Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

They don't have to write a report because the theory is what is wrong about ensuring a car is roadworthy? Ambiguous? Defect it and let the owner find out if it should have been!

Good luck with it. Last time I was defected the cop was a real prick about it, I was idling through a roundabout in 3rd minding my own business. I was polite but he certainly wasn't, torch in the car and face asking me what things are doing in the car, etc. This was ACT. Most of the time cops are polite but you remember the bad ones, especially if they give you a defect.

Time before that was a vehicle inspector in a car park! Should have just driven off.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/424221-defected/page/2/#findComment-6830264
Share on other sites

i give all police the chance to treat me respectively, because some are normal people and dont abuse the badge.

i was once defected, i asked him what mechanical qualification do you have to know what part is illegal, he told me i dont need any of that "i suspect" blah

i thought part engineering was to show particular modifications are safe and with in the road saftey ect?

i guess the frustrating thing is day off to clear and 50 odd bucks..

i think they really need to tighten the rules across AUS, i know lot of ppl who put claims in to ACT about false defects thats why inspectors are out in ACT with police.

i havnt experience them but have been told they are actually better to deal with then the police specially if ou have a engineering cert? i have only been told this.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/424221-defected/page/2/#findComment-6830294
Share on other sites

Pod filters and intercoolers kill, not poor drivers. The Police must do their up most to protect citizens from these harmful modifications by issuing fines.

It makes me sleep better knowing our tax dollars are going to such enforcement programs rather than kicking drug dealers doors in and putting multiple DUI offenders behind bars.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/424221-defected/page/2/#findComment-6830424
Share on other sites

If it was a Federal cop, they can book you in any state and issue you with any infrengment. I have NSW everything (Certs and all) but if pulled over in ACT everything is valid given they're feds. Whereas if I was booked in VIC, with all NSW certs and rego, I may be let off.

My brother has been let off a few times with his car given it was ACT Rego / licence etc.

goodluck nonetheless. I've been hearing a lot of people getting done.

Bit late to the party, but I need to correct some big misinformation here.

The Australian Federal Police have two branches effectively - Community Policing (which are the police you see around the ACT enforcing ACT law) and Federal Agents.

Federal Agents can only enforce federal law, they cannot enforce state laws such as traffic offences.

Community Policing can only enforce the territory they are deployed ins law, e.g. the ACT. ACT Community Policing AFP members are sworn in as "special constables" in NSW where they can pursue and arrest someone that has committed a crime in the ACT into NSW. There are *a lot* of restrictions around this as well.

So there are no "Federal cops" that roam around the country defecting cars in any state. AFP can only defect cars in the ACT (or anywhere else they do Community Policing), Federal Agents cannot enforce local state laws (without an invitation to cooperate with that states local police force).

Edited by Amaru
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/424221-defected/page/2/#findComment-6836347
Share on other sites

I cant believe a cop could defect you on a factory stock standard car.

Mate I would be arguing in court for sure. One point I would be certain to make is that cops are ill trained to do their jobs and dont know what they are doing.

I would also make the media aware. ; )

Today Tonight love that s*&t! LOL

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/424221-defected/page/2/#findComment-6837997
Share on other sites

My point is, is that if they do their jobs incompetently, i.e. not knowing a pod filter from a stock airbox etc. then this must be highlighted. Only then things might change.

Cops don't like bad press!

And just for the record, I am all for cops, I have many friends that are in the force (both NSW and AFP down here), but they must know their job.

They can not claim to "up hold the law" if they actually don't know what the law is!!

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/424221-defected/page/2/#findComment-6838111
Share on other sites

my ******** is with AFP here in canberra - he has no interest in modifyed cars - but hates the system and has had plenty of arguments with traffic cops with some of the things they say - they just defect and pull over modifyed cars because they can -

thats the sort of attitude that gives them a bad name and causing problems between police and the public.

what frustrates me is these guys are defecting and harrasing any modifyed car because they can - i have been let go a few times as i no some terminolagy (bad spelling) and how to log internal complaints through the police and they hates these as it is a mark on them and stops them getting permotions.

i only bring this up if they are not treating me respectivly or are trying to defect me like to low or loud with out actually checking -

i dont through this round - as there are good police out there - i dont mind copping a fine or defect if it is correct

Edited by Reese69
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/424221-defected/page/2/#findComment-6838121
Share on other sites

  • 1 month later...

You have to find a engineer that is Rta registered, I was talking to the police about it in sydney here after he defected my car, he said if I get it properly engineered by one registered with the Rta I could have my 20inch rims on my 33, but it has to be a legit engineer! So when the police punch your registration into the system it comes up with all the Rta info stated if its engineered or not. And they still defect after that u can take them to court and you will win!

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/424221-defected/page/2/#findComment-6890973
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Yep, there's a very minor drift left that happens a few seconds after letting go of the steering wheel, but not enough to bother me. Enjoying the car still!
    • Got you mate. Check your email!
    • I see you've never had to push start your own car... You could save some weight right now...
    • Sounds good.  I don't 100% understand what your getting at here. When you say, "I keep seeing YouTube videos where people have new paint and primer land on the old clearcoat that isn't even dulled down" do you mean this - there is a panel with factory paint, without any prep work, they paint the entire panel with primer, then colour then clear?  If that's what you mean, sure it will "stick" for a year, 2 years, maybe 3 years? Who knows. But at some stage it will flake off and when it does it's going to come off in huge chunks and look horrific.  Of course read your technical data sheet for your paint, but generally speaking, you can apply primer to a scuffed/prepped clear coat. Generally speaking, I wouldn't do this. I would scuff/prep the clear and then lay colour then clear. Adding the primer to these steps just adds cost and time. It will stick to the clear coat provided it has been appropriately scuffed/prepped first.  When you say, "but the new paint is landing on the old clearcoat" I am imagining someone not masking up the car and just letting overspray go wherever it wants. Surely this isn't what you mean?  So I'll assume the following scenario - there is a small scratch. The person manages to somehow fill the scratch and now has a perfectly flat surface. They then spray colour and clear over this small masked off section of the car. Is this what you mean? If this is the case, yes the new paint will eventually flake off in X number of years time.  The easy solution is to scuff/prep all of the paint that hasn't been masked off in the repair area then lay the paint.  So you want to prep the surface, lay primer, then lay filler, then lay primer, then colour, then clear?  Life seems so much simpler if you prep, fill, primer, colour then clear.  There are very few reasons to go to bare metal. Chasing rust is a good example of why you'd go to bare metal.  A simple dent, there is no way in hell I'm going to bare metal for that repair. I've got enough on my plate without creating extra work for myself lol. 
×
×
  • Create New...