Jump to content
SAU Community

Air Impact Wrench -v- Cordless

Priestley

By Priestley,
in General Automotive Discussion

 Share

Recommended Posts

Priestley Rising Star

Priestley

Posted
Posted

I'm in need of a rattle gun for some work I'll be doing in the middle of nowhere. Not sure which combination I should use:

Rattle gun + compressor + generator

or

Battery operated rattle gun + generator

My question would be, are the battery powered rattle guns any good? I'll be using it to work on cars and farm machinery, anything from removing wheel nuts to stripping drive trains/suspension/engines and I'm not sure if the electric option will have the power to do this.

Any input would be appreciated :)

Link to comment
https://www.sau.com.au/forums/topic/299074-air-impact-wrench-v-cordless/
Share on other sites
R31Nismoid Grand Master

R31Nismoid

Posted
Posted

Mate of mine has a rather expensive battery pack one - it does wheel nuts up virtually as tight as a air driven one. Not a lot between the two (you can tell when you undo them).

So depends on what costs what.

TerribleOne Enthusiast

TerribleOne

Posted
Posted (edited)

I've got a Snap On cordless gun and its the best thing I've ever bought. Blows my old Snap On air powered gun out of the water!

I can use it at work for 2 days (alot of use) without having to change the battery.

Comes at a huge cost though...around $950 will get you a gun with 2 batteries and a charger. I've had this one for about 18 months and it's not showing any signs of slowing down.

It's got over 800nm of torque, the only 1/2" gun I've got that will undo a Honda balancer!

Edited by TerribleOne
Priestley Rising Star

Priestley

Posted
  • Author
Posted

Battery powered is sounding good so far. Not having to cart a compressor around is a plus and if I could get 2 days out of it I probably wouldn't need a generator.

$950 isn't too bad. I've been looking at the Dewalt for about $600, have to check out the snap on.

Mase Mentor

Mase

Posted
Posted (edited)

I'd be careful with the Dewalt one.

I've got a Hitachi 18V 3amp impact driver with the 1/2" fitting on it. It's great for your general nuts and bolts but anything really tight it struggles with and isn't really designed for it. I usually just crack the tight ones with the breaker bar, then use the impact driver afterwards. It can crack about 75% of the work I do on the car though. It did smash all the gearbox bolts on the bellhousing with ease and lasts a couple of days work so I can't really complain.

You'd be better off spending the extra money on the snap on one that is designed to do the job properly.

EDIT: Just saw the DeWalt has a bit more torque than the Hitachi one so you should be right.

Edited by Mase
Duncan Grand Master

Duncan

Posted
Posted

The good ones are excellent. Battery life with regular use is pretty shithouse in my experience (think 1 or 2 sets of wheels then the torque starts to drop off)

but they are very flexible and convenient for occasional use. Wish I had the coin for one :P

mxfly Veteran

mxfly

Posted
Posted

I use an air at work and i have a DeWalt at home. Although the work one has multiple torque/speed settings, I find the DeWalt do just as good a job as the work one, and you have a bonus of being portable. Sure the batteries dont last a long time, but I bought a kit that came with 2 batteries so one is on standby all the time. If you buy the DeWalt, make sure you get the heavy duty batteries.

And 600 bucks is a great buy considering I paid 800 a few years ago.

  • 2 weeks later...
BezerkR32 Veteran

BezerkR32

Posted
Posted

x2

I've got a Snap On cordless gun and its the best thing I've ever bought. Blows my old Snap On air powered gun out of the water!

I can use it at work for 2 days (alot of use) without having to change the battery.

Comes at a huge cost though...around $950 will get you a gun with 2 batteries and a charger. I've had this one for about 18 months and it's not showing any signs of slowing down.

It's got over 800nm of torque, the only 1/2" gun I've got that will undo a Honda balancer!

Swiper the Fox Grand Master

Swiper the Fox

Posted
Posted
I've got a Snap On cordless gun and its the best thing I've ever bought. Blows my old Snap On air powered gun out of the water!

I can use it at work for 2 days (alot of use) without having to change the battery.

Comes at a huge cost though...around $950 will get you a gun with 2 batteries and a charger. I've had this one for about 18 months and it's not showing any signs of slowing down.

It's got over 800nm of torque, the only 1/2" gun I've got that will undo a Honda balancer!

x3 its the only thing for quick engine stripdowns and that pesky balancer bolt

GTR-N1 Grand Master

GTR-N1

Posted
Posted
I've got a Snap On cordless gun and its the best thing I've ever bought. Blows my old Snap On air powered gun out of the water!

I can use it at work for 2 days (alot of use) without having to change the battery.

Comes at a huge cost though...around $950 will get you a gun with 2 batteries and a charger. I've had this one for about 18 months and it's not showing any signs of slowing down.

It's got over 800nm of torque, the only 1/2" gun I've got that will undo a Honda balancer!

Replacement Wty too.

  • 2 weeks later...
Duncan Grand Master

Duncan

Posted
Posted

so can anyone recommend a brand other than snap on that has been worth buying? I really don't want strap on gear in the garage in case people get the wrong impression

(ie I am a fool who pays for a brand name even if there are better tools at a cheaper price)

BARCODE Contributor

BARCODE

Posted
Posted
so can anyone recommend a brand other than snap on that has been worth buying? I really don't want strap on gear in the garage in case people get the wrong impression

(ie I am a fool who pays for a brand name even if there are better tools at a cheaper price)

The Dewalt is very good for around $600.Had mine for over a year and can't fault it.Around 400nm with a full battery

Victory Mentor

Victory

Posted
Posted

I recently went through the process of purchasing a cordless impact wrench and finally settled on a Makita BTW450 18 v unit.

These have comparable or better power to the "Snap On" units and the batteries are compatable with the full range of Makita cordless products. The only issue is that they are not imported by Makita Australia and are either sourced from NZ or USA.

Here is a link to one of these on ebay (I purchased mine on ebay from NZ) -

http://cgi.ebay.com.au/Makita-BTW450-18v-L...=item4a9ca0815e

What will it cost?

Impact wrench ~$300

Batteries ~$100 each

Charger ~$150

Total around $750 plus delivery for each component

These units have heaps of power and once you have the charger and batteries Makita also make some good drills, angle grinders, nibblers, etc that use the same batteries.

These do everything that the "Snap On" units do but with the new Lithium battery technology. They use a very intellegent charger with a built in fan to keep the battery cool while charging and the ability to communicate with the chip in the battery and vary the charge rate depending on what the battery needs.

Priestley Rising Star

Priestley

Posted
  • Author
Posted (edited)
I recently went through the process of purchasing a cordless impact wrench and finally settled on a Makita BTW450 18 v unit.

These have comparable or better power to the "Snap On" units and the batteries are compatable with the full range of Makita cordless products. The only issue is that they are not imported by Makita Australia and are either sourced from NZ or USA.

Here is a link to one of these on ebay (I purchased mine on ebay from NZ) -

http://cgi.ebay.com.au/Makita-BTW450-18v-L...=item4a9ca0815e

What will it cost?

Impact wrench ~$300

Batteries ~$100 each

Charger ~$150

Total around $750 plus delivery for each component

These units have heaps of power and once you have the charger and batteries Makita also make some good drills, angle grinders, nibblers, etc that use the same batteries.

These do everything that the "Snap On" units do but with the new Lithium battery technology. They use a very intellegent charger with a built in fan to keep the battery cool while charging and the ability to communicate with the chip in the battery and vary the charge rate depending on what the battery needs.

Thats interesting. I had a look at the Makita but wasn't sure about the quality.

A group buy could be worth looking in to: http://cgi.ebay.com.au/7-MAKITA-18-VOLT-BT...#ht_1143wt_1165

Works out at around $228 for the unit (no battery or accessories).

Edited by Priestley
aleks Community Regular

aleks

Posted
Posted (edited)

I paid $880 for a Snap on with two batteries three weeks ago, wish I bough it earlier. Ni-cad batteries though, need lithium ion. But they charge pretty quick.

You could probably get away with an electric gun with an inverter instead of having to lug around a generator/compressor.

Edited by aleks

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share
Go to topic listing


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • MissMintyR33
      R33 persistent issues. P/steering and lag/misfire

      By MissMintyR33 · Posted

      I thought that might be the case, thats what I'll start saving for. Thanks for the info 
    • jtha7
      Strange issue RB25DET wont start

      By jtha7 · Posted

      Ps i found the below forum and it seems to be the same scenario Im dealing with. Going to check my ECU coolant temp wire tomorrow    From NICOclub forum: s1 RB25det flooding at start up Thu Apr 11, 2013 7:23 am I am completely lost on this. Car ran perfectly fine when I parked it at the end of the year. I took the engine out and painted the engine bay, and put a fuel cell with an inline walbro 255 instead of the in tank unit I had last year. After reinstalling everything, the engine floods when the fuel pump primes. if i pull the fuel pump fuse it'll start, and as soon as I put the fuse back in it starts running ridiculously rich. I checked the tps voltage, and its fine. Cleaned the maf as it had some dust from sitting on a shelf all winter, fuel pressure is correct while running, but wont fire until there is less than 5psi in the lines. The fuel lines are run correctly. I have found a few threads with the same problem but no actual explanation of what fixed it, the threads just ended. Any help would be appreciated. Rb25det s1 walbro255 fuel pump nismo fpr holset hx35 turbo fmic 3" exhaust freddy intake manifold q45tb q45 maf   Re: s1 RB25det flooding at start up Fri Apr 12, 2013 5:07 am No, I didn't. I found the problem though. There was a break in one of the ecu coolant temp sensor wires. Once it was repaired it fired right up with no problems. I would have never thought a non working coolant temp sensor would have caused such an issue.
    • jtha7
      Strange issue RB25DET wont start

      By jtha7 · Posted

      Hi sorry late reply I didnt get a chance to take any pics (my mechanics on the other side of the city) but the plugs were fouled from being too rich. I noticed the MAF wasn't genuine, so I replaced it with a genuine green label unit. I also swapped in a different ignitor, but the issue remains. I've narrowed it down a bit now: - If I unplug and reconnect the fuel lines and install fresh spark plugs, the car starts right up and runs perfectly. Took it around the block with no issues - As soon as I shut it off and try to restart, it won't start again - Fuel pressure while cranking is steady around 40 psi, injectors have good spray, return line is clear, and the FPR vacuum is working. It just seems like it's getting flooded after the first start I unplugged coolant sensors to see if its related to ECU flooding but that didnt make a difference. Im thinking its related to this because this issue only started happening after fixing coolant leaks and replacing the bottom part of the stock manifolds coolant pipe. My mechanic took off the inlet to get to get to do these repairs. My mechanics actually just an old mate who's retired now so ill be taking it to a different mechanic who i know has exp with RBs to see if they find anything. If you have any ideas please send em lll give it a try. Ive tried other things like swapping the injectors, fuel rail, different fuel pressure regs, different ignitor, spark plugs, comp test and MAF but the same issue persists.
    • GTSBoy
      Freddy Plenum vs Genuine options RB25

      By GTSBoy · Posted

      My return flow is custom and puts the return behind the reo, instead of at the bottom. All my core is in the air flow, rather than losing some of it up behind the reo. I realise that the core really acts more as a spiky heatsink than as a constant rate heat exchanger, and that therefore size is important.... but mine fits everything I needed and wanted without having to cut anything, and that's worth something too. And there won't be a hot patch of core up behind the reo after every hit, releasing heat back into the intake air.
    • Murray_Calavera
      R33 persistent issues. P/steering and lag/misfire

      By Murray_Calavera · Posted

      There is a really fun solution to this problem, buy a Haltech (or ECU of your choice) and put the MAF in the bin.  I'm assuming your going to want more power in future, so you'll need to get the ECU at some stage. I'd put the new MAF money towards the new ECU. 
×
×
  • Create New...