Jump to content
SAU Community

Recommended Posts

ok long question with lots of points

as some of you will know i took my car out to a new mechanic for my next round of mods, not a lot.. cam gear,z32afm,catchcan,powerfc retune and e-boost retune.

now the problem is when i spoke to him he said it would all be sweet but the morning i dropped it off to him he told me he'd never tuned with a PFC before and had had VERY limited knowledge with the e-boost, also didnt have a clue why i would want to change the AFM as its the same size. :Oops: told him it wasnt about the size but the voltage and tuning resolution with the PFC, looked on here and got a little info for him.

anyway he said he'll give it a bash and after installing and tuning the cam gear (ended up at 5degrees retarded) we managed to pull another 6.5rwkw. not a brilliant gain but at least its something.

next up will be the afm, as i said i got him a little info like what to wire to what etc

and was wondering if anyone could shed some light on exactly what he should be doing

also does anyone have instructions for tuning the PFC in english?

then he could do a bit of study before jumping in and that would make me feel a lot better.

he seems like a competent bloke, bathurst, rally wrx's and so on a specialty, he just has never seen a pfc nor have any of his colleagues hes been chating to recently.

Thankyou

(stressed) Jimbo :)

Tune will make or break a car Jimbo.

Having someone who freely admits that they have no Power FC tuning experience is asking for trouble in a big way.

I can think of several cars that have taken the cheaper or easier approach to tuning and ended up with an engine rebuild.

Take it to a reputable tuner.

Yeah, take it to someone experienced. If you don't want to offend him make up some crap like "I've just come into money problems, thanks for doing the camgear i think i need to save some more before i get the PFC and eboost done"...

so the general consensus is to take it back off this fella and that is a serious thought in my mind now

before i do that let me just check you understand and please reaffirm yourselves if you did.

he IS a good tuner with others (eg microtech and so on) and would understand the problems and air fuel ratios etc, just checking the pfc is that much diffeent to al those other ones that would make it that much more complicated.

thankyou

I got my old car (had an EMS ecu) tuned at a place that hadn't had much to do with EMS systems before,but the guy was a decent tuner.The end result was a 'decent' level of tune,but a bit costly,due to him not being familiar on how to navagate through the EMS system with the handpiece,so more time on dyno,so more $$$.....

That's what I would be worried about. What it amounts to is paying extra for incompetency. Just because some tuner doesnt know how to tune a very common ECU, why pay extra for him to learn?

I would take the car and drive very fast in the opposite direction as soon as you can before it costs you.

well there is a couple of positives in this.. atleast he a) has told you that he hasnt done PFC's before, he could have been silent and kept the car learnin, then charge you an arm and a leg. B) you obviously have some faith in him as a tuner to keep your car there and he would seem competent in installing cam gears ...

anyway what i would suggest, is if you dont want to take the car back straight away, and you seem like your on good terms with him, maybe ask him, if he can charge half price or something as of your buisness, he is learning a new skill which can help his buisness in the future...

i know when itook my car for an alarm install at local autobarn, he said he will only charge for normal hrs for installation for similar car, as he has never done a skyline before, (he did say bitch of a job) but he now knows how to do them (dropped car of at 8, picked up at 4)

Wether he is good with a Microtech or whatever is similar, but by no means the same.

It's totally different, and not understanding the AFM thing... well that to me says take the car elsewhere right away.

As Blitz said. A tune makes or breaks a car. If it breaks... you'll be buying a new motor... not him.

thank you for all the helpful replies guys.

the car is now back in my hot little hands. :D

we parted on good terms and we arranged that somewhere down the track if he would like he can study the system and use mine to navigate around and learn in his own time, he would get some experience and i would get a free tune. weather i want him to go buggering with it after getting the tune doen where it is now booked in for in a few weeks is a different story :(

he was gonna charge me a lot when i rang him this morning to tell him i was taking it back (all the hours he was dynotuning the cam gear) i told him i was very unhappy with that and ended up only having to pay for an hours labour...but he detuned the hks cam gear back to where it the original was and since its a different gear its actually making less power than wen i took it in, but i can live with that till next time.

again thanks for the advice peeps

James

Admitting he hasn't worked with it before i think was a decent sign. Most won't even tell you that until its too late or until you have learned the hard way.

Still, everybody has to learn somewhere, and if he is familiar with other EMS then I don't see him stuffing things up majorly. The only real reason you would take it there i guess is go "well, look, you're going to be learning off the whole thing, and it may may off more for you in future -- so i want much discounted rates". Paying a tuner to "learn" how to tune a system is asking for trouble.. and unfortunately it happens a lot out there. Reason why i think quite a few people do get ripped by performance workshops.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now


  • Similar Content

  • Latest Posts

    • Sounds like the rack seals blew.
    • ^ This is all good advice. I can imagine that there's some passive components in the HVAC controller that run that PWM output that could die, or suffer bad solder joints. It can be worth opening it up, taking a schmooze around looking for swollen electro caps, evidence of liquid escape anywhere, tracks that have been hot, lifted, cracked, etc. A DMM might not be suitable for seeing if the PWM output is pulsing. Might be too fast and too low voltage for a DMM to keep up. An analogue voltmeter might give a better hope. I use a handheld oscilloscope (<$100 from Aliexpress if you want something cheap). A DMM might see the voltage across the motor flicker. Otherwise, as above. If you can successfully see PWM action, then the control side should be good. If you can't see it with what you have, you might need to step up the instrumentation used, as above. Beyond that, and dbm7's advice on testing the motor directly, you're down to looking for broken wires, corroded connector pins, etc.
    • So Thanks for the comments etc. To follow up on this, we went down the path of fitting a divider down the middle of the external pipe that was added to the exhaust manifold and the divider went from very close to the external wastegate all the way up to the "V" part where the pipes from each side of the manifold joined. After this modification it was finally in a position to do the dyno-tune with some degree of success. Top end power was down about 10kw (250rwkw down to 240rwkw) I believe from previous but it seems to be more responsive lower down and at least it is now driveable and fun and back on the road to be enjoyed. Apparently the timing couldn't be run the same as it was running into knock and boost was down about 1psi. For all we know this could have been from the fuel being a bit older, or perhaps some slight complication from the new head gasket as we didn't have compression figures from before that mod to compare. I'm no mechanic and this is second hand info but I just wanted to follow-up to those that commented or read the original post with interest. After so many months of stuffing around this is a big win. The interesting part was most of the info around this was gained from information around Barra motors and not GTR as the manifold setup on the Barra with single turbo was more similar.  Thanks for those that helped with info. Regards Rob 
    • G'day ... first up, I very much doubt that's a resistor network (as used also for this job), but the part# looks right. The description of 'power module assembly' looks to be nissanese for 'PWM driven, ground switched, DC motor speed controller'.... the circuit in the schematic kinda infers that's the case... ...with the transistor symbol appearing in the unit described here as 'Fan Control Amp(lifier)'....being driven by pin20 on the HVAC unit,  and a feedback signal on pin19 from the motor negative terminal for some reason (might be motor fault detection, maybe they detect commutator switching to determine motor revs as well, I dunno)... but if they are  counting commutator spikes, a bad segment (or really worn brushes) will throw a spanner in the works... The motor itself will as said be brushed DC with segmented commutator, rated at 12VDC nominally ~ now-a-days I just unplug them, determine the positive wire, and hook them up to a variable power supply and find out how much current they draw, if they work etc etc ...you can also check for bad segments...ie; set the power supply up to feed 1volt @ 2amp max, then watch the wattage count as you slowly rotate the fan blower motor through a complete revolution ; any bad/dead segments will be clearly evident...some folks would just say determine the positive wire, and feed it battery voltage, and if fan spin, you've got a win...<grin>... well, at least that infers it should do something when plugged back in, and the HVAC unit commands it to run... and if it doesn't, you suspect the module, but you should check the PWM signal on pin20 is actually present, and if it is, blame the module ...  
    • Ah. OK. I take it back. I hadn't looked closely at the R33/4 arms and presumed that GKTech did as GKTech do everywhere else, which is to use sphericals there. The poly bushings are made to be 100% interchangeable, should use the standard bolt just fine. Every other bush in every other place in pretty much every other car, does.
×
×
  • Create New...