Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

yeah thats why you go tomei, they dont slap

it has nothing to do with the brand it has everything to do with the fact they are forged and the clearances you use.

You can minimise slapping by running as tight clearances as possible but the only way to avoid it entirely is to use non forged pistons, so no they will still slap.

And pretty sure Tomei pistons are made by Cosworth...I know some of them were.

If you dont want piston slap run a long skirt piston and really tight clearances. might cost you a handful of horsepower but much better for a street engine.

it has nothing to do with the brand it has everything to do with the fact they are forged and the clearances you use.

You can minimise slapping by running as tight clearances as possible but the only way to avoid it entirely is to use non forged pistons, so no they will still slap.

its everything to do with the brand, tomei use different forging process's and different blends of metals for there pistons, thats why you can set the piston to bore distance closer (as specified by tomei), and there not made by cosworth, ALOT of people that have visited the tomei workshop can back this up!

Surely their expansion properties are not that much different? Does anyone have them, I'm curious.

I'm sure they vary a bit but surely you'll still need a larger clearance than stock pistons.

i have some on the way, there were a few threads on gtr uk about them too, people where questioning about the piston to bore clearance, and found out it was due to how much the expand when heated, which is very minimal. There also the only piston manufacturer with cooling chanels just like the OEM rb26 and 2jz pistons

Interesting, perhaps the cooling channels restrict the expansion.

thats a good point, i know you can get non cooling too, and even the non cooling pistons have no slap.....

http://www.tomei-p.co.jp/_2003web-catalogu...iston_rset.html

some silent reading for you :P

no doubt they are a good piston. but most motors, built tight... won't have a problem regardless of what brand.

motors with wiseco, cp, whatever. ive heard plenty and all of them you couldn't pick if you tried.

plenty of tried and proven pistons out there without having to blow $3000 on tomei cooling channel items when a decent set will set you back around 1200.

either way to suggest tomei cooling channel as an option in this thread is ridiculous.

no doubt they are a good piston. but most motors, built tight... won't have a problem regardless of what brand.

motors with wiseco, cp, whatever. ive heard plenty and all of them you couldn't pick if you tried.

plenty of tried and proven pistons out there without having to blow $3000 on tomei cooling channel items when a decent set will set you back around 1200.

either way to suggest tomei cooling channel as an option in this thread is ridiculous.

if you read properly i didnt suggest tomei cooling pistons to anyone, just comparing. all i am saying is most pistons will have different heat expansion rates, tomei is one brand with the smallest of these (both cooling and non cooling).

You said it was everything to do with the brand, which is not the case at all as I've said - plenty of OTHER brands can also achieve a "slap"less result when the motor is built right. Hell you could build a shit motor and have Tomei's slap as well, wouldnt be hard with some of the motors I've seen built around the place.

End of the day Tomei pistons do not magically achieve something that nobody else has in the realm of piston slap in a cold motor.

You said it was everything to do with the brand, which is not the case at all as I've said - plenty of OTHER brands can also achieve a "slap"less result when the motor is built right. Hell you could build a shit motor and have Tomei's slap as well, wouldnt be hard with some of the motors I've seen built around the place.

End of the day Tomei pistons do not magically achieve something that nobody else has in the realm of piston slap in a cold motor.

yeah and that was in regards to piston slap, you seem to think tomei pistons are way out of everyones budget, i picked up a set for a few hundred dollars more, so why not go the extra? also read up on other forums other then skyaus (in relation to piston slap) and see what you find, it may shock you.....

Must be a combination of design and perhaps a higher silicon content in their pistons inorder to achieve those tight clearances and reduced piston slap.

Do they have some kind of power rating on the pistons?

Must be a combination of design and perhaps a higher silicon content in their pistons inorder to achieve those tight clearances and reduced piston slap.

Do they have some kind of power rating on the pistons?

not too sure ive heard people say 1500hp?

Tomei “cooling channel” are over 3k landed (RRP)

Normal Tomei are around 1800 landed (RRP)

Wiseco or CP (as an example) that come in around 1k-1.2k landed (RRP)

Tell me then please - what exactly do you get for 50% more cost (Tomei standard issue vs Wiseco/CP)?

Just reduced piston slap because of slightly different composition? Come on… Hardly a deal breaker.

Looks to be nothing drastic either way – as I cannot find a detailed spec sheet which would have me believe it’s probably not a lot different to most other pistson on the market, that for which, you can find detailed spec sheets.

Tomei ones don’t magically support another 1000hp, are any less prone to failure or anything else.

If the only thing they can claim is reduce piston movement in the bore due to their composition, then that honestly is not a deal breaker at all when you can have a motor built tight enough these days that piston slap isn’t really an issue.

I'm all for buying the best parts, but you must be mindful of a budget - and this guy is working to a very tight budget. An extra $600 or so when its simply not required, doesn't help him at all.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • I've got the rear ones, they're certainly beefy. I need to take them to my driveshaft guru to check over, he's very fussy about the quality of components so I'll let you know if they are made of cheese by a blind man.   Are you in Australia? A mate just had a set of EN26 shafts made for his K20 Lotus by our fabricator which were quite cheap (compared to Driveshaft Shop) so if you can procure the CV's and draw what you need he'd make them for ~$800 for the pair.
    • Had I known the diff between R32 and R33 suspension I would have R33 suspension. That ship has sailed so I'm doing my best to replicate a drop spindle without spending $4k on a Billet one.
    • OEM suspension starts to bind as soon as the car gets away from stock height. I locked in the caster and camber before cutting off the kingpin. I then let the upright down in a natural (unbound) state before re-attaching it. Now it moves freely in bump and droop relative to the new ride height. My plan is to add GKTech arms before the car is finished so I can dial camber and caster further. It will be fine. This isn't rocket science. Caster looks good, camber is good, upper arm doesn't cause crazy gain and it is now closer to the stock angle and bump steer checks out. Send it.
    • Pay careful attention to the kinematics of that upper arm. The bloody things don't work properly even on a normal stock height R32. Nissan really screwed the pooch on that one. The fixes have included changing the hole locations on the bracket to change the angle of the inner pivot (which was fairly successful but usually makes it impossible to install or remove the arm without unbolting the bracket from the tower, which sucks) and various swivelling upper arm designs. ALL the swivelling upper arm designs that look like a capital I (with serifs) suck. All of them. Some of them are in fact terribly unsafe. Even the best one of them (the old UAS design) shat itself in short order on my car. The only upper arm that works as advertised and is pretty safe is the GKTech one. But it is high maintenance on a street car. I'm guessing that a 600HP car as (stupidly, IMO) low as you are going is not going to be a regular driver. So the maintenance issues on suspension parts are probably not going to be a problem. But you really must make sure that however your fairly drastically modded suspension ends up, that the upper arms swing through an arc that wants to keep the inner and outer bolts parallel. If the outer end travels through an arc that makes that end's bolt want to skew away from parallel with the inner bolt, you will build up enormous binding and compressing forces in the bushes, chew them out and hate life. The suspension compliance can actually be dominated by the bush binding, not the spring rate! It may be the case that even something like the GKTech arm won't work if your suspension kinematics become too weird, courtesy of all the cut and shut going on. Although you at least say there's no binding now, so maybe you're OK. Seeing as you're in the build phase, you could consider using R33/4 type upper arms (either that actual arm, OEM or aftermarket) or any similar wishbone designed to suit your available space, so alleviate the silliness of the R32 design. Then you can locate your inner pivots to provide the correct kinematics (camber gain on compression, etc).
    • The frontend wouldn't go low enough because the coilover was max low and the upper control arm would collapse into itself and potentially bottom out in the strut tower. I made a brace and cut off the kingpin and then moved the upright down 1.25" and welded. i still have to finish but this gives an idea. Now I can have a normal 3.25" of shock travel and things aren't binding. I'm also dropping the lower arm and tie rod 1.25".
×
×
  • Create New...