounds of it.

Yup :(

Cams should be in the motor at the moment. Awaiting dyno time (for free)...

Will update as soon as I know more!

do you have the car, or has it been sitting in their workshop?

Id be telling them to f**k off by now for wasting your time. Surely the engine would be covered somehow, if someone stuffed the build, much the same as if you had a std engine built that went pop.

Engines not running right, looks like its our f**kup so we'll shift it aside and deal with it later.

UPDATE

Engine has had the following changed and is sitting waiting for dyno time:

Another CAS sensor (builder just wanted to make sure it wasn't the issue by trying a 100% working item)

Removed RB25DE (R32) camshafts and Installed RB20DET camshafts

Re-timed (using timing light)

Dump will be dropped if the motor pings on the next dyno run to rule out back pressure

I believe he has changed the ignitor pack

Builder said from his initial impression after the above parts where installed:

"Previously, on idle and throughout the rev range, the car would "pop/putter" alot instead of a nice clean flow of exhaust. Now since we have changed the items (listed above), the note is a lot cleaner and significantly less "poppy/puttery". Also, from an initial drive, the car feels alot more doughier than before. This doughier would reflect the feeling you would expect considering the level of timing (~8 degrees advanced max!) the motor has wound into it compared to how it previously felt."

The above I guess is nothing to be overly excited about, but I'd say at a guess its a step in the right direction.

The fact that the car feels a bit more doughier could reflect that originally the car may have been incorrectly timed. But it could also reflect many other things as well! So I'm not getting my hopes up...confused.gif

At present, Im waiting for dyno time early to mid next week, where Ill find out if any of these changes have helped.

If not, I think the only option is to go to E85.

Even if we do take off the head, and find it is the head which is the problem (which I 100% doubt it is), then there isn't a whole lot else to do but go to E85. Im not going to a 26 head as there is too much to change, far too much expense, and defeating the original purpose of the build to keep it looking stock.

If its not the head, and pistons are all as I've measured and calculated, then there's not a whole heap else to try except changing the ancillaries to the ECU - ignitor, ECU itself etc. etc. I'll be validating all the calculations I've done if we take the head off but guess I'll cross that bridge when I come to it.

Either way, I'm going to stick with the current direction of getting the head taken off if the above fails to change the problem. Then I'll address what I will do from there on in regarding workshop time, dyno etc.

Why aren't things ever simple wub.gif

Edited by R32Abuser

I'm unsure how you'd base-time the thing without using a timing light.

That aside, if the signal is not looking scattered after a change of CAS, sounds like a step in the right direction.

Better/more accurate ignition timing could well account for the different sound, and if it's running bugger all timing in the whole map then of course it will feel doughy. Sounds like a bit of mapping will help immensely. All being good it should take somewhere in the vicinity of at least 17-18 degrees at full load, which will make it stand up.

I don't recall the exact spec difference between the 25DE and 20DET cams, however neither are anything other than mild. So they should both work ok and give a fairly quiet engine note. At least he's considering that as an issue too.

Keep us posted

I'm unsure how you'd base-time the thing without using a timing light.

That aside, if the signal is not looking scattered after a change of CAS, sounds like a step in the right direction.

Better/more accurate ignition timing could well account for the different sound, and if it's running bugger all timing in the whole map then of course it will feel doughy. Sounds like a bit of mapping will help immensely. All being good it should take somewhere in the vicinity of at least 17-18 degrees at full load, which will make it stand up.

I don't recall the exact spec difference between the 25DE and 20DET cams, however neither are anything other than mild. So they should both work ok and give a fairly quiet engine note. At least he's considering that as an issue too.

Keep us posted

Refering to the RB30DOHC pdf:

HCR32 RB20DET Camshafts

Duration IN 240 deg

EX 240 deg

Lift IN 7.8mm

EX 7.8mm

LCA IN 115 deg

EX 120 deg

HCR32 RB25DE Camshafts

Duration IN 240 deg

EX 232 deg

Lift IN 7.8mm

EX 7.3mm

LCA IN 111 deg

EX 118 deg

Red is obviously the variations between the two camshafts. The main difference is between the Lobe centre angle (LCA) which, from what I have read, a larger LCA value creates less valve overlap. If I think about it, having more valve overlap would allow more intake charge to enter the motor during the exhaust stroke which would allow more fuel to sit in the chamber for a given duration of time. Not 100% sure on the effect of this but one would think this would create a greater tendencey to pre-ignite on any hot surface. Could be VERY wrong in this regard however!

Yeh Im pretty sure he timed it before using a timing light. You would ASSUME!

From what I was told, the timing wasn't scattered before hand, or at least it wasn't horribly bad.

The problem was last time they tried to wind timing into it, it would ping...So he left it with bugger all timing to make sure it would ping as least as possible.

Edited by R32Abuser

Agreed yes.gif

But with that in mind, why will cams with a wider LCA have a lesser tendencey to knock/ping etc.?

Fair few blokes on here have reported that the 25DE cams have caused the motor to be more prone to pinging.

Any further ideas on what I have said above or new theories?

Like I said I'm simply hypothesizing

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Really? That's piss weak. I didn't know they hobbled the shitboxen that badly. OK. So probs need to buy a flywheel too. But that's not too bad.
    • Hi all. I already posted some newbie-ish questions here and there but this will be my first "big" post. Last summer I went and fulfilled a kind of childhood wish, because I just thought I needed this experience in my life no matter what. The car I bought is a mildly modded 1995 BCNR33 Vspec. It was repainted to a metallic orange color all around and it had all windows reseated. Not so well done black respray in the trunk and a metallic black in the engine bay. From outside it looks very nice except for a minor paint error on the roof and the rear spats needing new adhesive tape. The inside is pretty clean and no broken plastics, missing or faded buttons. Even the adjustable mirrors and trunk antenna work like a charm. Despite a moderately long list of issues I don't (yet) regret buying this car. Most mechanical problems are just due to age, like worn rubbers here and there. The underside sadly has lots of corrosion, especially to the back. It looks like it either has been driven in the winter for a while or it lived near the saltwater in Japan, the rust is nothing terrible but it'll require to be looked after. Mostly panel gaps and all the mounted components underneath are a bit crusty, but I don't think anywhere has progressed so badly that there's going to be holes. Front right jacking rail is crushed and needs some care so it doesn't develop into a rust crater at some point. Worst part is definitely the strut towers. I thought they looked fine but after taking off the strut bar I noticed that it actually started bulging up on the passenger side. Probably would have passed on the car or negotiated down by some thousand Euros more if I had noticed this before buying, but here we are. Trunk area also has signs that there was a water leak to the interior once but nothing too crazy, I guess lots of Skylines had this at some point. As for the list of (known) issues, I'll try to make this compact. I hope the coloring is self explanatory. Mechanical: -Various busted or soon-to-be busted rubber bushings and ball joints. Will replace ball joints with OEM or better and bushings with polyurethane where possible. -Shaking steering wheel at above 80kph -downshift from 5th to 4th is a bit crunchy unless I rev-match, might just try to renew the shifter assembly, but it's not a priority issue -tailshaft centre bearing could use a replacement, is it worth going 1-piece tailshaft as it doesn't look too fresh all around? Chassis: -underbody corrosion on many spots and in hollow spaces, needs to be treated -corrosion on many bolts, hoses, lines, suspension components, subframes, will be treated when replacing of the bushings is needed as time goes on -strut tower top panels and some of the surrounding panels are rusty, so needs fixing. Will look into doing this with a buddy in the winter, otherwise bite the bullet and pay a professional -driver side door is misaligned to the body and needs to go a slight bit more inwards -both door windows are misaligned and have an airgap where the window meets the door at the B pillar -The Aerocatch latches for the bonnet have locks but no keys, need new keys. -driver side door window is kind of gritty and could use a polish -damaged jacking rails and front frame rails, from people lifting the car the wrong way, might have this fixed by a bodyshop Electrical: -Nismo tachometer is just bouncing and displaying nonsense, supposedly worked fine when the stock ECU was still in the car -An old Greddy boost controller sits on the dash which will be removed as it servers no purpose anymore. -a led segment rpm gauge is on the steering column, will probably also be (re-)moved once the Nismo tacho is working correctly -there was an attempt to make the sound system better by the previous owner but it was just inducing noise all the time, ripped out the amp and filters in the back, no music for now -trunk antenna goes up as long as the radio is on regardless of the mode, I want it to only rise if I choose Radio specifically or per switch -3rd brake light is a bit dimmer than the taillights but everything was converted to LEDs so mabye now it just seems dimmer? -reverse light flickers, have to test if that behavior changes when I fiddle with the gear stick. Hope I can get around changing the switch. -Left side taillight, blinker section has minor water intake and is humid after washing. Other side has a hole in it, probably for that exact reason. I'll probably reseal them entirely and plug the holes. Engine: -minor coolant drips on one or the other hose -rear turbo leaks oil onto the exhaust making the car essentially undriveable due to fire hazard -Oil filter relocation kit has an oil drip at the Dash lines, will probably make a new connection there and tighten real good and pray -throttle body assembly is slightly stuck for the first throttle pedal input after sitting for a while I'm always open to suggestions and advice from more experienced people, I'm sure half of this list is easily dealt with and just requires some time and effort to sort out properly. Once I have some proper pictures of the car I will post some in this thread, I just have to remember to take some more once I get the chance to. Will post updates when I have news on anything, I want to try to keep this thread as kind of a logbook as well. Ultimately my goal for this car is to just enjoy it. An engine rebuild is probably going to happen sometime as well, because it is old after all. It will never be fully new again, I am just not that rich. But I want it to look good, work well and not rot away while I drive it. I'm probably gonna spend a lot of money on this journey, hopefully not an unreasonable amount.
    • Hi all. So one of my major issues at the moment is my rear turbo leaking oil on the exhaust (and the general area). I presumed it was the rock hard super old drain hose, which it was not. So now I am in the midst of removing the rear turbo to get access to the banjo bolt that goes into the turbo oil feed. As one of the previous owners accidentally? tore off the OEM oil feed hardline that reaches behind the turbo, they ran braided lines directly to the turbo, presumably PTFE. Now, regardless if the line has rubber or teflon inside, is it just generally a bad idea to do this? I imagine these lines get quite hot being between the engine, turbo core and exhaust manifold. I suppose it's not too far fetched to think the line may even have melted. I'd love to hear your opinions on this as as the replacement OEM hardline piece is 130 per unit. And cutting open the currently mounted line to see inside will mean I just have to get a replacement either way. So far I am hoping maybe the bolt just loosened or (god forbid) they forgot one of the crush washers.
    • If it's a factory 20de manual probably has the 6 bolt flywheel in which case the det clutches won't work as they're 9 bolt.
    • All RB push clutches are interchangeable. AFAIK, the 4cyl ones are not. Different flywheels. The RB small box is not identical to the 4cyl boxes. Just very similar.
×
×
  • Create New...