Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Well, test drove a VX II Clubbie R8 and VY Clubbie R8 back to back today. I'm not going to bother comparing the subjective side of things. Interior and exteriors change with the fashion. I think you'll all be more interested in the performance side of things - how it goes, how it changes directions and how it stops. Both cars, unfortunatley, were automatics.

First up was the VXII. My Dad had the first drive. For some reason he more interested in seeing me behind the wheel, so he kept it short and we changed seats in a side street within 10min. The LS1 is bugger load more refined than the old 5L, it just seems to want to rev and makes a tasty noise doing it. Auto gear changes also seemed to have refined beyond the old neck jerker that was in the VT. Driving out of the side street, the first order of the day was the try and get it sideways onto the main road :(. It wouldn't lose traction tho, just buckled down and took off. Same corner in my car would have at least had the inside wheel spin. I guess with 1.7 odd tonnes, it takes a fair bit of pushing to get the VXII sideways. And on the R33, the power comes on more suddenly making control a little trickier.

Headed straight for the freeway for some speed runs. It certainly doesn't lack power, putting the right foot the firewall resulted in a growl from the exhaust and the speedo rapidly climbing. Oh, and dad boucing about the passenger seat asking me to take it easy :D. By the seat impression - my 'line would be able to keep lineball in a rolling start and probably standing start, if not in front. The extra 5kW of the VY only makes a difference in the brouchers. Nothing between the VXII and VY on the road. At 160kmh or so, acceleration seemed to be lowing down markedly - more so than in my 'line. Bit of a dissappointment, aren't these supposed have top end?

Throttle control by the way, is fantastic compored to the VT and more so compared to the 'line. I guess its something a turbo will never have, but it came as somewhat of a shock after driving the R33 for so long.

I was hoping beyond hope that the absolutley shithouse steering of the VT had been fixed but there was only a marginal improvement in the VXII. It was still waay too light, had no feedback, and worse, couldn't tell the driver what was going on at the wheels. This alone would make me puke at the thought of buying one. Ewww. Bad Holden. Bad HSv. Who are they making these cars for? The VY's steering is a vast improvement. Has some wieght to it and on centre isn't just a dead zone. Still not R33 quality, but its night and day compared to previous models.

Suspension tuning is a bit of a mixed bag. The VXII was moderatley firm and it handled bumps well, but it was still too much of a comprise. High speed bends had the car feel like is was floating and while it didn't feel out of control (or as bad as the VT), it didn't feel planted at all. The VY suspension is much improved, no floating and it felt planted on the same corner. The VXII didn't feel as good as my stock suspensioned R33 but the VY easily matched it for road holding and bettered it for ride quality. Didn't get to try either in twisties.

Braking wise, the VY is very nice. 4 pot calipers with 348mm rotors pulled up well. As a comparison, the R33 has 4 pot with 296mm rotors and 300kg odd less to pull up. Didn't get the chance to give them good enough testing to draw a comparison, but they're a big step in the right direction.

Overall, I felt the R33 stacked up well against them in outright speed and has much better feedback and suspension design. Be careful if you try and take them on, they DO pack a punch. Hopefully, dad will choose the VY cause the VXII is as shithouse as the VT. Summoner, you have some big gonads taking your VU to 260kmh :).

If my words sound biased, its most probably because they are. I am after all, a R33 driver :(

Note: If you're an anti-holden biggot who wants to spread hate, don't bother replying.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/6026-test-drove-a-vy/
Share on other sites

Wow!

A good all round view comparing 3 cars really, the VXII, VY and an R33.. just what I wanted to hear.

I do give holden credit for all the refinement they've done over the years, I can still honestly say they don't compare to the research and development put into the Jap cars.

Good review Gradenko :(

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/6026-test-drove-a-vy/#findComment-91011
Share on other sites

Im sure thats all well and good there m8 but ure leaving one thing out.

Do the chicks dig it?:( big cars like that just oooze appeal to the less car minded ppl.

Oh yeah u gotta get it for a nite and let me take it for a run;)

Yeh and good review beats the hell outta one of those car mag crappin on about how great the new dash looks and how much room the 2.3 kids have.:D

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/6026-test-drove-a-vy/#findComment-91039
Share on other sites

Guest GR33DyMANGO
Originally posted by Strich9ine

well.. some.. if not MOST chicks don't even know what a skyline is, so they just think "oooh, stato..." and "oooh, clubbie R8 mooite"

HHAHAaa... alot of chicks i know wouldnt go out with anyone that owned a commodore... and some wouldnt even talk to u if u owned one. pretty funny.

all they think is commy =bogan..... i know thats not true... i try and tell them most commy drivers are unfairly stereotyped, but what shuts them up is saying that they dont know a thing about cars so they should shut the 'ell up b4 they embarrase themselves..

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/6026-test-drove-a-vy/#findComment-91078
Share on other sites

an ex-girlfriend of mine didn't like commodores at all, she said she wouldn't go out with anyone who drove one, and said (like justin did), commodores=bogans

hence, emphasis on the ex part of the above paragraph

I wanted to get a VT 5.7L at one point in time, I was going out and looking at them. I saw a REALLY nice raven black gen3 for about 22,000 down in thornlie once but that sold. Now I see the SS's are coming down to about that price!

but I'm more than happy with mine now :(

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/6026-test-drove-a-vy/#findComment-91123
Share on other sites

Thanks for the comments, ppl.

puckish, the rear end of the VY felt much more planted than the VXII at speed (> 130kmh), no shakes or rattles and I could confidently take sweeping bends at 160kmh without wanting to lift off of hit the brakes. Doing the same in the VT requires a lot of faith and although the VXII wasn't bad, it still felt a little unsure. The VY comes closest to matching the R33s high speed stability.

They haven't solved the problems with wind noise though. Theres still a loud rustle (audible in the cabin) coming from around the A pillars at speed. The R33 is better designed in this area too.

Build quality, not much to say on this. I poked and pushed at the dash and its quality a big step over the VT style. The climate control buttons are especially improved. Didn't get enough time to test build quality further but in the showroom, there was a pristine VY Senator that had a plastic interior screw cover sitting on the floor. It'd fallen off some part of the car, and the car was brand new! i guess some things don't change.

Strich9ine, go take a drive in a VXII and see how it goes. Dealers are *real* desperate to get rid of their demo models and I'm sure they'd be happy letting ppl test drive them. lol, after driving the VXII, I told the salesman how substandard I thought the steering and suspension is and he fully agreed, saying the VY was better in a lot of respects. Then 10mins later, the boss comes over and starts telling us: "what a sweet car that blue auto VX R8 is. Best handling car out of the lot. I really like it over the VY". We just looked at him in stunned silence. He blew it big time:lol:

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/6026-test-drove-a-vy/#findComment-91241
Share on other sites

I'll never forget the dash on the VX at night. You could see the light globes through the black backing. Drove a AU2 for two days and was blown away with the handling and steering. Engine lacked grunt in the midrange through.

Gen 3's are okay but take a lot of rev's for a V8 to get going. Got taken in my mates VT Gen 3 (one of the first in Perth) and thought ho hum, threw him in the Soarer and he nearly wet his pants!

For what it's worth the BA Falcon looks the goods, but some recent write up's are worry some. Apprently Carpoint tried to pop the hood on a XR6T ute and the handle popped off !

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/6026-test-drove-a-vy/#findComment-91347
Share on other sites

he wet his pants in a soarer? BAHAHAH what a gumby.

While its true a gen3 is a rev happy v8, no soarer can match it for performance out of the box. I find it very hard that any soarer(tt v6 or v8) can make a gen3 driver wet himself.

thanks for the laugh tho :(

PS, yes i have been in soarers very ho hum :(

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/6026-test-drove-a-vy/#findComment-91350
Share on other sites

Originally posted by summoner

he wet his pants in a soarer? BAHAHAH what a gumby.  

While its true a gen3 is a rev happy v8, no soarer can match it for performance out of the box.  I find it very hard that any soarer(tt v6 or v8) can make a gen3 driver wet himself.

thanks for the laugh tho :(

PS, yes i have been in soarers very ho hum :(

My mates stock TT Soarer auto has raced a Gen3 VT manual. 2 of us in the soarer, one guy in the gen3, he only pulled on us at about mid range for a couple of seconds, then was even. not much in it at all.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/6026-test-drove-a-vy/#findComment-91352
Share on other sites

puckish, I haven't driven an early ls1, but hsv's 255 and 260 don't need all that many revs to really get going. The VY had (seemingly) a touch more poke down low, probably had more timing dumped on, but neither was "ho hum" at low revs. Of course, it could have beeen the auto playing tricks on me. With power mode on, it didn't take very much for it to drop a gear and go for it, so it always felt on the boil.

Was your Soarer modified? Cause I agree with summoner, a stock Soarer isn't likely to scare my grandmother. :(

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/6026-test-drove-a-vy/#findComment-91353
Share on other sites

Originally posted by Gradenko

Was your Soarer modified? Cause I agree with summoner, a stock Soarer isn't likely to scare my grandmother. :(

Yes Soarer is stock, the gen3 was the winner (and so he should have been with all that claimed power and a manual to match!), but as i said there was not a lot in it. i wouldn't underesitmate the soarer by all means, i know they aint the best round corners, but they can suprise in straight lines..

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/6026-test-drove-a-vy/#findComment-91364
Share on other sites

Just between us I owned a V6 Vt supercharged 'S' pack before the R33.

Mine was fine and I quite liked it for what it was.

Once daughter No1 got her car and we hardly ever went out together as a group I didn't need the room I got rid of it for the 33(a car for me not the family)

I love my Skyline but the dunnydoors aint bad.

Followed a new SS tonight which I suspect is a Holden test car with vic plates "VYSS 04" on it.

Looked cool in that bright green. Also getting used to the Magna rear end with Hyundai Elantra front end on it. Mind you the bodykit on the SS helps too

Cheers

Chris

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/6026-test-drove-a-vy/#findComment-91501
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • I know why it happened and I’m embarrassed to say but I was testing the polarity of one of the led bulb to see which side was positive with a 12v battery and that’s when it decided to fry hoping I didn’t damage anything else
    • I came here to note that is a zener diode too base on the info there. Based on that, I'd also be suspicious that replacing it, and it's likely to do the same. A lot of use cases will see it used as either voltage protection, or to create a cheap but relatively stable fixed voltage supply. That would mean it has seen more voltage than it should, and has gone into voltage melt down. If there is something else in the circuit dumping out higher than it should voltages, that needs to be found too. It's quite likely they're trying to use the Zener to limit the voltage that is hitting through to the transistor beside it, so what ever goes to the zener is likely a signal, and they're using the transistor in that circuit to amplify it. Especially as it seems they've also got a capacitor across the zener. Looks like there is meant to be something "noisy" to that zener, and what ever it was, had a melt down. Looking at that picture, it also looks like there's some solder joints that really need redoing, and it might be worth having the whole board properly inspected.  Unfortunately, without being able to stick a multimeter on it, and start tracing it all out, I'm pretty much at a loss now to help. I don't even believe I have a climate control board from an R33 around here to pull apart and see if any of the circuit appears similar to give some ideas.
    • Nah - but you won't find anything on dismantling the seats in any such thing anyway.
    • Could be. Could also be that they sit around broken more. To be fair, you almost never see one driving around. I see more R chassis GTRs than the Renault ones.
    • Yeah. Nah. This is why I said My bold for my double emphasis. We're not talking about cars tuned to the edge of det here. We're talking about normal cars. Flame propagation speed and the amount of energy required to ignite the fuel are not significant factors when running at 1500-4000 rpm, and medium to light loads, like nearly every car on the road (except twin cab utes which are driven at 6k and 100% load all the time). There is no shortage of ignition energy available in any petrol engine. If there was, we'd all be in deep shit. The calorific value, on a volume basis, is significantly different, between 98 and 91, and that turns up immediately in consumption numbers. You can see the signal easily if you control for the other variables well enough, and/or collect enough stats. As to not seeing any benefit - we had a couple of EF and EL Falcons in the company fleet back in the late 90s and early 2000s. The EEC IV ECU in those things was particularly good at adding in timing as soon as knock headroom improved, which typically came from putting in some 95 or 98. The responsiveness and power improved noticeably, and the fuel consumption dropped considerably, just from going to 95. Less delta from there to 98 - almost not noticeable, compared to the big differences seen between 91 and 95. Way back in the day, when supermarkets first started selling fuel from their own stations, I did thousands of km in FNQ in a small Toyota. I can't remember if it was a Starlet or an early Yaris. Anyway - the supermarket servos were bringing in cheap fuel from Indonesia, and the other servos were still using locally refined gear. The fuel consumption was typically at least 5%, often as much as 8% worse on the Indo shit, presumably because they had a lot more oxygenated component in the brew, and were probably barely meeting the octane spec. Around the same time or maybe a bit later (like 25 years ago), I could tell the difference between Shell 98 and BP 98, and typically preferred to only use Shell then because the Skyline ran so much better on it. Years later I found the realtionship between them had swapped, as a consequence of yet more refinery closures. So I've only used BP 98 since. Although, I must say that I could not fault the odd tank of United 98 that I've run. It's probably the same stuff. It is also very important to remember that these findings are often dependent on region. With most of the refineries in Oz now dead, there's less variability in local stuff, and he majority of our fuels are not even refined here any more anyway. It probably depends more on which SE Asian refinery is currently cheapest to operate.
×
×
  • Create New...