Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 42
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

You really need to get this analysed by someone independent, preferably without stripping it further 'yourself'. I would make the following observations:

- the wear shown in the picture extends ABOVE the max travel of the top ring in the bore (or that's the way it appears). That being the case, the piston/bore clearance measurement you give is meaningless since that was measured at the skirt (ie lower down the bore). To me it suggests abnormal loading of the piston. There also appears to be some evidence of poor/uneven ring seal.

- hardness tests (of what ??) prove nothing in terms of detonation.

- it would be rare indeed to find anything wrong with the piston material. You will need to show that the pistons were incorrectly/poorly manufactured (ie not 'fit' for purpose) or mis-described in some way by the manufacturer in effect misleading you/the engine builder in terms of your requirements.

Good Luck.

- Engine builder pulled it down.

Not really independent, I'm afraid. There are specialists that do this sort of engine failure work, but getting it done is not cheap. I have helped people in the past but it's a bit of a minefield.

-These pistons are barrel shaped not tapered. Mahle tech department (distributer) also agreed with the engine builder that clearences are OK, yet still blamed over boosting

I'm sure that's the case, but an explanation needs to be found for how wear like that could occur - esp in only 2000k's or so.

They DID agree that this was not the case.

I'm hardly surprised....

The more we dig into this problem the more we find indicators of a manufacturing issue.

Someone has to do the work to prove this for you to have a chance.

First thing i'm gonna say is that I don't think this thread will last long.

Second thing, I don't think your approach to the problem does much other than aggrevate ACL, who probably just see you as another whinging customer who f ucked up when using their product. Rather than theorising that "it's ACL's fault because we couldn't have done anything wrong", why don't you actually determine the root cause of the problem?

Is it only one cylinder or all of them?

First thing I’m going to say is that I don't think this thread will last long.

-Poor attitude, why do we have forums? Look up what it means.

We're not allowed to pay out on businesses. Read the forum rules mate. The lawyers f ucked true freedom of speech.

Why don't you actually determine the root cause of the problem?

-We have, that’s why we are taking legal action against ACL who we are holding responsible.

Care to share?

So far you have only told us about the damage. You don't appear to have given any reason other than 'faulty pistons'. What particular aspect of the piston is responsible for the damage?

Edited by browny

Guys;

come on, cool it a bit. we're being appraised of an issue that appears is piston related, that can't be bad in terms of sharing knowledge which is what these forums are designed to do. i am certainly interested in the outcome and the findings and i'm sure others are. let's just keep it objective.

tonkau; mate i can't post on behalf of SAU because I'm not a mod but would you consider editing your posts to remove any company names? i'd hate to see a 'situation' develop between a car manufacturer, an aftermarket parts supplier and a motorsport shop, particualry since one appears to be an employer. and we particularly don't want to get the SAU site involved in a litigation situation. i think we all acknowledge your frustration and that you're trying to do the right thing by other SAU members.

just my 2c guys, let's take a clinical approach to this and we can all win.

Kind Regards

Edited by Scooby

it really sucks when people dont responsibilty for their product being faulty or work being shoddy i have been stung in the past too tankau. I hope you stick it to ACL if it is really their fault because that sort damage shouldn't occur at only 2000k's. All the best with your problem dont give up take it to the furthest extent someone has to.

is there any literature at all that states the boost limit for the ACL piston or unsuitability for turbo apps ? if not, you've got em on that one I reckon. if warnings do exist they'll get you on it everytime, right or wrong, despite what we think the pistons should be able to do.

could there be another cause?

I personally hav never seen a piston with that sort of clearance ARIAS have problems with 0.0045" and are normally run at less than recomend but if the acl have required 0.007" clearance that is what has caused all the problems.What were the ring gap like and did this engine breathe or what.

pete

Edited by pnblight
First thing I’m going to say is that I don't think this thread will last long.

-Poor attitude, why do we have forums? Look up what it means.

Why don't you actually determine the root cause of the problem?

-We have, that’s why we are taking legal action against ACL who we are holding responsible.

As stated, doesnt matter what forum means. You cant come here slandering a product.

You've said it yourself that your no expert.

I think a thread such as this should wait until the court does decide who is or is not wrong based on both parties presenting thier side. Not us seeing one side without the other

This is very similar to the Catco/Magic CAT thread where there was only one sided information. You cant slander a product/business here on SAU openly without proven fact.

Retrotec's post has pout me in a 50/50 about locking this... i shall keep my eye on it and have a think.

Cheers

A quick look at ACL's web site suggests their standard range of "Race Series" pistons, which have been around for yonks, aren't forged. ACL never suggests they are. The warranty for these pistons specifically says they are not for forced induction applications.

ACL do have a newer range of "Race Series Hyperlite" forged pistons, which I think came out earlier this year (made by Mahale IIRC?). There is basically no literature on these. Since some of these pistons are specifically produced for turbo engines (BA turbo, Skylines etc), I cannot see how the standard "Race Series" warranty can apply.

So what Retrotec is saying seems correct, however I think it's not really relevant here because tonkau's problems seems to be with this newer series of "Hyperlite" forged pistons, which are a different beast altogether.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • I take it that you bought the centre to suit the GTR axles? As in there was a plan, not just somehow lucky that it worked? It all looks excellent, by the way.
    • New engine block time. Up to you whether you want to keep going down this road with this project. Unfortunately a lot of these cars are like this. The road to getting these cars into decent shape is long and not fun for reasons that you're discovering. 
    • Essay time. First things first, an RB running stock turbo and boost levels shouldn't get so bad as to stall from reversion if the recirc valve has been deleted. Should get a little fluffy and annoying, but in my experience, not so bad as to stall. Of course, every car is a bit different, so it remains possible that stalling will happen. So, running with no recirc valve is somewhat of an option, for otherwise stock stuff. Atmo BOVs cause all sorts of shit, even on an otherwise stock setup. Only gets worse the higher the boost and the bigger the turbo. At that point you really need to go for a different ECU and no AFM. Rebuilding the stock recirc valve configuration is not hard. You just need a stock or aftermarket BOV with the appropriate adapter for the 2 bolt flange on the back of the J pipe, and to get/make an appropriate ~1" pipe to get the air back to the turbo inlet, and to possibly modify the inlet (if it is not stock) to take the recirc pipe back in. Not hard. Just takes some cutting and welding. Putting an R35 type AFM into the car anywhere is not as simple as just buying the AFM and throwing it in. You will also need to buy the appropriate boss that will then need to be welded onto the pipe where you're installing it. You can clearly see why by looking at the photo posted above. They are not a "simple" swap for a stocker. You can't put on in place of the stock AFM. You can put one in place of the stock AFM, if you get the mounting boss and weld it to some pipe and otherwise make that pipe piece work like the stock AFM housing. Or you can buy such an adapter, either complete with the 4 bolt flange for the air box, or without, for varying degrees of work needed to then make it fit your stock airbox or some pod filter or whatever you have going on. Oh, and the R35 AFM is not plug and play. The wiring is different, but changing that is trivial. The plug is also different so you either end up repinning the original wires onto the new plug, or you just use a short adapter. If you weld a boss to the cold side pipe, the cold side pipe really wants to be 3", otherwise the scaling on the meter can get a bit weird, but whatever the pipe size, it's not as easy as just using the (fully documented in the Nistune doco) simple method for choosing R35 AFM in X" pipe size in the software, because the scaling will already be a bit different. Anyway, all of this has been comprehensively worked through on the Nistune forums, so there is full knowledge available. I would use a Link/Haltech before I would bother putting an AFM into a cold side pipe. That's a lot of effort for a bodge. Nistune is great, can work well even at fairly high power levels, but you are stuck with the limitations of it being the stock ECU, which includes needing to use an AFM, which is not always convenient for every set of modifications. You have to have a think about what you already have, what you want to have, and decide early if you'd be better off jumping ship to an aftermarket ECU. This so you don't waste time and money doing things 2 or 3 times. Never heard of ECUmaster. Sounds like a backyard operation. If there are good tuners for it where you are, and it is a solid product, then it will be fine. We're only talking about an R engine here. Back in the day they all ran on crude nasty early 90s ECUs and they were fine. You don't need a rocket surgeon's ECU to run one.
    • So left off with high hopes of having a gearbox in pretty quickly........ Got the adapter plate that week and had to chase a few threads and work out how/where everything goes as no instructions. Got the adapter fitted, test fitted gearbox and found had to cut and shave a few things. Tunnel required some hits with a decent hammer to give some clearance on passenger side but it fits with no problems,  could fit a 8hp70 with a little more work. For a cross member I wasn't going to spend $1100 on so shiny machined piece. Went through a few designs and remembered I had a gktech s chassis to cd00# cross member. Fitted that and found its close enough with a few extra bits welded so have gone that way and still a work in progress.  After this got into modifying the intercooler with some bends and clamps. I was procrastinating on this as was not keen to cut up and weld it myself but happy with the outcome.  Onto the radiator shroud and oil cooler mount. This thing took way longer than I thought it would but having to add an extra oil cooler for the trans and wanting everything within the chassis rails its good enough for now. It mounts to the chassis and gives plenty of room for lines and pipes. All the coolers are rubber mounted and sealed the shroud on the top and sides, will use some tape to seal the bottom gap of about 10mm. 20250508_111500.mp4   Next job was to build the new diff and after a delay with a friend got built this week. I ended up putting it all together with supervision and was good to learn how to set one up correctly. I ended up going a 3.69 ratio, nismo 1.5 way gt pro with gtr Axel's. Stripped it all down, gave all the parts a good clean, pressed on new bearings and set backlash. Was good working in a clean assembly room with all the gear. Once got home wire wheeled the case and hit it with some rollbar/chassis black paint. Got a few more bits done but will leave them for the next update.
    • That could be drilled, ground and welded. Would stop it progressing and leaking. But that block shouldn't be pushed very hard, as what you see there is a massive warning sign. But that fix also isn't going to happen properly with the engine in the car, and assembled. So you're looking at anew block if you're doing all that work anyway.
×
×
  • Create New...