Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

So....forget the "which one your tuner is more comfortable with" line

The tuner will be myself...As I want to learn the in's and out's of basic stuff :thumbsup:

So the setup will be on a 1JZ auto, so no matter what ecu I pick it will be piggy backed onto the standard ECU and just fuel and ignition controlled by the new ecu.

So..need to know which (this is also to help others not just myself)

a) User friendliness

b) Tune ability

c) Input/Output - for extra fans, WMI etc etc

d) Support - email / forums / phone etc

e) Value for money

So, my Choices are,

The Adaptronic E420D

Haltech Sprint 500

EMS Stinger

Greddy Emanage blue

Greddy Emanage ultimate

Wolf V4X

Adaptronic E440

Black Box M1

Would be muchly appreciated if people would weigh in on their thoughts about these ECU's (within SAU guidelines) or other ECU's if I have missed any.

Cheers

A.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/383556-budget-ecus/
Share on other sites

  • Replies 125
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

I should ad that I'm not opposed to the more expensive ECU's

but given the 1J runs batch injection, the more expensive ECU's are twice the price for what equates to 2 more ignition drivers...I can live with wasted spark if I save nearly 1000 bucks :thumbsup:

Also have seen it mentioned a few times in the last month or so...but I'm giving another vote towards having a dedicated Tuning sub-section

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/383556-budget-ecus/#findComment-6118470
Share on other sites

Your best two options would be:

Wolf V4X

Haltech Platinum 500

The wolf has more programmable outputs (6 from memory) and a 3bar map sensor whereas the 500 has a 1.5bar map sensor and 2 programmable outputs so it depends on how many inputs/outputs you want and if boost is involved and how much

Both good units and will do what you need very well.

I wouldn't use any of the other units if those two are in your list

If you had to pick a cheaper option:

Emanage

Stinger (although recently I found these to have a really weird trigger angle lock at 60deg which can present problems)

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/383556-budget-ecus/#findComment-6118526
Share on other sites

I don't have any experience with 1J's, but for what it's worth I know three people using the EMS Stinger 4424 to very good effect and with no complaints. Having been in the HJ Monaro with a turbocharged 304, I can understand why they love it so much...

But again, not much experience. Just thought I'd give you my 2c thumbsup.gif

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/383556-budget-ecus/#findComment-6118532
Share on other sites

Your best two options would be:

Wolf V4X

Haltech Platinum 500

The wolf has more programmable outputs (6 from memory) and a 3bar map sensor whereas the 500 has a 1.5bar map sensor and 2 programmable outputs so it depends on how many inputs/outputs you want and if boost is involved and how much

Both good units and will do what you need very well.

I wouldn't use any of the other units if those two are in your list

If you had to pick a cheaper option:

Emanage

Stinger (although recently I found these to have a really weird trigger angle lock at 60deg which can present problems)

Thanks, care to elaborate on the trigger lock on the Stingers?..and 1.5Bar map sensor on the Haltech is no good to me...1J's run 10psi standard so already past the resolution (.5Bar +ve pressure) Can they be fitted with a GM 3Bar or similar?

see how much the hks fcon piggyback is

Can be had for cheap...the software and funky weird HKS dongle however is not, unfortunately :(

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/383556-budget-ecus/#findComment-6118534
Share on other sites

nah the guys who make fc hako can supply fcon cable cheap

Awesome, something to look at then.

I have actually just been going over the new EMS Stinger software.....So simple even I understand it...even comes with a base 1jz map lol :D

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/383556-budget-ecus/#findComment-6118589
Share on other sites

I know the EMS Stinger works a treat, did on my old 1JZ...never failed! Scenes as this topic is about ecu's...does anyone know if the Wolf V4X can be used in an auto series 2 R33 skyline RB25DET? Ive got it out of my old mazda familia gtx and dont want to sell it if i can still find use for it in my skyline...

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/383556-budget-ecus/#findComment-6118672
Share on other sites

I can supply the E420D piggyback for dirt cheap, its a good pick as far as money concern. The plug in version that I've had worked pretty well on Rb25det, and software is quite user friendly. How ever I don't have any personal experiences with 1JZ, it should work as good.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/383556-budget-ecus/#findComment-6118741
Share on other sites

How cheap is cheap Stao?

Pm Me?

Also - Vipec/Link users

Was playing with the software last night...Geez there are some menu's and I'll be honest and say it is a little out of my scope. However I'm sure if I dun did read the destructions I would have a better idea lol

So far, the Stinger I have been able to find everything easily but lacks helps menu's, Wolf's help menu box's are great, but I can't find a way of changing the load scale, Link/Vipec looks and feels great to use, but without knowing what everything is, it looks tricky and slow to use for the less experienced guys like me.

On the cost side of it, The Stinger's price looks great, but doesn't come with a loom...so add that to the cost and you're at Wolf V4X money..and a couple of hundred more than the Adaptronic and the Haltech.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/383556-budget-ecus/#findComment-6118900
Share on other sites

You cant change the Load scale on the V4x. Using the map tracer its actually not that bad.

Once you do 1 run it will trace what load point/rpm you are on and you tune those cells.

We use Wolf V500 on the quickest 1JZ in Australia and there is no way we could have gone as fast with a lesser ecu.

The V4X is the baby brother. not quit as powerful with outputs but still a good ecu.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/383556-budget-ecus/#findComment-6119064
Share on other sites

Adaptronic will come with launch control and flex fuel capability type stuff, its good value for the money. I also know a couple of my old streeter mates who are tuning these themselves on road with a wideband and kmon. Price is good too.

Have done an EMS stinger and cant say I was impressed. Scrub that off your list IMHO.

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/383556-budget-ecus/#findComment-6119078
Share on other sites

I had a look at the map sensor calibration table in the Wolf software...just seems weird to me...almost like signal bending, because 100% load on a 250cc motorbike will be way different to 100% load on a 600rwhp 1jz powered commodore ute.

I'm sure it works ok...just prefer the idea of scaling the load points by manifold pressure x rpm, eg max 10psi boost, so scale the load points from say -14.7psi to +14.7psi

that way I know what I am looking at in regards to setting up a target AFR map, or even just punching in a rough timing base map (will be road tuning a lot so will be tricky to hold a steady state load at high rpm)

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/383556-budget-ecus/#findComment-6119081
Share on other sites

Adaptronic will come with launch control and flex fuel capability type stuff, its good value for the money. I also know a couple of my old streeter mates who are tuning these themselves on road with a wideband and kmon. Price is good too.

Have done an EMS stinger and cant say I was impressed. Scrub that off your list IMHO.

Cheers, that is another thing I forgot to mention (flex fuel) but I do feel that is a little advanced for me, dual maps would be a big plus

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/383556-budget-ecus/#findComment-6119083
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now



  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • So, I started this repair and got as far as "fixing" the holes with some fibreglass. God all those years working on boats came back quickly. I decided I'd reach out to some rust guys just to see what they would say about it. I came across a guy about 40 mins away and went to see him. He said the windscreen needs to come out, that there might be some more bits around the windscreen and he'd quote them at the time. But his quote was $300 to remove and replace windscreen and $3k for the damage he can see. He said he could respray the roof for $1200 and the bonnet for another $800 (somebody has previously rattle canned it, its horrendous). This is $5300 + any small additional bits. It's a lot, I get that and the name of one of my fave youtube channels 'Not Economically Viable' comes to mind.  I'm not being financially rational, but I've taken him up on the quote. He's opening a new shop in November with more room, so we're waiting for that. I'll leave the currently missing headliner out until then. I'm looking forward to it being fixed and having the paint looking nice again (lots of clear coat issues on the roof too). / flame suit on.
    • Oh and some up-and-comings; New rear drivers wheel bearing. I'll do that this weekend while the diff is out. The car is already up and the d/c axles and missing exhaust will help with space. This is the last bearing for me to do and I've been dragging my feet on it. I also have some new EBC blue stuff pads for the car and some new brake fluid. I haven't ever flushed the fluid in this car and looking forward to it. I have 600 degree fluid to put in. Not exactly "race fluid" but better than the typical stuff I have been using.
    • A proper clutch/plate type mechanical diff with quite a lot of pre-load and high locking % is better for drifting. Much more consistent in its behaviour. A helical can be annoyingly vague and inconsistent in how it responds under the sorts of abuse found in drifting.
    • Some updates here. I pulled the entire interior out, minus some trim to respray the seats with Colourlock dye. It turned out really nice though I accidentally let the dog in the car after and she scratched up the front seat.  This is what it looked like before, the colour was just washing out everywhere but thankfully the leather was in good nic. Then after the respray   And after the bloody dog jumped in The headliner is out waiting to be retrimmed, but it will stay out now until Nov - see why below. I replaced the stereo/headunit with a period-styled Android headunit. I have no after pics, but I'll get some. This is because of the missing pixels. I tried to fix this twice with replacement ribbon cables but couldn't. Also the bluetooth interface I'd bought for this was crap. Then there's the rusty roof. Pics and info in this other thread. I have decided to get this repaired professionally, but I'll update that thread. This is why the headliner will stay out for now. I'll be getting the roof and bonnet resprayed at the same time the rust is fixed. I also had an interesting issue with my drivers door lock.  For a small period I was having issues getting any 12v power to the car - I mean *any*. It would have no dash lights, nothing. It happened while I was at the shops and I couldn't get in the car. So, we had 2 problems. The most pressing here is that I was locked out. I have only a single physical key hole on the car, the drivers door and no amount of turning would unlock the car. Surely it doesn't need power for this? The second issue is why am I losing all power periodically, The battery isn't dead, its almost like the battery isn't even there. Two issues that were surprisingly easy to fix. You fellow BMW over-engineering lovers will appreciate this. The lock in the door has 5 states; mechanical lock, electric lock, neutral, electric unlock, mechanical unlock achieved at -90 degrees, -45 degrees, 0 degrees, 45 degrees and 90 degrees. Although, the unlock is towards the front of the car, so opposite for LHD countries. Sticking the key in and turning 45 left or right is what is used 99% of the time. It activates the central locking etc. 90 degrees is for dead battery access and, obvs, only un/locks the one door. But because the mechanical lock is never used and is 27 years old, it seizes up. I was totally unable to turn the key far enough to get to the mechanical unlock (At the time of locking myself out, I didn't even know this was a thing). I eventually did it with some vicegrips and teflon spray.  I made a quick vid for other E39 peeps.   The battery issue is totally new to me also - It wasn't making sufficient contact between the post and the terminal. The terminal was bolted on tight, but the car wouldn't have power. After checking the battery with my multimeter I accidentally contacted the terminal and the battery post and the car got power. The battery was only a few years old and in good condition. I cleaned the post and the terminal with a wire brush, bolted it back on tight and never had the issue again. I'm still surprised that despite having solid contact it didn't work. Also, the car was getting Warragamba sized pools of water in the back when it rained. My initial concern was another rust problem. But when I went out on Weds while it was raining and while I had no headliner in I could see a steady stream of water coming through the roof mounted aerial. As this aerial is for the (now removed) car phone I pulled it out and whacked a blanking grommet in the hole. It seems fine now. I'm thinking I might get the hole permanently filled when the rust is fixed. Moving forward and things in progress; The tailgate needs some attention. I have taken all the trim off to clean it all and address some small rust spots. I have partially done all of this but I'll finish it up hopefully this weekend. As all the trim are now entirely devoid of trim clips I have bought a heap of strong velcro and I'm hoping it does a good enough job as any of this trim in good condition is super expensive and usually in Europe as we dont have many of the wagons here. Suspension and brakes!!! This is exciting. In the front; New control arms New sway bar links New lower Eibach springs (the only modification I'm planning on this car) M Sport shocks (these came with the car and will replace the longer shocks in the car) New top mounts Used 540i calipers (stock brakes suck!) New 540i disks and pads (22x296 mm for 528 and 30x334 mm for 540i) New front wheel bearings (thank all that is holy for bolt on bearings!) Annnnd in the back; New control arms New sway bar links Adjustable air suspension arms (fool the car into what the current height is so the self levelling suspension can match the new front ride height) New ball joints I'll also be doing a brake fluid flush while I'm in there. I'm planning on switching the car over to the 16's that came with it so I can clean up and respray the M Sport 17's. They've lost a lot of colour over the years and have some gutter rash. None of this will start until the E90 is back.
    • You mean you will regret it for drifting duties? I don't quite follow.
×
×
  • Create New...