Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

So I think ive watched every RB video on youtube haha. There is a very specific sound that I would like to get from my rb25 but I cant seem to pinpoint exactly what brings out this sound from these engines. It might sound crazy but the sound of these engines was one of the primary reasons for my choosing it over a JZ engine for my swap, so I want to get the exact sound from it that I like. Its hard to get much tech info from any sources here in the states so I figured you guys would be the best to ask. As far as I can tell from videos it doesnt really matter if its an rb26, rb25, rb30, or rb25neo, they all sound pretty much the same given the same setup.

Here are a couple standard sounding RBs, im sure you all know what an RB sounds like but I guess ill put these here to kind of set a baseline. Just your average RB sound

I really like this one, but not quite the sound im talking about

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j9YOBLjjTJs

This one is getting closer but still not there

And here is the sound im trying to achieve, its kind of a crunchy screaming wail and higher pitch than the previous videos.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6LMv_Rp1VEg&list=FLmjK5nvga3Hx18GsD4dhE8Q&index=20

Does anybody know what these cars might have in common in the engine/exhaust that give them this sound? They seem to be straight pipe but I dont think this is the main thing that gives the sound.

Thanks

Edited by Carbibbles
Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/442169-how-do-i-get-this-sound/
Share on other sites

See at first I thought it had something to do with a larger than normal exhaust (straight pipe of course), like running a 3.5" instead of 3". But ive watched some videos of cars with 3.5" and even 4" that dont seem to get this sound.

I have a twin scroll tubular manifold waiting to go on, and ill be running a borg warner s366.

Did you watch the videos? Its definitely not the wastegate(s), I had planned to do atmospheric dumps on my wastegates but I know that wont get me the particular sound im after. There is a distinct difference between the first set of videos and the second.

Im sure this post/thread comes off as ricey but I know what im doing and the exhaust sound is important to me. I really dont want to spend a ton of money and time fabricating/re-fabricating parts to get the sound im after. I was hoping someone who has been around a lot of RB cars would be able to identify and give some experience based input to what kind of setups produce this particular exhaust sound. There arent any other RB cars in my area, and really not a lot in the USA compared to other countries. Its hard to track down information that I would usually be able to collect by just going to the dragstrip and asking people about their setups.

It's not ricey, but it is pretty stupid.

You've chosen your turbo and manifold. You want to run straight through exhaust. But you want to make your car sound like those? Well, does that mean your willing to change turbos, manifolds, wastegate size for the sound?

If so, then spend your time emailing the people who own the cars in the vids and ask their setup, instead of playing guessing games on a forum.

If not, put your flaming car together with a 3.5 inch exhaust, fabrication which means you can either plumb back or vent to atmosphere the wastegates. Then go drive it!

Two other points.

You're placing all of your faith in sound shot off camera phones and goPros. Ever listened back to a recording off one of those and thought it sounded exactly like the real thing?

Also, RBs sound completely different. A 26 doesn't sound like a 25, which doesn't sound like a 30.

  • Like 1

It's not ricey, but it is pretty stupid.

You've chosen your turbo and manifold. You want to run straight through exhaust. But you want to make your car sound like those? Well, does that mean your willing to change turbos, manifolds, wastegate size for the sound?

If so, then spend your time emailing the people who own the cars in the vids and ask their setup, instead of playing guessing games on a forum.

If not, put your flaming car together with a 3.5 inch exhaust, fabrication which means you can either plumb back or vent to atmosphere the wastegates. Then go drive it!

I wouldnt say its stupid, why cant I have the sound that I love so much? The sound of these engines really is one of the primary reasons im staying with it. I could easily swap it out for a 2JZ and spend a ton less money making big power. I want to run a straight through exhaust because I think that is something all these cars have in common, normally I would prefer a resonator at least. I like a loud exhaust but im not one to try and have an insanely loud exhaust. I am willing to change turbos (within my power goals) and fabricate another turbo manifold if I knew exactly what features contributed to the sound I am trying to acheive. I have also tried contacting the people with these cars but no success, asking here was a last ditch effort because I figured the guys on here have been around a lot of RBs and might be able to easily give some info on the subject.

Two other points.

You're placing all of your faith in sound shot off camera phones and goPros. Ever listened back to a recording off one of those and thought it sounded exactly like the real thing?

Also, RBs sound completely different. A 26 doesn't sound like a 25, which doesn't sound like a 30.

I can see your point but the sound I am hearing is so distinct that I know its not just a microphone/speaker inaccurately re-producing it. I have heard this exhaust note from all three platforms you mentioned so I know its not tied to the displacement base.

Thanks for the link, I couldnt find in the thread but do you know what exhaust manifold he is running. And is that car straight pipe?

Like this?

Get one of these:

cc9038.jpg

Yes thats it, do you mean one of those manifolds in particular or a tubular manifold in general?

I have this one right now but id be willing to fab up one with a different design if that has something to do with it.

post-116644-0-86182100-1398264600_thumb.png

Here man, this skyline sounds really similar to the sound your looking for. Imo, i reckon this sound sounds much better then the one your looking for, sounds exactly like the r34 gtr from 2 fast 2 furious. In the vid description he posts down exactly what hes done to the car to get that sound. So you could potentially go for this sound, maybe it could help you with the sound your looking for.

But yeah, i reckon go for this sound man, it sounds so epic, i wish i could get my r33 to sound like this.

Here man, this skyline sounds really similar to the sound your looking for. Imo, i reckon this sound sounds much better then the one your looking for, sounds exactly like the r34 gtr from 2 fast 2 furious. In the vid description he posts down exactly what hes done to the car to get that sound. So you could potentially go for this sound, maybe it could help you with the sound your looking for.

But yeah, i reckon go for this sound man, it sounds so epic, i wish i could get my r33 to sound like this.

It sounds good but id say thats more of the standard RB sound, really just playing with mufflers to get the exact note you want.

I think niZmO_Man is on to something, those manifolds looked kind of like 6boost so I started youtubing 6boost mani cars and they all seem to have the sound I want. Im thinking that the runner length and arrangement of the 6boost manifold might be whats getting this sound. Thanks for your response niZmO_Man :)

The manifolds I posted are R31 GTS-R style. R31House make new ones.

IMG_0290_0Xyk_3.jpg

IMO, that's what you want. The long runners gives it that awesome sound up in the rev range.

The 6boost is similar. They make high mount and low mount I believe. There is a company in NZ that does a high mount, Sinco I think it is. The one you have is a Full Race manifold?

The manifolds I posted are R31 GTS-R style. R31House make new ones.

IMG_0290_0Xyk_3.jpg

IMO, that's what you want. The long runners gives it that awesome sound up in the rev range.

The 6boost is similar. They make high mount and low mount I believe. There is a company in NZ that does a high mount, Sinco I think it is. The one you have is a Full Race manifold?

Ok I think that has it pretty much solved. Thanks a ton for the help niZmO_Man :)

The manifold I have right now is an AFI Turbo, its very similar to the full-race. It will probably be up for sale soon haha, ill probably buy a sinco unless its a pain to ship from NZ in which case ill just build one based on 6boost/sinco design.

  • 1 year later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Yeah, they look good. I should try to fit them on mine. But being a GTSt, the guard shape probably doesn't suit properly.
    • Nah, it's not a simple voltage divider. I'm not enough of an electronics guru to know how they make these circuits work. If I had a better idea of how the ECU's temperature measuring is done, I could then actually do as you want, which is turn that resistance chart into a voltage chart. But my approach has not worked. What I did was interpolate the sensor ohms values for the temperatures you listed, as you did not have any of them on a temperature ending in zero or 5. These are: °C ECU V sensor ohms (interpolated) 58 2.68 11.85 57 2.7 11.89 56 2.74 11.93 54 2.8 12.01 49 3.06 12.208 47 3.18 12.284 43 3.37 12.42 I then assumed 5V supply to the resister and calculated the voltage drop across the sensor for each of those, which is just 5 - the above voltages, and then calculated the current that must be flowing through the sensor. So you get:             Values in sensor °C ECU V sensor ohms (interpolated) Supply volts Volt drop Current 58 2.68 11.85     5 2.32 0.195781 57 2.7 11.89     5 2.3 0.19344 56 2.74 11.93     5 2.26 0.189438 54 2.8 12.01     5 2.2 0.183181 49 3.06 12.208     5 1.94 0.158912 47 3.18 12.284     5 1.82 0.14816 43 3.37 12.42     5 1.63 0.13124 And then use that current and the ECU's sensed voltage (which must be the voltage drop across the in ECU resister is there is one) to calculate the resistance of that in ECU resistor. You get:             Values in sensor   Other resistor °C ECU V sensor ohms (interpolated) Supply volts Volt drop Current   Volt Drop Resistance 58 2.68 11.85     5 2.32 0.195781   2.68 13.68879 57 2.7 11.89     5 2.3 0.19344   2.7 13.95783 56 2.74 11.93     5 2.26 0.189438   2.74 14.46381 54 2.8 12.01     5 2.2 0.183181   2.8 15.28545 49 3.06 12.208     5 1.94 0.158912   3.06 19.25592 47 3.18 12.284     5 1.82 0.14816   3.18 21.46325 43 3.37 12.42     5 1.63 0.13124   3.37 25.67816 And that's where it falls apart, because the resulting resistance would need to be the same for all of those temperatures, and it is not. So clearly the physical model is not correct. Anyway, you or someone else can use that information to go forward if someone has a better physical model. I can also show you how to interpolate for temperatures between those in the resistance chart. It's not fun because you've got to either do it like I did it for every 5°C range separately, or check to see if the slope remains constant over a wide range, then you can just work up a single formula. I'm just showing how to do it for a single 5° span. For the 58°C temperature, resistance = 11.77+2*(11.97-11.77)/5 The calc is a little arse backwards because the resistance is NTC (negative temperature coefficient), so the slope is negative, but I'm lazy, so I just treated 58 as if it was 2 degrees away from 60, not 3 degrees away from 55, and so on.
    • Um.... This is not easy. I will have a fiddle with it, but make no promises. I think, given the explicit resistances vs temperature, and your ECU measured voltages, it should be possible to match them up. I will do that by assuming a 5V supply from ECU to sensor, find out how much current would have to flow to produce that voltage, then use that current as a .... nah f**k. That won't work. The supply voltage is fixed, but there's nothing to say that the ECU regulates the current too. Um... I dunno. I guess there's a voltage divider setup in the ECU. As in, there's another resistance between the ECU's sense terminal and ground. That way, as the sensor resistance changes, that's how they get a floating voltage that varies with the temperature, without having to control the current. Give me a minute or 3.
    • *that* is a question for chatgpt (or someone that understands maths....but I'd try chatty). Drop them the table and ask for the formula
    • Alright. Exhaust has been looked at, and booked in 'soon'. I'm not 100% convinced it's going to be as good as possible but I'm going to go with it anyway. If I get a reasonable thing that works for 10 years I mean that's twice as long as I've lived with the current one. I have a more pressing issue. I have fixed my MPVI3 (by buying a new one). Excellently, one can wire in analog 0-5v inputs to the ECU itself. I had wideband already via Serial so I also wired it in via the direct input. The idea being I can use the standalone logging without a laptop and have Wideband data in it. The other wire I thought I'd use oil temp. This is where I've gone crazy. HPTuners requires you to implement a formula so you know how much volts = how much temp. This seems relatively simple to me. However I cannot find the scale for this anywhere on the internet, nor decipher how to figure it out without removing the sensor from the car. All I know is that voltage actually goes up as temperature goes down. I am using the actual gauge, so I can see what the temp is. The signal wire has been branched off into the MPVI3. EXAMPLE: 2.68v = 58C 2.7 = 57C 2.74v = 56C 2.8V = 54C 3.06V = 49C 3.18V = 47C 3.37V = 43C I think the gauge is 50-150C. It may be more. It may be less, because I can't find it for the love of f**k. It appears all the information about the gauges I have has been scoured from the internet, but the sender is VDO 320.021 I believe the resistance chart is this How the f**k do I convert this to a voltage? Once I have a voltage... I then have to perform this transform of said voltage to show it in the scanner: https://www.hptuners.com/help/VCM-Scanner/Content/vcm_scanner/defining_a_transform.htm @GTSBoy you're probably my only hope here TEST YOUR MIGHT
×
×
  • Create New...