Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

hey guys just wondering if anyone out there using tomei poncams in their rb20 have ever snapped one in half

i was driving down the road and gave it a bit of squirt then it sounded like i lost a cylinder...so when i got home i checked for coilpacks and all the usual stuff (ignitors, sparkplugs) and then did a compression test...cylinder 6 read 0psi i took the rocker covers off and cranked the motor over and i noticed that the inlet cam was completely snapped in two pieces right where cylinder 6 valves start so the valves werent in operation....the motor is still in good nick nothing wrong with the valves nor the piston...but im just curious on how strong these poncams are, if a camshaft that is around an inch thick of solid steel can just cleanly snap in two it must have been a manufacturing defect or something. i dont know.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/105803-tomei-poncam-broken/
Share on other sites

Snapped cam?!?!? WTF?

how long were they in the car?

Still they should not snap,

Pull it out and see if it was a fatigue failure (looks a bit like rings in a tree trunk at the edges if you are look end on),

Were they staight? (hard to tell now)

Was something not alligned correctly? (hard to miss-align cams I know)

Were all the tolerances / torque settings on the cam retainers correct?

You may have a case to claim faulty manufacturing.

My 2c

Edited by JCMarshall_Law

cams are very easy to snap. i can almost bet on the fact it was an installation problem. either incorrect torque, or torqued up incorrectly (ie in the wrong order). or the caps were possibly not perfectly positioned (swapped around) when being torqued up.

they were installed correctly with the torque settings used out of the rb20det workshop manual..they were brand new and were in the car for about 6000k's...and no none of the caps were swapped around i had them layed out perfectly where they came from...my mechanic thinks someone had dropped them hard in transport which might have put a hairline crack through them that was not visible to the human eye

i'd have thought the same as the Baron, did you install them yourself? if a hard drop in transport could put a hairline crack in a cam then it won't cope with the stress of being a bump stick, hard drop or not. and if it was enough of a hit to do that then you prob see a mark on the cam...a big one.

was it the same head ?

Edited by Scooby

i dont think it's unique to poncams. i've heard of other brands of cams snapping, and even in other models of cars. but like i said, it's nearly always a small installation problem, or it can be a bearing problem. but it's possible it could have been damaged in transit, or have suffered a manufacturing fault.

cams are very easy to snap. i can almost bet on the fact it was an installation problem. either incorrect torque, or torqued up incorrectly (ie in the wrong order). or the caps were possibly not perfectly positioned (swapped around) when being torqued up.

Wow, I had no idea, I have not seen a snaped cam before, although I'm not a mechanic and I don't play with cars everyday. Interesting.

Good to see people seem to agree with my ideas on the failure.

Ive heard of heaps snapping too. There's no warrenty against this either, as they believe its always an installation error; ie torquing up in wrong order or with the incorrect orientation of the lobes. Bummer.

Hi Waldo, that is most unusual. Snapping a long, straight 6 camshaft is remarkably easy, I have seen quite few. But it usually happens during, or very soon after, installation, not 6,000 k's later. It will be interesting to se if it is twist break or a straight side load crack. An inspection of the surrounding parts may reveal something else.

I will be very interested in what you find out.

:P cheers ;)

PS; you where very lucky that the valves were closed, not open, when the cam broke, otherwise bent valves would be the result.

Edited by Sydneykid
well until we get pics its a bit hard to say poncams are dodge when there are 100's upon 100's of people using them.

Every one i've heard of has been incorrect installation

yeah i must concur.

i installed my own cams according to the jpnz manual (that i forked out 132$ usd for mind you) and following the proper removal and install instructions along with torque specs i havent had a problem yet.

It will be interesting to se if it is twist break or a straight side load crack.  An inspection of the surrounding parts may reveal something else.:D cheers :O

a twist break? that'd be huge torque. i'd have thought the tooth belt would strip before that happened.

Tensioning up the the bolts must be precise. If your torque wrench cost you less than $100 you need to be carefull. If it cost less than $50 maybe thats your problem.

When I did my cams in the shed I took the factory reccomendations and added a step in between at the last torque to be sure.

The cams are very easy to snap and even bend enough to weaken them so they let go 6,000kms down the track.

yeah i tensioned the bolts up in the exact order of the manual to exactly the right torque...and i checked the oil feed fo the bearings where it sat and they are all fine...i will get a picture tomorrow and post it up it just looks like a complete snap in half as if you broke it over your knee..and iut snapped right halfway down cylinder 5 actual so only 1 inlet valve was opening in cylinder 5 and none on cylinder 6...and now one of the bearings has the slightest mark in it from where it broke and wedged itself..it snapped one of the bolts that hold the cam caps down aswell.

Broke a bolt you say?

I think it's probably the bolt that gave out then. The old bolts are a bit of a lottery when putting them back in, I broke one on mine on putting the cams back in. Next time I do a set of cams I will use new ones or ARP's, it makes sense really.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Hey Dave, welcome aboard! Good to see another soon-to-be Stagea owner here. The wagons are awesome — plenty of space, still got that Skyline DNA, and loads of potential if you’re into mods. Definitely post up pics when you get it, everyone here loves seeing new builds. What model/year are you looking at?
    • See if you can thermal epoxy a heatsink or two onto it?
    • The other problem was one of those "oh shit we are going to die moments". Basically the high spec Q50s have a full electric steering rack, and the povo ones had a regular hydraulic rack with an electric pump.  So couple of laps into session 5 as I came into turn 2 (big run off now, happily), the dash turned into a christmas tree and the steering became super heavy and I went well off. I assumed it was a tyre failure so limped to the pits, but everything was OK. But....the master warning light was still on so I checked the DTCs and saw – C13E6 “Heat Protection”. Yes, that bloody steering rack computer sitting where the oil cooler should be has its own sensors and error logic, and decided I was using the steering wheel too much. I really appreciated the helpful information in the manual (my bold) POSSIBLE CAUSE • Continuing the overloading steering (Sports driving in the circuit etc,) “DATA MONITOR” >> “C/M TEMPERATURE”. The rise of steering force motor internal temperature caused the protection function to operate. This is not a system malfunction. INSPECTION END So, basically the electric motor in the steering rack got to 150c, and it decided to shut down without warning for my safety. Didn't feel safe. Short term I'll see if I can duct some air to that motor (the engine bay is sealed pretty tight). Long term, depending on how often this happens, I'll look into swapping the povo spec electric/hydraulic rack in. While the rack should be fine the power supply to the pump will be a pain and might be best to deal with it when I add a PDM.
    • And finally, 2 problems I really need to sort.  Firstly as Matt said the auto trans is not happy as it gets hot - I couldn't log the temps but the gauge showed 90o. On the first day I took it out back in Feb, because the coolant was getting hot I never got to any auto trans issues; but on this day by late session 3 and then really clearly in 4 and 5 as it got hotter it just would not shift up. You can hear the issue really clearly at 12:55 and 16:20 on the vid. So the good news is, literally this week Ecutek finally released tuning for the jatco 7 speed. I'll have a chat to Racebox and see what they can do electrically to keep it cooler and to get the gears, if anything. That will likely take some R&D and can only really happen on track as it never gets even warm with road use. I've also picked up some eye wateringly expensive Redline D6 ATF to try, it had the highest viscosity I could find at 100o so we will see if that helps (just waiting for some oil pan gaskets so I can change it properly). If neither of those work I need to remove the coolant/trans interwarmer and the radiator cooler and go to an external cooler....somewhere.....(goodbye washer reservoir?), and if that fails give up on this mad idea and wait for Nissan to release the manual 400R
    • So, what else.... Power. I don't know what it is making because I haven't done a post tune dyno run yet; I will when I get a chance. It was 240rwkw dead stock. Conclusion from the day....it does not need a single kw more until I sort some other stuff. It comes on so hard that I could hear the twin N1 turbos on the R32 crying, and I just can't use what it has around a tight track with the current setup. Brakes. They are perfect. Hit them hard all day and they never felt like having an issue; you can see in the video we were making ground on much lighter cars on better tyres under brakes. They are standard (red sport) calipers, standard size discs in DBA5000 2 piece, Winmax pads and Motul RBF600 fluid, all from Matty at Racebrakes Sydney. Keeping in mind the car is more powerful than my R32 and weighs 1780, he clearly knows his shit. Suspension. This is one of the first areas I need to change. It has electronically controlled dampers from factory, but everything is just way too soft for track work even on the hardest setting (it is nice when hustling on country roads though). In particular it rolls into oversteer mid corner and pitches too much under hard braking so it becomes unstable eg in the turn 1 kink I need to brake early, turn through the kink then brake again so I don't pirouette like an AE86. I need to get some decent shocks with matched springs and sway bars ASAP, even if it is just a v1 setup until I work out a proper race/rally setup later. Tyres. I am running Yoko A052 in 235/45/18 all round, because that was what I could get in approximately the right height on wheels I had in the shed (Rays/Nismo 18x8 off the old Leaf actually!). As track tyres they are pretty poor; I note GTSBoy recently posted a porker comparo video including them where they were about the same as AD09.....that is nothing like a top line track tyre. I'll start getting that sorted but realistically I should get proper sized wheels first (likely 9.5 +38 front and 11 +55 at the rear, so a custom order, and I can't rotate them like the R32), then work out what the best tyre option is. BTW on that, Targa Tas had gone to road tyres instead of semi slicks now so that is a whole other world of choices to sort. Diff. This is the other thing that urgently needs to be addressed. It left massive 1s out of the fish hook all day, even when I was trying not too (you can also hear it reving on the video, and see the RPM rising too fast compared to speed in the data). It has an open diff that Infiniti optimistically called a B-LSD for "Brake Limited Slip Diff". It does good straight line standing start 11s but it is woeful on the track. Nismo seem to make a 2 way for it.
×
×
  • Create New...