Jump to content
SAU Community

Battery / Alternator Issue...

Charles89

By Charles89,
in General Maintenance

 Share

Recommended Posts

Charles89 Grand Master

Charles89

Posted
Posted

Ok, here's my issue. Yesteday when I was working on my car, I left my car in ignition to play music (should have put it into ACC) thinking my battery is good enough to last a while..

4 hours later, the music just died and I realised I've just drained my battery... So I had to get the car jump started. It starts with no problems at all and end up going for a 5-10mins drive to dinner. But after dinner, battery went flat again.. So I used a jumper pack to start the car.

Once started, I went for a 1-2hr cruise, and what I notice is, everytime I put my highbeam on or even fog lights, it would drain so much battery that it will restart my headunit and also stalls the car...

And today, I started the car a few times, a couple of times it took a few secs to start, but didn't have to use the jumper pack, but the highbeam problem is still there...

But what I don't get is, my battery was 100% healthy before I drained it out and never had any of those issues above, which I'm guessing my alternator was fine before that...

So what can cause these issues? And the battery should have been fully charged by a 1-2hr drive right? And is it true that once the battery is drained, it won't hold charge again?..

Any help would be appreciated! :D

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/386795-battery-alternator-issue/
Share on other sites
  • Replies 42
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Posted Images

t_revz Grand Master

t_revz

Posted
Posted
  On 29/12/2011 at 4:21 PM, Charles89 said:

Once started, I went for a 1-2hr cruise, and what I notice is, everytime I put my highbeam on or even fog lights, it would drain so much battery that it will restart my headunit and also stalls the car...

And today, I started the car a few times, a couple of times it took a few secs to start, but didn't have to use the jumper pack, but the highbeam problem is still there...

So what can cause these issues? And the battery should have been fully charged by a 1-2hr drive right? And is it true that once the battery is drained, it won't hold charge again?..

1-2hrs should be fully charged. after 10-15 mins should have enough to be able to restart the engine without assistance,

not true about flat battery not being able to be recharged. was prob down to 7-8v when the headunit turned off. that story comes from batteries that go flat and are left for a period of time which causes chemicals to change in the battery.

batt terminals arent loose from where you clipped jump leads on? maybe you twisted them a little causing them to come off.

need a multimeter to compare voltage at battery and alternator to see if its not charging correctly anymore or if not getting to the battery anymore.

could potentialy be the battery or alternator from having to work harder than normal charging back up too but i wouldnt buy anythnig until you test it

Charles89 Grand Master

Charles89

Posted
  • Author
Posted
  On 30/12/2011 at 1:48 AM, t_revz said:

1-2hrs should be fully charged. after 10-15 mins should have enough to be able to restart the engine without assistance,

not true about flat battery not being able to be recharged. was prob down to 7-8v when the headunit turned off. that story comes from batteries that go flat and are left for a period of time which causes chemicals to change in the battery.

batt terminals arent loose from where you clipped jump leads on? maybe you twisted them a little causing them to come off.

need a multimeter to compare voltage at battery and alternator to see if its not charging correctly anymore or if not getting to the battery anymore.

could potentialy be the battery or alternator from having to work harder than normal charging back up too but i wouldnt buy anythnig until you test it

The terminals are definitely not loose, but possibly a bit too dirty lol.

erik - yeah I might try that first and see what happens.

Just hoping I haven't killed my battery :S

89CAL Grand Master

89CAL

Posted
Posted

Check the water level inside the battery as well. And as above check your terminals. If everything was 100% before hand then I wouldnt expect the battery or alternator to be completely dead afterwards, especially the alternator

Just check everything, start at the battery and work your way to the alternator

Charles89 Grand Master

Charles89

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I just had a good look in the engine bay, checked all fuses and connections, they seem to be all good.

Then took the car for a drive, took a couple of seconds to start but still started, the voltage on my MFD was reading 14.5v or so, but when I use highbeam, the voltage drops to about 13v, headunit restarts, car almost stalls, then after I turn highbeam off, everything becomes normal again....

89CAL Grand Master

89CAL

Posted
Posted

Hmmmm it shouldnt drop that much when turning the high beams on. I had to put a new battery in mine yesturday and thought the charging voltage was low so was turning lights on and off. It only dropped momentarily (only by 0.4v or so at the most) and then went back to its charging voltage.

Check the wiring for your high beams if its only when using the high beams it seems to cause the problems. 13v shouldnt cause anything to drop out either. Id expect that to happen more around 8v or so.

Somethings wrong there. Check your water level in your battery, and check your wiring, especially around your head lights

Missileman Veteran

Missileman

Posted
Posted (edited)

If it helps here are some voltage readings I took from the battery terminals earlier today...

R32 gtst auto

resting volts = 12.91

idle volts = 14.15

idle + headlights on = 14.03

idle + high beam on = 13.98

I went for 300km drive on Wednesday so the battery should have been well charged.

Cheers

Mike.

Edited by Missileman
Charles89 Grand Master

Charles89

Posted
  • Author
Posted
  On 30/12/2011 at 11:36 AM, 89CAL said:

Hmmm.... Does it have a window type thing with a colour indicator showing the condition of the battery? If it truly is maintenance free then you cant check the water level, what sort of battery is it?

There's no window, no nothing...

Charles89 Grand Master

Charles89

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Here's some readings that I took down just before.

When driving, my voltage is between 13.8 and 14.2.

When idling, it goes to about 13.8 with headlights on.

When driving, I tried high beaming, everything seems fine, no drop of voltage like before.

But when I was idling and tried high beam, voltage drops and car almost stalls.

So would it be my battery or alternator? I've lined up a optima yellow top for pick up tomorrow, so I hope it's not my alternator...

89CAL Grand Master

89CAL

Posted
Posted

Sounds like your alternator is working fine for the voltages while driving along. You can get your battery tested at an Auto Elec's shop using a carbon pile tester or whatever they use at that shop. Will tell you if the battery is stuffed or not.

what is your idle RPM? It seems a bit weird that it only has the issue when idling. I wouldnt assume that the alternator is spinning to slow at idle but if your RPM is really low, it might be a problem. Still not convinced though

so when your idling and turn the high beams on it stalls? or does it nearly stall? try sitting in neutral giving it a few revs and turning the high beams on, leave the revs up for a bit then let it to return to idle.

Just to see what happens, if its the sudden load at the low RPM or if its just not producing enough amps at that speed to charge the battery.

Charles89 Grand Master

Charles89

Posted
  • Author
Posted

I just picked up an Optima yellow top 750CCA from my friend today, he used it for like a year.

After I installed the yellow top, the same thing is still happening :S

And I idle at about 700?

So can this be the alternator?....

Are there any fuses I should be checking too?..

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • GTSBoy
      Rb25 trigger kit and timing misalignment

      By GTSBoy · Posted

      Are you suggesting that the kit did a cheap and nasty job of just jamming the wheel in between other things and caused the misalignment? I mean, we normally do this with an integrated crank trigger wheel, not something bodged on. It's not 1995 any more.
    • joshuaho96
      R-chassis INNER tie rod torque spec?

      By joshuaho96 · Posted

      I mean, given the number of BMWs you own their tolerance for improper torque is rather low. The number of torque + angle spec bolts and non-reusable bolts in one is nuts.
    • joshuaho96
      Question about BoV on RB25DET NEO

      By joshuaho96 · Posted

      Atmospheric vent requires something that doesn't use a MAF for load. You would need a standalone ECU for that.
    • drifter17a
      Rb25 trigger kit and timing misalignment

      By drifter17a · Posted

      Hey all,   I’ve got an RB25 with a trigger kit that includes a crank wheel, and I’ve hit a wall trying to sort a timing belt tracking issue. The belt either rides right on the edge of the cam/crank pulleys or walks slightly forward once the engine starts. It tracks okay-ish for a moment, then creeps right to the edge—and honestly, it’s stressing me out.   I’ve spent hours removing and reinstalling the belt, double-checking everything:   Tensioner setup is good, checked multiple times Idler pulley and washers are all in the correct places Followed the RB25 timing procedure step-by-step     The only thing I changed was the rear crank washer—I swapped the OEM one for a Neato version, and it made things worse. The belt now sits even more forward than before. I’m beginning to think the crank trigger wheel itself (from the trigger kit) is the issue—poor design or slightly off dimensions.   What’s strange is that with the previous belt setup, it actually ran fine for a couple of years—around 4,000 to 5,000 miles, even with hard driving and high RPMs. But even then, the belt was always riding right on the edge, and I know that’s not ideal or safe long term.   At this point, I’m debating whether to:   Machine a few mm off the crank trigger wheel to bring it back in line, or Replace it entirely with a better-designed unit     Only thing is, I already have the Cherry Hall sensors, bracket, etc.—I just want to replace the wheel only, not the entire kit. Anyone know a brand or supplier that sells just the crank trigger wheel on its own?   Would really appreciate any feedback—especially from anyone who’s run into this exact issue and found a reliable fix.   Thanks in advance.
    • Kapr
      Question about BoV on RB25DET NEO

      By Kapr · Posted

      Hi...a little refresh. Is Nistune gonna be enough to run BoV? Or do i need some proper ECU? 
×
×
  • Create New...