Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

DSG's (or should I say a dual clutch transmission) are one of those new automotive toys that will eventually dominate the automotive world much like its predecessor the tiptronic gearbox did.

But unlike the tiptronic gearbox - which really is rubbish - the DSG is a truely great thing and the more I've been exposed to them the more I think I may never want to buy a genuine manual gearbox again. So many forum hero's rubbish these things and I know it's been one of the complaints of the new GT-R but if you ever really get a chance to see what one of these things can do and understand how much the driver still needs to input one to make a car drive perfectly and yet discover how much one of these things can improve your driving compared to a manual stick you'll understand why some people like me think they are the bee's knees.

The hardest part is finding cars which actually have one that normal people can afford. Just because a car as some flappy paddles attached to the steering wheel doesn't mean it has a DSG gearbox. The ever reveired Jerermy Clarkson often goes on about how he hates "flappy paddle gearboxes" but usually the ones he complains about are actually just tiptronics (which I agree are rubbish). More and more he is starting to compliment them and everytime he has it has been a DSG box and yet he has never publically put 2 and 2 together on this front. I guess the hard part is people keep calling all these things different things.

For example - BMW have their SMG gearboxes but they are just a tiptronic gearbox. They have just released their first DSG style box in the new M3 only within the last month and won't be available until the end of the year I think. Other big names like Aston Martin, Porsche and Mercedes also use tiptronics which are really no different to the ones found in all the falcadores and magnas.

The first experiences I had with a propper DGS was in a Maserati Gran Sport which is the same unit as found in the 360 Straddale, which has been since improved in the F430. The one in the Audi R8 is just as brilliant especially on a track. But the hard part is all of these cars are so expensive and the new GT-R is going to fall under this catagory as well.

So the point of this thread was to try and work-out which cars currently that fall under "Affordable" (which I'm classing as under $100K) actually have one of these gearboxes as last night I could only think of a few.

I've driven both the VW Golf R32 and the Passat R36 and their ones are one of the best. So much so that it was one of the deciding factors in my ordering one of the new R36 Passat Wagons for the Mrs. The GTi also has it but I'm not sure if other VW's come with it or not?

I also just drove one of the new EVO X MR SST's back from Syd to Melb the fun way and again the gearbox in that was great and really what made me start this thread. But they are the only cars I can think of that have one. Is there any others I'm missing??

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/238199-affordable-cars-with-a-dsg/
Share on other sites

  • Replies 47
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Snowy, just have to correct you, maybe you were in a hurry.

The SMG in BMW's isn't a "tiptronic", it's an automated clutch manual gearbox. And I think it's appalling.

The term Tiptronic was coined by Porsche in the early 90's for their "sporty" auto gearboxed 911. It was the first vehicle to have the extra little selector slot beside the normal shift.

Over the years, seems most people have somehow started calling all gear selectors with the Porsche style +/- shifters Tiptronic.

I love "DSG's", IF they're in the right car. And I think we shouldn't be calling them DSG, as thats just Volkswagen's term for it. How about we call them dual clutch transmissions (DCT)?

IMO, while a DCT is great for a sports car, it's not ideal for a larger luxurious style car or tight driving situations, where a more conventional automatic 'box is much better. See what can be done with the ZF auto for instance, given the right programming and actual locking torque convertor, it can be smooth as silk, while still blipping the throttle when a manual downshift has been asked of it. A DCT on the other hand can sometimes be caught nappuing between gears, especially in auto mode. Yes, even VW's, which is seen as one of the best.

I think within 10 years, there'll be only two gearboxes offered. A smart traditional automatic box with high tech convertor lockup for great economy and smoothness, and DCT for more sporting cars.

Snowy, just have to correct you, maybe you were in a hurry.

The SMG in BMW's isn't a "tiptronic", it's an automated clutch manual gearbox. And I think it's appalling.

Meh - it's not a dual clutch which is what I'm looking for :D And I'm happy to call it a DCT rather than DSG. But sometimes the 1st ones just stick. It's like ordering a scotch and coke rather than a scotch and cola. It's the same thing even if its made with Pepsi :D

IMO, while a DCT is great for a sports car, it's not ideal for a larger luxurious style car or tight driving situations, where a more conventional automatic 'box is much better. See what can be done with the ZF auto for instance, given the right programming and actual locking torque convertor, it can be smooth as silk, while still blipping the throttle when a manual downshift has been asked of it. A DCT on the other hand can sometimes be caught nappuing between gears, especially in auto mode. Yes, even VW's, which is seen as one of the best.

Yeah but in all the ones I've driven when you have been driving around town they are perfect in Auto mode. As that is when having the Auto option is gold. When driving the EVO back from Syd we had the car in Auto when cruising along the freeways and when driving through Canberra but as soon as we got into the twisties the SST was turned on and the stability control was turned off and the fun began in ernest. It really was the best of all worlds.

The only problem was it's an EVO. But the R36 is a corker of a car from the short time I had in it :)

But it sounds like the VW's and the EVO are all we have as options right?

Aston , Jag etc are also manualised Autos. My understanding is that you have dual clutch DSG, manual cars that have hydraulics for clutch activation (Ferrari etc) and then you have the autos which have a manual option with different degrees of success. Some bad, some really good

Yeh Snowy... I reckon the Golf Gti is the kickoff point for a true sporty DCT car at the moment.

Although, for under 20k, you can get one of these with a robotised manual, ala SMG, assuming you don't mind going nuts trying to drive it smoothly :D;

MJ54FTV_20.jpg

Edited by Marlin
So what do you do with your left foot? Tap away pretending you are the drummer from Fear Factory?

Mate, wait til you drive a 35 gtr, you'll be sold on the DCT virtues believe me. Although it might not be as satisfying as a trad manual, the pace you can get by not worrying having the right gear is astounding, especially on a road you're not familiar with, and it's where the 35 gets alot of its pace from. It's nuts!!!!

The only unfortuante thing is, and its only in SOME situations, it won't let you left foot brake and have throttle at the same time, no doubt something the tuning companies will be working on.

Since when do Golfs come with 200kw 2.0L turbocharged engines and AWD?

Or do you mean they have just taken the best bits of all the golfs and put it into one car and then put a different badge on it? :P (And hopefully the same sound system as the S8 has - now THATS impressive).

My Dad has a VW Jetta with the 2.0t from the Golf GTi and has the DSG. Really is a fantastic car to drive and great if you need a bit more room over a Golf.

my dad has one too

awsome car..dont even feel the gears change and its bloudy fast i tells ya

audi tt have them... bit of a woman's car but still sexy deep down... +1 for lightning fast gearchanges etc

that said, there are few things i would love more than the new 911 with porsche's DPK box.. .drool

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • The other problem was one of those "oh shit we are going to die moments". Basically the high spec Q50s have a full electric steering rack, and the povo ones had a regular hydraulic rack with an electric pump.  So couple of laps into session 5 as I came into turn 2 (big run off now, happily), the dash turned into a christmas tree and the steering became super heavy and I went well off. I assumed it was a tyre failure so limped to the pits, but everything was OK. But....the master warning light was still on so I checked the DTCs and saw – C13E6 “Heat Protection”. Yes, that bloody steering rack computer sitting where the oil cooler should be has its own sensors and error logic, and decided I was using the steering wheel too much. I really appreciated the helpful information in the manual (my bold) POSSIBLE CAUSE • Continuing the overloading steering (Sports driving in the circuit etc,) “DATA MONITOR” >> “C/M TEMPERATURE”. The rise of steering force motor internal temperature caused the protection function to operate. This is not a system malfunction. INSPECTION END So, basically the electric motor in the steering rack got to 150c, and it decided to shut down without warning for my safety. Didn't feel safe. Short term I'll see if I can duct some air to that motor (the engine bay is sealed pretty tight). Long term, depending on how often this happens, I'll look into swapping the povo spec electric/hydraulic rack in. While the rack should be fine the power supply to the pump will be a pain and might be best to deal with it when I add a PDM.
    • And finally, 2 problems I really need to sort.  Firstly as Matt said the auto trans is not happy as it gets hot - I couldn't log the temps but the gauge showed 90o. On the first day I took it out back in Feb, because the coolant was getting hot I never got to any auto trans issues; but on this day by late session 3 and then really clearly in 4 and 5 as it got hotter it just would not shift up. You can hear the issue really clearly at 12:55 and 16:20 on the vid. So the good news is, literally this week Ecutek finally released tuning for the jatco 7 speed. I'll have a chat to Racebox and see what they can do electrically to keep it cooler and to get the gears, if anything. That will likely take some R&D and can only really happen on track as it never gets even warm with road use. I've also picked up some eye wateringly expensive Redline D6 ATF to try, it had the highest viscosity I could find at 100o so we will see if that helps (just waiting for some oil pan gaskets so I can change it properly). If neither of those work I need to remove the coolant/trans interwarmer and the radiator cooler and go to an external cooler....somewhere.....(goodbye washer reservoir?), and if that fails give up on this mad idea and wait for Nissan to release the manual 400R
    • So, what else.... Power. I don't know what it is making because I haven't done a post tune dyno run yet; I will when I get a chance. It was 240rwkw dead stock. Conclusion from the day....it does not need a single kw more until I sort some other stuff. It comes on so hard that I could hear the twin N1 turbos on the R32 crying, and I just can't use what it has around a tight track with the current setup. Brakes. They are perfect. Hit them hard all day and they never felt like having an issue; you can see in the video we were making ground on much lighter cars on better tyres under brakes. They are standard (red sport) calipers, standard size discs in DBA5000 2 piece, Winmax pads and Motul RBF600 fluid, all from Matty at Racebrakes Sydney. Keeping in mind the car is more powerful than my R32 and weighs 1680, he clearly knows his shit. Suspension. This is one of the first areas I need to change. It has electronically controlled dampers from factory, but everything is just way too soft for track work even on the hardest setting (it is nice when hustling on country roads though). In particular it rolls into oversteer mid corner and pitches too much under hard braking so it becomes unstable eg in the turn 1 kink I need to brake early, turn through the kink then brake again so I don't pirouette like an AE86. I need to get some decent shocks with matched springs and sway bars ASAP, even if it is just a v1 setup until I work out a proper race/rally setup later. Tyres. I am running Yoko A052 in 235/45/18 all round, because that was what I could get in approximately the right height on wheels I had in the shed (Rays/Nismo 18x8 off the old Leaf actually!). As track tyres they are pretty poor; I note GTSBoy recently posted a porker comparo video including them where they were about the same as AD09.....that is nothing like a top line track tyre. I'll start getting that sorted but realistically I should get proper sized wheels first (likely 9.5 +38 front and 11 +55 at the rear, so a custom order, and I can't rotate them like the R32), then work out what the best tyre option is. BTW on that, Targa Tas had gone to road tyres instead of semi slicks now so that is a whole other world of choices to sort. Diff. This is the other thing that urgently needs to be addressed. It left massive 1s out of the fish hook all day, even when I was trying not too (you can also hear it reving on the video, and see the RPM rising too fast compared to speed in the data). It has an open diff that Infiniti optimistically called a B-LSD for "Brake Limited Slip Diff". It does good straight line standing start 11s but it is woeful on the track. Nismo seem to make a 2 way for it.
    • Also, I logged some data from the ECU for each session (mostly oil pressures and various temps, but also speed, revs etc, can't believe I forgot accelerator position). The Ecutek data loads nicely to datazap, I got good data from sessions 2, 3 and 4: https://datazap.me/u/duncanhandleyhgeconsultingcomau/250813-wakefield-session-2?log=0&data=7 https://datazap.me/u/duncanhandleyhgeconsultingcomau/250813-wakefield-session-3?log=0&data=6 https://datazap.me/u/duncanhandleyhgeconsultingcomau/250813-wakefield-session-4?log=0&data=6 Each session is cut into 3 files but loaded together, you can change between them in the top left. As the test sessions are mostly about the car, not me, I basically start by checking the oil pressure (good, or at least consistent all day). These have an electrically controlled oil pump which targets 25psi(!) at low load and 50 at high. I'm running a much thicker oil than recommended by nissan (they said 0w20, I'm running 10w40) so its a little higher. The main thing is that it doesn't drop too far, eg in the long left hand fish hook, or under brakes so I know I'm not getting oil surge. Good start. Then Oil and Coolant temp, plus intercooler and intake temps, like this: Keeping in mind ambient was about 5o at session 2, I'd say the oil temp is good. The coolant temp as OK but a big worry for hot days (it was getting to 110 back in Feb when it was 35o) so I need to keep addressing that. The water to air intercooler is working totally backwards where we get 5o air in the intake, squish/warm it in the turbos (unknown temp) then run it through the intercoolers which are say 65o max in this case, then the result is 20o air into the engine......the day was too atypical to draw a conclusion on that I think, in the united states of freedom they do a lot of upsizing the intercooler and heat exchanger cores to get those temps down but they were OK this time. The other interesting (but not concerning) part for me was the turbo speed vs boost graph: I circled an example from the main straight. With the tune boost peaks at around 18psi but it deliberately drops to about 14psi at redline because the turbos are tiny - they choke at high revs and just create more heat than power if you run them hard all the way. But you can also see the turbo speed at the same time; it raises from about 180,000rpm to 210,000rpm which the boost falls....imagine the turbine speed if they held 18psi to redline. The wastegates are electrically controlled so there is a heap of logic about boost target, actual boost, delta etc etc but it all seems to work well
    • hahah when youtube subscribers are faster than my updates here. Yes some vid from the day is up, here:  Note that as with all track day videos it is boring watching after the bloopers at the start.  The off was a genuine surprise to me, I've literally done a thousand laps around the place and I've never had instability there; basically it rolled into oversteer, slipped, gripped and spat me out. On the way off I mowed down one of the instructor's cones and it sat there all day looking at me with accusing cone eyes as I drove past. 1:13:20 was my fastest lap, and it was in the second session, 3rd lap.  It (or me!) got slower throughout the day as it got hotter.      
×
×
  • Create New...