Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Long story short, I recently replaced a f**ked gearbox in my car. I had to replace the clutch too, as the f**ked gearbox took the clutch with it.

I've had the car back maybe two weeks since it was all fixed up, and haven't given it any stick at all. Anyway tonight I was driving home, was a nice cold night, no one around so I thought I'd have a bit of fun.

Nothing major, I rolled off gradually from the lights before punching the throttle, then as I quickly put the car into second I stomped the throttle again only to have the revs literally fly up and the car not gain any power.

I thought the rear tyres were spinning, so I quickly put it in third and eased off on the accelerator, but again the revs flew up and I moved no where. It was at this point I obviously realized it was the clutch spinning not the wheels.

At the next stop it became apparent by the stink it was indeed clutch not the wheels. My question is, should a new clutch do this (HD Exedy) in an NA Supra? And how much damage have I done to my current one with this little stunt?

I've given my car much, much rougher shifts and launches at DECA etc, and nothing like this has happened before. Is there a chance they've stiffed me with a dodgy clutch, or was I just too enthusiasitic?

The car drove home fine, the clutch didn't feel any different. Just frustrating after having literally just replaced the clutch.

Thanks.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/298577-burning-the-clutch/
Share on other sites

No, a properly installed standard clutch shouldn't do this let alone a heavy duty.

Was the flywheel machined at the same time as clutch being replaced?

Did they replace the whole clutch and not just the contact plate or pressure plate?

Might have been oil/grease on the flywheel, this can cause such symptoms. You might have a leaking rear main engine seal.

No, a properly installed standard clutch shouldn't do this let alone a heavy duty.

Was the flywheel machined at the same time as clutch being replaced?

Did they replace the whole clutch and not just the contact plate or pressure plate?

Might have been oil/grease on the flywheel, this can cause such symptoms. You might have a leaking rear main engine seal.

Flywheel was machined, and the rear main seal was replaced when the clutch was done the first time (maybe 3 months ago - pain in the ass having to replace it again).

Pretty sure the whole clutch was done, they just used another HD Exedy kit again.

How much damage can I do to a clutch when spinning it for... less than 5 seconds in second and third.

Thanks.

Long story short, I recently replaced a f**ked gearbox in my car. I had to replace the clutch too, as the f**ked gearbox took the clutch with it.

I've had the car back maybe two weeks since it was all fixed up, and haven't given it any stick at all. Anyway tonight I was driving home, was a nice cold night, no one around so I thought I'd have a bit of fun.

Nothing major, I rolled off gradually from the lights before punching the throttle, then as I quickly put the car into second I stomped the throttle again only to have the revs literally fly up and the car not gain any power.

I thought the rear tyres were spinning, so I quickly put it in third and eased off on the accelerator, but again the revs flew up and I moved no where. It was at this point I obviously realized it was the clutch spinning not the wheels.

At the next stop it became apparent by the stink it was indeed clutch not the wheels. My question is, should a new clutch do this (HD Exedy) in an NA Supra? And how much damage have I done to my current one with this little stunt?

I've given my car much, much rougher shifts and launches at DECA etc, and nothing like this has happened before. Is there a chance they've stiffed me with a dodgy clutch, or was I just too enthusiasitic?

The car drove home fine, the clutch didn't feel any different. Just frustrating after having literally just replaced the clutch.

Thanks.

why did you do that with a new clutch?you stuffed your clutch and most likely gonna need a new one.

i stuffed my standard clutch and could smell like a electrical smell and then got an exedy sports tough clutch installed and my mechanic told me to drive normal until the clutch is worn in.

its not recommended doing stuff like that with a new one.

He said he's had the car back for nearly two weeks...don't know about you guys but I don't drive far to work and I still cover about 400km in a week. If this is his daily and he's true to his word of taking care of it up until now then I'd say it was a dicey install.

Have you driven the car hard since this happened? To see if it does it again?

He said he's had the car back for nearly two weeks...don't know about you guys but I don't drive far to work and I still cover about 400km in a week. If this is his daily and he's true to his word of taking care of it up until now then I'd say it was a dicey install.

Have you driven the car hard since this happened? To see if it does it again?

Been too paranoid it'll happen again. Guess I'll have to find out anyway, might do it later tonight and see what happens.

To the above poster I had no idea clutches had to worn in. No one ever told me.

Installer should have told you that...always wear in new mechanical items.

It's possible there was just a bit of oil/grease on the flywheel that needed to be burnt off. Don't be paranoid about it...you can't stuff it up any worse than you already have if you have actually stuffed it. Give it some stick and let us know if she spins.

You can bring it past my work during the day if you can be bothered making the trip up Eastlink.

Installer should have told you that...always wear in new mechanical items.

It's possible there was just a bit of oil/grease on the flywheel that needed to be burnt off. Don't be paranoid about it...you can't stuff it up any worse than you already have if you have actually stuffed it. Give it some stick and let us know if she spins.

You can bring it past my work during the day if you can be bothered making the trip up Eastlink.

Where do you work?

I'm actually looking for a new mechanic I can trust as this one has done a couple of suspect things in the past. Wouldn't have taken the car there for the gearbox, but it needed to be towed and didn't have much choice.

I suspect that you need to adjust your clutch pedal height cos that's what happen to me when i install new replacement Twin plate for my HKS. Been playing around with the pedal height while using the old clutch plate bcos the grabbing point was too high. The slip will happen on higher revs meaning the clutch is not fully engaged. If yours only slip once or twice then probably the clutch is still ok. Hope this would help you....Cheers!

I suspect that you need to adjust your clutch pedal height cos that's what happen to me when i install new replacement Twin plate for my HKS. Been playing around with the pedal height while using the old clutch plate bcos the grabbing point was too high. The slip will happen on higher revs meaning the clutch is not fully engaged. If yours only slip once or twice then probably the clutch is still ok. Hope this would help you....Cheers!

I've previously always had HD Exedy clutches. Car came with one (nearly dead) when I bought it, and I replaced it with one.

Would replacing the gearbox and clutch (with the same model box and clutch) affect it, or is it only for when changing the type of clutch?

I gave the car a rather *hard launch the other night, and the car gripped fine, so here's hoping it was just a bit of oil.

* Anyone else give their car a hard time when it's pissing them off?

this same thing happened to me last week in my skyline r33 gtst was just standard clutch tho it done it to me a couple times the same night ended up burning the clutch so im now installing a heavy duty one but yeh 1 of the times i droped it down to third and it done it and second time i snapped second thought it was wheel spining but it was burning my clutch

I was lucky enough to have a friend adjust the pedal height back up slightly because the HKS Twins naturally release at the very top only, so was my bad for trying to follow other type of clutch kits. Btw how much clamping force and HP can the HD Exedy take before slip happens? I've been to the Exedy website but kinda confuse by the amount of product ranges available.

Where do you work?

I'm actually looking for a new mechanic I can trust as this one has done a couple of suspect things in the past. Wouldn't have taken the car there for the gearbox, but it needed to be towed and didn't have much choice.

At a gearbox and diff specialist, PM if you want some details :P

You don't want us as regular mechanics though...we charge shitloads lol. Engineers doing hoistwork = big bills.

How does one go about burning a clutch? I'm relatively new to driving manual.

Cheers,

fibbo.

Whilst the clutch is slipping... IE, it should be engaged, but isn't "locking up"... Or more, as described, revs go up, but speed/power doesn't match.

This leads to a burnt clutch. Also, dodgy shifts do as well, IE "Flaring" gears...

Yep. The clutch contact plate uses friction against the flywheel to move the car...if it won't grip the flywheel when you release the clutch pedal then it's slipping somehow...either because the pressure plate is worn, or you're using too high revs for the clutch on take off, or because there is oil/grease on the flywheel. Symptoms are experienced as if you have your foot on the clutch pedal...engine revs up easily...you go nowhere. If it slips too much then the friction material on the contact plate gets really hot and wears out quickly. Not so much a big deal for an already worn in clutch, but for a new clutch that hasn't bed in properly yet...this will destroy it.

Need more info... Can you still engage gears? and let the clutch out to drive? What does the clutch pedal feel like? springy or soft and doughy. Where is the contact point? high or low in the pedal travel. Not sure with HD clutches but anything with a puk or button type clutches are not ment to be ridden (at high revs) as this causes heat and wears the clutch. So they are either on or off with the pedal.

  • 1 month later...

I did a launch this morning at ~6 grand, and felt it slip and could smell what I presume is coming from the clutch?

It was a stock clutch and I'm getting a new twin plate in ~2 weeks, just thought I'd try and find the limits of my stock one. Well I have :D

Hope it can get me through the next 2 weeks and is not too stuffed? :P

I did a launch this morning at ~6 grand, and felt it slip and could smell what I presume is coming from the clutch?

It was a stock clutch and I'm getting a new twin plate in ~2 weeks, just thought I'd try and find the limits of my stock one. Well I have :(

Hope it can get me through the next 2 weeks and is not too stuffed? :banana:

lol twin plate? that's a bit excessive isn't it :(

Stock clutch will be fine unless it's to the point of slipping as you come on boost.

I run an exedy 4puck sprung button clutch, we'll see how it handles 500rwhp when the engine goes back in. For lower power levels it's an awesome clutch but was a bit of a cop to drive when it was behind the RB20. Needed 3500rpm to take off normally lol.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Welcome to !
    • As I've said elsewhere, I am using the stock intercooler piping path in the engine bay, and a return flow cooler, and making ~250 rwkW (without any effort put into trying to turn it up past there just yet) and expect to be able to make some more, and frankly, I would be perfectly happy with 260-270rwKW. This is peak road Skyline usability territory. You go past there and, sure, the car will snap necks more when it's on boost, but it will also break shit all the time, cost a (even larger) fortune in tyres, etc etc. Anyway, I also do not like the over-the-fan pipe path, and you don't have to do it.
    • I see, honestly I’m not too fussed about the looks. The only reason to go plenum is to make the piping easier instead of the classic over the rad etc. 
    • Not easy to quantify wrt something like how many fractions of a second slower it would be over 0-100. But given that a 250-300rwkW car is able to do that launch sprint in 5-6 sec (and faster with appropriate tyres, and surface)..... giving up as much as a second would feel like torture. A ~450HP capable turbo is not going to make lots of boost in the 2000-3000 rpm range. So, whilst with some boost on hand it will be faster accelerating in that rev range than your engine currently is NA, it will not feel like a fast car until the boost is solidly in. You know what your car feels like right now when you open it up at 2000rpm. if you've ever been in an actual fast car, you will appreciate that the NARB25 is.... not exciting. Well, add some boost and it will be better. But shorten the intake runners and it might not be better at all. It might come out better, but it could end up feeling the same. For me, it's not the 0-X km/h sprints that matter. It is easy to fry the tyres with anything over 200 rwkW. You can't use all the power available in 1st and 2nd anyway, you have to modulate the throttle. What matters is how the car reacts when you're driving in traffic in 4th or 5th and have maybe 2000 rpm on board, and you want/need to add some speed quickly, and don't have time for the downshift. It won't make boost, it will be all NA (at the speeds we're talking about - remember how fast you're going at 2000 in 4th! and don't plan on breaking the limit by too much.) So giving away NA torque is not what I would consider practical for a street car. And retaining that NA torque builds boost faster which makes the car faster. The flashy plenum is not actually better, unless you're looking at a track car where you can keep it on the boil all the time.  
    • So how much difference does it make you think? Like 1 second in the 0-100?  I was have smaller turbo so hopefully that spools quick GTX2871.  currently it’s NA so you can imagine pretty slow, but I do want fast accusation a little as there’s not many places I’ll be driving where I go over 80 even near me. So 0-60 and 0-80 targets   
×
×
  • Create New...