Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

Hello everyone, I thought I would share, I had my cambelt done today at the garage they decided not to replace the water pump as it appears to be okay. So they got it all done and took for a test drive and the water pump snapped where it connects to the fan. Ruined radiator fan and trans cooler.

Lesson learned today.. Always replace water pump lolpost-119800-0-03946500-1379052903_thumb.jpg

post-119800-0-78919700-1379052937_thumb.jpg

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/431786-rb25de-waterpump-blew-to-bits/
Share on other sites

Wow! That's the first time I've seen that. I would be hesitant to go back there. It's really worth replacing the water pump, idler, Tensioner and cam seals when it is all apart, especially when you are paying someone else to do it.

The waterpump is driven by the fanbelt not the cambelt and before i took it in the fan belt was pretty tight, I think that maybe they didnt install it correctly after inspecting it and it got jammed i dont know how else it could break there.

They are going to replace the broken parts (hope they dont charge me for it) I will see how it turns out when i pick up on monday

Wow that would've sounded horrible when it went. Definately getting a pump change when the timing belt is replaced. :O

I recently did my ancillary belts and even though my fan belt was tight, I had to tighten it again to stop squealing.

Kinda makes you wonder just how tight is overtight.

I had a substantial piece of the water pump snap off underneath the shaft. I was freaked out too.

Timing belt was replaced months ago.

So yeah, I believe it. Looked like the casting had a hairline crack.

The waterpump is driven by the fanbelt not the cambelt and before i took it in the fan belt was pretty tight, I think that maybe they didnt install it correctly after inspecting it and it got jammed i dont know how else it could break there.

They are going to replace the broken parts (hope they dont charge me for it) I will see how it turns out when i pick up on monday

But you have to take off all the ancillary belts to do the timing belt ;)

Or possible the shop used a breaker bar and cranked the car to crack the nut but screwed up and cracked the water pump.

Slight chance?

Big chance! Even if the water pump was a cheap n nasty casting it didnt "blew to bits"!

Its had a lot of force put on it and its been broken

Edited by StevenCJR31

I would never do that - just put the car in gear and use some of the man power to torque it out - cranking the car is so bloody dangerous i reckon!

I always crack the nut by cranking it over. It only takes a split second to do it, just make sure the brake bar is suitable. My car is an auto so the put it in gear thing won't work.

Why are they cutting corners? Sounds like a shit shop who doesn't care. They also caused this. I changed my water pump when I did my belt not because it needed to but more the might as well factor.

Also I never needed to crank to crack the nut. Big breaker bar to take it off and properly torqued on. I'd also bet they used a rattle gun or just guestimated the torque when putting the nut on the crank.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • So could it be assumed it has been installed intentionally with potentially a power FC boost controller kit? 
    • Had my rig on Matt's dyno at PITS the other day. After a few years between tunes I added a few sensors and swapped intercoolers. Result. 553hp at 26psi. Not bad for an FJ20 that was built in 2007. The problem.. It filled the overflow bottle on hard runs which leads me to believe the head gasket isn't sealing. I have a coolant pressure sensor which was reading cap pressure at 22psi and occasionally overrunning to 23/24 psi on deceleration after a pull. It was not spiking. It has arp2000 head studs and a cometic gasket. As its been 18 years in service, I pulled the engine out and head off. Everything looks good but we obviously have an issue. Where I'm at.. Years ago I had the same issue, I checked the stud tension and they were all over the place. Some at 60 to 70 and some up near 90. I nipped them all to 100ft lbs and this stopped the water push until now. I believe this compromised the gasket back then. What do I do? 2 options are..  1) I bought arp 625+s, which I could put in with a new gasket. Thinking Kameari this time, reassemble and try again. 2) strip the block, get fire rings machined in with copper gasket and try that. I do not want to push it more than 28 to 30psi. I think the turbo will be out by then anyway. (G30-770). My other concern is the long term ability of a copper head gasket. Are they streetable for years? I feel like a new gasket with the new studs will probably suffice, but I don't know. Any thoughts welcome and advice on copper gaskets and fire rings. Thanks!
    • I'm a fan of the JZX110, and the Aristo. Big cruiser cars, and with the factory cars, super comfortable and feel like you're driving an armchair! And the JZ motors are a pretty nice engine too, especially with some basic mods.   The import process, and the need to be able to trust people, and the fact there's so many scammers around is what ever puts me off wanting to go through that ordeal!
    • I don't care for these at all, but at least the underside looks straight and not rusty. A good basis for a long life. Many cars from Japan have been lifted with forklifts and f**ked almost irrepairably.
    • Yes, but it's not dumb or dodgy. You can build a perfectly good boost controller from a pressure reg, a relief valve (looks same same as a reg if all from Norgren or SMC, for example) and a check valve. I ran one for years. Only superceded with  EBC because I could get one for cheaps and wanted finer control.   THis mod is certainly not a sketchy boost mod, provided the boost is kept below the "spin to death" threshold of the turbos.
×
×
  • Create New...