Jump to content
SAU Community

M35 Timing Chain Stretch: Third Party Warranty Claim

Turning Japanese
 Share

Recommended Posts

Turning Japanese Apprentice

Turning Japanese

Posted
Posted

Hello folks.

I am in Auckland New Zealand.

I need some help and advice I have a M35 bought second hand two years ago and added an extended warranty it has done 150k. I now have a diagnosed 'stretched' timing chain. The warranty co. (DriveRight via IAG NZ) is claiming this is 'wear and tear' and not covered. however the engine fault light is on, it stutters now as a result and could cause major internal damage if it breaks. Calling Nissan NZ, they say the chains 'shouldn't..but can stretch' and in their opinion it has failed as they should last for the lifetime of the vehicle with regular servicing.

Other Warranty companies (Like Autosure NZ) cover this replacement due to stretch. So in my view the component has failed. However DriveRight say it has not failed...yet!

The clincher of this is that DriveRight now know the part is 'faulty' and will not cover any damage as a result of continuing to drive. I'm stuck. The warranty clearly states this component is covered (Timing chain and Timing chain tensioners)...but we seem to have a disagreement on the interpretation of 'failure'.

Has anyone experienced this?
My bill is estimated to be $2500 to replace chain.

Cheers.

ClassOne Enthusiast

ClassOne

Posted
Posted

Technically it has not failed, the component is still in tact and has not lost any partial component of its primary construction or warn out to the point that it has failed.

Yes it is warn but it technically has not failed.

Just like a wheel bearing, just because its making a racket does not mean it has failed, it is just at the upper limit of its life span.

A failure would be indicated by a permenant non repairable failure of an integral component.

They are right by saying it is ware and Tare,

But Nissan identified this as a component failure as such.

You could also argue the term failure.

Does that mean complete failure to function OR partial failure to function

Which the latter is true. And you have a supported claim by the manufacturer.

Your dealing with an insurance company, they don't want to pay you.

So you need to be smart with terminology and build yourself a solid case.

I would use the term "failure" as your primary argument, because if it doesn't say complete failure, then it can also partially fail so technically it has failed.

Daleo Grand Master

Daleo

Posted
Posted

If they are alleging the chain hasn't failed; by their own reasoning, there is no risk in continuing to drive the car.

They cannot play it both ways; it has either failed and requires replacement, or it is fine, and they must accept and repair any damage the chain does if/when it fails catastrophically.

They cannot hold you to ransom with an essentially undriveable vehicle. A catastrophic failure will cost much more than a chain replacement.

F**k them and their bullshit insurance speak.

KiwiRS4T Grand Master

KiwiRS4T

Posted
Posted

You could ring Consumer (not sure if you have to be a member) - or "Fair Go" for advice on your rights.

For technical info see Soichi (ST Hytech) or Joe Kyle (Joe's Mechanical Services)- both Nissan experts

projects Contributor

projects

Posted
Posted

i left a message on the other forum, but i've recently replaced a chain also. they do stretch, but this is a 280+ km engine i done. I would class your situation as wear and tear, but then as said if they dont class it to be a failure and they do cover when it does fail they'll be up for a bigger bill to replace the motor than replacing a chain that is 'failing' according to manufacturer's assessment already.

So have you decided to get someone to replace it all now for $2.5k?

KiwiRS4T Grand Master

KiwiRS4T

Posted
Posted

What shop is it in? Sounds like a lot of money. If you're not already there try and get a price on the phone from Soichi and Joe.

I need to make a call tomorrow morning on asking the mechanics to proceed with the replacement. Going to talk to the insurer one more.time now with my new information

Thanks all

projects Contributor

projects

Posted
Posted

a good mechanic who know's his way around a stagea, (most wont because they dont need this replacement done often) should be able to do the replacement in a full day. I used to work at nissan and got my parts at cost which was just over $700, retail was about $1k. The fluids need to be replaced, 5l of oil and coolant, you might as well get them to do a oil filter as well. And then the labour factor. So 2.5K is a bit but wouldnt say its to far off the right figure.

scotty nm35 Grand Master

scotty nm35

Posted
Posted

The small cam chains will require a lot of work to replace I think, as the cams may need to be removed... I would get them to replace the chain and guides only if that's what they diagnosed.

What were the symptoms, noisy chain slap?

What engine are we talking about?

The water pump can be easily changed without dropping the front of the engine, don't bother doing it now if it's still working.

projects Contributor

projects

Posted
Posted

I didnt do the secondary chains. They have tensioners to take up the slack and the chains are short enough that any wear would not cause any stretch issues like the primary.

I replaced my water pump while I was in there cause of the high k's. It was starting to show a bit of play and bearing noise. But if yous is fine I'd leave it in there, like what Scotty said.

Turning Japanese Apprentice

Turning Japanese

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Hello there,

well I thought I would give those interested a bit of an update.

After some extensive negotiations with the warrant company they have conceded that the chain (in my case) has FAILED.

This is excellent news as it means they are willing to front for the repair.

Still excluded in their view were the chain guides - as they thought they could be reused. I decided to still replace them.

So a lesson here for anyone reading in a similar position is...do not accept the first DECLINE or NO.

While the chains may have some 'wear' over the lifetime of an engine....they should not cause the engine to FAIL (In my case camshaft sensor fault and Stuttering engine, particularly on hills)

I appreciate your tips and advice and now have a puuuuuring Stagea again.

Cheers

scotty nm35 Grand Master

scotty nm35

Posted
Posted

Make sure they change the guides, especially the tensioner one. (known failure point as the plastic guide plate becomes brittle.)

I would say this may be the main cause of your issues, or perhaps the tensioner. If the chain has indeed 'stretched' or worn beyond what the tensioner can take the slack of, then I would be checking the oil feed squirters to the chain aren't blocked.

Daleo Grand Master

Daleo

Posted
Posted

Hello there,

well I thought I would give those interested a bit of an update.

After some extensive negotiations with the warrant company they have conceded that the chain (in my case) has FAILED.

This is excellent news as it means they are willing to front for the repair.

Still excluded in their view were the chain guides - as they thought they could be reused. I decided to still replace them.

So a lesson here for anyone reading in a similar position is...do not accept the first DECLINE or NO.

While the chains may have some 'wear' over the lifetime of an engine....they should not cause the engine to FAIL (In my case camshaft sensor fault and Stuttering engine, particularly on hills)

I appreciate your tips and advice and now have a puuuuuring Stagea again.

Cheers

Look, I think NO is always the standard first response from these 3rd party warranty suppliers.

It's always worth fighting! If their initial response is NO; what's the worst that could happen?

Good to hear you stuck to your guns & got what you paid for.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • MBS206
      Duncan's V37.......race car?

      By MBS206 · Posted

      Even more fun, leave all the ADAS stuff plugged in, but in different locations, hopefully avoid any codes!   And honestly, all these new cars with their weird electronics. Pull all the electronics out Duncan, and just shove an aftermarket ECU and if needed a trans controller in, along with a PDM. Make it run basic but race car styled!
    • Duncan
      Duncan's V37.......race car?

      By Duncan · Posted

      To follow up a question from earlier too since I had the front bar off again (fking!) This is what is between the bumper and the drivers side wheel And this is the navigator side, only one thing but its a biggy! So basically....no putting coolers in the wheel arches without a lot of moving other stuff. Assuming I move to properly race prepping this car I'll take that job on and see how the computers respond to removing a whole bunch of ADAS modules
    • Duncan
      Duncan's V37.......race car?

      By Duncan · Posted

      So I prepped the car for another track day on Wednesday (will be interesting to see coolant temps post flushing out and the larger reservoir, with a forecast of 3-14 being 20o cooler than last time I took it out). Couple of things to mention; since I am just driving the car and not taking a support vehicle, I took the rear seats out and just loaded the back up Team Trackday style. Look at all that space! To cover off removing the rear seat....it is weird (note the hybrid is probably different because it wouldn't have folding rear seats) Basically, you remove the lower seat base, very similar to a r series but it is a clip that pulls forward to release the base rather than it being bolted down. Easy Then, you need to remove the side section of the rear seat on each side. There is a 14mm head nut at the bottom of the side piece, the it slides upwards off a hook at the top to release; you also need to unhook the seatbelt from the loop at the top. Then the centre piece is weird. You need to release/fold the seats forward with the tab in the boot on each side From there, there are 2,x12mm headed bolts holding the rear of each seat to the folding bracket, under the trim between the rear seat and the boot (4x christmas tree clips there, they suck). The seat is out but you can see where the bolts attach to the bracket
    • RP1421
      S15 Spec R

      By RP1421 · Posted

      As discussed in the previous post, the bushes in the 110 needed replacing. I took this opportunity to replace the castor bushes, the front lower control arm, lower the car and get the alignment dialled in with new tyres. I took it down to Alignment Motorsports on the GC to get this work done and also get more out of the Shockworks as I felt like I wasn't getting the full use out of them.  To cut a very long story short, it ended up being the case the passenger side castor arm wouldn't accept the brand new bush as the sleeve had worn badly enough to the point you could push the new bush in by hand and completely through. Trying a pair of TRD bushes didn't fix the issue either (I had originally gone with Hardrace bushes). We needed to urgently source another castor arm, and thankfully this was sourced and the guys at the shop worked on my car until 7pm on a Saturday to get everything done. The car rides a lot nicer now with the suspension dialled in properly. Lowered the car a little as well to suit the lower profile front tyres, and just bring the car down generally. Eternally thankful for the guys down at the shop to get the car sorted, we both pulled big favours from our contacts to get it done on the Saturday.  Also plugged in the new Stedi foglights into the S15, and even from a quick test in the garage I'm keen to see how they look out on the road. I had some concerns about the length of the LED body and whether it'd fit in the foglight housing but it's fine.  I've got a small window coming up next month where I'll likely get a little paint work done on the 110 to remove the rear wing, add a boot wing and roof wing, get the side skirt fixed up and colour match the little panel on the tail lights so that I can install some badges that I've kept in storage. I'm also tempted to put in a new pair of headlights on the 110.  Until then, here's some more pictures from Easter this year. 
    • joshuaho96
      R32 GTS (RB20DE) Injectors Replacement

      By joshuaho96 · Posted

      I would put a fuel pressure gauge between the filter and the fuel rail, see if it's maintaining good fuel pressure at idle going up to the point when it stalls. Do you see any strange behavior in commanded fuel leading up to the point when it stalls? You might have to start going through the service manual and doing a long list of sensor tests if it's not the fuel system for whatever reason.
×
×
  • Create New...