Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

hey guys my mate has an r33 s2, he wants to put his afm in the cooler piping. would i be able to get some feedback? is it safe? does it affect the computer?

if i can get some replies that would be great

much appriciated :)

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/183632-afm-in-the-cooler-piping/
Share on other sites

Can be done, no real beneficial reason to do it unless you want to make the car dose/flutter pretty loud.

I believe you get a few stalling issues when the AFM is in the cooler piping due to the air flow readings being altered.

Not 100% sure so wont get into detail, someone else will get into that.

What was the reason behind putting it into the cooler piping?

Edited by abu
Can be done, no real beneficial reason to do it unless you want to make the car dose/flutter pretty loud.

I believe you get a few stalling issues when the AFM is in the cooler piping due to the air flow readings being altered.

Not 100% sure so wont get into detail, someone else will get into that.

What was the reason behind putting it into the cooler piping?

he just wants to do it to get a bit of a longer and louder flutter/dose pretty much. but thanks for your information mate :)

The afm was not designed to be fitted in a pressurised environment, besides that I don't know why you would want to... Some people supposedly do it to stop stalling after they block off/fit atmo bov or they want to fit a gulping big 6" intake pipe thats not needed.

he just wants to do it to get a bit of a longer and louder flutter/dose pretty much. but thanks for your information mate :D

No worries.

Personally think its worth it for the dose, but some would disagree, if not most!.. :)

Edited by abu
doing that reduces lag a little i dont know how exactly but it does...just get a good tune too to keep everything safe..and of course it gives the flutter.

Reduces lag!?

Are you sure man?

I dont see how it would, there wouldn't be any reason why it would..

Edited by abu

It improves throttle response by reducing the amount of air between the afm and inlet valve. I'll try to explain how this works.

AFM only measure air flowing past its sensor wire, now all of the air between the afm and the inlet valves has been premeasured. The engine must use this air before the afm sends the signal to the ecu to adjust load points that the ecu used to calculate fuel and timing requirements.

So say you're driving along at part throttle then u floor it there is some time that passes before the afm measures the change in airflow.

does it make much difference, probably bugger all.

Oh yeah if i was going to do this i'd put the afm post cooler and i'd look at getting a afm body machined from alloy.

cheers

he just wants to do it to get a bit of a longer and louder flutter/dose pretty much. but thanks for your information mate :)
bam said i want to put on a big 6" intake

rofl x 2

doing all that just for a bit of dose...or whatever the f**k it is

i read in a mag that this gets done to fix PFC disease(rare idle issue), they also said that doing it should not affect your tune as it is still measuring air flow past a wire (weather its pre or post turbo its still the same airflowing through it). thats wat i gathered from the article.

Aif

It improves throttle response by reducing the amount of air between the afm and inlet valve. I'll try to explain how this works.

AFM only measure air flowing past its sensor wire, now all of the air between the afm and the inlet valves has been premeasured. The engine must use this air before the afm sends the signal to the ecu to adjust load points that the ecu used to calculate fuel and timing requirements.

So say you're driving along at part throttle then u floor it there is some time that passes before the afm measures the change in airflow.

that isn't quite right. the ecu also works off tps so it will know when the throttle is being opened and will put in some enrichment to compensate.

also you have the fact that the afm will cop a heap of oil if your turbo seal blows or you have blow by issues and would need to be cleaned every few days.

i done this only for the reason this to my car was to eliminate the 4 inch inlet of the turbo being reduced to like 2 1/2" from the afm so i put it on the pressure side of the piping so i can have 4 inh all the way to the turbo inlet

f*#k the dose i try my hardest to get rid of it if you want a dose get a vl

muzza'z lol

I wish all you dosing (fully sick) skyline owners would sell up and go back to Homodores.

Sick of all this bullshit modification for the sake of a stupid sound which impresses very few people anyway!

Save your time and money on actually modifying for a performance gain perhaps.......aahhh whatever each to their own.

Flame away my dosing freinds.

i htink this idea is flawless at best without an ECU tune of some sort to compensate for the new AFM location

my understanding of hte AFM is this..

the AFM works by calculating. it does not directly measure airflow.

it has a wire that hangs into the lumen of the pipe. this wire heats up to a certain temperature that correlates with a certain resistance in the AFM (contains a variable resistor). when ambient air flows over that wire, it cools the wire down. the more air that flows over the wire, the more it cools the wire down. thus, as airflow increases the wire cools down more and the resistance in the AFM changes. this correlates with a change in voltage to the ECU.

this way, the ECU knows approximately what the airflow is based on the hot wire's operation.

now i see 2 major flaws with placing the AFM in the cooler piping

1) the air is compressed. there is absolutely no evicence that i've ever seen that says that compressed air will cool the wire at the same rate as air at atmospheric pressure. let's look at it from the particle model. say i have 100 particles of O2 in a fixed space and it cools the hot wire by 0.1degC. well if this is compressed to 1bar i now have 200 particles in that fixed space. who's to say that this compressed air will cool the wire by 0.2degC? i don't think the relationship will be as linear as you might think.

2) the air is hot. that's right, its after the turbo. that means that the air going over the wire could be up to 50-80degC having just come out of hte turbo. i don't think hot air will be able to extract heat from the wire as would ambient air, and if it does then it wouldn't be at the same rate as ambient air that passes over the AFM normally.

--> but, i believe that both these issues could be compensated for by a good tuner

so, in summary... my understanding is:

1) the AFM works on a hot wire principal

2) placing it after the AFM means that it measures compressed air not normal air, thus it will not measure effectively without a re-tune

3) placing it after the AFM means that it measures hotter air rather than ambient air, thus it will not measure effectively without a re-tune

this is only based on my understanding of how the AFM works and my understanding of basic physics/chemistry. it might help or it might not, but i thought i would throw it in for discussion

cheers,

Warren

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • GCG is a good company, they're a major distributor for Garrett in Japan as well.
    • Nah, OEM washer bottle and brake fluid reservoirs are fine I don't know what it is with the plastic that Mazda used, some plastics, like the washer bottle and brake fluid res are fine, and still look new after 20 years use, where as the coolant expansion tank, and PS reservoir, that I replaced with new OEM items when I first got the car, turned yellow and started getting brittle a few years later If the dirty yellow stained plastics didn't trigger me there wouldn't be an issue, but they did, much like the battery bracket....... Meh As for going back to work full time to support car stuff, nope, why, because I own a Mazda NC MX5, not a Nissan R series Skyline 🤣
    • I've never heard of CJ-motor, so can't advise you on them. I'd just go straight to GCG for a GCG highflow though. Seems no point to use a middleman. I'm somewhat surprised that the price on the CJ site is lower than the GCG retail price. Even though CJ would get a discount of some sort, you would hardly expect them to give up so much margin. Maybe the price is out of date? Having said that "I'd go to GCG"...when I did my highflow, I went to Hypergear. I did this https://hypergearturbos.com/product/rb25dethighflow/#tab-dyno-results with the R34 OP6 450HP profile. With the BB centre (extra $400) and intially with the standard boost actuator, but I eventually got him to send me the high pressure one when I got to the point of being able to actually use it. Ends up costing the same sort of money as the GCG highflow, but this is, of course, the turbo that I KNOW has a shorter length core and so moves the comp cover rearwards. The GCG apparently doesn't do that. My mechanic also swears by the GCG highflow, given that we have another turbo rebuilder who does something essentialy the same as theirs, using Garrett wheels. He says it stands up at really low revs and makes good power. I haven't pushed my HG highflow past ~240-250rwkW yet (should have a little more in it, but unclear how much) and it does have a fairly gentle boost ramp. OK, it's much better now that I have gotten my boost controller tuned up on it.  A lot of my earlier unhappiness was because I couldn't keep the wastegate flap as closed as it needed to be (including some mechanical issues). I'd still prefer it to boost up nearly as quickly as the stocker, and it certainly a bit slower than that. So maybe the GCG one is worth the first look (for you).
    • Ok thanks 🙂 I will higly consider this. Any "known" company for a good reviews and experience to send that off? Is that CJ-motor good one? Or go straight to GCG site? I need to use VPN to even find some of those "shops" let alone access them 🙂 
    • You can literally put in as much WMI as it takes to quench the combustion totally (and then back it off a little, obviously), and it will keep making more and more power. The power comes from the cooling effect of the water (and the meth) and the extra fuel (the meth, which also has massive octane). It is effectively exactly like running E85. One might be slightly better than the other, but they are damn close. But with either you can lean on the boost or the timing (or both) waaaay more than with just petrol and the results are similar. Here's the first thing I googled for an anecdotal bit of evidence. Can't access the attachment without being a gold member, but it is there for the getting if able to, or searched up elsewise perhaps. https://www.hpacademy.com/forum/general-tuning-discussion/show/wmi-vs-e85/
×
×
  • Create New...