Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Engine Technology International (ETi) issue January 2005: ETi contributors wax lyrical about what they think are the finest engines ever made.

Among the powerplants that graced the minds of them are:

Jaguar V12

Alfa Romeo 2000cc DOHC ca 1960

Chevrolet Smallblock

Ford-Cosworth DFV

Rover V8

Napier Sabre

BMW 4.4L V8 Valvetronic

Ford 427 SOHC

Ducati V-twin

Hillman Imp

Napier Deltic

Graham Johnson, editor of this magazine chose the HONDA 2-Liter (S2000) F20C.

"Why has no-one else selected this engine as the all-time great? Ill educated, soulless bunch (referring to the other contributors). What's not to love about this unit? It's got power: 240bhp to be exact, meaning it has more horses per liter than any other naturally aspirated engine - ever. It's got character too: actually it's got two - one, shy retiring type below 6,000rpm, and a fuel-crazed, raver above and beyond to 9,000rpm.

But there's more - this DOHC powerhouse sounds gorgeous at full flight; like it belongs in the nose of a Touring Car racer or even between the legs of the maddest motorcyclist.

And it's fuel efficient in that one can - 'one' I assume being someone limper of wrist - drive to an average of 13.6L/100km (32mpg). Hell, it even looks good, longitudinally mounted as an engine should be.

You just gotta thrash this one: it wants it; it demands a thorough, daily clear out - make that between each gear change (which, by the way, is another joyful experience because the subby lever is connected to the greatest gearbox of all time - another story).

Faults? Just one: Honda installed it in the S2000, a sports car the rump of which is not always as faithful as the power source.

Dads, grandads, then great grandads... this engine will be a talking point for a long time to come. This is the greatest engine of all time, and, thus far, it's got five International Engine of the Year Awards trophies to prove that fact."

- Graham Johnson, Engine Technology International | January 2005. Page 35.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/63935-the-greatest-engine-of-all-time/
Share on other sites

yeah, that is what I am wondering. Maybe a mix of all them. Are they taking into account price? and price of replacement parts? Working on these engines?

But I would question how "reliable" some of them would be, and power figures are all so relative to the era. Obviously a newer engine will be a bit better on economy and power than an older one. So why not just pick every engine of the last 3 years?

Have they taken an age weighting? i.e. price, performance, and reliability of that time compared to everything else of that time?

Yeah it's a very subjective question, "What do you think is the greatest engine of all time" is. Just a quick glance through the list of the engines and you will immediately see that they range from 4 cylinders right through to 18 cylinder diesel monsters.

I read the entire article and each contributor to the magazine "Engine Technology International (ETi)" gave their opinion. Their experience ranges from motoring journalism, engineering as well as racing among others.

One of the contributors mentioned the Chevy Smallblock because of its economic impact and success for GM. The Rover V8, originally a GM motor, was chosen by another because it was ironically successful in Rovers' hands when it failed in GMs'.

The Jaguar V12 is very intersting because it's known to constantly break down, but at the time, the smooth power delivery amazing as you would expect from a dozen pots! The contributors come from many backgrounds and their age and experience obviously makes a big part of their decision. Some of the engines have become part of their fond memories of working on them or racing them. Like the Chevy motor which was chosen by an American.

This wasn't an award, trophy or accolade to try to determine 'the greatest motor ever', rather it the opinion of a panel of journalists who contribute to "Engine Technology International", a well respected automotive industry magazine that engine developers and car makers worldwide subscribe to.

The engines are not totally isolated to automotive use, the Napier Deltic was a 18 cylinder diesel turbo used in locomotives i believe. The magazine also mentions other engines such as aeroplane engines like the Merlin as SteveL mentioned... one of the most powerful aerial engines of its' era.

Other information of interest included a mention of solid fuel rocket motors used by the Apollo rockets used in the 60s and 70s by NASA, as well as 25,000rpm 125cc Honda racing engines...

If they had based their list on the 'Greatest PERFORMANCE engines of all time' I believe it would have been very very different. Surely more Japanese motors would have been mentioned (RB26 being one of the most successful ones from Japan).

My Favourtie Engines In category Order

4 Cylinder NA

Nissan L16 (the L block had a huge foot print, with the biggest conrods I ever did see.,..)

4 Cylinder Turbo

Nissan SR20DET from S15

Rotary

Mazda 13BTT Sequential setup..

6 Cylinder Inline Turbo This was hard, I own an RB26 and think it is unbeatable but the 2JZ is one awesome engine.. so equal honors...

Nissan RB26DETT from R34

Toyota 2JZ-GTE from RZ Supra

6 Cyliner Inline NA

Chrysler Slant 225 (If it wasn't for the Over and Under head these things would ahve been unstoppable.)

6 Cylinder 'V'

Chrysler 3.9L from 1990

V8 Cylinder Small Block

Chrysler 340ci from E49 Charger (perfect bore to stroke ratio for block.)

V8 Cylinder Big Block

Chrysler 440ci RB Block

V10 Cylinder

Chrysler V10 from Dodge (basically the same engine as 340.. wiht two extra cylinders)

You can probably tell I like Chryslers hey, spent a lot of time building them in my younger days..

Hate to burst his bubble about the S2000 ! Hah ! Piffle and codswallop !

But my favorite is th Alfa Romeo 33/2 (Daytona) 90 degree V8. Capacity 1995cc (Thats under 2Litres people).Twin over head cams. Two spark plugs per cylinder.Fuel injected.

Horsepwer 270 @ 9600rpm And this car was made from 1967 to 1969. Car weighed in at 580kg and had a top speed 298km/h

Read it and weep !

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • I thought I'd come back and add something I JUST learned. A Toyota LandCruiser with a 1HZ, mates perfectly with a bottle of Nulon brake fluid. As in, it perfectly screws in. Great make shift funnel when you cut the bottom of it off. This may work for your Corolla.   Unfortunately, tipping a 10L drum is much harder than a 4 to 6L bottle, and they no longer include the easy pour tap which was just perfection to use previously.  
    • Guys since i bought r33 gts25t coupe 1994 automatic a/t(manual swap 350z gearbox)  all i got is problems, always problems. Lets start with that when i turn key into ignition(ON) fuel pump doesnt always works. Sometimes i have to turn key twice Off/on/off/on until it primes. Its new, dw300 - 340lph. My gearbox broke so i did gearbox swap, install different intake manifold, injectors and i take pipes. Car was sitting in garage for more than half a year. I did assembly all not that long ago and when i turn ignition cant hear prime. All of sudden it stopped working. Theres many videos on YouTube how to make relay mod on r33 straight from battery so i did and it doesnt work! 😰 30 - battery positive  87 - positive from fuel pump to relay 85, 86 - one of two wires from original fuel pump wires(light blue, grey) and it didn’t work. so I check on ignition and took original BLUE relays wires from trunk, next to fuses. (I believe it’s IGN+ and ECU pin 18. it didn’t work…  tried connecting (IGN+ from og relay) and (ECU 104 from 1of4 FPCM wires) to my new relay 85/86 and it didn’t work.  I unplug FPCM. Didn’t work. im thinking what’s wrong   fuel pump is working, if I leave IGN+ on 85 and 86 straight to ground it works but it’s just nonstop. Since it getting constant 12v after key in ON. light blue wire gives me 6-8v.  so how this should be connected? What causing ECU not giving — on pin? Or I did sth wrong and that’s why it doesn’t work? I need negative signal on ECU that control fuel pump. What this should be?
    • You can use your VIN to look up the factory part number somewhere like amayama, and then look to order new if necessary. https://www.amayama.com/en/genuine-catalogs/nissan Depending on price you might want to rebuild instead. @GTSBoy I had an interesting insight into US market parts when the Titan rear calipers were sticking. New calipers were dirt cheap, about 20% more than a rebuild kit....they are just considered throw away maintenance items
    • Funny, but really not funny. Thank god (most) f the world has moved on since then
    • Lots of votes for driving onto a plank first; that is the quickest way I've found, 25mm is enough for my case but that will vary by car It also depends where you are going for. On the 32 I can get to the rear diff with my floor jack if I do that end first, and get it up on stands. Then I lift the front from either front tow hook as high as needed, also onto stands. Sometimes I need a small lift on the other tow hook to get it level enough If I do the front first I can't get to the rear diff because of the angle of the car Other options are getting to the front mount of the rear subframe from in front of the wheel (if only lifting one side, or just do both which is a bit of a pain compared to one lift from the diff), or also the gearbox cross member mount on the driver's side if you are  just trying to lift the driver's side. I This is the jack I use; it says 75mm clearance but of course that is only on the lower section so if you have to reach too far in like the diff you still get stuck. https://www.snapon-bluepoint.com.sg/category/Floor-Jacks/product/Floor-Jack,-2-Ton-Low-Profile
×
×
  • Create New...