Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hello all, this is something many of you may or may not know about so I thought I would put it up and see what people think.

Recently an engine was built by me and the bolt for the idler pulley on the timing belt snapped. This happened about 2000km in (I think). All my engines get new bolts there so it came as quite a surprise. The owner and I decided to investigate. I have never had a new bolt break in this way.

He flies aircraft and has contacts for testing bolts etc so we bought 10 8.8 high tensile M10 x 70 bolts and sent them to his guy for MPI (Magnetic Particle Inspection) testing.

7 out of the 10 failed the MPI due to surface irregularities that are at high risk of a crack starting in that area.

So we had three we could use on his engine. I decided to send the other 7 off to be treated to see if we can improve the statistics and then have them re-tested.

I'll let you all know the result once I have them

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/290065-bolt/
Share on other sites

Same thing happened to my engine, 500kms in.

New piston, valves, head and a new idler bolt later. Was rebuilt and has been going strong.

If you eventually get a new stronger replacement, i would be buying one off you in a second if i or anyone i knew was building an RB.

As the result of a snapped $15 bolt creates a whole word of heartache :(

And Daniel im sure you have done a few timing belts, but i think the tension has a part to play with these bolt failures also.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/290065-bolt/#findComment-4854482
Share on other sites

Out of interest, was any other damage caused when this bolt snapped? Was it a bolt supplied by Nissan or otherwise?

yeah every valve touched. Decoro valves too.

I know what you mean NYTSKY but I can assure you overtension is not a problem.

I would have done 20 belts this year alone. Always set them a certain way and double check deflection after 4 rotations.

It was a genuine Nissan bolt and washer. The other 10 purchased are aftermarket bolts

I'm going to try cryogenic treating them first, then back in for MPI

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/290065-bolt/#findComment-4855292
Share on other sites

never heard of it, are those bolts being torqued up or by hand, Ive done many on rb engines and never felt the need to replace the bolt, i tension by hand with loctite using original bolt, Is sounding like the brand new replacement bolt isn't up to the original spec.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/290065-bolt/#findComment-4856150
Share on other sites

never heard of it, are those bolts being torqued up or by hand, Ive done many on rb engines and never felt the need to replace the bolt, i tension by hand with loctite using original bolt, Is sounding like the brand new replacement bolt isn't up to the original spec.

Go and get an old idler bolt xrayed. You'll never put one back in, I gaurantee it!

the new bolt that snapped was a genuine nissan bolt made for the idler pulley specifically ??

yes it was.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/290065-bolt/#findComment-4857691
Share on other sites

Go and get an old idler bolt xrayed. You'll never put one back in, I gaurantee it!

yes it was.

yes the new bolts are actually a Navara part number which is a little bit of a concern.

Edited by DiRTgarage
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/290065-bolt/#findComment-4857708
Share on other sites

Um couldn't you simply sue Nissan for the damages if you can prove, with xrays and whatnot, that it was their genuine bolt that snapped due to shoddy QC ?

Already considered that but it's not really in my best interest (or budget) to chase a large car dealership for around $2000

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/290065-bolt/#findComment-4858446
Share on other sites

small claims tribunal costs nothing .. I'm sure they'd pay up to avoid bad publicity if you had expert opinions (and xrays) that it was their bolt that failed under normal conditions.

1. It's probably like 3 - 4 days of my time which works out to be about $3k

2. It's not working under normal conditions considering its a RB26/30

3. They could just say I have to prove it wasn't my fault, which there is no way that I can other than going off the other gazillionty timing belts I have done without problems.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/290065-bolt/#findComment-4858492
Share on other sites

+1 Get a higher grade. The extra safety factor in property class 12.9 or 10.9 bolts will help or you can try removing the surface irregularities by polishing

Property class 12.9 is 1200MPa UTS and 0.9x(1200)=1080MPa yield

Property class 10.9 is 1000MPa UTS and 0.9x(1000)=900MPa yield

as compared to

Property class 8.8 is 800MPa UTS and 0.8x(800)=640MPa yield

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/290065-bolt/#findComment-4858695
Share on other sites

  • 3 weeks later...
Anyone had this problem with the tensioner pulley stud? I just snapped mine! :thumbsup:

Luckily no engine damage though! :)

Yeah I had a guy come in with a noise once. Turns out the tensioner stud broke and the belt was pushing the bearing into the side of the lower cover. Lucky save that one was.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/290065-bolt/#findComment-4893249
Share on other sites

Yeah I had a guy come in with a noise once. Turns out the tensioner stud broke and the belt was pushing the bearing into the side of the lower cover. Lucky save that one was.

Yeah... pretty much the same problem here. The car started making a horrible noise. Pulled off the timing covers to find heaps of slack on the tensioner side of the belt. So lucky not to skip any teeth!

I wonder if this is in any way related to power levels ? ie. has anyone had either the factory tensioner or idler pulley bolts snap out of the blue on a mildly modified car ie 200-270kw?

Mine would fall in this category.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/290065-bolt/#findComment-4893647
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • The team at OBD2 Australia are pretty good, shoot them an email and ask them. I've dealt with them before for work stuff. I'd be shocked if it didn't work, so long as Consult can activate the ABS. But you might need to use KLine for it which would be the stopper, as I don't think that piece does KLine comms.
    • Yeah and hence my ghetto way of slamming the brakes, get the ABS to cycle, rebleed seems to be a sensible workaround.
    • Hey! Happy to help. Nothing inherently wrong with the adapter, it's more so with Brett Collins himself. He gave me a lot of incorrect information when I was in contact with him and was extremely rude when I challenged him. He stated I could not use any aftermarket twin plate clutches except for his own, not to use the dush shield, bla bla bla and it was all BS.  Collins stated to cut roughly 14mm's off the housing, I took off 15mm to make room for the dust shield. I would confirm with whatever adapter manufacturer you're using. 
    • There's plenty of OEM steering arms that are bolted on. Not in the same fashion/orientation as that one, to be sure, but still. Examples of what I'm thinking of would use holes like the ones that have the downward facing studs on the GTR uprights (down the bottom end, under the driveshaft opening, near the lower balljoint) and bolt a steering arm on using only 2 bolts that would be somewhat similarly in shear as these you're complainig about. I reckon old Holdens did that, and I've never seen a broken one of those.
    • Let's be honest, most of the people designing parts like the above, aren't engineers. Sometimes they come from disciplines that gives them more qualitative feel for design than quantitive, however, plenty of them have just picked up a license to Fusion and started making things. And that's the honest part about the majority of these guys making parts like that, they don't have huge R&D teams and heaps of time or experience working out the numbers on it. Shit, most smaller teams that do have real engineers still roll with "yeah, it should be okay, and does the job, let's make them and just see"...   The smaller guys like KiwiCNC, aren't the likes of Bosch etc with proper engineering procedures, and oversights, and sign off. As such, it's why they can produce a product to market a lot quicker, but it always comes back to, question it all.   I'm still not a fan of that bolt on piece. Why not just machine it all in one go? With the right design it's possible. The only reason I can see is if they want different heights/length for the tie rod to bolt to. And if they have the cncs themselves,they can easily offer that exact feature, and just machine it all in one go. 
×
×
  • Create New...